This book was pretty wild!
Full disclosure, I had to read this book for a class I’m taking. That being said, I did actually read the whole thing word-for-word. It was definitely entertaining, and I couldn’t help but finish it.
My initial though after finishing the book was: “that’s it?” While there was stuff happening in this book, there was not nearly enough plot for my taste. Given the length of this book, relatively little happened. I don’t want to spoil anything for prospective readers, but there are only a few main plot points, all of which are completely postponed for the other books in this series. Not a single plotline reached its conclusion; this book cannot, under any circumstance, stand alone. I know that’s not the point of a book in a series, but there was very little material that didn’t rely on a second book, and the plot unfolded sooo slowly.
It’s very clear that the author has a plan. She sprinkles breadcrumb after breadcrumb for the reader to pick up on and utilizes chapter of her book for each breadcrumb. Because of this, the book’s pacing was incredibly slow, and the writing got clunky and somewhat unclear at times. However, it is a nice reward to finally get to a plot point where everything connects, where we can finally munch on those breadcrumbs. Overall, though, I would say that the breadcrumbs are mostly heavy-handed and unnecessary.
The characterization in this book was almost non-existent. Many of the characters were VERY one-dimensional, cookie cutter, and lacked backstory. The men in this book basically only got physical descriptions, and the main character basically just objectifies every man she meets. Marlowe, Nathan, Cerne, Anasi, Finnbhera; they’re all described as hot in some way or another, and are given very little backstory. Even other female characters weren’t given many deeper backstories, plotlines, or descriptions. The main character, Luna, is especially one-dimensional and reads very much like a typical Wattpad y/n character. She doesn’t want the responsibility she’s given, she hates participating in things, she’s way too cool to show her affection to others, she immediately catches the eye of all the men in this book, she is adorably awkward and shy, she just wants a boring, normal life; the list goes on. The bottom line for me is that there isn’t a single character in this book that I feel emotionally invested in.
Finally, I was very frustrated with the lack of character agency in this book, especially for the main character. There is not a single time in this book that Luna genuinely has to make a hard choice. Everything she does is because some exterior force requires it. This book is an example of the “Chosen One” trope done poorly, and Luna never once really steps up to the plate. The ending only comes because of an exterior, deus-ex-machina-type force coming in to temporarily conclude the plot. This all leads to a very bipartisan reading experience, with little to no rooting for/against any of the characters.
Overall, the book was entertaining (there are some pretty ~freaky~ things that go on between characters that are highly amusing), it was written by someone who has a plan, and it wasn’t terrible. However, I had major issues with pacing and characterization, and I was left pretty underwhelmed and uninvested. I’m interested to see where the next book goes (I also have to read that one for class), and (hopefully) how the pacing picks up and we find out more about the characters. Stay tuned!