Chronicles of the Cumberland Settlements

by Paul Clements

Eye witness accounts of life and settlement of Nashville and Middle Tennessee area 1779-1796. 300 maps.

785 pages, Hardcover

First published January 1, 2012

Reviews

[Abrahamus · Rating 5 out of 5]

I worked with the author/editor, Paul Clements (whom I now count as a friend), on the design for this book and for some associated promotion when it was first published about ten years ago. In the intervening years I have skimmed it here and there often, but finally committed to doing a thorough (though gradual) read-through beginning back in 2019. This hefty volume (almost 800 pages if the indices are included) offers a treasury of insight into the settlement of my own native region. The content consists primarily of a broad assemblage of excerpts from primary source, first-hand (or second-hand in some cases) accounts by those of European descent who were involved in establishing the first permanent settlements in the area now known as Middle Tennessee. (Also, most helpfully, copious and detailed maps are interspersed throughout the pages.) Clements provides additional background and commentary in the brief introductions for each chapter (which, after several introductory chapters of pre-historical background on the various native tribes of the region, proceed chronologically by year from 1780, when the Robertson and Donelson parties established a permanent settlement at what eventually became Nashville, until 1796, when Tennessee was granted statehood by the U.S.) and in the appendices. What emerges is a sustained account that features many, many instances (from all parties involved) of both the best and worst that humanity has to offer: harrowing brutality, inspiring bravery and endurance, noble self-sacrifice, shameful treachery, devoted loyalty, and abhorrent cruelty. The legacy of James Robertson, who exhibited immense personal bravery and determination, along with a steadfast commitment to dealing honorably with the natives (despite counting two of his own sons among those brutally murdered), shines forth as perhaps the most under-appreciated example of leadership from the founding era of the state and of the nation.

[Jim · Rating 4 out of 5]

Very small font is a bit hard to read, but well worth the effort! Chock full of first hand history that you will never come across. Paul has dug it all up for us and made getting a grasp of the trials and toughness of the Cumberland settlers as easy as sitting on your couch. Great job! An important historical compilation.