The book is about the Detroit Tigers magical 1968 season in which they won a World Series. It was the last year that American League and National League champions were chosen based simply on their records. It was the last time a starting pitcher won 30 games and it was probably the last time a ballplayer refused to accept a raise from management when Al Kaline told GM, Jim Campbell, that he wasn't worth $100,000. Oh have things changed.
I was a boy 6 years of age, and my earliest memories were of the Detroit Tigers. It was a nice book to reminisce about my heroes and to try to determine what I actually remember about that season. It turns out that I remembered almost nothing but that's alright. I still get a chill when I think about Mickey Stanley, Bill Freehan, Stormin Norman Cash, Al Kaline, Willie Horten, Northrup, McAuliffe, Gates "the Gator" Brown, and Micky Lolich, etc.
The book is a series of interviews by George Cantor, a beat writer for the Free Press who wrote the book 25-30 years after that season. I think any baseball fan would find the interviews interesting. It was a different era, dominated by the pitcher. Denny McLain won 31 games and many of the players were making $18,000/year. Cantor's interview with pitcher Earl Wilson was my favorite. Earl was a black man who grew up in Louisiana, deep in the Jim Crow south. When he first visited Detroit as a member of the Boston Red Socks, he fell in love with the city. He couldn't believe that middle class black people owned these huge mansions. He was eventually traded to Detroit and after he retired, he made Detroit his home and he started a business there. I had to laugh when Earl Wilson questioned the sanity of modern-day baseball owners. He said that baseball would be the last business he would enter into in this world and said that after paying out the outlandish salaries of modern-day players, that owners have trouble making 1% ROI. Wilson also didn't like the DH rule stating that he hit 35 home runs as a starting pitcher, and he considered his bat as one of his weapons to outperform the opposing pitcher.
Not all the interviews went as well. Gates Brown was full of sour grapes. Gates claimed he was never happy about being relegated to a pinch-hitting role in 1968 even though he hit >.400 with 19 pinch hits. I empathize with Brown but even Al Kaline, a future Hall of Famer, had a hard time getting plate appearances with that loaded outfield. The Gator sported two World Series Tigers championship rings because he was a batting coach for the 1984 Tiger's team. He quit coaching because the Tigers only offered him a small $2,500 raise after that series. The Tigers signed Gates Brown out of the Ohio State penitentiary, and it was sad to hear how disgruntled he was. Did he not realize that every kid I knew that played baseball idolized him? That has to be worth something - especially to a guy who was signed on a prison baseball yard while serving hard time, incarcerated. Cantor makes no mention of the infamous hot dog story where Mayo Smith called Brown to pinch hit early in the game while the Gator was sneaking a hot dog break. Brown had a bit of a weight problem and management was always on his back about it. Anyway, the Gator tucked the two dogs in his jersey and went up to bat. He ended up hitting a double and slid face first into second base. Pureed hot dog with mustard and ketchup was all over the front of his uniform causing the shortstop and second basemen and Gates teammates back in the Tiger's dugout to roar with laughter. How can you write a book about the '68 Tigers and not include this story?
It was clear to me that the author, George Cantor despised Denny McLain and he seemed to use poison ink every time he referred to McLain in the book. Cantor mentions a time that he and another reporter, Joe Falls, paid McLain a visit to confront him about a comment that McLain had made that had offended Falls. It was just prior to McLain's last World Series start and it almost came to blows. Cantor writes that Falls asked him to go with him to confront McLain and warned that it may lead to a fight and Cantor wrote "Oh what fun." I thought that this was very unprofessional. This jogged one childhood memory: I never liked those two sports writers. Cantor writes, what if they did get in a fight McLain became injured just prior to his game 6 start? The Tigers would have lost the World Series because of these two media hacks? McLain was not a good guy, but this was very low-brow, unprofessional conduct by Falls and Cantor. They could have waited till after the series to confront McLain. Cantor gives another example of his buddy Falls writing a story based on an interview with an intoxicated Joe Sparma that caused problems in the clubhouse. I would have barred these two from the clubhouse for life.
The book starts in the end of the '67 season when the Tigers lost the pennant down the stretch to the Boston Red Sox. It picks up in Lakeland, Florida for the Tigers '68 spring training. Cantor provides sketchy coverage of the regular season and a disjointed coverage of the World Series. The 68' series was interesting. Mickey Stanley was the starting center fielder during the regular season, and was moved to shortstop because Ray Oyler, the starting shortstop during the regular season, was hitting 0.100. The Tigers' star and future hall of famer, Al Kaline, was put out of action earlier in the season when he was hit by a wild pitch and had accepted the role of a bench player upon his return to action. This was because manager, Mayo Smith, didn't want to upset a winning recipe. He had Horton in left, Stanley in CF, and Northrup in RF and it was the best outfield in the American League. To get the future hall of famer's bat back in the lineup, Smith made the unprecedented decision to move the team's best athlete, Mickey Stanly, from CF to SS and put Kaline in the outfield. Mickey had 6 regular season games to get used to shortstop after the Tigers clinched the pennant during the regular season. The move paid off. in the World Series, Kaline responded with a 1.055 OPS with 11 hits including two doubles and two homeruns. Mickey Stanley, on the other hand, made two errors at short but neither resulted in a run. Mickey did say that the move made him uncomfortable, and it ruined his World Series experience. There are a lot of stories like this in the book.
This book is a decent read about the '68 Tigers with several enjoyable interviews. Just don't expect a Danial James Brown, Boys in the Boat caliber read, and you will do fine. If you're a Tigers fan or at least a baseball fan and can put up with some slightly disjointed but interesting interviews, put together by a beat writer about our national pastime, then you should enjoy this book.