What do you think?
Rate this book
Candy-Coated Mystery #12
Three Fudges and a Baby
When her pregnant best friend’s doula is found with a smoking gun, fudge maker Allie McMurphy’s sleuthing becomes a labor of love . . .
DID THE DOULA DO IT?
April is not only the start of “fudgie” season on picturesque Mackinac Island, it’s when Allie’s BFF Jenn Carpenter is due. Jenn wants to have her baby on the island, so she’s lined up a midwife and a doula. But she’s two weeks overdue—and if one more person tells her she looks ready to pop, she’s going to go bananas.
If there was a list of what not to expect when you’re expecting, right at the top would be coming upon your doula holding a gun over the body of her fiance. Clearly in shock, Hannah Riversbend claims not to have shot him. Jenn asks Ally to prove the doula’s innocence before her special delivery arrives. The clock is ticking as Ally races to solve the murder in time for Jenn’s bun to come out of the oven. . .
DID THE DOULA DO IT?
April is not only the start of “fudgie” season on picturesque Mackinac Island, it’s when Allie’s BFF Jenn Carpenter is due. Jenn wants to have her baby on the island, so she’s lined up a midwife and a doula. But she’s two weeks overdue—and if one more person tells her she looks ready to pop, she’s going to go bananas.
If there was a list of what not to expect when you’re expecting, right at the top would be coming upon your doula holding a gun over the body of her fiance. Clearly in shock, Hannah Riversbend claims not to have shot him. Jenn asks Ally to prove the doula’s innocence before her special delivery arrives. The clock is ticking as Ally races to solve the murder in time for Jenn’s bun to come out of the oven. . .
336 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published March 26, 2024
15 people are currently reading
2471 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 110 reviews
March 26, 2024
Nancy CoCo is a new to me Author and I’m impressed with the first book of her’s that I’ve read. I loved her writing style and she has completely won me over. Three Fudges and a Baby is the twelfth book in CoCo’s Candy Coated Mysteries. I didn’t have a bit of trouble keeping up with the story. I was drawn into the book and my interest was further peaked as I turned the pages. I do feel it’s better to start a series with book one but I had an opportunity to read an arc copy and thought I would give it a try. I loved the book and I have found a new Cozy mystery Author. I loved that the geographical location for these murder mysteries is Mackinac Island in Michigan. I’m familiar with this area.
Early in the book main character, sleuth Allie and her friend Jenn come upon a dead body while they are out for a walk. Jenn’s doula is in a daze and covered with blood. She’s holding a smoking gun and sitting on a stairway from her apartment, that comes down to the street . The murder victim is the doula’s fiancé. It doesn’t look good for Hannah Riverslund. She’s holding a gun at the scene of the crime. Earlier that morning Hannah and the victim, Matthew Jones were heard arguing loudly and now he’s dead. But there wasn’t any witnesses and no one heard a gunshot. Allie questions the new D.A. decision to arrest Hannah for the murder of her fiancé. Something isn’t right and everyone says Hannah wouldn’t kill anyone. If there is even a shred of doubt Allie feels led to investigate the murder. She wants to be sure the wrong person hasn’t been arrested while the real murderer runs free.
I recommend this book to readers of Cozy Mystery and to Fans of the Author. This book is scheduled to be released on 3/26/24.
I voluntarily read an advanced readers copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed here in this review are my own.
#ThreeFudgesandaBaby #NetGalley
Early in the book main character, sleuth Allie and her friend Jenn come upon a dead body while they are out for a walk. Jenn’s doula is in a daze and covered with blood. She’s holding a smoking gun and sitting on a stairway from her apartment, that comes down to the street . The murder victim is the doula’s fiancé. It doesn’t look good for Hannah Riverslund. She’s holding a gun at the scene of the crime. Earlier that morning Hannah and the victim, Matthew Jones were heard arguing loudly and now he’s dead. But there wasn’t any witnesses and no one heard a gunshot. Allie questions the new D.A. decision to arrest Hannah for the murder of her fiancé. Something isn’t right and everyone says Hannah wouldn’t kill anyone. If there is even a shred of doubt Allie feels led to investigate the murder. She wants to be sure the wrong person hasn’t been arrested while the real murderer runs free.
I recommend this book to readers of Cozy Mystery and to Fans of the Author. This book is scheduled to be released on 3/26/24.
I voluntarily read an advanced readers copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed here in this review are my own.
#ThreeFudgesandaBaby #NetGalley
October 13, 2024
"Three Fudges and a Baby (Candy-Coated Mysteries #12)" by Nancy Coco is mostly baby themed. However, this one annoyed me more than previous books in the series for a couple of reasons. I am going to be a bit harsher than I usually am. Sorry.
First was Allie's mother and Allie being a push over to her. Her mom shows up with zero warning expecting Allie to entertain her and an ex of Allie's, that she got to bring her. She goes so far as to basically call Allie rude for not being available. Yes, Allie has so much time while running a business that she can drop everything when her mom is unexpectedly around. Then Allie pretty much lets Jenn be the reason she can't do-things instead of just pointing out to her mother that's how things are when you give no warning of a visit and you run a business. If she can run the business she can stick up for herself with her mom a bit more. Not just try, then give up after one comment.
The second thing that really bothered me is the book, continuity issues, or Allie's lack of memory for things she's told or talked about. I've come to expect that of this series but this one has been the worst for that. She is told numerous times about a suspect's relationship to another and the victim, acts like she never knew. Gets told by the primary suspect information that is then never talked about and then changed. Seriously, at one point she's told some crucial information about the culprit but it goes right over her head with a different conclusion and can't get past that it's not a particular suspect she's already focused on. If she had been logical about it she would have caught the culprit sooner. Instead this one just keeps going on.
Over all though, it was a nice story for the Jenn narrative side of things. We get the birth of Jenn and Shane's baby. We still have relationship drama for Ali (which I hope is finally over in the next book). Honestly, it feels like the series is winding down to its final book or two. Which is probably good. They're getting to that repetitive spot some series hit.
First was Allie's mother and Allie being a push over to her. Her mom shows up with zero warning expecting Allie to entertain her and an ex of Allie's, that she got to bring her. She goes so far as to basically call Allie rude for not being available. Yes, Allie has so much time while running a business that she can drop everything when her mom is unexpectedly around. Then Allie pretty much lets Jenn be the reason she can't do-things instead of just pointing out to her mother that's how things are when you give no warning of a visit and you run a business. If she can run the business she can stick up for herself with her mom a bit more. Not just try, then give up after one comment.
The second thing that really bothered me is the book, continuity issues, or Allie's lack of memory for things she's told or talked about. I've come to expect that of this series but this one has been the worst for that. She is told numerous times about a suspect's relationship to another and the victim, acts like she never knew. Gets told by the primary suspect information that is then never talked about and then changed. Seriously, at one point she's told some crucial information about the culprit but it goes right over her head with a different conclusion and can't get past that it's not a particular suspect she's already focused on. If she had been logical about it she would have caught the culprit sooner. Instead this one just keeps going on.
Over all though, it was a nice story for the Jenn narrative side of things. We get the birth of Jenn and Shane's baby. We still have relationship drama for Ali (which I hope is finally over in the next book). Honestly, it feels like the series is winding down to its final book or two. Which is probably good. They're getting to that repetitive spot some series hit.
May 26, 2024
An okay story. I felt the mystery was overshadowed by all the conflict going on with the protagonist and the main supporting characters (which I tired of quickly). Jenn, the best friend, is a mess waiting to go into labor. Allie and Rex have the usual conflicts about Allie putting herself in danger. And, Allie’s mother trying to run her life was ridiculous. This was my least favorite story of the entire series, thus far. At least the pets were their normal sweet selves.
March 23, 2024
It had been yet another hectic week for Allie, the owner of the Historic McMurphy Hotel and Fudge Shop. Heading to a meeting with Jenn’s doula, Allie and her best friend Jenn stumbled upon a dead body. Unfortunately, that grim discovery wasn’t the only unpleasant shock of the week. With relationship issues, mother troubles, and a murder investigation underway, one wonders if Allie’s situation could get any worse?
This latest installment in the Candy-Coated Mystery series is an entertaining addition. The book presents an engaging mystery set against the picturesque backdrop of Mackinac Island, featuring a varied ensemble of characters. Thanks to Kensington and NetGalley for an ARC. The opinions expressed are mine.
This latest installment in the Candy-Coated Mystery series is an entertaining addition. The book presents an engaging mystery set against the picturesque backdrop of Mackinac Island, featuring a varied ensemble of characters. Thanks to Kensington and NetGalley for an ARC. The opinions expressed are mine.
May 17, 2024
What an amazing story. Filled with twists and turns plus a few surprises along the way. Loved the ending and can’t wait to read the next book.
April 1, 2024
Hmm I’m not sure what to rate this book. I was screaming who the killer was from the beginning but she was sooo blinded by who she assumed it was she couldn’t see the killer. I don’t get how she thinks she solved any murders at this point. She is always attacked by the actual killer and then figured it out in what I call final boss speech. Also alll the drama with her relationship with Rex and her mother. I would cut off her mother; she was so frustrating her meddling in her personal life and her work life. I feel like I must be the only person that hates Ross in friends but agrees. They were on a break. Her break with Rex , fine I guess but then confides in a man that wants her and she knows it and when confronted with that is like but I was honest with you. I have felt like she deserved better a lot in this series but now Rex deserves better. How hurtful! Also, I don’t get how we are in book 11 and still have hints of a love triangle. I’m so over it. I think I am done with the series….
April 27, 2024
Dollycas’s Thoughts
Spring on Mackinac Island means the “fudgies” are coming! It also means it is time for Allie McMurphy’s best friend Jenn Carpenter to deliver her baby, but it seems Baby Carpenter is in no hurry to exit the safe, warm, comfort of Mama’s womb. Her midwife and doula assure her that being two weeks late is no big deal but she is more than ready for the baby to embark on their trip down the birth canal so she can see her toes again.
Movement is a good way to start labor whether it be walking or waddling so Jenn and Allie walk down to the Coffee Bean to meet her doula, Hannah Riversbend. But when they take a shortcut down an alley they find Hannah holding a gun and her fiance, Matthew Jones dead on the ground. It is clear the woman is in shock and she says she didn’t kill him but she was holding the gun.
With her doula in the slammer, Jenn is freaking out. She begs Allie to find the real killer fast. She can’t give birth without Hannah. She is going to be busy making fudge but she can’t let her friend down, so she decides to find out how to do it all, and oh, did I forget to mention her mother is in town with an agenda of her own?
McMurphy Hotel and Fudge Shop owner Allie McMurphy has her hands full in Three Fudges and A Baby and she rolls with just a couple of missteps, just as I have come to expect. Business is brisk and she needs to hire an assistant as soon as possible. Her mother makes a surprise visit and expects her to drop everything so that she can get back together with her old boyfriend because he has money and her current boyfriend, Officer Rex Manning is not good enough for her. Jenn is cranky and rightly so, being nine and a half months pregnant is not fun. And now Allie has a murder to solve. She is a fantastic protagonist and all the people Ms. Coco has put in her orbit are cleverly created and true to life, even Allie’s mother.
The mystery is well-plotted with plenty of twists. Rex wasn’t totally on board with Heather Riversbend being the killer but he had to follow the evidence. He takes a huge chance to help Jenn. He is such a good guy. Hear that Mrs. McMurphy! Allie gets help from the “seniors” as she and her puppy Mal try to figure out who has a motive to kill Matthew Jones. Gossip starts to run rampant on the island and in a surprising turn Allie makes a deal with the devil. So much happens within the pages of the book that the pages were absolutely flying. The takedown was scary but I had the right guilty party at the top of my personal suspect list and that always feels good.
Mackinac Island is a special place that I have always wanted to visit. I may never actually make the trip so for now I settle for the virtual trips Ms. Coco takes me on in this series. I know there is nothing like fudge made by a professional like Allie, but the author includes easy recipes at the start of several chapters. I suggest picking one to make before you start reading because you will be craving fudge.
Three Fudges and A Baby is a wonderful addition to this series. It is full of engaging characters, sans a meddling mother and an intriguing mystery set on the #1 Best Island in the Continental U.S. The final paragraphs of the book are not going to make Allie’s mother happy but I am thrilled. The teaser chapter has me longing for April 2025 when Fudge and Murder is set to be released.
Spring on Mackinac Island means the “fudgies” are coming! It also means it is time for Allie McMurphy’s best friend Jenn Carpenter to deliver her baby, but it seems Baby Carpenter is in no hurry to exit the safe, warm, comfort of Mama’s womb. Her midwife and doula assure her that being two weeks late is no big deal but she is more than ready for the baby to embark on their trip down the birth canal so she can see her toes again.
Movement is a good way to start labor whether it be walking or waddling so Jenn and Allie walk down to the Coffee Bean to meet her doula, Hannah Riversbend. But when they take a shortcut down an alley they find Hannah holding a gun and her fiance, Matthew Jones dead on the ground. It is clear the woman is in shock and she says she didn’t kill him but she was holding the gun.
With her doula in the slammer, Jenn is freaking out. She begs Allie to find the real killer fast. She can’t give birth without Hannah. She is going to be busy making fudge but she can’t let her friend down, so she decides to find out how to do it all, and oh, did I forget to mention her mother is in town with an agenda of her own?
McMurphy Hotel and Fudge Shop owner Allie McMurphy has her hands full in Three Fudges and A Baby and she rolls with just a couple of missteps, just as I have come to expect. Business is brisk and she needs to hire an assistant as soon as possible. Her mother makes a surprise visit and expects her to drop everything so that she can get back together with her old boyfriend because he has money and her current boyfriend, Officer Rex Manning is not good enough for her. Jenn is cranky and rightly so, being nine and a half months pregnant is not fun. And now Allie has a murder to solve. She is a fantastic protagonist and all the people Ms. Coco has put in her orbit are cleverly created and true to life, even Allie’s mother.
The mystery is well-plotted with plenty of twists. Rex wasn’t totally on board with Heather Riversbend being the killer but he had to follow the evidence. He takes a huge chance to help Jenn. He is such a good guy. Hear that Mrs. McMurphy! Allie gets help from the “seniors” as she and her puppy Mal try to figure out who has a motive to kill Matthew Jones. Gossip starts to run rampant on the island and in a surprising turn Allie makes a deal with the devil. So much happens within the pages of the book that the pages were absolutely flying. The takedown was scary but I had the right guilty party at the top of my personal suspect list and that always feels good.
Mackinac Island is a special place that I have always wanted to visit. I may never actually make the trip so for now I settle for the virtual trips Ms. Coco takes me on in this series. I know there is nothing like fudge made by a professional like Allie, but the author includes easy recipes at the start of several chapters. I suggest picking one to make before you start reading because you will be craving fudge.
Three Fudges and A Baby is a wonderful addition to this series. It is full of engaging characters, sans a meddling mother and an intriguing mystery set on the #1 Best Island in the Continental U.S. The final paragraphs of the book are not going to make Allie’s mother happy but I am thrilled. The teaser chapter has me longing for April 2025 when Fudge and Murder is set to be released.
January 9, 2024
Three Fudges and a Baby by Nancy Coco is a sweet culinary cozy mystery that is the 12 th book in the delightful Candy-Coated Mystery series.
I have really enjoyed all twelve books in this series thus far. This was a nice addition. Mackinac Island is such a unique and special location, amd makes for a perfect local for this series. I also liked that Allie’s friend, Jenn, gets a spotlight in this installment when her doula is the suspect in a murder…Allie and company to the rescue…
4/5 stars
Thank you NG and Kensington Books for this wonderful arc and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion.
I am posting this review to my GR and Bookbub accounts immediately and will post it to my Amazon, Instagram, and B&N accounts upon publication on 3/26/24.
I have really enjoyed all twelve books in this series thus far. This was a nice addition. Mackinac Island is such a unique and special location, amd makes for a perfect local for this series. I also liked that Allie’s friend, Jenn, gets a spotlight in this installment when her doula is the suspect in a murder…Allie and company to the rescue…
4/5 stars
Thank you NG and Kensington Books for this wonderful arc and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion.
I am posting this review to my GR and Bookbub accounts immediately and will post it to my Amazon, Instagram, and B&N accounts upon publication on 3/26/24.
April 5, 2024
Too much exposition, and it's awkward and clunky. It reads like a children's chapter book. "My name is Allie, and I was preparing for my third season on Mackinac Island." The characters feel really shallow. The main character's best friend is distraught because her doula has been arrested. Her dialogue is so stilted and childlike.
*
“I love you,” she blubbered. Her voice was shaking. “But you don’t know anything about having babies. I need Hannah’s comfort and calm soul!”
“I don’t want a different solution,” she wailed. “I want Hannah!”
*
Comfort and a calm soul are not precluded to doulas.
I feel like this book has a shoddy grasp of facts. Here's another example: the district attorney, if brusque, is correct -- you shouldn't let cats roam freely outside. They kill native birds, and their feces is toxic. Also, the "bodycon" outfit Allie wears to the fancy dinner is an odd choice. Bodycon, especially the strapless, short dress she describes, is for clubbing or raves, not formal dinners or weddings. It feels like the author just wanted to describe something "sexy" without really giving a thought to what would actually be worn at such an event. It's also a misogynistic double standard on the author's part that a full face of makeup makes Allie look "stunning," whereas previously a woman with a full face of makeup is described to be "unstable" and is rude and antagonistic.
I am not Black myself, so I can't speak definitively to this, but in my opinion it's a little fetish-y when skin tone is described as "chocolate."
I'm not here for the overbearing mother trope. This series would be a better "kid detective" mystery. And while we're at it, please lose the "crazy ex-girlfriend" trope, plus the "evil bitch villian with too much makeup trope." Enough said. I'm still not over that painfully detailed paragraph describing every last bit of makeup on that poor woman's face. Makeup is morally neutral, people. Contour and microbladed eyebrows don't make you an evil person any more than putting on a green shirt or a purple shirt.
Dear lord, and the "boyfriend's ex-wife" trope. It's almost impressive how many misogynistic stereotypes this author can cram into one book. If the rest of this book was just the word "cunt" over and over, it would be less offensive.
It's always terribly sticky to figure out a way to have the main character plausibly investigate and figure out the murder each time, and often this involves them putting themselves into catastrophically stupid situations. Rex isn't wrong when he says that Allie should leave the investigating to the professionals. It's stupid at best, dangerous and illegal at worst for a civilian to be doing what she does.
I felt that Rex asking Allie to marry him, and then her being interrupted by her phone and not answering him was a little ridiculous and contrived. I'm not really sure what the author is trying to do here with the overarching story, but I do hope it gets resolved.
Also, when you're toasting, it's "hear, hear," not "here, here." How in the world did the editor miss that?
I quite like the idea of Harry as a love interest, even if it does make Allie veer into Mary Sue territory. It is a little ironic that she was dogging on Rex for treating her like a princess in a tower who needed to be saved, but then Harry actually saved her by buying out her contract. I'm not sure why the author would pick up this plotline again to immediately throw it away.
*
“I love you,” she blubbered. Her voice was shaking. “But you don’t know anything about having babies. I need Hannah’s comfort and calm soul!”
“I don’t want a different solution,” she wailed. “I want Hannah!”
*
Comfort and a calm soul are not precluded to doulas.
I feel like this book has a shoddy grasp of facts. Here's another example: the district attorney, if brusque, is correct -- you shouldn't let cats roam freely outside. They kill native birds, and their feces is toxic. Also, the "bodycon" outfit Allie wears to the fancy dinner is an odd choice. Bodycon, especially the strapless, short dress she describes, is for clubbing or raves, not formal dinners or weddings. It feels like the author just wanted to describe something "sexy" without really giving a thought to what would actually be worn at such an event. It's also a misogynistic double standard on the author's part that a full face of makeup makes Allie look "stunning," whereas previously a woman with a full face of makeup is described to be "unstable" and is rude and antagonistic.
I am not Black myself, so I can't speak definitively to this, but in my opinion it's a little fetish-y when skin tone is described as "chocolate."
I'm not here for the overbearing mother trope. This series would be a better "kid detective" mystery. And while we're at it, please lose the "crazy ex-girlfriend" trope, plus the "evil bitch villian with too much makeup trope." Enough said. I'm still not over that painfully detailed paragraph describing every last bit of makeup on that poor woman's face. Makeup is morally neutral, people. Contour and microbladed eyebrows don't make you an evil person any more than putting on a green shirt or a purple shirt.
Dear lord, and the "boyfriend's ex-wife" trope. It's almost impressive how many misogynistic stereotypes this author can cram into one book. If the rest of this book was just the word "cunt" over and over, it would be less offensive.
It's always terribly sticky to figure out a way to have the main character plausibly investigate and figure out the murder each time, and often this involves them putting themselves into catastrophically stupid situations. Rex isn't wrong when he says that Allie should leave the investigating to the professionals. It's stupid at best, dangerous and illegal at worst for a civilian to be doing what she does.
I felt that Rex asking Allie to marry him, and then her being interrupted by her phone and not answering him was a little ridiculous and contrived. I'm not really sure what the author is trying to do here with the overarching story, but I do hope it gets resolved.
Also, when you're toasting, it's "hear, hear," not "here, here." How in the world did the editor miss that?
I quite like the idea of Harry as a love interest, even if it does make Allie veer into Mary Sue territory. It is a little ironic that she was dogging on Rex for treating her like a princess in a tower who needed to be saved, but then Harry actually saved her by buying out her contract. I'm not sure why the author would pick up this plotline again to immediately throw it away.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 14, 2024
As the weather begins to warm up a little on Mackinac Island, Allie McMurphy, local hotelier and award winning fudge maker, is very busy indeed. Alongside all her usual tasks, she is keeping a watchful eye on her best friend, Jenn, who is now two weeks over her due date and desperate for her first baby to arrive. When Hannah Riversbend, the carefully chosen doula, is suddenly the main suspect in a murder case, panic ensues. Jenn is sure the young woman is innocent and absolutely certain she can't give birth without her there and begs Allie to find the real killer fast.
Unfortunately, as the investigation begins to take shape Allie’s mom arrives on the island with an old flame she hasn't seen since they graduated college together, when he proposed! With Jenn's doctor wanting her to head to the mainland to be induced, and Allie’s boyfriend, police officer Rex Manning, not at all thrilled by the arrival of Brett or her mother, both of whom want more of her than she has to spare, Allie isn't sure she won't be breaking the promise she made to her BFF especially as one of the consequences of that promise could ruin her reputation on Mackinac forever.
Book thirteen in this fun cosy series did have a few problems but was still a good read and set the scene for exciting times ahead. Allie, Rex, and Jenn were on great form, and I enjoyed her Mom's visit very much, especially as she was such an awful woman! My main concern was the actual killer’s identity because when the relevant information was discovered no one seemed able to take the next logical step when I think most of the readers would which proved to be both a disappointing and anticlimactic way to finish the investigation. I gave the book 3.5/4 stars because the rest of the storyline, which didn't include the latter part of the whodunnit, were great, and I enjoyed them the most.
I was able to read an advanced copy of this book thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Kensington Books, but the opinions expressed are my own. Although this didn't hit all the high notes, there is a teaser chapter from book 14, and I definitely can't wait to read that.
Unfortunately, as the investigation begins to take shape Allie’s mom arrives on the island with an old flame she hasn't seen since they graduated college together, when he proposed! With Jenn's doctor wanting her to head to the mainland to be induced, and Allie’s boyfriend, police officer Rex Manning, not at all thrilled by the arrival of Brett or her mother, both of whom want more of her than she has to spare, Allie isn't sure she won't be breaking the promise she made to her BFF especially as one of the consequences of that promise could ruin her reputation on Mackinac forever.
Book thirteen in this fun cosy series did have a few problems but was still a good read and set the scene for exciting times ahead. Allie, Rex, and Jenn were on great form, and I enjoyed her Mom's visit very much, especially as she was such an awful woman! My main concern was the actual killer’s identity because when the relevant information was discovered no one seemed able to take the next logical step when I think most of the readers would which proved to be both a disappointing and anticlimactic way to finish the investigation. I gave the book 3.5/4 stars because the rest of the storyline, which didn't include the latter part of the whodunnit, were great, and I enjoyed them the most.
I was able to read an advanced copy of this book thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Kensington Books, but the opinions expressed are my own. Although this didn't hit all the high notes, there is a teaser chapter from book 14, and I definitely can't wait to read that.
April 10, 2024
Still one of my favorite series. And this one did not disappoint me. Cannot wait for the next one.
January 19, 2024
Three Fudges and a Baby is the twelfth installment in the Candy Coated Mystery series set on Mackinac Island and featuring fudge maker Allie McMurphy. Allie is starting her third season on the island and business has been great at her family's Historic McMurphy Hotel and Fudge Shop.
Allie's best friend Jenn Carpenter is expecting her first baby with husband Shane. Jenn has hired a midwife and doula so that she can have the baby on the island. When Hannah Riversbend, the doula doesn't answer Jenn's texts, Allie and Jenn along with Allie's furry companion Mal, make their way to Hannah's house. There they find the woman sitting on the steps, holding a gun and the body of her finance dead just feet away.
Convinced that Hannah wouldn't hurt a fly, Jenn asks Allie to please find the real killer and clear Hannah's name in time for the birth of her son. Allie teams up with boyfriend, Officer Rex Manning to solve the murder and along the way has to deal with her overbearing mother and an ex-boyfriend.
A great addition to the series with a surprising twist at the end. Featuring returning characters, furry companions and delicious recipes, this installment proved to be another fun filled romp on Mackinac Island.
I received an advanced copy of Three Fudges and a Baby from NetGalley via Kensington Publishing. While not required to write a review I am happy to offer my honest opinion.
Allie's best friend Jenn Carpenter is expecting her first baby with husband Shane. Jenn has hired a midwife and doula so that she can have the baby on the island. When Hannah Riversbend, the doula doesn't answer Jenn's texts, Allie and Jenn along with Allie's furry companion Mal, make their way to Hannah's house. There they find the woman sitting on the steps, holding a gun and the body of her finance dead just feet away.
Convinced that Hannah wouldn't hurt a fly, Jenn asks Allie to please find the real killer and clear Hannah's name in time for the birth of her son. Allie teams up with boyfriend, Officer Rex Manning to solve the murder and along the way has to deal with her overbearing mother and an ex-boyfriend.
A great addition to the series with a surprising twist at the end. Featuring returning characters, furry companions and delicious recipes, this installment proved to be another fun filled romp on Mackinac Island.
I received an advanced copy of Three Fudges and a Baby from NetGalley via Kensington Publishing. While not required to write a review I am happy to offer my honest opinion.
April 29, 2024
It's spring on Mackinac Island and Allie McMurphy is happy to have survived her second winter. The McMurphy hotel is doing better than ever and her fudge business is keeping her so busy she'll need an assistant for the busy summer season. Allie's BFF Jenn is overdue with her first baby and is very anxious. Jen is adamant about having the baby on the island and has lined up the best doula to help her. When Hannah is late for an appointment with Jenn, Allie and Jenn go in search of the doula only to find her holding a nearly smoking gun over her fiancé, Matthew. Hannah appears to be in a state of shock and can't tell them anything. There's a new hotshot DA in town and he's eager for a win. He seems to think this case is a slam dunk and is ready to convict Hannah! Jenn knows Hannah is a kind, gentle soul and would never do such a thing. Besides, she was devoted to Matthew and he to her. Jenn DEMANDS Allie solve the mystery before she gives birth. With contractions coming quickly, Allie is running out of time. Can she reach a compromise so Hannah can deliver the baby? Meanwhile, Allie's mother comes to visit unexpectedly, bringing along Allie's ex-boyfriend, Brett, intending to play matchmaker. Allie isn't interested in rekindling her romance with Brett or his sleazy resort project but in order to help Jenn and save Hannah, she made need his help.
I love the cozy setting in this series and I continue to read it for the fudge and the adorable BichonPoo puppy, Mal. This murder was a bit disappointing since Mal didn't exactly discover the body. She did lead Jenn and Allie towards the scene of the crime but this time, Mella was already there. I enjoyed the gag of Mal finding a body and Allie calling 911 and the operator asking if this is Allie McMurphy and who is dead now. It was cute and funny. This story is not so cute and funny. The murder victim was a great guy who didn't deserve to be gunned down, let alone only in his 20s. That gave the mystery a much darker tone than normal. Also the railroading of the doula made the story rather intense. Then there is a subplot about Allie and her mother, Jen's whining and the prolonged agony of the love triangle. Needless to say, this was not my favorite book in the series.
Allie is NEARLY as great a sleuth as Hannah Swensen! Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder Like Hannah, everyone thinks Allie is such a great sleuth and has solved all these murders, but has she? No she has not. I don't think there has been a murder she's figured out before the killer came after her. She's been nearly killed over and over again and gotten friends hurt in the process. This time the killer boasts and all but confesses and Allie ignores the obvious. She's given the information more than once too!
Allie has some nerve bristling at Rex's concern over her involvement in the mystery! He's perfectly right and he's also a trained professional and she's not. He knows how to handle himself in tense situations because he's been trained to do so. He also loves Allie for some unknown reason and doesn't want to see her get hurt. I think Rex needs to move on! Allie is too immature to communicate her feelings effectively but Rex, having been married and divorced twice, knows better. They need to work out these issues before they get back together. Allie also needs to learn how to communicate with her mother. I get it. Her mother is just awful. She doesn't see Allie, get Allie or even listen to what Allie is trying to tell her. She's pushing Allie to be what SHE thinks Allie should be like and want what SHE wants. If she wants her daughter to live closer to home and raise a family nearby, just say so. Allie loved her grandfather, she loves the hotel and making fudge and after 2 years, I think she's more Islander than Fudgie. Parents need to back off and let their adult children make their own decisions and learn lessons on their own. Now, where Allie's mother could be useful is in counseling Allie in how to work on her relationship with Rex.
Usually I like Jenn better than Allie but here she is just obnoxious. I've never been pregnant so I don't know what she's feeling and don't empathize with her. She acts like she's the only person to ever give birth and Hannah is the ONLY person who can help her do this. The nurse, Esha, seems nice and cheerful. I'm sure she would be great in the delivery room. Jenn acts entitled and witchy. What if another woman was in labor at the same time and needed Hannah too? Would Jenn share? I don't think she would. Shane is very sweet and supportive, if a bit nervous and over protective. Yes her mother would drive me crazy too and I certainly would have banned her in advance, same with the in-laws. Jenn and Shane should have set up the ground rules to begin with before the families showed up. I don't have a whole lot of sympathy for Jenn. (Her name is spelled both Jenn and Jen. I thought it was Jen with one n?)
Carol Tunisian and the book club ladies get involved in this one too. They don't always agree but they feel the need to do something. I feel like they don't understand the reality of the situation and it's a game to them. It gives them mental stimulation and something to do. Sure no one hears as much gossip as the seniors in the senior center but they better be careful.
The only character I like and feel sympathy for in this novel is Hannah. Hannah seems sweet, kind and calm. She was devoted to Matthew and prepared to marry him. There is not any rumor or hearsay that paints Hannah in a bad light. Only one minor piece of gossip from someone who supposedly witnessed an argument between them. Yet, that's only one story from one person. Shouldn't character count for something? What motive would Hannah have for killing Matt? Now, his ex-girlfriend, Angel, is Allie's top suspect and mine too. She's one of those women who isn't happy unless she has two men fighting over her. Her methods are less than ethical. She lies and cheats to get her own way and win over whichever man she wants at the time. Matthew is "boring" so she wants Vincent. Vincent won't marry her so she wants Matt back but she really wants Vincent and is using Matt to make Vinnie jealous. I think she's lying to them both and trying to trap Vinnie into marrying her. He sounds like a real prize (said sarcastically). They deserve each other.
I kind of like Harry Winston but he presumes too much and doesn't consult or tell Allie. He takes advantage of her vulnerability to do something for her, to be her knight in shining armor. Matt's parents seem like lovely people. They both have limited mobility and enjoy having people over to visit. That may be a problem as someone has stolen the father's gun! With everyone in the neighborhood having access to the house, there's unlimited suspect possibilities!
Monica Grazer, owner of a nearby what-not shop, is sometimes friendly and sometimes bristly. She enjoys gossiping about other people but I think she's spreading rumors on purpose. The new DA is rude and arrogant. He offers unsolicited advice about Mella without knowing Allie or Mella's situation. Then he proceeds to accuse Hannah of murder and make all kinds of assumptions based on no evidence at all. I'm wondering if he is the actual murderer and putting the blame on Hannah. He doesn't sound trustworthy to me. While Matthew's co-worker Joan is shocked and upset by the news of his murder, co-worker Victoria is less upset. She says she didn't know Matthew well and seems like she's more interested in the murder as a true crime TV special than as the death of someone she knew and worked with. Maybe she knows who may have killed Matthew and wants to solve this one on her own?
Allie's ex is an ex for a reason. Brett is kind of sleazy. He's a wannabe politician and all he cares about is status. He has money already and if he's going to marry Allie, he expects her to be a trophy wife and entertain his political cronies with her culinary skills. He doesn't understand or appreciate what she's trying to tell him about the island and why people visit. He has a vision that doesn't fit the character of the island and is determined to railroad it through. I thought Trent and the Jessops were bad! Brett is even worse. When Allie needs help, he comes through with a quid pro quo. That seems ominous to me. I hope Allie read that contract!
I will probably read the next book in the series but I'm tired of Allie and hope she matures between this book and the next.
I love the cozy setting in this series and I continue to read it for the fudge and the adorable BichonPoo puppy, Mal. This murder was a bit disappointing since Mal didn't exactly discover the body. She did lead Jenn and Allie towards the scene of the crime but this time, Mella was already there. I enjoyed the gag of Mal finding a body and Allie calling 911 and the operator asking if this is Allie McMurphy and who is dead now. It was cute and funny. This story is not so cute and funny. The murder victim was a great guy who didn't deserve to be gunned down, let alone only in his 20s. That gave the mystery a much darker tone than normal. Also the railroading of the doula made the story rather intense. Then there is a subplot about Allie and her mother, Jen's whining and the prolonged agony of the love triangle. Needless to say, this was not my favorite book in the series.
Allie is NEARLY as great a sleuth as Hannah Swensen! Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder Like Hannah, everyone thinks Allie is such a great sleuth and has solved all these murders, but has she? No she has not. I don't think there has been a murder she's figured out before the killer came after her. She's been nearly killed over and over again and gotten friends hurt in the process. This time the killer boasts and all but confesses and Allie ignores the obvious. She's given the information more than once too!
Allie has some nerve bristling at Rex's concern over her involvement in the mystery! He's perfectly right and he's also a trained professional and she's not. He knows how to handle himself in tense situations because he's been trained to do so. He also loves Allie for some unknown reason and doesn't want to see her get hurt. I think Rex needs to move on! Allie is too immature to communicate her feelings effectively but Rex, having been married and divorced twice, knows better. They need to work out these issues before they get back together. Allie also needs to learn how to communicate with her mother. I get it. Her mother is just awful. She doesn't see Allie, get Allie or even listen to what Allie is trying to tell her. She's pushing Allie to be what SHE thinks Allie should be like and want what SHE wants. If she wants her daughter to live closer to home and raise a family nearby, just say so. Allie loved her grandfather, she loves the hotel and making fudge and after 2 years, I think she's more Islander than Fudgie. Parents need to back off and let their adult children make their own decisions and learn lessons on their own. Now, where Allie's mother could be useful is in counseling Allie in how to work on her relationship with Rex.
Usually I like Jenn better than Allie but here she is just obnoxious. I've never been pregnant so I don't know what she's feeling and don't empathize with her. She acts like she's the only person to ever give birth and Hannah is the ONLY person who can help her do this. The nurse, Esha, seems nice and cheerful. I'm sure she would be great in the delivery room. Jenn acts entitled and witchy. What if another woman was in labor at the same time and needed Hannah too? Would Jenn share? I don't think she would. Shane is very sweet and supportive, if a bit nervous and over protective. Yes her mother would drive me crazy too and I certainly would have banned her in advance, same with the in-laws. Jenn and Shane should have set up the ground rules to begin with before the families showed up. I don't have a whole lot of sympathy for Jenn. (Her name is spelled both Jenn and Jen. I thought it was Jen with one n?)
Carol Tunisian and the book club ladies get involved in this one too. They don't always agree but they feel the need to do something. I feel like they don't understand the reality of the situation and it's a game to them. It gives them mental stimulation and something to do. Sure no one hears as much gossip as the seniors in the senior center but they better be careful.
The only character I like and feel sympathy for in this novel is Hannah. Hannah seems sweet, kind and calm. She was devoted to Matthew and prepared to marry him. There is not any rumor or hearsay that paints Hannah in a bad light. Only one minor piece of gossip from someone who supposedly witnessed an argument between them. Yet, that's only one story from one person. Shouldn't character count for something? What motive would Hannah have for killing Matt? Now, his ex-girlfriend, Angel, is Allie's top suspect and mine too. She's one of those women who isn't happy unless she has two men fighting over her. Her methods are less than ethical. She lies and cheats to get her own way and win over whichever man she wants at the time. Matthew is "boring" so she wants Vincent. Vincent won't marry her so she wants Matt back but she really wants Vincent and is using Matt to make Vinnie jealous. I think she's lying to them both and trying to trap Vinnie into marrying her. He sounds like a real prize (said sarcastically). They deserve each other.
I kind of like Harry Winston but he presumes too much and doesn't consult or tell Allie. He takes advantage of her vulnerability to do something for her, to be her knight in shining armor. Matt's parents seem like lovely people. They both have limited mobility and enjoy having people over to visit. That may be a problem as someone has stolen the father's gun! With everyone in the neighborhood having access to the house, there's unlimited suspect possibilities!
Monica Grazer, owner of a nearby what-not shop, is sometimes friendly and sometimes bristly. She enjoys gossiping about other people but I think she's spreading rumors on purpose. The new DA is rude and arrogant. He offers unsolicited advice about Mella without knowing Allie or Mella's situation. Then he proceeds to accuse Hannah of murder and make all kinds of assumptions based on no evidence at all. I'm wondering if he is the actual murderer and putting the blame on Hannah. He doesn't sound trustworthy to me. While Matthew's co-worker Joan is shocked and upset by the news of his murder, co-worker Victoria is less upset. She says she didn't know Matthew well and seems like she's more interested in the murder as a true crime TV special than as the death of someone she knew and worked with. Maybe she knows who may have killed Matthew and wants to solve this one on her own?
Allie's ex is an ex for a reason. Brett is kind of sleazy. He's a wannabe politician and all he cares about is status. He has money already and if he's going to marry Allie, he expects her to be a trophy wife and entertain his political cronies with her culinary skills. He doesn't understand or appreciate what she's trying to tell him about the island and why people visit. He has a vision that doesn't fit the character of the island and is determined to railroad it through. I thought Trent and the Jessops were bad! Brett is even worse. When Allie needs help, he comes through with a quid pro quo. That seems ominous to me. I hope Allie read that contract!
I will probably read the next book in the series but I'm tired of Allie and hope she matures between this book and the next.
February 8, 2024
Through NetGalley, I received a free copy of THREE FUDGES AND A BABY (Book 12 of the Candy Coated Mystery series) by Nancy Coco in exchange for an honest review. Jenn Carpenter, Allie’s event planner and best friend, is overdue. Jenn’s pregnancy has run two weeks late, and Jenn refuses to give birth without the assistance of her doula. That is a problem because the doula, Hannah Riversbend, is currently under arrest for murdering her fiancé. To get Jenn her doula, Allie has to cut a deal with a devil Meanwhile, Allie’s mom causes trouble between Allie and her boyfriend; Allie’s mom shows up with Allie’s highly successful high school boyfriend and pushes Allie to re-ignite the relationship. In order to avoid the matchmaking of her mamma and to help out Hannah and Jenn, Allie once again tries to catch a killer.
I like the book and the series. I recommend this book to fans of the series and the series to fans of cozy murder mysteries featuring family businesses, island life, candy making, tourist seasons, and furry friends.
#ThreeFudgesandaBaby #NetGalley
I like the book and the series. I recommend this book to fans of the series and the series to fans of cozy murder mysteries featuring family businesses, island life, candy making, tourist seasons, and furry friends.
#ThreeFudgesandaBaby #NetGalley
December 26, 2023
#ThreeFudgesandaBaby #NetGalley Allie McMurphy is back in the 12th addition to this wonderful series.
Allie's best friend Jenn is 2 weeks overdue for her baby, she's tired, uncomfortable, and cranky. All she wants is to have her baby, but when her Doula is suspected of murder, Jenn begs Allie to find the real killer.
I really loved this book, there were so many emotions and twists and turns that I stayed up late to finish it.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for selecting me to read an advanced copy of the book.
Allie's best friend Jenn is 2 weeks overdue for her baby, she's tired, uncomfortable, and cranky. All she wants is to have her baby, but when her Doula is suspected of murder, Jenn begs Allie to find the real killer.
I really loved this book, there were so many emotions and twists and turns that I stayed up late to finish it.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for selecting me to read an advanced copy of the book.
April 9, 2024
I must be the only one who thought the major plot line of this book to be a big stretch. Additionally, I don't see/feel the chemistry between Allie and Rex.
March 22, 2024
Fudgie season is about to blow wide open on Mackinac Island, which means that Allie is about to be very busy. More importantly, her bestie, Jenn, is about to give birth. As a matter of fact, she is two weeks overdue. When Hanna (Jenn's doula) is found standing over her the dead body of her future husband, Allie knows everything is about to implode. She does not believe that mild-mannered Hanna, who makes her living helping new mothers during the birthing process, would hurt a flea, much less her future husband. However, she is literally holding the smoking gun, which means it does not look good for her.
Jenn is frantic to get Hanna out of jail before she has her baby. This means Allie and company need to solve the mystery of who killed Matthew quickly. To make matters even more difficult for Allie, her over-bearing mother shows up at the hotel with Allie's ex-boyfriend, Brett. She is convinced that Allie needs to give up the hotel and marry Brett. Her mother drives me crazy. She is so snobby with her nose stuck so high in the air she would drown if it rained. Then you have slimy Brett. I do not trust him as far as I can throw him. I do love all of Allie's friends on the island, and I believe her and Rex belong together. We will just have to wait and see.
This was another fun mystery to solve in the Candy Coated Mystery series. I always enjoy the descriptions of the fudge, and the recipes that are shared will make your mouth water. My favorite character is the little white dog on the cover, Mal. Mal charms everyone she meets. A good cozy mystery is not complete without a cute dog or cat. The mystery was fun to try and solve as there were several suspects to choose from. Caution - reading this book will make you hungry for chocolate.
Thank you to Kensington Books and NetGalley for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Jenn is frantic to get Hanna out of jail before she has her baby. This means Allie and company need to solve the mystery of who killed Matthew quickly. To make matters even more difficult for Allie, her over-bearing mother shows up at the hotel with Allie's ex-boyfriend, Brett. She is convinced that Allie needs to give up the hotel and marry Brett. Her mother drives me crazy. She is so snobby with her nose stuck so high in the air she would drown if it rained. Then you have slimy Brett. I do not trust him as far as I can throw him. I do love all of Allie's friends on the island, and I believe her and Rex belong together. We will just have to wait and see.
This was another fun mystery to solve in the Candy Coated Mystery series. I always enjoy the descriptions of the fudge, and the recipes that are shared will make your mouth water. My favorite character is the little white dog on the cover, Mal. Mal charms everyone she meets. A good cozy mystery is not complete without a cute dog or cat. The mystery was fun to try and solve as there were several suspects to choose from. Caution - reading this book will make you hungry for chocolate.
Thank you to Kensington Books and NetGalley for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
April 26, 2024
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the chance to read this book!
As always I’m always grateful and happy to return to the wonderful cozy world Nancy Coco has created. The island of Mackinac is basically its own little world after all, and Ally our main protagonist has to interview and manage the local populace in order to solve a murder mystery, and quick! Her best friend Jenn is due to give birth any day, but refuses to face it without her beloved doula by her side. Ally needs to help her friend, but her mother has also arrived with her ex in tow and is determined to see her married and moved off island.
If this is your first dip into this delightful cozy series I recommend going back and reading the rest to get a real feel for both the atmosphere and character development so far. Each book is as enjoyable as the last and well worth the time spent on Mackinac. Although following the predictable cozy format, there is a certain joy I get from such books. It’s not groundbreaking or surprising and much like slipping on a well used shoe.
As always, a fun romp with great characters and settings. Five stars.
As always I’m always grateful and happy to return to the wonderful cozy world Nancy Coco has created. The island of Mackinac is basically its own little world after all, and Ally our main protagonist has to interview and manage the local populace in order to solve a murder mystery, and quick! Her best friend Jenn is due to give birth any day, but refuses to face it without her beloved doula by her side. Ally needs to help her friend, but her mother has also arrived with her ex in tow and is determined to see her married and moved off island.
If this is your first dip into this delightful cozy series I recommend going back and reading the rest to get a real feel for both the atmosphere and character development so far. Each book is as enjoyable as the last and well worth the time spent on Mackinac. Although following the predictable cozy format, there is a certain joy I get from such books. It’s not groundbreaking or surprising and much like slipping on a well used shoe.
As always, a fun romp with great characters and settings. Five stars.
April 30, 2025
When her pregnant best friend’s doula is found with a smoking gun, fudge maker Allie McMurphy’s sleuthing becomes a labor of love . . .
DID THE DOULA DO IT?
April is not only the start of “fudgie” season on picturesque Mackinac Island, it’s when Allie’s BFF Jenn Carpenter is due. Jenn wants to hav…
If there was a list of what not to expect when you’re expecting, right at the top would be coming upon your doula holding a gun over the body of her fiance. Clearly in shock, Hannah Riversbend claims not to have shot him. Jenn asks Ally to prove the doula’s innocence before her special delivery arrives. The clock is ticking as Ally races to solve the murder in time for Jenn’s bun to come out of the oven. . .
DID THE DOULA DO IT?
April is not only the start of “fudgie” season on picturesque Mackinac Island, it’s when Allie’s BFF Jenn Carpenter is due. Jenn wants to hav…
If there was a list of what not to expect when you’re expecting, right at the top would be coming upon your doula holding a gun over the body of her fiance. Clearly in shock, Hannah Riversbend claims not to have shot him. Jenn asks Ally to prove the doula’s innocence before her special delivery arrives. The clock is ticking as Ally races to solve the murder in time for Jenn’s bun to come out of the oven. . .
May 14, 2024
Another in the 'fudgy' series, this book tells the story of what happens when Allie's best friend, Jenn, is about to give birth when her doula is arrested for murder. There is much going on here, and Allie has to investigate and do everything she can to help the woman be released in time to help Jenn give birth. There is a lot of suspense and edgy action because of the impending baby. This is another satisfying book in this series.
February 11, 2024
I enjoy the Candy Coated Mysteries that Nancy writes. This is the 12th book in the series and it was enjoyable. So many questions surrounding the storyline. You definitely want to keep reading to see if they are answered the way you guessed they would be. Such a fun cozy mystery that you will enjoy for sure.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and the publisher. All words are my own.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and the publisher. All words are my own.
February 8, 2024
This is a fun cozy mystery read with great characters. Allie and Rex are dating. Allie owns her family's hotel and fudge making businesses on Mackinac Island. Rex is the chief of police. Allie is trying to solve a murder that her friend's doula is accused of. Allie knows she is innocent of killing her fiancé. She is being framed by the killer. Will Allie be able to solve this mystery and clear her friend before it's too late? Read it and find out! I received a complimentary copy of this book but was not required to leave a review.
February 6, 2024
Hannah Riversbend, Jenn's doula is accused of murdering her boyfriend , Matthew Jones. Jenn's due to deliver any day and only wants Hannah at her side to help her stay calm. But will Hannah be able to perform her duty or will she be prison bound. Can Allie find a way to clear Hannah if she is indeed innocent, without being the next victim? Will Jenn get her chosen doula or will she be forced to chose another? Must read to find out.
February 1, 2024
This one was a quick read for me and I enjoyed it. Fudge make Allie McMurphy sets out to help her pregnant friend Jenn's doula when she is found in the alley with her dead finance holding the murder weapon. The clock is ticking on this one, as Jenn is already two weeks overdue and could go into labor at any time!
Thanks to Netgalley for an arc of this book.
Thanks to Netgalley for an arc of this book.
January 23, 2024
I so love this series. The location is fun, unique, and there are great likeable characters. Then there's the fudge talk which always gives me a craving.
This book has us awaiting the birth of Jenn's child. While out with Allie, they come across a murder victim and are shocked at who supposedly did it. All this is at play throughout the book and built to keep us guessing.
We also have some visitors in Allie's life, not related to the murder. It causes her angst, some iffy behavior but I am happy to say things do work out and I am really looking forward to the next book.
Oh, and there is a baby!
5 stars for the fun.
Thank you to Kensington and NetGalley for allowing me to read this in exchange for a fair review.
This book has us awaiting the birth of Jenn's child. While out with Allie, they come across a murder victim and are shocked at who supposedly did it. All this is at play throughout the book and built to keep us guessing.
We also have some visitors in Allie's life, not related to the murder. It causes her angst, some iffy behavior but I am happy to say things do work out and I am really looking forward to the next book.
Oh, and there is a baby!
5 stars for the fun.
Thank you to Kensington and NetGalley for allowing me to read this in exchange for a fair review.
January 22, 2024
Another enjoyable addition to this series- it is a pleasure to see the characters continue to develop and grow while the plot lines remain fresh and innovative.
January 2, 2024
A nice addition to this series. You may solve the mystery before the reveal, but following the characters who are now your friends makes it worth the read
May 3, 2024
https://openbooksociety.com/article/t...
Brought to you by OBS Reviewer Jeanie
I fully enjoyed this new mystery in its series. If a humorous cozy mystery could be considered “feel good”, it would be this one. Allie and her friends on Mackinac Island have formed real friendships since she moved there. The authentic, charming setting is a delight for the senses, especially in the spring. Allie inherited the Historic McMurphy Hotel and Fudge Shop from her beloved grandfather, and running it is all she ever wanted to do. She is beginning her third tourist season, following her second full winter there. The murder and the person of interest were shocking and a challenge to solve. Several recipes for rich, sweet delights are included throughout the novel.
Those who live on Mackinac Island year-round are a special kind of hardy Midwest folks, including Allie and her boyfriend, Rex. Most are friendly and down-to-earth. It is a delight to learn more about the regular characters as well as appreciate those who are only in this novel. Who they are is demonstrated throughout, with just the right amount of background for their roles.
Jenn is Allie’s best friend and an expert party planner. She is also two weeks overdue with her and her husband Shane’s first baby. Jenn insisted on having an at-home delivery with her midwife, Sarah, in attendance, and her doula, Hannah. Worst case, she would deliver in the clinic on the island, but refused to leave the island for a hospital.
Jenn was to meet Hannah one morning, so Allie walked with her. They headed for the alley entrance to Hannah’s apartment, and saw Hannah turn into it. Her fiancé, Matthew, followed her. Before Allie and Jenn reached the alley, a young man in a hoodie ran out of it, almost knocking Jenn over. Monica, a shop owner, said that Matthew and Hannah had an animated, heated conversation moments earlier. They got almost to Hannah’s and saw a man lying on the ground at the stairway going up to Hannah’s. Hannah was sitting on the stairs, holding a gun, eyes open but unresponsive. Matthew had a puddle of blood around him. Jenn hurried away to call 911 while Allie checked to see if he was still alive, but it was too late. Allie, with the help of her calico cat, got the handgun and moved it away from Hannah. Police officers Rex and Charles arrived first. Within minutes, the new DA joined the scene.
Even though she couldn’t speak and was in shock, Hannah was the only person of interest in the death of her fiancé. The DA thought his first major case would bring notoriety to bolster his political aspirations. There is no way he could lose with Hannah having been found with the smoking gun and blood on her clothes, so the police work for the case was complete.
Jenn is horrified. She knows Hannah, and the doula was her only choice after researching several women to coach her and Shane through labor and delivery. Jenn’s wails and weeping had little effect on anybody. Allie, an amateur sleuth who has solved several murders since moving to Mackinac Island, visited Hannah as the shock wore off to ask questions about what happened. Hannah’s bail was set at a half million dollars. As a last resort to keep her friend calm and happy, Allie made a deal with the devil to pay Hannah’s bail before Jenn gave birth. She, with the help of some ladies from the senior center, looked into every aspect of the case. This time, blocked from finishing an official investigation, Rex is glad for her snooping. He believed in justice, not railroading someone to quickly close a case for an easy win.
In the meantime, Allie’s mother made a rare trip to Mackinac with Allie’s high school and college beau, who is now very wealthy and has his own political aspirations. He would do anything to get Allie to marry him, but she was over him a long time ago. Her love for Rex was worth more than a fortune.
This mystery kept me guessing, and huge surprises greeted me at the end! I had briefly considered the real bad guy, but there didn’t seem to be a motive. My favorite suspect almost seemed too obvious, and had what many would consider a good motive. I was very satisfied with how the mystery was resolved, and how a couple other situations worked out. I am looking forward to the next mystery in the series, and highly recommend this one!
Brought to you by OBS Reviewer Jeanie
I fully enjoyed this new mystery in its series. If a humorous cozy mystery could be considered “feel good”, it would be this one. Allie and her friends on Mackinac Island have formed real friendships since she moved there. The authentic, charming setting is a delight for the senses, especially in the spring. Allie inherited the Historic McMurphy Hotel and Fudge Shop from her beloved grandfather, and running it is all she ever wanted to do. She is beginning her third tourist season, following her second full winter there. The murder and the person of interest were shocking and a challenge to solve. Several recipes for rich, sweet delights are included throughout the novel.
Those who live on Mackinac Island year-round are a special kind of hardy Midwest folks, including Allie and her boyfriend, Rex. Most are friendly and down-to-earth. It is a delight to learn more about the regular characters as well as appreciate those who are only in this novel. Who they are is demonstrated throughout, with just the right amount of background for their roles.
Jenn is Allie’s best friend and an expert party planner. She is also two weeks overdue with her and her husband Shane’s first baby. Jenn insisted on having an at-home delivery with her midwife, Sarah, in attendance, and her doula, Hannah. Worst case, she would deliver in the clinic on the island, but refused to leave the island for a hospital.
Jenn was to meet Hannah one morning, so Allie walked with her. They headed for the alley entrance to Hannah’s apartment, and saw Hannah turn into it. Her fiancé, Matthew, followed her. Before Allie and Jenn reached the alley, a young man in a hoodie ran out of it, almost knocking Jenn over. Monica, a shop owner, said that Matthew and Hannah had an animated, heated conversation moments earlier. They got almost to Hannah’s and saw a man lying on the ground at the stairway going up to Hannah’s. Hannah was sitting on the stairs, holding a gun, eyes open but unresponsive. Matthew had a puddle of blood around him. Jenn hurried away to call 911 while Allie checked to see if he was still alive, but it was too late. Allie, with the help of her calico cat, got the handgun and moved it away from Hannah. Police officers Rex and Charles arrived first. Within minutes, the new DA joined the scene.
Even though she couldn’t speak and was in shock, Hannah was the only person of interest in the death of her fiancé. The DA thought his first major case would bring notoriety to bolster his political aspirations. There is no way he could lose with Hannah having been found with the smoking gun and blood on her clothes, so the police work for the case was complete.
Jenn is horrified. She knows Hannah, and the doula was her only choice after researching several women to coach her and Shane through labor and delivery. Jenn’s wails and weeping had little effect on anybody. Allie, an amateur sleuth who has solved several murders since moving to Mackinac Island, visited Hannah as the shock wore off to ask questions about what happened. Hannah’s bail was set at a half million dollars. As a last resort to keep her friend calm and happy, Allie made a deal with the devil to pay Hannah’s bail before Jenn gave birth. She, with the help of some ladies from the senior center, looked into every aspect of the case. This time, blocked from finishing an official investigation, Rex is glad for her snooping. He believed in justice, not railroading someone to quickly close a case for an easy win.
In the meantime, Allie’s mother made a rare trip to Mackinac with Allie’s high school and college beau, who is now very wealthy and has his own political aspirations. He would do anything to get Allie to marry him, but she was over him a long time ago. Her love for Rex was worth more than a fortune.
This mystery kept me guessing, and huge surprises greeted me at the end! I had briefly considered the real bad guy, but there didn’t seem to be a motive. My favorite suspect almost seemed too obvious, and had what many would consider a good motive. I was very satisfied with how the mystery was resolved, and how a couple other situations worked out. I am looking forward to the next mystery in the series, and highly recommend this one!
February 16, 2024
Jenn is about ready to pop with her new baby (son or daughter, we don't know yet!) Her dream is to have her baby on the island but the clinic isn't equipped for that so Jenn finds a midwife and a doula and makes arrangements to allow her to have her baby at the clinic. Everything is going great until her doula, Hannah, is found in the alley behind her apartment with a smoking gun in her hand and her dead fiancé, Matthew, at her feet. Jenn demands that Allie figure out who really killed Matthew so Hannah can be present for her delivery.
I will start out by saying that I had very definite feelings about a lot of the things that happened in this book. Though I didn't like a lot of it, it's a sign of a well-written book if it can evoke strong feelings in the reader. That being said, the things that bothered me were many. Jenn being at least three weeks past her due date when the baby was born was unrealistic. I can't imagine that being allowed to happen, if only because the baby would be enormous and the likelihood of being delivered by a midwife at a clinic (particularly one not prepared to perform a C-section) at that point would surely be very, very small.
Another thing that bothered me was Allie's mom. She's really something else. She's only concerned about having grandchildren and having a son-in-law she can brag about. Allie's passions and feelings are meaningless to her mom, she only cares about what she wants for Allie, not what Allie wants for herself. Which unfortunately is very realistic. Also, Allie's mom trying to foist Brett upon Allie even though he's not Allie's type at all was super annoying. Allie's only response to her mom's overstepping was "I love you," which felt almost as though she was inviting the abuse.
I felt like the investigation was a bit clunky and marred by some silly arguments that popped up between Allie and Rex. In the past I've felt that Allie's stubbornness when it comes to others worrying about her safety was a bit childish and I felt that here too. She overreacts and assumes people are just trying to tell her what to do and I find that a bit annoying. People who care about her should be telling her to be careful, she shouldn't be faulting them for that. I also thought it was odd that Allie didn't speak to one critical witness until very near the end of the story. The suspects were few and the killer was quite clear from very early in the story. That's not necessarily a bad thing but it took some fun out of the investigation.
Overall, I did enjoy this story though it was probably one of my least favorite of the series. I love the setting on Mackinac Island and the McMurphy Hotel is very cool. The fudge recipes all sound really good, though I have never tried to make any of them. I also appreciate that they're not all chocolate based, some are other flavors and chocolate-free. Though this wasn't my favorite of the series, this is still a series I highly recommend.
Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
I will start out by saying that I had very definite feelings about a lot of the things that happened in this book. Though I didn't like a lot of it, it's a sign of a well-written book if it can evoke strong feelings in the reader. That being said, the things that bothered me were many. Jenn being at least three weeks past her due date when the baby was born was unrealistic. I can't imagine that being allowed to happen, if only because the baby would be enormous and the likelihood of being delivered by a midwife at a clinic (particularly one not prepared to perform a C-section) at that point would surely be very, very small.
Another thing that bothered me was Allie's mom. She's really something else. She's only concerned about having grandchildren and having a son-in-law she can brag about. Allie's passions and feelings are meaningless to her mom, she only cares about what she wants for Allie, not what Allie wants for herself. Which unfortunately is very realistic. Also, Allie's mom trying to foist Brett upon Allie even though he's not Allie's type at all was super annoying. Allie's only response to her mom's overstepping was "I love you," which felt almost as though she was inviting the abuse.
I felt like the investigation was a bit clunky and marred by some silly arguments that popped up between Allie and Rex. In the past I've felt that Allie's stubbornness when it comes to others worrying about her safety was a bit childish and I felt that here too. She overreacts and assumes people are just trying to tell her what to do and I find that a bit annoying. People who care about her should be telling her to be careful, she shouldn't be faulting them for that. I also thought it was odd that Allie didn't speak to one critical witness until very near the end of the story. The suspects were few and the killer was quite clear from very early in the story. That's not necessarily a bad thing but it took some fun out of the investigation.
Overall, I did enjoy this story though it was probably one of my least favorite of the series. I love the setting on Mackinac Island and the McMurphy Hotel is very cool. The fudge recipes all sound really good, though I have never tried to make any of them. I also appreciate that they're not all chocolate based, some are other flavors and chocolate-free. Though this wasn't my favorite of the series, this is still a series I highly recommend.
Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
January 24, 2024
Would you be willing to sell your soul to "the devil" to help a friend?
The emotions seem to swirl about in this book. Not only Jenn, past her due date and insistent she just can't have this baby without doula Hannah there, but the family ties that both complicate and comfort, not to mention bumps on the road to romance. If it isn't obvious, I love books that are character driven and this one is that plus. Allie is dealing with all of them, not to mention keeping her fudge business going during off-season on Mackinac Island. I've never been there but have come to adore Mackinac Island's slower moving, ol' fashioned ways. I mean, the cops ride bicycles and we're talking the kind you peddle, not motorized. Horse-drawn carriage meander about with both locals and tourists and Victorian homes seem to dominate much of the area.
Jenn's raw emotions and determination to have her baby on the island with the help of Hannah and a midwife come to dominate Allie's hours, hours complicated by the arrival of her mother with an ol' boyfriend of Allie's in tow. Seems he's done well for himself and flown in on his own plane and dear ol' mom thinks Allie should give him another chance. After all, he may be governor someday. Never mind Allie is in love with Rex, the island's investigative detective. And, oh, my, Allie and Jenn stumble across a murder victim and, yikes, holding the gun is Hannah, who turns out to have been his girlfriend. That's when things get complicated.
That's all I'm going to say about the plot because it's too much fun to immerse yourself in life in Mackinac and Allie's world to spoil anything. Let's just say, things get testy between Rex and Allie as she plows forward trying to help Jenn by investigating. As usual, that means putting herself in danger although I'm glad to see she's gotten far smarter about having backup handy. So, who killed Matthew, a man everyone seems to have liked? Could it really have been Hannah? How far will Allie go to help Jenn? What does her mother say that gives Allie pause about her life's plan? Why does having your reputation precede you both help and hinder? How reliable are eye-witnesses? Is Jenn being devious? Who...oh, never mind. Enough teasers. This book is a fun read with great characters and a unique setting. I love how character driven it is, almost to the point that whodunit becomes secondary to trying to mentally sort out the side stories. Thanks #NetGalley and #KensingtonCozies for allowing me this sneak peek at the turmoil and joy surrounding Jenn's blessed event.
The emotions seem to swirl about in this book. Not only Jenn, past her due date and insistent she just can't have this baby without doula Hannah there, but the family ties that both complicate and comfort, not to mention bumps on the road to romance. If it isn't obvious, I love books that are character driven and this one is that plus. Allie is dealing with all of them, not to mention keeping her fudge business going during off-season on Mackinac Island. I've never been there but have come to adore Mackinac Island's slower moving, ol' fashioned ways. I mean, the cops ride bicycles and we're talking the kind you peddle, not motorized. Horse-drawn carriage meander about with both locals and tourists and Victorian homes seem to dominate much of the area.
Jenn's raw emotions and determination to have her baby on the island with the help of Hannah and a midwife come to dominate Allie's hours, hours complicated by the arrival of her mother with an ol' boyfriend of Allie's in tow. Seems he's done well for himself and flown in on his own plane and dear ol' mom thinks Allie should give him another chance. After all, he may be governor someday. Never mind Allie is in love with Rex, the island's investigative detective. And, oh, my, Allie and Jenn stumble across a murder victim and, yikes, holding the gun is Hannah, who turns out to have been his girlfriend. That's when things get complicated.
That's all I'm going to say about the plot because it's too much fun to immerse yourself in life in Mackinac and Allie's world to spoil anything. Let's just say, things get testy between Rex and Allie as she plows forward trying to help Jenn by investigating. As usual, that means putting herself in danger although I'm glad to see she's gotten far smarter about having backup handy. So, who killed Matthew, a man everyone seems to have liked? Could it really have been Hannah? How far will Allie go to help Jenn? What does her mother say that gives Allie pause about her life's plan? Why does having your reputation precede you both help and hinder? How reliable are eye-witnesses? Is Jenn being devious? Who...oh, never mind. Enough teasers. This book is a fun read with great characters and a unique setting. I love how character driven it is, almost to the point that whodunit becomes secondary to trying to mentally sort out the side stories. Thanks #NetGalley and #KensingtonCozies for allowing me this sneak peek at the turmoil and joy surrounding Jenn's blessed event.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 110 reviews