I was given this book in exchange for an honest review.
Precipice is an epic fantasy novel that follows the story of two half-sisters investigating a deeply interwoven conspiracy that spans three nations across the world of Velyn. Danika is a practitioner of healing magic in the form of a paladin with a great deal of field experience. Kiruna falls into the elemental wizard role as a powerful leader with an independent council of magic users. Each woman must follow a thread that ultimately leads her to confront a different facet of the evil forces threatening to destroy their world.
Let me open by saying that Anthony DeRouen is not a novice. His writing had the usual indie publishing hiccups, but also showed the telltale signs of great things to come. This author is clearly a student of the craft, and it shows in the three subsequent updates he sent me before I finished reading the book for my review. If I could give stars for effort, this book would get five.
If you are someone who enjoys epic fantasy, then Precipice might be perfect for you. I say might, because at first glance, it feels very much like a contemporary story with Danika playing the equivalent of a modern combat medic in a fantasy setting. As the story develops however, you find yourself straying into more familiar Tolkein-esque territory, with magical races and supernatural forces. There’s some great content for fans of Martin, if you can handle where the story ends. There’s also some fine reading for Tolkein fans, if you can weather the opening of the book until it picks up speed.
Here’s where things get tricky. The reason it’s difficult to make a recommendation for a select group is because of the breadth of the worldbuilding. There is a lot going on in Precipice. In fact, it’s far too ambitious for one book. The learning curve is a steep cliff, and I found myself losing my hold more than once. To DeRouen’s credit, there seems to be a very complex setting at work beneath the text of this book. The problem I had was that everything jumps out at you like a pop-up book full of generic fantasy elements.
The parallel story lines were difficult to track, and there was a lack of the sweeping descriptions that usually accompany a tale of this magnitude. People tend to accuse epic fantasy authors of being verbose, but when you start mixing up people, places, and even things because you don’t have any memorable imagery to cement them in your mind, you begin to understand why the masters put the epic word counts in their epic fantasy books.
I would have liked a deeper dive into Danika’s journey. She was a strong female protagonist that was interesting from moment one. If the book had followed her story alone, I think it would have carried much better than trying to include both sisters in parallel. Most of the characters had great potential, but didn’t seem to evolve very much over the course of the book (except for Danika). Keep in mind, my viewpoint might be overly critical because I’ve read so many great fantasy books.
While I admit to a lower tolerance for the genre, I think the author bit off more than he could consume. A really solid developmental edit would have made this book into several volumes, and helped clarify the groundwork for what looks to be a very promising mythos. The scope of the setting far outweighs the power of the storytelling in its current form, and I found myself leaning in and backing away in equal parts. Scale Precipice down a bit, and you have a heroic fantasy book that is well worth reading.
3 out of 5 stars. Pick this up if you’re a fan of the Game of Thrones television show, but haven’t gotten around to reading any of the books.