Down the centuries, self-starvation has taken many morbid guises - in the extremes of religious fasting and the abstinence of the saints; in hunger strikes; in the exhibition of iving skeletons and hunger artists; in the fate of melancholica, hystericsm the possessed and bewitched. This strange story culminates in the 19th century labelling of anorexia nervosa, a condition which has since attracted a host of theories and explanations and a vast literature, the course of which a medical curiosityhas been transformed into a modern disease. In the history of psyhiatry this is a remarkable account, of great clinical ad historical importance, which will interest anyone concerned with the interaction of culture and the individual. Walter Vandereycken, an international authority on the research and treatment of eating disorders, is Professor of Psychiatry at the Catholic University of Leuven, Belgium. Ron Van Deth is a psychologist in Leiden, the Netherlands.
An informative and largely well-written book (aside from an extremely tangential section in the final chapter), with a lot of well-researched content. However, it lacks argumentative momentum throughout. This is made more frustrating by highly promising, but underdeveloped, suggestions, such as the importance of attending to contemporary practices of self-starvation amidst abundance, a peculiar setting reflecting the significance of political and economic questions in the theorisation of anorexia. Further development of this idea would have added a refreshing perspective on hackneyed argument concerning the damaging thin ideal and diet industry. Particularly intriguing was the question with which the book ended: to what extent are present-day psychologists and psychiatrists contributing to the problem through their theorisations? Since two highly qualified psychologists have authored this book, I would have hoped for at least a gesture towards an answer. Nevertheless, the very posing of the question rests on a pleasing degree of self-awareness on the part of the authors that the narratives of their field may, in fact, be as limiting as the stigma and ignorance they are trying to combat.
thought it may be interesting or that there’s some sort of education but this book was awful. the idea of it is good but it’s so bad written and there’s too much historical information that wasn’t even true. the main aspects of the topic are not in the book and the authors just copy pasted the opinions of past people
sehr interessant nicht nur über einzelschicksale zu lesen, sondern sich der historischen entwicklung von esstörungen anzuschauen. angenehmer schreibstil und trotzdem fachlich kompetent.