True crime is pretty much everywhere these days. In podcasts, in tv documentaries and in fiction. So it's hard to make something featuring this topic stand out, to do things differently. I must admit that 'True Crime' felt very much "been there, done that".
Ten years ago, Katy disappeared. She left work and was never seen again. Her case was never closed, but neither is it an active investigation anymore. But now, a tv company wants to make a true crime documentary about Katie. Katie's mother, Grace, reluctantly agrees, hoping the broadcast might lead to new leads, the truth of what happened that day, but mostly shine a light on the dangers of being a woman. However, things don't go at all like she expected.
The story switches between episodes from the documentary, Grace dealing with open wounds and her grief, and the reader even hears Katy as she explains what happened the day she went missing. It is mostly the true crime parts that feel like you've read or seen them before. I get that it's hard to put a twist on it but the "stage directions", for instance, have become rather tiresome. I found the effect this documentary has on Grace much more fascinating. In fact, her story interested me a lot more than whatever else was happening. The way she exists, rather than lives. How alone she is, how she's pushed almost everyone away, and how her only connections are forum members who are still trying to figure out what happened to Katy.
There were three suspects back in the day. All three get their say. Is one of them responsible for Katy's disappearance? Do they know more than what they're saying? Could there be someone else the police never even considered? It wasn't easy to figure out because none of the potential suspects came across as particularly likeable or trustworthy. But someone is most definitely making sure that certain things will not see the light of day.
This is also where I, personally, thought things went a little off the rails. I never could have predicted where this story was heading, which is always a bonus, but I had a tough time with plausibility. I couldn't help but wonder that Katy put herself in danger by making a slew of stupid decisions. Ultimately causing heartache for those around her. Honestly, my heart broke multiple times for her poor mum, Grace. Not only did she lose her daughter but the documentary also slowly forces her to come to terms with the fact that maybe she didn't know her daughter as well as she thought she did. Will Grace ever find out the truth of what happened to her Katy?
With a cast of suspicious characters, a determined mother, secrets that must be unearthed, and a decade old case to solve 'True Crime' has a lot going for it. It's a compelling and tense read, and once I started I had to keep going to find out what happened ten years ago. It definitely also has that true crime vibe from the tv documentaries, but I was never quite able to shake that feeling that I've read something exactly like this before. A good and enjoyable read but, despite the odd twist here and there, ultimately a fairly standard mystery.