4.5 Stars
But I gave it a 5 anyway, because I'm a sucker for anything that appeals to the fangirl in me. And whether you like comic books or your interest in such things only applies to the film adaptations, you might want to give Kingdom of Heroes a try.
One caveat, sometimes it's obvious that Phillips is a fanboy himself. For example, one of the characters in this novel, Anthony Barren, goes by the moniker The Iron Knight and is a genius-engineer-playboy who builds himself a metal suit that can fly and shoot stuff at people. Barren (as an adjective) has a cousin called "stark." Get it? No? Also, Tony is short for Anthony. Still don't get it? Then there is no hope for you.
For those of you still with me, I could see where Anthony Barren might grate into the squeamish nerves of the critic, but critics tend to be irritated by nearly everything, so take the similarities with a grain of salt. Or go find a sense of humor if it bothers you. I loved it.
I also loved the Detective. Maybe even in an I-want-to-have-your-babies kind of way. (FYI: babies are right up there with slow and painful death on the list of things that I want. Anyway...) He's the real hero of this novel, a loveable rogue who exudes a nearly-perfect combination of reluctant hero, smartass, and dog-petter. The Detective's cohorts and gatekeepers along the way were equally interesting I might add, each with a distinct personality and motivation, though perhaps the mystery villain in the stolen armor was the best of the bunch. Phillips definitely has a talent for characterization.
The plot lures you in with swift world-building and an irresistible mystery in the first half, followed by a big reveal around the mid-point. I've seen that come as a disappointment to some other reviewers, and though I felt the slight change of pace as well, Phillips keeps plenty of threads hanging and many body parts flying. That's enough to require me, at least, to spontaneously generate a superpower just to put the bloody thing down. And those threads lead to a fingernail-biting, will-he/won't-he climax that seems impossible to resolve, yet somehow wraps up in a way that is both believable and satisfying.
In the interest of disclosure, included in this freshman effort are sparse profanity and much-less-sparse gore. In other words, AWESOMENESS.
All things considered, you'll feel a bit guilty for not paying at least double the book's retail. Yeah, it's cheap, so you have zero excuses. Go buy it, now.