What do you think?
Rate this book
Story of Monuments Men #1
Shadowed by Grace
Shadowed by Grace is the first in a stirring new series of stand-alone historical suspense novels by acclaimed author Cara C. Putman. Desperate to save her dying mother, Rachel accepts her newspaper’s assignment to travel to Italy to captures images dangerously close to the front lines of WWII. Her real motive – to find the father she never knew -- an artist she hopes can offer the comfort and support both she and her mother need to survive. It’s an unlikely situation for love and faith to flourish, but soon Rachel not only finds herself, but also her long-lost earthly father, and ultimately, the man her Heavenly father created to cherish and provide for her.
352 pages, Paperback
First published December 4, 2013
35 people are currently reading
1408 people want to read
About the author
Cara C. Putman
66 books1,896 followersCara C. Putman lives in Indiana with her husband and four children. She is a clinical assistant professor in law and ethics at Purdue University's School of Business. She has loved reading and writing from a young age and now realizes it was all training for writing books. She loves bringing history and legal romantic suspense to life.
An honors graduate of the University of Nebraska, George Mason University School of Law, and Krannert School of Management, Cara left small town Nebraska and headed to Washington, D.C., to launch her career in public policy.
Cara is an author chasing hard after God as she lives a crazy life. She invites you to join her on that journey. She's currently writing her 41st book with more on the way. Please check out her website to learn more about her books and read first chapters.
An honors graduate of the University of Nebraska, George Mason University School of Law, and Krannert School of Management, Cara left small town Nebraska and headed to Washington, D.C., to launch her career in public policy.
Cara is an author chasing hard after God as she lives a crazy life. She invites you to join her on that journey. She's currently writing her 41st book with more on the way. Please check out her website to learn more about her books and read first chapters.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 152 reviews
October 29, 2018
4.5 stars
This story was a real winner for me and yet another reason to love Cara Putman's writing. The story is beautifully crafted and set in an interesting locale, Italy in 1944 as the fighting front moves north for the German retreat. I could easily imagine the scenery and the photography Rachel created, and I also enjoyed Scott as an MC--though it was Rachel who held my attention most. A bit of mystery connected with disappearing Italian art helped move the story along, though I was sure of the culprit from the moment the crimes were spoken of.
This story was a real winner for me and yet another reason to love Cara Putman's writing. The story is beautifully crafted and set in an interesting locale, Italy in 1944 as the fighting front moves north for the German retreat. I could easily imagine the scenery and the photography Rachel created, and I also enjoyed Scott as an MC--though it was Rachel who held my attention most. A bit of mystery connected with disappearing Italian art helped move the story along, though I was sure of the culprit from the moment the crimes were spoken of.
October 7, 2018
An enjoyable historical novel that really took me back in time.
July 12, 2024
This wil always be one of the favorites of my books.
February 9, 2014
There are a lot of books written about war – and very few of them say anything new. It takes a special kind of person to tell an old story in a new way and to shed light on aspects of the war that few of us have heard about.
Meet Cara C. Putman – the author of Shadowed By Grace.
Shadowed By Grace is a World War II novel about two groups of people who served very important roles during this era but didn't get the respect they deserved from the peers: the Monuments Men and female journalists.
We learn about some of the hardships these two groups faced through our two central characters: Lieutenant Scott Lindstrom and Captain Rachel Justice.
Scott enlisted in the Army as an officer with the Monuments, Fine Arts, and Archives Division at great personal cost not because he had to – but because he wanted to. Scott wanted to do something meaningful in the war. He had heard tales of how the Third Reich was destroying the art, architecture, and culture of Western civilization, and wanted to do everything in his power to preserve it… even if he wasn't considered a “real soldier” by his peers.
Rachel is a photo-journalist whose mother is dying of tuberculosis. She has only one chance of saving her: to find her father – a man who she has never met – in Italy, his last known location. So, she does the unthinkable: she uses her sway and convinces her editor to send her abroad on assignment – to take pictures from the war zone – in the hopes of pursuing her goal. Rachel soon finds out that neither the military nor the United Press is happy to have her on board. Scott observes that although he "might not receive much respect from his peers... she got less."
The two formally meet in Italy when Scott is assigned to “babysit” Rachel upon their arrival at the military base. As you might imagine, neither one of them is thrilled by this arrangement. What transpires, however, is a beautifully written story of adventure, romance, and God’s providence that enlightens, engages, and enriches the reader.
There are so many things that I loved about Shadowed By Grace: the unique storyline… the impeccably researched details… the way the story builds... the unfolding characters themselves.
This is the first book that I have read by Cara C. Putman but it won’t be my last. She is now on my list of authors whose books I can’t wait to read more of.
To read my review in its entirety, please visit Create With Joy.
Disclosure: I received a copy of this book from the publisher for review purposes. However, the opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Meet Cara C. Putman – the author of Shadowed By Grace.
Shadowed By Grace is a World War II novel about two groups of people who served very important roles during this era but didn't get the respect they deserved from the peers: the Monuments Men and female journalists.
We learn about some of the hardships these two groups faced through our two central characters: Lieutenant Scott Lindstrom and Captain Rachel Justice.
Scott enlisted in the Army as an officer with the Monuments, Fine Arts, and Archives Division at great personal cost not because he had to – but because he wanted to. Scott wanted to do something meaningful in the war. He had heard tales of how the Third Reich was destroying the art, architecture, and culture of Western civilization, and wanted to do everything in his power to preserve it… even if he wasn't considered a “real soldier” by his peers.
Rachel is a photo-journalist whose mother is dying of tuberculosis. She has only one chance of saving her: to find her father – a man who she has never met – in Italy, his last known location. So, she does the unthinkable: she uses her sway and convinces her editor to send her abroad on assignment – to take pictures from the war zone – in the hopes of pursuing her goal. Rachel soon finds out that neither the military nor the United Press is happy to have her on board. Scott observes that although he "might not receive much respect from his peers... she got less."
The two formally meet in Italy when Scott is assigned to “babysit” Rachel upon their arrival at the military base. As you might imagine, neither one of them is thrilled by this arrangement. What transpires, however, is a beautifully written story of adventure, romance, and God’s providence that enlightens, engages, and enriches the reader.
There are so many things that I loved about Shadowed By Grace: the unique storyline… the impeccably researched details… the way the story builds... the unfolding characters themselves.
This is the first book that I have read by Cara C. Putman but it won’t be my last. She is now on my list of authors whose books I can’t wait to read more of.
To read my review in its entirety, please visit Create With Joy.
Disclosure: I received a copy of this book from the publisher for review purposes. However, the opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
December 31, 2013
What I Loved
My favorite part of this unique story was that Cara Putman's writing drives forward with every word. I could hardly put Shadowed by Grace down, and, when I did, I found myself wondering what would happen next. This story is not only well-researched, well-written, and unique--it's compelling in its pace, too!
This book is well-researched because Cara knows her history! Check out the Fact or Fiction behind it and then grab a copy of Shadowed by Grace to discover this little-known facet of WWII. I had no idea there were Monuments Men operating to save the treasures of Western Civilization, but there were men like Scott, passionate about the mission.
This book is also unique because it covers WWII Italy--a sector of history I had never read about before. Yet I came away from Shadowed by Grace with not only a greater appreciation for the Greatest Generation, but for having experienced the journey with Scott and Rachel. Scott is devoted to his cause, and Rachel makes art with her camera. These are two characters I won't soon forget.
What I Didn't Like As Much
With the intensity of war serving as a harsh background, it would have been easy for Cara to rush the romance, but she doesn't. I appreciated that and how Scott and Rachel's relationship flows naturally. They hit a bump in the road about midway through the book that made me wince, but I liked that not-everyone-is-perfect aspect.
Shadowed by Grace is going on my keeper shelf! I look forward to the rest of this series!
My favorite part of this unique story was that Cara Putman's writing drives forward with every word. I could hardly put Shadowed by Grace down, and, when I did, I found myself wondering what would happen next. This story is not only well-researched, well-written, and unique--it's compelling in its pace, too!
This book is well-researched because Cara knows her history! Check out the Fact or Fiction behind it and then grab a copy of Shadowed by Grace to discover this little-known facet of WWII. I had no idea there were Monuments Men operating to save the treasures of Western Civilization, but there were men like Scott, passionate about the mission.
This book is also unique because it covers WWII Italy--a sector of history I had never read about before. Yet I came away from Shadowed by Grace with not only a greater appreciation for the Greatest Generation, but for having experienced the journey with Scott and Rachel. Scott is devoted to his cause, and Rachel makes art with her camera. These are two characters I won't soon forget.
What I Didn't Like As Much
With the intensity of war serving as a harsh background, it would have been easy for Cara to rush the romance, but she doesn't. I appreciated that and how Scott and Rachel's relationship flows naturally. They hit a bump in the road about midway through the book that made me wince, but I liked that not-everyone-is-perfect aspect.
Shadowed by Grace is going on my keeper shelf! I look forward to the rest of this series!
did-not-finish
May 19, 2022I read to 20% because the historical aspects really interested me. However, I just wasn't connecting with the characters and new characters and emotions were just said like "just had started feeling this way a week ago" "This guy had been around a week and was not the bane of his existence". Not exactly like that, but not very well written.
While I loved the idea behind this story, I just wasn't interested in continuing to read due to how bland the characters felt.
While I loved the idea behind this story, I just wasn't interested in continuing to read due to how bland the characters felt.
December 15, 2013
Photojournalist, Rachel Justice achieved authorization to travel to Italy in the throes of World War II with the pretext of catching real-time photographs of the effects of war. Her ultimate goal, however, was to locate her father, a man she had never known. Her passion to find her biological father stemmed back to early childhood when she was looked down upon because her mother was unmarried. The ache to know her earthly father consumed her at this stage of her life, particularly because her mother's health was declining as a result of tuberculosis. Their finances had dwindled to next to nothing and Rachel was certain her father could help.
Rachel's mother had studied art in Italy as a young woman. With that information Rachel was armed with her mother's diary and a notebook of sketches done by an Italian artist whose name she didn't know. The only clues to his identity were his initials. Her mother refused to divulge her father's name, and forbade her to search for him, but Rachel believed that if she could locate him, he could offer financial assistance toward her mother's care and provide her the father figure she craved so much.
Private Scott Lindstrom received his assignment as an officer in Monuments, Fine Arts and Archives Division, a division of the army devoted to locating and protecting priceless art and monuments. In Naples his general assigned Scott to accompany Rachel through war-torn areas as she sought newsworthy photographs for publication back in the United States. Scott's mission was to preserve the history of Western Civilization, the masterpieces and sculptures that he could locate. Having a tag-along wasn't his idea of accomplishing his job. The Monuments division followed behind the warring troops, dangerously close to the front lines, their jobs inspecting local monuments, beginning reconstruction and assisting in protecting priceless works of art.
Throughout this wartime novel Rachel observed Scott's strong faith in God even when tragedy was all around them. His prayers were simple and conversational, awakening questions in Rachel's mind about her loss of faith and a heavenly father. This underlying current is beautifully blended into this strong story of war and its casualties, unimaginable scenes of destruction and danger. An incredible amount of research has gone into the writing of this novel.
Cara Putman has created a masterful novel of classic proportion regarding events throughout Italy during World War II. The development of the characters throughout this poignant story is natural and human, realistic and at times painful. The author has done an outstanding job at creating settings that become visible through her descriptions. I found this book very difficult to put down; however, I did not want to rush through the book. I savored every detail. This is a book that I highly recommend and will read again.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from Wynn-Wynn Media in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own, and no monetary compensation was received for this review.
Rachel's mother had studied art in Italy as a young woman. With that information Rachel was armed with her mother's diary and a notebook of sketches done by an Italian artist whose name she didn't know. The only clues to his identity were his initials. Her mother refused to divulge her father's name, and forbade her to search for him, but Rachel believed that if she could locate him, he could offer financial assistance toward her mother's care and provide her the father figure she craved so much.
Private Scott Lindstrom received his assignment as an officer in Monuments, Fine Arts and Archives Division, a division of the army devoted to locating and protecting priceless art and monuments. In Naples his general assigned Scott to accompany Rachel through war-torn areas as she sought newsworthy photographs for publication back in the United States. Scott's mission was to preserve the history of Western Civilization, the masterpieces and sculptures that he could locate. Having a tag-along wasn't his idea of accomplishing his job. The Monuments division followed behind the warring troops, dangerously close to the front lines, their jobs inspecting local monuments, beginning reconstruction and assisting in protecting priceless works of art.
Throughout this wartime novel Rachel observed Scott's strong faith in God even when tragedy was all around them. His prayers were simple and conversational, awakening questions in Rachel's mind about her loss of faith and a heavenly father. This underlying current is beautifully blended into this strong story of war and its casualties, unimaginable scenes of destruction and danger. An incredible amount of research has gone into the writing of this novel.
Cara Putman has created a masterful novel of classic proportion regarding events throughout Italy during World War II. The development of the characters throughout this poignant story is natural and human, realistic and at times painful. The author has done an outstanding job at creating settings that become visible through her descriptions. I found this book very difficult to put down; however, I did not want to rush through the book. I savored every detail. This is a book that I highly recommend and will read again.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from Wynn-Wynn Media in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own, and no monetary compensation was received for this review.
February 10, 2014
With the Monument's Men being the rage right now with the premiere of the movie, I wanted to read something set in the time and setting similar to the movie before I go see it. Sadly, this is not a reason to pick this particular book. I should have just read The Monuments Men: Allied Heroes, Nazi Thieves, and the Greatest Treasure Hunt in History instead if I wanted that particular flavor to read about. Some of the reviews really mentioned the "romance" factor of this novel. Based on those, I should have realized this is a romance novel with a historical twist, not a historical novel with a romantic twist.
What this book has going for it: Based in WWII, various settings around Italy, a driven female lead character.
What this book disappointed me with: a search for a father with nothing to go on but a sketchbook that may or may not even have anything to do with the father; an ill mother as the driving force of said quest which seems extremely flat; a woman photographer traveling with soldiers to the war front with the excuse for her being there as "because she's just that good"; the Monument's Man the lead character becomes entangled with is simply roaming around, looking in towns, asking what's lost, blah, blah, blah, until the end of the book; lots of what felt to me like "forced" coincidences to tie up the ending.
I wanted to like this more than I did. I love historical fiction, especially this era, but it just fell short for me. If you want to read compelling historical fiction related specifically to the adventure of the Monument's Men, you might look elsewhere. If, however, you want a book heavy on the Christian romance with a backdrop of WWII thrown in you'll probably enjoy this book. It wasn't badly written for the romance genre. I just personally didn't know what this book was actually aimed towards from the summary.
What this book has going for it: Based in WWII, various settings around Italy, a driven female lead character.
What this book disappointed me with: a search for a father with nothing to go on but a sketchbook that may or may not even have anything to do with the father; an ill mother as the driving force of said quest which seems extremely flat; a woman photographer traveling with soldiers to the war front with the excuse for her being there as "because she's just that good"; the Monument's Man the lead character becomes entangled with is simply roaming around, looking in towns, asking what's lost, blah, blah, blah, until the end of the book; lots of what felt to me like "forced" coincidences to tie up the ending.
I wanted to like this more than I did. I love historical fiction, especially this era, but it just fell short for me. If you want to read compelling historical fiction related specifically to the adventure of the Monument's Men, you might look elsewhere. If, however, you want a book heavy on the Christian romance with a backdrop of WWII thrown in you'll probably enjoy this book. It wasn't badly written for the romance genre. I just personally didn't know what this book was actually aimed towards from the summary.
March 30, 2018
I found this book fascinating! Rachel, a photographer, is searching for her dad in Italy – but it is during WWII and the Nazi’s are still there. She gets attached to a military unit, to take pictures of the war, but no one is expecting or wanting a woman in their unit. I really enjoyed reading about this part of the war as the Americans pushed the Germans out of Italy as I’d never read anything about it before. Great book – lots of surprises and I recommend!
February 15, 2017
By Andrea Renee Cox
A while back I won a copy of Cara Putman’s book Shadowed by Grace, and I had no idea whether or not I’d like it. I’d never read anything by Cara before. The story sounded interesting, though, and I like discovering new-to-me authors, so I dove into it with an open mind. Boy, am I glad I did! What a treasure this book turned out to be.
Set in WWII, it tells the story of a photojournalist who travels to Italy to capture images of the war to help the folks back home really understand what it’s all about. Of course that isn’t the only reason she took on the job, but I can’t give away all her secrets. When she starts her journey, Rachel Justice wonders if she’ll ever be able to find peace in a time of war.
Throughout the chapters, I found myself completely immersed in the time period and setting. I’ve never been to Italy, but I sure felt like I was right there with Rachel. That’s when I realized I’d discovered a new favorite author. When history and the characters and the place really leap off the pages and come alive, that’s when I realize I’m falling in love with reading all over again.
One thing that really resonated with me was Rachel’s longing to “do something that matters.” I don’t know about you, but that’s what whispers through my heart too. I want to do something that matters. Something that not only will make a difference in the world, but something that really makes a difference in the spiritual sense. Furthering God’s kingdom. Advancing the Gospel. I’m not sure exactly what this something is yet, but I know God will reveal it to me in the right time. In the meantime, I’ll keep focusing on the tasks before me, which I’m sure are preparing me for whatever may come next.
A while back I won a copy of Cara Putman’s book Shadowed by Grace, and I had no idea whether or not I’d like it. I’d never read anything by Cara before. The story sounded interesting, though, and I like discovering new-to-me authors, so I dove into it with an open mind. Boy, am I glad I did! What a treasure this book turned out to be.
Set in WWII, it tells the story of a photojournalist who travels to Italy to capture images of the war to help the folks back home really understand what it’s all about. Of course that isn’t the only reason she took on the job, but I can’t give away all her secrets. When she starts her journey, Rachel Justice wonders if she’ll ever be able to find peace in a time of war.
Throughout the chapters, I found myself completely immersed in the time period and setting. I’ve never been to Italy, but I sure felt like I was right there with Rachel. That’s when I realized I’d discovered a new favorite author. When history and the characters and the place really leap off the pages and come alive, that’s when I realize I’m falling in love with reading all over again.
One thing that really resonated with me was Rachel’s longing to “do something that matters.” I don’t know about you, but that’s what whispers through my heart too. I want to do something that matters. Something that not only will make a difference in the world, but something that really makes a difference in the spiritual sense. Furthering God’s kingdom. Advancing the Gospel. I’m not sure exactly what this something is yet, but I know God will reveal it to me in the right time. In the meantime, I’ll keep focusing on the tasks before me, which I’m sure are preparing me for whatever may come next.
February 16, 2014
Because I went to see the movie "The Monuments Men" while reading this, I'm afraid I can't help but compare the two, and I loved them both.
"Shadowed by Grace" tells the story of Rachel Justice, a photojournalist who is assigned to work with a U.S. soldier tasked with protecting culturally important works of art as Germany withdraws from Italy. Scott Lindstrom is the Monuments Man who is relying on his contacts in Italy to foster trust and to facilitate locating the artworks. Little does he know that Rachel's primary purpose is a personal quest that might interfere with his mission. Added to their sometimes conflicting agendas is the fear that someone is stealing the priceless masterpieces right from under their noses.
The George Clooney movie uses humor to ease some of heartbreak of WWII, while Cara Putnam takes us there, viewing the devastation through the sensitive lens of Rachel's camera. The effect was powerful when Rachel stopped to perfectly frame the scene and to describe what she was seeing. Another difference between the movie and the book was that the movie gives a broad overview of several different teams as they fan out across Europe. "Shadowed by Grace" allows us to invest emotionally in one couple and their journey, giving it a much richer feel.
Kudos to the author for the wonderful story. Whether or not you've seen "The Monuments Men" movie, this novel offers a more developed characterization of the men and women who rescued the treasures of our civilization.
"Shadowed by Grace" tells the story of Rachel Justice, a photojournalist who is assigned to work with a U.S. soldier tasked with protecting culturally important works of art as Germany withdraws from Italy. Scott Lindstrom is the Monuments Man who is relying on his contacts in Italy to foster trust and to facilitate locating the artworks. Little does he know that Rachel's primary purpose is a personal quest that might interfere with his mission. Added to their sometimes conflicting agendas is the fear that someone is stealing the priceless masterpieces right from under their noses.
The George Clooney movie uses humor to ease some of heartbreak of WWII, while Cara Putnam takes us there, viewing the devastation through the sensitive lens of Rachel's camera. The effect was powerful when Rachel stopped to perfectly frame the scene and to describe what she was seeing. Another difference between the movie and the book was that the movie gives a broad overview of several different teams as they fan out across Europe. "Shadowed by Grace" allows us to invest emotionally in one couple and their journey, giving it a much richer feel.
Kudos to the author for the wonderful story. Whether or not you've seen "The Monuments Men" movie, this novel offers a more developed characterization of the men and women who rescued the treasures of our civilization.
February 18, 2014
When I commenced my reading of this book, I wasn't sure what I thought of it. I generally savor and appreciate historical books, and WWII is a time period I generally relish. Because I was fairly certain of the predictable outcome of the inserted romance, I was not terribly enthused. The Christian message was generally pleasing but I was rather lethargic about continuing it. I assumed I would give it a lower a rating.
However, as I persevered, I soon discovered that there was more depth to this story than I realized. The book was historically dense, and I was completely oblivious to how the war affected Italy. That seems to be one of the countries that is only mentioned in passing. Envisioning a female photographer who fearlessly took breathtaking photos from the front lines made the story all the more intriguing. The Christian message was subtle but strong. And the last third of the book was filled with intense action and a bit of pathos. Althought the romance was sappy I was able to excuse that due to the amazing story this Christian novel told.
I had not realized until I was well into the book that this was a story similar to the "Monument Men" film that is out now. I am even more interested in going to view that film in light of what I have read here.
I was sent a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. I was not financially compensated, and all opinions are 100 percent mine.
However, as I persevered, I soon discovered that there was more depth to this story than I realized. The book was historically dense, and I was completely oblivious to how the war affected Italy. That seems to be one of the countries that is only mentioned in passing. Envisioning a female photographer who fearlessly took breathtaking photos from the front lines made the story all the more intriguing. The Christian message was subtle but strong. And the last third of the book was filled with intense action and a bit of pathos. Althought the romance was sappy I was able to excuse that due to the amazing story this Christian novel told.
I had not realized until I was well into the book that this was a story similar to the "Monument Men" film that is out now. I am even more interested in going to view that film in light of what I have read here.
I was sent a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. I was not financially compensated, and all opinions are 100 percent mine.
December 10, 2013
While I never have truly studied WWII, I have been fascinated by the novels written during that period. There is a certain “romance” if you will and base a novel on foreign soil and you have the makings for a captivating and sweeping story, because what reader doesn’t like to be transported to another world entirely when they sit down to read?
“Shadowed by Grace” in and of itself is a unique plot line. The main characters aren’t your typical soldiers, but they are fighting to protect something so important to society. I loved the tidbits of history sprinkled throughout the story and the telling of what happened to these pieces of art to protect them from being stolen and carried away, not to be found for years to come-if ever.
The landscape is rich in texture and setting. I rode in the back of that army jeep just as much as our hero did. Rachel is a compelling heroine with a story to tell and the romance of the book took me on a thrilling ride. This has such a strong feel of those old classic movies with Cary Grant or Audrey Hepburn as our main characters and I found myself living a piece of their lives through the pages of the story.
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the author for a pre-release copy.
“Shadowed by Grace” in and of itself is a unique plot line. The main characters aren’t your typical soldiers, but they are fighting to protect something so important to society. I loved the tidbits of history sprinkled throughout the story and the telling of what happened to these pieces of art to protect them from being stolen and carried away, not to be found for years to come-if ever.
The landscape is rich in texture and setting. I rode in the back of that army jeep just as much as our hero did. Rachel is a compelling heroine with a story to tell and the romance of the book took me on a thrilling ride. This has such a strong feel of those old classic movies with Cary Grant or Audrey Hepburn as our main characters and I found myself living a piece of their lives through the pages of the story.
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the author for a pre-release copy.
hardcopy-review-to-read
August 8, 2014I’ve been a book reviewer since 2007 and I remember when Cara Putman’s first novella came out. I remember being curious about what a lawyer would write, and what type of imagination would come out on the page. Although Dying for Love was the first story of hers I actually read in the novella collection Cherry Blossom Capers. Cara’s writing is enjoyable and keeps me in suspense. It seems now that I can say her stories are all a delight and intrigue from beginning to end.
When it comes to reading war time novels for me, most of the time they are a hit or a miss, and parts of this reminded me of Tricia Goyer’s espionage war time stories also dealing with art work, but Cara is a different type of author and definitely one to keep the pages turning.
I received this product free for the purpose of reviewing it. I received no other compensation for this review. The opinions expressed in this review are my personal, honest opinions. Your experience may vary. Please read my full disclosure policy for more details.
posted: http://creativemadnessmama.com/blog/2...
When it comes to reading war time novels for me, most of the time they are a hit or a miss, and parts of this reminded me of Tricia Goyer’s espionage war time stories also dealing with art work, but Cara is a different type of author and definitely one to keep the pages turning.
I received this product free for the purpose of reviewing it. I received no other compensation for this review. The opinions expressed in this review are my personal, honest opinions. Your experience may vary. Please read my full disclosure policy for more details.
posted: http://creativemadnessmama.com/blog/2...
January 3, 2014
I love novels set in World War II, and this story presents a new facet with which I was not familiar. Cara Putman has created a fascinating fictional tale based on a group of individuals who had an important role in the war. I loved the title as soon as I saw it, and it became even more special as I read the book and connected its meaning to the story. Pulsating with the emotion of war, romance, and family relationships, this novel whisked me across time to this pivotal era in world history. I won't ever look at a classic painting or sculpture that predates WW II without thinking of this book and the men who risked all to ensure that these treasures were saved for future generations. Start your year off right with this moving story!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Cara Putman and B&H Publishers as part of their Blogger Review program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Cara Putman and B&H Publishers as part of their Blogger Review program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
January 17, 2014
Shadowed by Grace paints a timeless romance in the midst of destruction with colors so vivid you feel like you're living the story along with the characters. Cara Putman balanced rich historical facts with fiction beautifully. I received a history lesson without feeling like I got one. This story shows the sacrifice so many made, and reminds us that even during hardship, God's grace is always working for the good of His children.
Want to read
December 29, 2013Just bought this one!
May 17, 2023
While this book could be slow at times, it was quite beautiful. There are so many facets to WWII, so many stories to be told, and a fictionalized account of the Monuments Men is a great addition. I really liked both Rachel and Scott's characters. I loved that Rachel was a photographer and how Putman showed her searching for and finding the impactful moments. Photographs that make people feel something are rare and incredible.
There is a little side mystery with a revelation that I definitely didn't see coming!
I did feel like the ending was either a bit too abrupt or maybe a little incomplete. But it was a good book.
"There had to be more to life than wavering in and out of lives. Struggling to know and be known. Always holding back from the real fear that if she exposed who she truly was, the rejection would follow in a rush. (pg 230)
There is a little side mystery with a revelation that I definitely didn't see coming!
I did feel like the ending was either a bit too abrupt or maybe a little incomplete. But it was a good book.
"There had to be more to life than wavering in and out of lives. Struggling to know and be known. Always holding back from the real fear that if she exposed who she truly was, the rejection would follow in a rush. (pg 230)
June 1, 2017
This was an interesting Christian historical fiction book about a subject I didn't know much about. Much artwork was destroyed or stolen during WW II, and it is fascinating to know some experts were in the thick of the war finding and trying to preserve it. Add in a romance and a family relationship mystery and this is a book worth reading.
August 5, 2024
I found this book very interesting, I had never heard of the Monuments Men. Scott and Rachel’s story has a little bit of mystery and suspense, is packed with interesting history, a swoony romance, and a trip through war-torn Italy.
October 22, 2018
This was an OK story, set in Italy in 1944. I didn't find the plot extremely believable but the setting was interesting to be sure.
June 13, 2022
Strong main character and loved the historical aspects. Little predictable but good read.
February 12, 2014
Source: Free copy from Litfuse Publicity and B and H Publishing in exchange for a review.
"The Monuments, Fine Arts, and Archives program" was "established in 1943" during World War II.
The group was "under the Civil Affairs and Military Government Sections of the Allied armies."
Their job was to protect, secure, rescue, fine arts stolen by Germany.
Both men and women were involved in this mission. See link for more information from Wikipedia.
The time period is March 1944. Shadowed by Grace, begins with a conversation between a young woman named Rachel and her editor. She wants to travel to Italy to cover combat operations and her boss is uneasy. Her sick mother is in a Philadelphia hospital. Rachel has another reason for wanting to go to Italy; however, her secondary goal does not have the blessing from her mother. Rachel is given "press credentials" and an "honorary classification as captain" and sent overseas to Italy. She is assigned to a lieutenant who is apart of the Monuments group and he will be her escort.
Shadowed by Grace, gave me the opportunity to do further research.
(By the way, The movie Monuments Men begins today at theaters.)
I am familiar with the Monuments Men; but had not read books on this history.
My dad a Veteran of World War II, D-day Omaha Beach and Battle of the Bulge. Dad passed away last August. He and I both have read extensively books on World War II.
The main character in Shadowed by Grace is a photographer, not a writer. There were few women photographers and writers involved in journalism work during World War II. These women were gutsy, defiant, independent. It was not considered feminine or socially acceptable for a woman to do this type of work. (Several links are given below with the emphasis on women journalists during World War II.)
I'm reminded of a story my dad told about when he was photographed for a photo in Life Magazine August 1944 issue. He thought the photographer was crazy for being out there in the middle of, "Battle of the Hedgerows." I can imagine my dad's shock if he'd seen a woman photographer, he would have been appalled and angry.
Pros and Cons:
1. I believe Shadowed by Grace has correct historical facts. One minor problem I disliked, the names of the main characters are modern. Rachel is an Old Testament bible name, but not common for children born in 1920 (in the US.) Two other names, Tyler and Scott are modern names. (See link below from the Social Security Administration of the top names for children born in 1920.) I feel it would've given better authenticity to have common names used for this era.
2. In the military, rank and last names are used. I noticed when speaking audibly to each other last names are used, but in their thoughts first names are used. I feel last names should have been precedent. Although, the Monuments Men were not trained military, they were assigned to the Civil Affairs and Military Government Section, it is possible they did not have to adhere to the using of last names and rank.
3. Shadowed by Grace, had an opportunity to share a story which has not been told before in a Christian fiction book, female photographers and journalists during World War II. I feel this became a background for a love story. I would have liked to see Rachel's personality more tough, resilient, gutsy. She had a double focus in her mission to Italy; but as soon as her "boots" were on the ground she is persuaded by a handsome face.
4. I do feel Shadowed by Grace gives a vivid impression of several factors: civilian abuse, death, carnage of war, fear of enemy, lack of food and shelter.
5. A brief mention of Mt. Vesuvius interruption, March 1944. This was the last time Vesuvius interrupted. I thought this is really interesting the author showing another bit of history.
6. I have an old book of my dad's, it's from the Office of the Chief of Military History, Department of the Army: U. S. Army in World War II European Theater of Operations Cross-Channel Attack by G. A. Harrison. I wanted to point out the history of 5th Army in Italy operations. The 5th Army is where Rachel is later assigned.
"The landing behind the enemy lines facing the Fifth Army was designed to force the Germans to pull out and leave the road to Rome open. Instead of pulling out, the Germans held the Fifth Army attack at the Gustav Line and counterattacked the beachhead." ---This was early in 1944.
Over-all I really liked this book. I did not give the book 5 stars, because I would have liked less dilly- dally romance, more of the war and what the Monuments Men did.
"The Monuments, Fine Arts, and Archives program" was "established in 1943" during World War II.
The group was "under the Civil Affairs and Military Government Sections of the Allied armies."
Their job was to protect, secure, rescue, fine arts stolen by Germany.
Both men and women were involved in this mission. See link for more information from Wikipedia.
The time period is March 1944. Shadowed by Grace, begins with a conversation between a young woman named Rachel and her editor. She wants to travel to Italy to cover combat operations and her boss is uneasy. Her sick mother is in a Philadelphia hospital. Rachel has another reason for wanting to go to Italy; however, her secondary goal does not have the blessing from her mother. Rachel is given "press credentials" and an "honorary classification as captain" and sent overseas to Italy. She is assigned to a lieutenant who is apart of the Monuments group and he will be her escort.
Shadowed by Grace, gave me the opportunity to do further research.
(By the way, The movie Monuments Men begins today at theaters.)
I am familiar with the Monuments Men; but had not read books on this history.
My dad a Veteran of World War II, D-day Omaha Beach and Battle of the Bulge. Dad passed away last August. He and I both have read extensively books on World War II.
The main character in Shadowed by Grace is a photographer, not a writer. There were few women photographers and writers involved in journalism work during World War II. These women were gutsy, defiant, independent. It was not considered feminine or socially acceptable for a woman to do this type of work. (Several links are given below with the emphasis on women journalists during World War II.)
I'm reminded of a story my dad told about when he was photographed for a photo in Life Magazine August 1944 issue. He thought the photographer was crazy for being out there in the middle of, "Battle of the Hedgerows." I can imagine my dad's shock if he'd seen a woman photographer, he would have been appalled and angry.
Pros and Cons:
1. I believe Shadowed by Grace has correct historical facts. One minor problem I disliked, the names of the main characters are modern. Rachel is an Old Testament bible name, but not common for children born in 1920 (in the US.) Two other names, Tyler and Scott are modern names. (See link below from the Social Security Administration of the top names for children born in 1920.) I feel it would've given better authenticity to have common names used for this era.
2. In the military, rank and last names are used. I noticed when speaking audibly to each other last names are used, but in their thoughts first names are used. I feel last names should have been precedent. Although, the Monuments Men were not trained military, they were assigned to the Civil Affairs and Military Government Section, it is possible they did not have to adhere to the using of last names and rank.
3. Shadowed by Grace, had an opportunity to share a story which has not been told before in a Christian fiction book, female photographers and journalists during World War II. I feel this became a background for a love story. I would have liked to see Rachel's personality more tough, resilient, gutsy. She had a double focus in her mission to Italy; but as soon as her "boots" were on the ground she is persuaded by a handsome face.
4. I do feel Shadowed by Grace gives a vivid impression of several factors: civilian abuse, death, carnage of war, fear of enemy, lack of food and shelter.
5. A brief mention of Mt. Vesuvius interruption, March 1944. This was the last time Vesuvius interrupted. I thought this is really interesting the author showing another bit of history.
6. I have an old book of my dad's, it's from the Office of the Chief of Military History, Department of the Army: U. S. Army in World War II European Theater of Operations Cross-Channel Attack by G. A. Harrison. I wanted to point out the history of 5th Army in Italy operations. The 5th Army is where Rachel is later assigned.
"The landing behind the enemy lines facing the Fifth Army was designed to force the Germans to pull out and leave the road to Rome open. Instead of pulling out, the Germans held the Fifth Army attack at the Gustav Line and counterattacked the beachhead." ---This was early in 1944.
Over-all I really liked this book. I did not give the book 5 stars, because I would have liked less dilly- dally romance, more of the war and what the Monuments Men did.
January 19, 2014
"YOU HAVE ONCE CHANCE to make this fly." Bobby Hamilton leaned across his broad desk and stared her down." I had to pull more strings than I knew I had to get the brass to bite on sending a woman to Italy. Who sends a woman to a worn-torn country? Getting credentials? What a mess." The man waved his beefy hands down in a dismissive gesture. "Then getting you on the Queen Mary?" He chomped hard on his cigar.
Rachel perched on the chair in his crowded office as the Andrew Sisters belted out "Bogie Woogie Bugle Boy" on the small Kadette radio sitting atop a stack of papers on Bobby's overloaded credenza. She kept her back so straight her men's-style tailored blazer pulled her shoulders back.
She didn't blink, couldn't give a single sign of weakness. Her editor may have taken all those steps, but she'd had to convince him first, all while watching her mother waste away day by day.
"I hope you know what you're doing, Justice."
"I do." she put as much force behind the word as she could without shouting.
He leaned back in his chair, unlit cigar poised to punctuate a thought. "You've got talent. A way with that camera."
She stroked the case, feeling as if it naturally extended from her.
"Don't let me down. Send back photos that will wow readers." He didn't have to mention his bosses.
"Yes, sir." Rachel lurched to her feet and straightened her skirt's front pleat as she hurried from the room before he could call her back.
:There was so much to do. Too much before she could join the mass of soldiers and handful of civilians who would cross the Atlantic aboard the HMS Queen Mary. If she hurried, she could finish cleaning the apartment and still make it to the hospital before visiting hours ended. It was a stop Rachel had to make, yet dreaded. How could she explain to her mother what she was doing while hiding her secondary purpose?"(Excerpt.)
In the latest novel from best selling author Cara C Putman, Shadowed by Grace takes readers into the heart of Italy in 1944 following United Press photography Rachel Justice as she attempts to locate her father whom she believes can help provide the money to help her mother battle tuberculosis and get well. The only clue she has is her mother's journal and a sketchbook from an artist with the initials RMA.
Her only ally in the process is Lieutenant Scott Lindstorm who is assigned as an officer with the Monuments, Fine Arts, and Archives Division to escort Rachel along the way to shot photographs for the division in need of good press. He was there to help shore up classic buildings that had stood since the Roman Empire that aerial bombings destroyed. Or locate priceless pieces of art created by the masters of the thirteenth century to ensure the fighting hadn't destroyed them. Or plan for the restoration of those that had been touched by the war. The tales that art disappeared behind the lines made it more important than ever that he leave the city for the locations where the sculpture, paintings and altarpieces were housed. He wasn't looking for a tagalong.
What ensues will cause them both to question their true purpose for being in Italy during WWII and in the process find a much deeper meaning into why their paths crossed after all!
I received Shadowed by Grace by Cara C. Putman compliments of Litfuse Publicity and B and H Publishing Group for my honest review. I did not receive any monetary compensation for a favorable review and the opinions expressed are strictly my own. This took me into a side of the war I never knew existed as a division of men know as the Monument Men, protected the culture of the country by guarding and locating precious works of art. This is based on true life events that transpired during the war along with a touch of romance to keep the story interesting. Being a huge fan of WWII history I absolutely LOVED this and wanted to know how it would all play out with WWII Italy being the backdrop. I was not disappointed and easily give this novel a 4.5 out of 5 stars.
Rachel perched on the chair in his crowded office as the Andrew Sisters belted out "Bogie Woogie Bugle Boy" on the small Kadette radio sitting atop a stack of papers on Bobby's overloaded credenza. She kept her back so straight her men's-style tailored blazer pulled her shoulders back.
She didn't blink, couldn't give a single sign of weakness. Her editor may have taken all those steps, but she'd had to convince him first, all while watching her mother waste away day by day.
"I hope you know what you're doing, Justice."
"I do." she put as much force behind the word as she could without shouting.
He leaned back in his chair, unlit cigar poised to punctuate a thought. "You've got talent. A way with that camera."
She stroked the case, feeling as if it naturally extended from her.
"Don't let me down. Send back photos that will wow readers." He didn't have to mention his bosses.
"Yes, sir." Rachel lurched to her feet and straightened her skirt's front pleat as she hurried from the room before he could call her back.
:There was so much to do. Too much before she could join the mass of soldiers and handful of civilians who would cross the Atlantic aboard the HMS Queen Mary. If she hurried, she could finish cleaning the apartment and still make it to the hospital before visiting hours ended. It was a stop Rachel had to make, yet dreaded. How could she explain to her mother what she was doing while hiding her secondary purpose?"(Excerpt.)
In the latest novel from best selling author Cara C Putman, Shadowed by Grace takes readers into the heart of Italy in 1944 following United Press photography Rachel Justice as she attempts to locate her father whom she believes can help provide the money to help her mother battle tuberculosis and get well. The only clue she has is her mother's journal and a sketchbook from an artist with the initials RMA.
Her only ally in the process is Lieutenant Scott Lindstorm who is assigned as an officer with the Monuments, Fine Arts, and Archives Division to escort Rachel along the way to shot photographs for the division in need of good press. He was there to help shore up classic buildings that had stood since the Roman Empire that aerial bombings destroyed. Or locate priceless pieces of art created by the masters of the thirteenth century to ensure the fighting hadn't destroyed them. Or plan for the restoration of those that had been touched by the war. The tales that art disappeared behind the lines made it more important than ever that he leave the city for the locations where the sculpture, paintings and altarpieces were housed. He wasn't looking for a tagalong.
What ensues will cause them both to question their true purpose for being in Italy during WWII and in the process find a much deeper meaning into why their paths crossed after all!
I received Shadowed by Grace by Cara C. Putman compliments of Litfuse Publicity and B and H Publishing Group for my honest review. I did not receive any monetary compensation for a favorable review and the opinions expressed are strictly my own. This took me into a side of the war I never knew existed as a division of men know as the Monument Men, protected the culture of the country by guarding and locating precious works of art. This is based on true life events that transpired during the war along with a touch of romance to keep the story interesting. Being a huge fan of WWII history I absolutely LOVED this and wanted to know how it would all play out with WWII Italy being the backdrop. I was not disappointed and easily give this novel a 4.5 out of 5 stars.
February 13, 2014
The morning after I finished reading Shadowed by Grace, the daily newspaper had a front page article about the movie Monument Men, and I immediately flew to my computer and wrote an excited note to Cara Putman that went something like this:
Hello Cara, Just last evening I completed reading your wonderful book Shadowed by Grace. This morning I picked up today's edition of the Ft Worth Star Telegram and my eye immediately fell to the lower left column on the first page. There was a picture of Robert Edsel above the words “Dallas man drove movie on WWII art rescue”...and went on to talk about the movie made about Monument Men, based on his book about the group’s heroic efforts. Of course, my attention was caught immediately because I had just read his name in your personal notes at the back of the book. Just wanted to let you know....your story made quite an impression on me...imagine finding this article this morning!! Best of God's Blessings, Barb Shelton
Not only did reading this article put real faces to the imaginary names in Cara’s story, it enlightened me to the thorough research she immersed herself within to write this fascinating story. Now, I could see Lieutenant Scott Lindstrom as George Clooney (instead of Gregory Peck) and had already imaged Anne Hathaway as Captain Rachel Justice.
Cara Putman’s story is indeed based on cultural affairs….and I do not mean that word loosely regarding Rachel and Scott! Each, the epitome of respectable ethics in an ungracious period of history. Some of the characters in the story rank as unscrupulous and conniving, while other’s exhibit bravery and faith in God to grace them with safety and daily provisions of which there was little. It was dangerous to lose direction while traveling by jeep, especially if the driver had already lost his way spiritually.
This is a love story surrounded by treacherous conditions of war. Ms. Putman’s exclusive subject on saving historical art masterpieces was literally unknown to me and I reverentially appreciate learning how this world has been able to continue the study and enjoyment of historic art because of a few military men assigned their duty as Monument Men.. God is our eternal guardian and brings about good from the worst of circumstances through his children and angels.
If you have noticed the absence of story details in this review, that is on purpose. You can read those in other fine reviews of Shadowed by Grace and on the back cover of the book. The uniqueness of this story is complimented by the unusual civilian career as an art museum curator held by Scott Lindstrom; and the fact that a woman photographer, Rachel Justice, assigned to the war zone during that time in history was not a common happening. Will the mystery of finding the father in Italy Rachel never knew be “wrapped up?” Will Scott be allowed to understand why Rachel is so afraid of falling in love? Why is Rachel’s ill mother so unwilling to offer Rachel the answers to her birth? This story is about war, peace, love, culture, fear, bravery, searching, redemption, and God’s grace fulfilled. Oh, by the way, Cara Putman graciously replied to my note, and my respectful regard for her as an author and friend is sincerely touched. Her writing fulfilled my expectations because it taught me something important about history I did not know. I eagerly anticipate reading her next book. You need to read this story!
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from LitFuse Publicity Group in exchange for my honest review. All opinions expressed are my own, and no monetary compensation was received for this review.
Hello Cara, Just last evening I completed reading your wonderful book Shadowed by Grace. This morning I picked up today's edition of the Ft Worth Star Telegram and my eye immediately fell to the lower left column on the first page. There was a picture of Robert Edsel above the words “Dallas man drove movie on WWII art rescue”...and went on to talk about the movie made about Monument Men, based on his book about the group’s heroic efforts. Of course, my attention was caught immediately because I had just read his name in your personal notes at the back of the book. Just wanted to let you know....your story made quite an impression on me...imagine finding this article this morning!! Best of God's Blessings, Barb Shelton
Not only did reading this article put real faces to the imaginary names in Cara’s story, it enlightened me to the thorough research she immersed herself within to write this fascinating story. Now, I could see Lieutenant Scott Lindstrom as George Clooney (instead of Gregory Peck) and had already imaged Anne Hathaway as Captain Rachel Justice.
Cara Putman’s story is indeed based on cultural affairs….and I do not mean that word loosely regarding Rachel and Scott! Each, the epitome of respectable ethics in an ungracious period of history. Some of the characters in the story rank as unscrupulous and conniving, while other’s exhibit bravery and faith in God to grace them with safety and daily provisions of which there was little. It was dangerous to lose direction while traveling by jeep, especially if the driver had already lost his way spiritually.
This is a love story surrounded by treacherous conditions of war. Ms. Putman’s exclusive subject on saving historical art masterpieces was literally unknown to me and I reverentially appreciate learning how this world has been able to continue the study and enjoyment of historic art because of a few military men assigned their duty as Monument Men.. God is our eternal guardian and brings about good from the worst of circumstances through his children and angels.
If you have noticed the absence of story details in this review, that is on purpose. You can read those in other fine reviews of Shadowed by Grace and on the back cover of the book. The uniqueness of this story is complimented by the unusual civilian career as an art museum curator held by Scott Lindstrom; and the fact that a woman photographer, Rachel Justice, assigned to the war zone during that time in history was not a common happening. Will the mystery of finding the father in Italy Rachel never knew be “wrapped up?” Will Scott be allowed to understand why Rachel is so afraid of falling in love? Why is Rachel’s ill mother so unwilling to offer Rachel the answers to her birth? This story is about war, peace, love, culture, fear, bravery, searching, redemption, and God’s grace fulfilled. Oh, by the way, Cara Putman graciously replied to my note, and my respectful regard for her as an author and friend is sincerely touched. Her writing fulfilled my expectations because it taught me something important about history I did not know. I eagerly anticipate reading her next book. You need to read this story!
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from LitFuse Publicity Group in exchange for my honest review. All opinions expressed are my own, and no monetary compensation was received for this review.
January 26, 2014
First let me say, the cover is beautiful. I know we're not to 'judge a book by it's cover', but I'm afraid I do that on occasion. :) And this book cover just claims my attention.
Next, I need to also mention that as an author (unpublished) myself, I know how much of yourself, you put into your stories, and how much you love them, no matter what anyone else says. I felt like I could see just how much Mrs. Putman cherished this story of hers. I, personally, felt like you could detect that in "Shadowed by Grace" and I appreciated that.
I am still contemplating all my thoughts on this book. It stuck with me, which if a book is boring or uninteresting to me, it won't stay with me. But I will be honest and say that I had a bit of a hard time really getting into the book. Some parts just didn't grab my attention and keep it there.
The idea of the book is great - the setting is fantastic, the realness is good, and the characters are marvelous. But it lacked something, in my opinion. The story itself wasn't as great as I was hoping for. That doesn't mean that someone else won't love it though. In fact, I think many would greatly enjoy it, especially if they love art. I, however, have never really been interested in art, and therefore didn't enjoy it quite as much.
I really liked the characters, though. Rachel specifically. She was very real. All the characters were well built-up.
I didn't mind the romance - I actually thought it was at a pretty okay level for the most part. Some books focus mainly on the romance and it is heavily played out in the book, but that wasn't the case in "Shadowed by Grace" and I appreciated that. I think that at some points the kissing was a little much, and they kind of jumped into a relationship between the two main characters, but I also think that it was a bit more believable because of the war.
Mrs. Putman, you can tell, did a lot of research for this book. That made it very real and believable.
This book wasn't a favourite for me, but there was something about it that 'sparked'. I don't know exactly how to explain it. Besides the story itself, there is something in the pages that I can't quite put my finger on, but I really liked. Something that got in my head and settled there. The book continued to play out in my head even after I finished it. There's a certain curiosity with it - between the words -that I loved; something written between the lines.
Sometimes I loved the style of writing, and sometimes it confused me, but overall I liked how the author wrote how she wanted to. I think an author has a right to write how they want and I saw that in this book.
The message of God's love towards the end was very good, as well. I think that aspect was well written, though some parts were a bit brief or sudden. Rachel's journey was good and interesting to follow.
There is great potential in this book; there were just some rough parts. The more I think about the book, the more I think fondly of it and want to give it another try sometime in the future.
Next, I need to also mention that as an author (unpublished) myself, I know how much of yourself, you put into your stories, and how much you love them, no matter what anyone else says. I felt like I could see just how much Mrs. Putman cherished this story of hers. I, personally, felt like you could detect that in "Shadowed by Grace" and I appreciated that.
I am still contemplating all my thoughts on this book. It stuck with me, which if a book is boring or uninteresting to me, it won't stay with me. But I will be honest and say that I had a bit of a hard time really getting into the book. Some parts just didn't grab my attention and keep it there.
The idea of the book is great - the setting is fantastic, the realness is good, and the characters are marvelous. But it lacked something, in my opinion. The story itself wasn't as great as I was hoping for. That doesn't mean that someone else won't love it though. In fact, I think many would greatly enjoy it, especially if they love art. I, however, have never really been interested in art, and therefore didn't enjoy it quite as much.
I really liked the characters, though. Rachel specifically. She was very real. All the characters were well built-up.
I didn't mind the romance - I actually thought it was at a pretty okay level for the most part. Some books focus mainly on the romance and it is heavily played out in the book, but that wasn't the case in "Shadowed by Grace" and I appreciated that. I think that at some points the kissing was a little much, and they kind of jumped into a relationship between the two main characters, but I also think that it was a bit more believable because of the war.
Mrs. Putman, you can tell, did a lot of research for this book. That made it very real and believable.
This book wasn't a favourite for me, but there was something about it that 'sparked'. I don't know exactly how to explain it. Besides the story itself, there is something in the pages that I can't quite put my finger on, but I really liked. Something that got in my head and settled there. The book continued to play out in my head even after I finished it. There's a certain curiosity with it - between the words -that I loved; something written between the lines.
Sometimes I loved the style of writing, and sometimes it confused me, but overall I liked how the author wrote how she wanted to. I think an author has a right to write how they want and I saw that in this book.
The message of God's love towards the end was very good, as well. I think that aspect was well written, though some parts were a bit brief or sudden. Rachel's journey was good and interesting to follow.
There is great potential in this book; there were just some rough parts. The more I think about the book, the more I think fondly of it and want to give it another try sometime in the future.
January 15, 2014
About the Book:
Shadowed by Grace is the first in a stirring new series of stand-alone historical suspense novels by acclaimed author Cara C. Putman. Desperate to save her dying mother, Rachel accepts her newspaper’s assignment to travel to Italy to captures images dangerously close to the front lines of WWII. Her real motive – to find the father she never knew -- an artist she hopes can offer the comfort and support both she and her mother need to survive. It’s an unlikely situation for love and faith to flourish, but soon Rachel not only finds herself, but also her long-lost earthly father, and ultimately, the man her Heavenly father created to cherish and provide for her.
About the Author:
Since the time I could read Nancy Drew, I have wanted to write mysteries. In 2005 I attended a book signing at my local Christian bookstore. The rest, as they say, is history. There I met Colleen Coble. With prompting from my husband, I shared my dream with Colleen. Since those infamous words, I've been writing books.
Shadowed by Grace is my 17th novel and a story of my heart. I have also written one non-fiction title (the Complete Idiots Guide to Business Law).
In addition to writing, I am an attorney, lecturer at a Big Ten university, active in women's ministry, and all around crazy woman. Crazy about God, my husband and my kids. I graduated with honors from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln (Go Huskers!) and George Mason Law School. Because I had a few spare moments, I am now in Purdue University's MBA program. You can learn more about my books at http://www.caraputman.com.
My Review:
Rachel only wants to whats best for her mom, even if that means finding her father in a war filled country. Having a job with a widely known newspaper, she easily was sent over to the country to take photos. But seeing the destruction is not what she had imagined, or even the handsome soldier who was forced into following her around day after day. Not matter how much it saddened her to see the homeless people, the orphaned kids, there was nothing in her power she could do. She knows that if she can just get these things on film that it will start a chain reaction back in America, but this handsome solider seems to be standing in her way.
Scott finds this photographer smart and so beautiful its intoxicating. But he can't let that stand in the way of his orders, even if he doesn't like them. Why would he want to make her so bored she'd want to go home, if she was there for a purpose. But still he didn't know what the purpose was for, all she said was she was there to take photo's to send back home to show what is really going on across seas. Being around her, he questions not only his-self but also his duties, he wants to do anything and everything to make her happy. But there's no way to know what she's truly there for and why. Maybe he could find a way to help her, if he only knew.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from Litfuse Publicity.
Shadowed by Grace is the first in a stirring new series of stand-alone historical suspense novels by acclaimed author Cara C. Putman. Desperate to save her dying mother, Rachel accepts her newspaper’s assignment to travel to Italy to captures images dangerously close to the front lines of WWII. Her real motive – to find the father she never knew -- an artist she hopes can offer the comfort and support both she and her mother need to survive. It’s an unlikely situation for love and faith to flourish, but soon Rachel not only finds herself, but also her long-lost earthly father, and ultimately, the man her Heavenly father created to cherish and provide for her.
About the Author:
Since the time I could read Nancy Drew, I have wanted to write mysteries. In 2005 I attended a book signing at my local Christian bookstore. The rest, as they say, is history. There I met Colleen Coble. With prompting from my husband, I shared my dream with Colleen. Since those infamous words, I've been writing books.
Shadowed by Grace is my 17th novel and a story of my heart. I have also written one non-fiction title (the Complete Idiots Guide to Business Law).
In addition to writing, I am an attorney, lecturer at a Big Ten university, active in women's ministry, and all around crazy woman. Crazy about God, my husband and my kids. I graduated with honors from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln (Go Huskers!) and George Mason Law School. Because I had a few spare moments, I am now in Purdue University's MBA program. You can learn more about my books at http://www.caraputman.com.
My Review:
Rachel only wants to whats best for her mom, even if that means finding her father in a war filled country. Having a job with a widely known newspaper, she easily was sent over to the country to take photos. But seeing the destruction is not what she had imagined, or even the handsome soldier who was forced into following her around day after day. Not matter how much it saddened her to see the homeless people, the orphaned kids, there was nothing in her power she could do. She knows that if she can just get these things on film that it will start a chain reaction back in America, but this handsome solider seems to be standing in her way.
Scott finds this photographer smart and so beautiful its intoxicating. But he can't let that stand in the way of his orders, even if he doesn't like them. Why would he want to make her so bored she'd want to go home, if she was there for a purpose. But still he didn't know what the purpose was for, all she said was she was there to take photo's to send back home to show what is really going on across seas. Being around her, he questions not only his-self but also his duties, he wants to do anything and everything to make her happy. But there's no way to know what she's truly there for and why. Maybe he could find a way to help her, if he only knew.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from Litfuse Publicity.
September 10, 2016
Rachel Justice is about to cross the Atlantic on HMS Queen Mary, bound for war-torn Europe, to photograph the fighting as America liberates Italy from the Germans. Her real motivation isn't to bring the war to the minds of her US readers--although that is part of it. She's going to Italy, in search of the father she never knew. Rachel needs to find her father because her mother is suffering from tuberculosis, and is likely to die soon without more medical treatment—treatment Rachel is hoping her father can help pay for.
Lieutenant Scott Lindstrom is an officer in the Monuments, Fine Arts and Archives Division, better known as the Monuments Men. I’d never heard of them, so this was a pleasant surprise which elevated the novel from interesting into something more original, which I like. (The division will also be the subject of an upcoming film, The Monument Men, starring George Clooney and Cate Blanchett. After reading Shadowed by Grace, I’m looking forward to seeing the movie. And not just because it’s got George Clooney.)
Rachel and Scott meet when he is assigned to show her around. Fate keeps throwing them together as the fighting moves north, closer to Tuscany, where Rachel believes her father lives. The plot works well on several levels, with the romance between Rachel and Scott developing as they spent more time together, supported by subplots of war, missing artefacts and Rachel’s search for her father, and for faith. Overall, the book flowed well, and presented an original plot, likeable and interesting characters and an underlying Christian message.
The one thing that annoyed me was when a British character introduced himself as “Leftenant Alistair Barkley”. Yes, I understand they are trying to show us the different accent, but in that case, why not introduce the Americans as Lootenant? And wouldn’t a Southerner pronounce words differently than someone from Los Angeles or Boston? So why weren’t these words spelled differently? (And why was Barkley referred to as Indian? The British ran India in 1945, and Barkley’s family was from England, so he would have considered himself British or English, not Indian.)
I have read a couple of Cara Putman’s contemporary novellas, and while they were solid, they weren’t special in the way Shadowed by Grace is. I just hope we see more in this series—Shadowed by Grace is published by B&H, who announced last year they were closing their fiction line. It would be a shame if this were Putman’s only novel in this vein.
Recommended for historical fiction fans.
Thanks to B&H Books and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.
Lieutenant Scott Lindstrom is an officer in the Monuments, Fine Arts and Archives Division, better known as the Monuments Men. I’d never heard of them, so this was a pleasant surprise which elevated the novel from interesting into something more original, which I like. (The division will also be the subject of an upcoming film, The Monument Men, starring George Clooney and Cate Blanchett. After reading Shadowed by Grace, I’m looking forward to seeing the movie. And not just because it’s got George Clooney.)
Rachel and Scott meet when he is assigned to show her around. Fate keeps throwing them together as the fighting moves north, closer to Tuscany, where Rachel believes her father lives. The plot works well on several levels, with the romance between Rachel and Scott developing as they spent more time together, supported by subplots of war, missing artefacts and Rachel’s search for her father, and for faith. Overall, the book flowed well, and presented an original plot, likeable and interesting characters and an underlying Christian message.
The one thing that annoyed me was when a British character introduced himself as “Leftenant Alistair Barkley”. Yes, I understand they are trying to show us the different accent, but in that case, why not introduce the Americans as Lootenant? And wouldn’t a Southerner pronounce words differently than someone from Los Angeles or Boston? So why weren’t these words spelled differently? (And why was Barkley referred to as Indian? The British ran India in 1945, and Barkley’s family was from England, so he would have considered himself British or English, not Indian.)
I have read a couple of Cara Putman’s contemporary novellas, and while they were solid, they weren’t special in the way Shadowed by Grace is. I just hope we see more in this series—Shadowed by Grace is published by B&H, who announced last year they were closing their fiction line. It would be a shame if this were Putman’s only novel in this vein.
Recommended for historical fiction fans.
Thanks to B&H Books and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.
January 29, 2014
I received this book from Litfuse Publicity for no charge in exchange for my honest review of this book. The opinions expressed here are my own!
Book Description:
Shadowed by Grace is a dramatic story inspired by the Monuments Men of World War II by acclaimed author Cara C. Putman. Desperate to save her dying mother, Rachel accepts her newspaper’s assignment to travel to Italy to capture images dangerously close to the front lines of WWII. Her real motive – to find the father she never knew -- an artist she hopes can offer the comfort and support both she and her mother need to survive. It’s an unlikely situation for love and faith to flourish, but soon Rachel not only finds herself, but also her long-lost earthly father, and ultimately, the man her Heavenly father created to cherish and provide for her.
My Thoughts:
Shadowed by Grace is the first fiction book I have read by Cara C. Putman and I enjoyed it. This book focuses on the Monument Men of World War II and the artifacts that went missing during WWII and how the United States soldiers worked to find them. Photographer Rachel finds herself teamed up with Monuments Man Scott Lindstrom as they head north in Italy. As they travel, they encounter locals who either welcome or distrust them, and pillaged Catholic churches. They help where they can, and Rachel takes photographs of the devastation. They eventually reach the castle of Montegufoni, where many works from Florence were hidden for safety during the war. It is there that they meet a former associate of Scott’s, a man who may hold the key to Rachel’s personal history.
As most familiar with my blog know, I am a huge Historical Fiction fan! I love to read these books that have fact and fiction weaved together. Cara C. Putman writes with authority about the world during WWII especially Italy, Germany, and The United States, the jobs of Monument Men, the military during WWII, and works of art of Italy. As I read this book I could see these works of art in my mind from the vivid descriptions through out this book. I enjoyed the characters in this book especially Rachel. Her determination and dedication to her art were heart warming. Also her journey to finding God in her life again especially through Scott's display of faith. I felt like I was there watching the events unfold. I loved the historical facts that went into this book. I learned quite a bit about WWII I didn't know. I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys Christian Historical Fiction, you won't be disappointed. I give this book 4 stars! I look forward to reading more from Cara C. Putman.
Book Description:
Shadowed by Grace is a dramatic story inspired by the Monuments Men of World War II by acclaimed author Cara C. Putman. Desperate to save her dying mother, Rachel accepts her newspaper’s assignment to travel to Italy to capture images dangerously close to the front lines of WWII. Her real motive – to find the father she never knew -- an artist she hopes can offer the comfort and support both she and her mother need to survive. It’s an unlikely situation for love and faith to flourish, but soon Rachel not only finds herself, but also her long-lost earthly father, and ultimately, the man her Heavenly father created to cherish and provide for her.
My Thoughts:
Shadowed by Grace is the first fiction book I have read by Cara C. Putman and I enjoyed it. This book focuses on the Monument Men of World War II and the artifacts that went missing during WWII and how the United States soldiers worked to find them. Photographer Rachel finds herself teamed up with Monuments Man Scott Lindstrom as they head north in Italy. As they travel, they encounter locals who either welcome or distrust them, and pillaged Catholic churches. They help where they can, and Rachel takes photographs of the devastation. They eventually reach the castle of Montegufoni, where many works from Florence were hidden for safety during the war. It is there that they meet a former associate of Scott’s, a man who may hold the key to Rachel’s personal history.
As most familiar with my blog know, I am a huge Historical Fiction fan! I love to read these books that have fact and fiction weaved together. Cara C. Putman writes with authority about the world during WWII especially Italy, Germany, and The United States, the jobs of Monument Men, the military during WWII, and works of art of Italy. As I read this book I could see these works of art in my mind from the vivid descriptions through out this book. I enjoyed the characters in this book especially Rachel. Her determination and dedication to her art were heart warming. Also her journey to finding God in her life again especially through Scott's display of faith. I felt like I was there watching the events unfold. I loved the historical facts that went into this book. I learned quite a bit about WWII I didn't know. I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys Christian Historical Fiction, you won't be disappointed. I give this book 4 stars! I look forward to reading more from Cara C. Putman.
Read
January 3, 2020I DNF it at page 191. I really wanted to like this book. I couldn't get into it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 152 reviews