When it didn’t put me to sleep, I really enjoyed it.
Ladies, gentleman, non-binary aristocracy and everything outside and inbetween, step aside, because the cure for insomnia has been right there in front of our eyes all this time.
Yes, alright, that might be quite the overstatement, as I have not fallen in a endless slumber (yet) reading this book or else I wouldn’t be awake to write this review (although… it has taken me quite a while… hasn’t it…), and as you see I have given this 4 stars, and those weren’t for pity points and naps.
So, why, you might asked, have you given this book 4 stars, then?
That’s a bit of a tricky question.
You see, there are quite a few reasons why I could potentially have rated this lower:
-I’m more of a prose gal, and if I read poetry, I’m very dependent on them alliterations, rhymes, just some sort of regulations and rules I can apply to appease my desire to find harmony in books if I can’t find it in myself. (Apparently, I’m feeling particularly edgy today.)
-The endless and, more importantly, trivial enumerations really did put me to sleep (I was not exaggerating that part) – I put aside this book multiple times, because I just got way too tired to keep reading (especially during train rides), and there were a few parts where it took me two or three naps to power through them.
-Quite a few poems were themed around war, which is a subject matter I usually tend to avoid – in this case, I found myself enjoying them considerably more. Maybe because there was more going on then when I learned that the baker bakes bread and the shoemaker makes shoes and the dog makes woof and the cat makes meow… (not the exact wording, but way too close)
But, I hear you asking, the first question you asked yourself in this fictional conversation is why you rated this book as 4 stars, and we haven’t even actually asked that question – and still you told us only reasons why you shouldn’t have rated it 4 stars.
To that I say: patience (although you are very right).
So, the thing is, Whitman’s language is just amazing. Yes, there are parts that I felt were quite boring, but the sheer power of his words still captivated me and I saved so. many. quotes. Seriously, there were so many good parts, so many gems hidden inside this concrete blocks of triviality and boredom, and I found so much inspiration for one of the characters I have in mind for one of my countless writing projects that I’m really, really glad to have sat through all of it.
And really, what have I lost considering the only downside were free naps?
Also, have I mentioned it's queer?
[I’ll hopefully add some of my gazillion favourite quotes at some point, but currently I can’t be bothered :)]