Many Moons Ago = 3 stars (pretty good)
September 2025 = 2 stars / skimmed to write review
Long ago, I was an A.S. fan and read most of her books. Now, I’m rereading some to see what I think and write reviews. Sadly, my tastes have changed, and I’m not enjoying them as much as before. However, a few successful rereads motivate me to keep trying.
🟊 At least I remember reading A.S.'s books, unlike many others which are easily forgotten.
THE CHARACTERS:
Anne Kirkland (34) is an assistant editor who loves her family's historic home from the Revolution era. It's falling apart, and she fights to keep it livable. Though her family is full of successful artists, they’re bad with money and rely on Anne, a struggling jack of all trades.
🥃 She regularly drinks expensive cognac.
Noah Grant (32) is a corporate lawyer fed up with the system. He's doing one last assignment for his father-in-law, before switching to a role where he can truly make a difference. The loss of his wife and unborn child three years ago left him traumatized and wary of relationships. Though their marriage was troubled, he never plans to marry again.
Side Characters:
▪️Wilson, a staid lawyer and Anne's fiancé.
▪️Holly Kirkland, a renowned cellist.
▪️Ashley Kirkland, a successful painter who's gay.
▪️Proffy, the Kirkland siblings' father.
A BRIEF PLOT SUMMARY
﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀
The MCs meet when Noah is sent to New Jersey to evaluate an old, rambling house for The Allibet Foundation's artist retreat. If suitable, he’ll handle the negotiations. Three Kirkland family members want to sell, but Anne is the only one unaware of the plans. She refuses to let go—despite knowing she can't afford to maintain the house and that it's a lost cause.
Over two weekends, the MCs go from lust and making out to falling in love. Anne cheats on Wilson, but it's okay because he and Holly are secretly in love, and neither Anne nor Wilson truly care for each other. Finally (at 80%), Anne and Wilson break up so he can pursue Holly. They soon get married.
Near the story’s end, Anne learns the house is sold during Ashley’s art gallery opening. Deeply hurt, she leaves to stay with her aunt in Vermont, refusing to talk to her family. Weeks pass. Noah, now in Connecticut, realizes he loves Anne and wants her back. His aunt brings the MCs back together, when she tells Anne about a job building a seaside cottage, which turns out to be Noah’s home. They reconcile and then have sex at the cottage, where they'll live after marriage. Despite Noah’s wish to avoid children after his wife’s death, Anne gets pregnant.
At the hospital, Anne is about to have their baby, and Noah is terrified she’ll die. Over the past nine months, he’s been a nervous wreck, obsessing over every twinge and fearing the worst. When she goes into the C-section, Noah, previously unable to be with her, finally shows up to support her. They welcome a baby girl named Lillian.
﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀
❗Despite a reviewer's claim, Noah and Holly do not have sex. She attempts to push him, he considers it, but he never goes through with it.
A FEW DISLIKES:
🔻 The repeated mentions of Anne and Wilson 'making love,' as well as the reference to her past sexual encounters in college.
🔻Anne believes she's mediocre among her talented family, but it turns out she's even more brilliant—capable of doing almost anything exceptionally well. She felt a bit too much like a 'Mary Sue' for me.
🔻 There are many repetitive words and phrases, such as "Celtic Gypsy eyes," "Gypsy face," "Celtic blue eyes," "blue eyes," "gypsy blue eyes," "Celtic Gypsy gaze," and "Gypsy smile."
🔻 Anne prays to an impassive God. So why bother praying?
🔻I didn't feel any love or passion between the MCs.
🔻The sex scenes aren't sexy.
Sex Scene Except:
The white-hot flames were building now, licking her body, and she clung to him like a boat adrift in a storm-tossed sea. And then suddenly, unexpectedly, it happened, and she was flung out into the sky in a shower of stars, and in that explosion of glory she felt his body stiffen in her arms, heard his strangled cry, and she wept, for the joy of being alone no longer.