Her Wicked Sin

Sins of Salem #1

by Sarah Ballance

Salem, Massachusetts, 1692 On a moonless night, he rides into the winter forest on his beast as black as midnight . . . Dashing stranger, Henry Dunham, comes to Salem on a mysterious errand, but is thrown from his horse in the dead of night and rescued by the local Puritan midwife, Lydia Colson. Haunted by her past, Lydia is running from her own dark secrets, avoiding intrusive questions by pretending her dead husband is simply . . . away. But when she and Henry are caught in a compromising situation, one punishable by Puritan law, he saves her from scandal by claiming to be her errant spouse . . . and claiming her bed. Forced to fake a marriage, Lydia and Henry find their passion overwhelming and their vows a little too real. As their lies become truths, a witch hunt closes in on Lydia, threatening not only their burgeoning love, but her life. Contains mature themes.

Genres: Historical, Historical Romance, Romance, Historical Fiction

154 pages, ebook

Published September 9, 2013

About the author

Sarah and her husband of what he calls “many long, long years” live on the mid-Atlantic coast with their six young children, all of whom are perfectly adorable when they’re asleep. She never dreamed of becoming an author, but as a homeschooling mom, she often jokes she writes fiction because if she wants anyone to listen to her, she has to make them up. (As it turns out, her characters aren’t much better than the kids). When not buried under piles of laundry, she may be found adrift in the Atlantic (preferably on a boat) or seeking that ever-elusive perfect writing spot where not even the kids can find her.

She loves creating unforgettable stories while putting her characters through an unkind amount of torture—a hobby that has nothing to do with living with six children. (Really.) Though she adores nail-biting mystery and edge-of-your-seat thrillers, Sarah writes in many genres including contemporary and ghostly paranormal romance. Her ever-growing roster of releases may be found on her website.

Reviews

[Alexandra · Rating 4 out of 5]

my second read by Sarah Ballance, and I really enjoy her writing and storytelling, but the resolution feels like it happens too quickly

[Angie Elle · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thank you to ENTANGLED: SCANDALOUS and Netgalley for providing a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

3.5 stars

The set up for this series is interesting and unique. The Salem Witch Trials are an untapped time in our history as far as settings go, and the author did a wonderful job capturing the intensity that surrounded these events. The cover, however, fails to mimic this, so if you’re interested in this book, I suggest sticking to the synopsis to make your choice. It’s disappointing, because the options for something eye-catching to draw a reader in are endless. Surprisingly, this book did include insta-lust and insta-love. I can see the draw of lust on both parts of the MC’s, but I’d expect the heroine to be a bit wary of tying herself so hastily to a man because of her past. I liked Lydia. She was living a life where, for multiple reasons, she was constantly looking over her shoulder, but she never let her convictions waver. Henry was a wonderful hero. He was well-travelled and intelligent, and he genuinely cared for Lydia. He was very careful with the secrets she shared with him, and his first instinct was always to make her comfortable. They dynamics in the Puritan community were interesting. Untamed gossip could lead to someone’s death, and it almost felt like ‘friends’ and neighbors were desperate to point the finger at someone else lest accusations and death find them. I thought the pacing of this book was pretty swift, but that’s to be expected from the length. I give the author props for sliding a mystery into the book that the reader isn’t even aware of until everything clicks into place. While Her Wicked Sin was an enjoyable read, it left me wanting more. I think this book would have benefited from a bigger word count and more exploration of the period in which it was set.

This review was originally posted at Badass Book Reviews.

[Joe Breedon · Rating 5 out of 5]

Sarah Ballance, author with Entangled Publishing, LLC has brought us her latest release, Her Wicked Sin.

Set in 1692 Salem, Massachusetts, her story begins with Lydia Colson. Lydia is a midwife by trade, returning home one winter night from a duty. She comes across a man, Henry, in a dark forest; his foot stuck in the stirrup of his horse and he is in great pain. True to the nature of her profession, she offers him assistance. Providing him and his horse with accommodations for the night, the story takes off.

These two strangers quickly relate and grow accustomed to each other. However, neither of whom come without past issues which are addressed: Henry, his search for his brother, his father's attempts to find him a suitable spouse and then Lydia with her secrets regarding her ex husband and accusations of witchcraft, a crime punishable by death. The two provide support for each other, even in an extremely compromising situation, and grow very close. Fighting through the trials and tribulations of colonial era Salem and the witch trials, will they grow close enough to build a loving relationship? Or will they fail and part ways? Read it, and find out!

Sarah Ballance has done an exceptional job with this release. The story is well built, plot flows effortlessly and the language is true to the era. An exciting read, start to finish! Definitely a must read!

[Crystal · Rating 4 out of 5]

I received a copy of this book from NetGalley in place of an honest review.

Lydia Colson is running from her past. She never wants to think about her abusive husband ever again. She just wants to help other people out and that will come back to haunt her when she makes enemies out of some people in town.

Henry Dunham is set on a journey to find his half brother from his mother's first husband. He has an accident on his horse and Lydia is there to help him with his ankle.

This is a book that is set in the Old Salem when they had the witch hunt, when many women lost their lives because of lies. I was glad that Lydia found Henry and that she has a chance to make a life with him. Everyone deserves a second chance. Not many people get a chance to find love after being through what Lydia had to endure. This was wonderfully written and I just feel in love with the characters and the story.

[Nadene (Totally Addicted to Reading) · Rating 5 out of 5]

Her wicked sin is a very interesting read. It provided me some insight into the whole issue of the Salem Witch trials and what it was like to live in that time period. The writing was very descriptive, which enabled me to have a clear picture of what was happening in the story. The language used is definitely not modern which is a clear indication that the author did her due diligence prior to writing this title. The characters were quite colourful and they helped to add flavour to the story. The people of Salem were a part of a religious group called the Puritans. They were of the belief that sexual sin, be it fornication or adultery was punishable by death. I believed them to be a set of religious hypocrites. My least favourite character is Rebecca. She is the town gossip and she sought to stir up trouble whenever she could. Then there were the Abbot children, who were quite devious in their actions and thoughts. They were responsible for spreading lies, with the help of other members of the town, about Lydia the female protagonist. These lies had dire consequences.
Lydia had come to Salem to escape her past. She had learned skills that enabled her to become the town's physician. Henry the male protagonist is a wealthy merchant who came to Salem searching for his brother. The relationship that developed between these two had started out on a lie but it became a force to be reckoned with. This story is a page turner. There was one particular incident I never saw coming when it happened I was like OMG it can't be.
This is a must read for lovers of historical romance.
I was given an ARC to provide a honest review.

[Darcus Murray · Rating 4 out of 5]

I was really excited to read this book because I have a strange obsession with the Salem Village witch trials. I'm not big on historical, but give me Salem and I'll gladly read it.

This book was so good! I think it had enough of the horrible trials to show what life was like then without making them the center point of the story. The characters are very easy to like and enjoyable to read.

The story itself is very interesting and kept you into it. The relationship between the two characters is sensual and has twists that made me gasp. The little twist towards the end caught me off guard completely, made sense and pissed me off all at the same time. I'm just glad it was resolved by the end because if I had had to wait for another book, I wouldn't have been able to stand it.

I would definitely recommend this book and would read it again in a heartbeat.


Favorite Character: Lydia
Ratin: 4 Stars.

[Diana Quincy · Rating 5 out of 5]

When I heard "Her Wicked Sin" was set in Salem, Massachusetts during the Salem witch trials, I was intrigued and wanted to read it. I wasn't disappointed.

The dialogue and Puritan lifestyle infused this story with interesting details that really set it apart. I love historical romances that teach me a little about history and "Her Wicked Sin" definitely does that. (I gave it an extra star for its uniqueness.)

All in all, Sarah Ballance has written a sweet romance with appealing characters. "Her Wicked Sin" has its spooky moments and I totally did not see the big twist coming near the end of the book. If you are bored with the usual historical romances, check out "Her Wicked Sin." I was entertained from start to finish.

[ᑭᑌᑎƳᗩ [Punya Reviews...] · Rating 3 out of 5]

My review contains spoilers and they're mostly my thoughts as I went with the book... for more, visit Punya Reviews...

Sarah Balance’s Her Wicked Sin, book 1 of Sins of Salem, had a very interesting backdrop; the dark and superstitious Salem, Massachusetts laden with the frenzy of the disgraceful witch-hunting. I don’t recall reading a romance novel set in that time-frame, so I found the notion rather refreshing. However, there were things that bugged me too. I’ll try to explain in my review.

Lydia, the young h of our story, has been living in Salem for the past year under a false surname and has been working as a physician and a mid-wife. No one has ever seen her husband, whom Lydia claims to have been out at the sea. That she’s waiting for his return. But no one knows of the dark past that still haunts Lydia. Even though she’s found a rather good life in Salem and has come to know some good neighbors, Lydia is running because she murdered her drunk and abusive husband in the dead of the night, right after his beating that led her to miscarry their child. Other than that brute, she didn’t have a family, losing them in a fire at once. She thought her husband would be her lifeline because they met right after she lost her family. But that was not to be. Lydia is beautiful, a fact that made her husband suspicious and illogically mean towards her. Nothing good came from that marriage, and though Lydia thinks she’s rid of him for good, she can’t rest easy, always in fear that her little secret would be out one day and she’d be punished.

One night, on her way home from attending a birth, Lydia saves a handsome, young stranger. The man, Henry as he introduces himself, has been wounded from a fall from his horse; a giant, black steed with obvious good and powerful breeding. Lydia takes him home to attend to his injuries. Although Henry, ever the gentleman, raises his concern about her being with him alone in her house, Lydia brushes it aside. She’s the village physician and Henry’s leg is badly wounded. What can happen between them? Besides everybody knows she’s married and waiting for her husband. But still, the Puritans in this village will have a fit if they learn about it. Adultery is condemned to death penalty, that’s surely a cause for concern.

As if to make matters worse, a nosy and disdainful neighbor of Lydia, Rebecca Mathers drops by with the news of an illness just that night. This woman, who considers herself someone of import in the village, is nothing but a busybody with a pinched face and a mouth full of righteous words. And though she was once a friend to Lydia, after witnessing her husband’s interest in Lydia, Rebecca has turned mean. Just how mean and vengeful, we find out as the story progresses.

Henry is found at Lydia’s house by Rebecca; an obvious bad news. To save her from the ill gossip and the punishment for adultery, Henry steps in and introduces himself as her husband. Lydia is shocked but goes with his plan. But she knows this won’t stop Rebecca’s mouth and the whole village would likely know about her ‘errant husband’s’ return by the morning.

Henry tells Lydia that he’s in search of his eldest half-brother because his mom is ill and wants to see her son. The half-brother in question had a bad relationship with Henry’s father, hence he left and severed all ties with them. Lydia is sympathetic but she’s also worried about the fate of the story they’ve just woven to stop the gossips.

At this point, Henry expresses his interest in Lydia, who has already confessed to being a widow. When a day passes between them, Henry convinces Lydia that he’s totally into her and wants to marry her in earnest. Lydia, at first, can’t believe it, though she wants to. Then again, she has been starving for affection since her family passed away. Neighbors here, though solicitous, aren’t really prone to showing affection in public, certainly to people not of their own families. Moreover, they’re easily suspicious of strangers. Lydia has not been able to find that deep of a bond with anyone. So, she easily gives in and they handfast that night without any witness.

Now here was the problem. I was like, huh? How can this happen? I mean they just met, exchanged a few words and wrought a plan to stave off the gossip. I totally understood that part, Henry’s intention to help Lydia. But aside from Lydia sensing that Henry is, indeed, a gentleman and from a well off family (his horse, clothing gave it away) and Henry expressing his attraction to her (of course, she’s beautiful), I saw nothing that solid between them. Even the attraction was lukewarm, so in my mind I couldn’t validate their insta-love which resulted to that handfasting. When bits of pieces of her husband’s abusive behavior were revealed, Lydia’s instant trust in Henry also seemed rather unbelievable to me.

Then there was the writing style. The narrative, and the dialogue, was rather of period-style, quite heavily so. Maybe it was done to be true to the time-frame but I’m not used to with that kind of narrative. Because of that, it took me a while to get into the story because I kept re-reading these lines often to get the exact meaning.

For a while, these problems kinda flattened the story for me; at least for the first couple of chapters where Henry is introduced throughout the village as Lydia’s husband to satiate the overly curious neighbors’ interests. Soon, they also consummate their handfasting. For the first time in her life, Lydia enjoys the sex act, something that she hated beforehand. Yet, after everything, Lydia keeps on doubting the turn of events, convinced that Henry wouldn’t stay beyond couple of weeks. But she thinks she’s falling for Henry nonetheless. Funny thing was, it was Henry who expresses his love first and tries to convince Lydia that he’ll stay with her, even after his brother is found. Henry’s musings proves that his intentions where Lydia is concerned are clear and true. He doesn’t care for the riches of his family one way or the other, so a simple life with his new wife is all he craves.

In between, that woman, Rebecca, comes down upon Lydia with a vengeance, cooking up trouble. Her apparently oblivious husband, Thomas keeps trying to be gentlemanly towards Lydia, an attention she’d rather not have. Rebecca’s ire and ugly nature is something she doesn’t want to deal with. Yet, she can’t shake off Thomas’s attention cause she doesn’t want to appear rude either.


A fanciful illustration of the Salem Witch Trial, source Wikipedia

At this point, I still wasn’t sure of the story and where it was going until the time when a gossip starts brewing in Salem. Arrests have already been made on accusation of witchcraft, which cast a dark and dreary pall throughout the village. People seem on the edge, nervous and waiting for the something bad to happen anytime, to anyone. Just then, someone spreads a gossip about a stranger being seen on a huge, black horse which is said to be the Devil’s very own steed. Then, Lydia heard that someone was looking for her, a stranger. Lydia didn’t know anyone who can specifically look for her but the law, to charge her with the murder. Yet with all the gossip and people’s sudden odd behavior around her, Lydia becomes scared. At the same time, Lydia starts sensing that she’s being watched from afar. But she never really could figure out the source. Her house being on the outskirts of the village, Lydia often has to return home alone. And even though Henry wants to be with her, she knows he won’t be here always. So what can she do?

At that time, a well-off family’s mistress calls on her to check on her seemingly ill daughters. But upon examination, Lydia finds that the daughters are perfectly fine. Indeed, it was the eldest girl’s plan to act ill so that they can skip their chores around the house. When Lydia confronts them and tells their mother that everything’s fine, that vile girl promises that there would be trouble for her. I couldn’t believe the kind of poison these illiterate, superstitious people harbored! That they’d resort to just about anything to erase a person they thought they don’t want around. Before getting into the review, I was reading some articles online. The reasons behind these hangings were just mind-blowing... and asinine IMO.

And so, trouble soon finds Lydia. She’s charged with witchcraft because she rides a big black horse, Henry’s horse Willard. Because some stranger is looking for her, even Henry is a stranger to the village. And then, those same children, the 4 daughters of that family, start acting crazy, swearing that they see Lydia at night in spectral form! She comes in to taunt them, in turn making them ill. So it was no surprise that their mother accuses Lydia of practicing witchcraft on ‘spectral evidence’. Rebecca the b!tch was only happy to supply some more gossip to fuel it further. Sadly, no one in the town comes to Lydia’s rescue because they knew they’d be in trouble too. People who defended an accused individual were also often accused of the same practice.

Henry, on the other hand, had just found some proof about his brother’s presence and whereabouts in Salem. Just that morning, he went in search of him, so he had no idea what was happening to Lydia. She’s arrested on those ridiculous charges and thrown into jail. When Henry hears of it later, he decides it’d be best to not let the others know of his identity so that he, too, is not thrown in jail with her. He instantly plans to go to his father and beg for help if needs be.

Unfortunately, when Lydia finally gets the chance to have a glimpse of Henry, she misunderstands him. Thinking him all appalled and angry, she decides all hope of a rescue is lost for her. By then Henry has already confessed to her about his rich and influential family, a name everyone knows; a fact he tried his best to hide so it doesn’t hinder his quest. Henry also, repeatedly, told Lydia that he’d be there for her no matter what. Yet, he leaves and doesn’t return for her for the next week when she’s kept in a dark, dank cell and ultimately, after a farce of a trial, is condemned to hang. Lydia tells herself that she knew this would happen. Henry has left her to her fate. After all, no one really knows the truth but herself and him. She has no right to claim anything, and now, no hope to live as well. But what hurts her most is the fact that this time, she has truly fallen in love. Was she wrong to trust him that much?

Yet we find that the truth is far from that. Henry runs into some delays while at home due to his father, the reason why he couldn’t come ASAP. When he finally states his case to his father, the man out and out refuses to help Henry on this. A dejected but undefeated Henry decides he’d do something on this own...

Lydia’s rescue was rather dramatic, thanks to Henry and an unexpected help. She’s let go in the dead of the night with an ultimatum; she must leave Salem this night, never to return again. But her past was waiting at her doorstep to haunt her once again. While getting ready to leave, Lydia finds her first husband standing in her room, all sneering and mocking. She now knows who was watching her. It was also apparent to me that the whole witchcraft gossip was spread by this jerk because he was just that... a mean jerk. When he proceeds to rape her, Henry bursts in and boy oh boy, we’re faced with another rather shocking revelation. It kinda made me, I don’t know, uncomfortable.

Though Henry saves Lydia, I was left with questions. In the light of that revelation, I’m still not sure how Lydia and Henry can marry and live as man and wife because when they leave for Henry’s home, her first husband was rather alive. Nothing was really explained or hinted at for the story ends right after that. This is why I felt that the ending was abrupt. Was her first marriage annulled later? Did the man die because I knew Henry was going to see to it that he rots in jail. I don’t even know what went on back in those days to justify this. *scratches head*

In the conclusion, I must say I enjoyed the last couple of chapters, mainly the part where Lydia was going through her ordeals after being accused and the suspense it brought to the story. I felt sad for her, knowing that this actually happened in the 1692 Salem where people were unjustly accused and murdered (I’ll call it ‘murder’ cause those hangings, to me, were just that). It angers me to read just how vile, vengeful and corrupt people were, and still are. I think the author was able to capture those emotions in her writing. 3.5 stars.

[Tin · Rating 4 out of 5]

Disclosure: I received a copy of this book from the blog tour organizer for review purposes. Many thanks to Sarah Ballance, Bewitching Book Tours and Entangled Publishing for the opportunity. Yes, this is an honest review.

* * *

Lydia Colson arrived in Salem Village a year before and serves as physician to the village. No one questioned the absence of her husband or the suddenness of her appearance. Henry Putnam was on his way to Salem Town to look for his missing older brother. Lydia encounters him on her way home one evening, having fallen off his horse and in need of care.

A stranger in a married woman's cottage: to prevent gossip from spreading, Henry pretends to be Lydia's husband and the growing physical attraction between Lydia and Henry elevates their pretend marriage into a real one. But their marriage is tested when Lydia is accused of witchcraft and Henry must weigh in the balance his family's reputation and livelihood and his new wife's life.

It's very rare to find a historical romance novel set during the Salem Witch Trials and this is the main reason why I requested to read Sarah Ballance's Her Wicked Sin. It's a very challenging period to write about because it was such a recognizable period in American History and there is always the danger of the Salem Witch stories overshadowing an author's own story -- but Sarah Ballance does a good job of keeping the story of Lydia and Henry in the foreground. Considering that this is a novella, Ballance delivers the full package.

The author captures the very restrictive atmosphere of Salem during those times and the precariousness of every person's position: one hint of witchcraft, one tiny rumor is all it takes to destroy a person.

Lydia came to Salem to escape her past and to start fresh but, what was once Lydia's safe haven becomes a place of distrust and fear -- and the final straw was the very malicious accusation of the Abbott children. We also see the defenselessness and the hopelessness of the accused "witch" -- Lydia was put in a very difficult position and every word she uttered was used against her. It really was a no-win situation.

Where, then, is the love story? While their courtship and "marriage" happened very quickly, Henry's commitment is tested several times: the first is when he decides to inform his very wealthy, very well-connected family of his marriage to Lydia. The second was when Lydia was accused of witchery. Even though they've only known each other for a short while, Henry's faith in his wife was amazing: he listened, and accepted -- and didn't judge. His first instinct is always to help.

My one small complaint is the resolution -- Lydia's ending was a bit rushed (and a bit too neat) but, more importantly, I hated, yes, HATED, the Abbot children and Goody Rebecca I really wanted to see them get their comeuppance but they get away with their misdeeds. I understand, however, that Ballance is remaining faithful to the historical period and no such justice was possible during that time. I am glad that Lydia and Henry get their happy ending (as happy as can be managed in such Puritan circumstances).

[Gigi staub · Rating 4 out of 5]

On a moonless night, he rides into the winter forest on his beast as black as midnight….

Dashing stranger, Henry Dunham, comes to Salem on a mysterious errand, but is thrown from his horse in the dead of night and rescued by the local Puritan midwife, Lydia Colson.

Haunted by her past, Lydia is running from her own dark secrets, avoiding intrusive questions by pretending her dead husband is simply…away. But when she and Henry are caught in a compromising situation, one punishable by Puritan law, he saves her from scandal by claiming to be her errant spouse…and claiming her bed.

Forced to fake a marriage, Lydia and Henry find their passion overwhelming and their vows a little too real. As their lies become truths, a witch hunt closes in on Lydia, threatening not only their burgeoning love, but her life.

Review:

Though I don't read a lot of historicals this book caught my attention because it is about Salem. I thought the writer did an excellent job in her research and making you feel like you were in that period of time. From the language, to the descriptions of everyday life and the blending of fact made the story come alive.

Lydia is a midwife trying to start a new life in Salem. She has been living on her own for a year telling everyone her husband is away. Lydia is a strong person to keep her secret, live on her own and in a place where neighbors are turning on neighbors. How scary it must have been to never know if one little thing said or done wrong is going to put you on trial and that is what happens to Lydia.

Lydia happens upon Henry while out helping a neighbor, she rescues Henry and takes him back to her house. Their attraction is instantaneous, this leads to being found in compromising position and forces Henry and Lydia to pretend that Henry is the husband who has been away.

I love the intimate scenes between Lydia and Henry, they are sexy and romantic. The hand-fast scene was one of my favorites.

Henry is so great, he fights to save Lydia both with his family and the government. In the end he literally fights his brother to save her.

This was a great story and according to Goodreads says it is book #1, so I cannot wait to see what the next book holds.

4stars

[Farrah · Rating 4 out of 5]

My Rating: 3.5/5

I haven't ever seen a historical romance set in the time of the Salem witch trials and, since I think that time is very interesting, I was excited about reading this. It didn't quite meet all my expectations, but I did really enjoy it. Her Wicked Sin was a lovely read, complete with a wonderful setting and steamy romance. I really liked this book.

My favorite part of the book was definitely the setting. The author did a great job re-creating the world of Puritan Salem and the superstition of the witch trials. It was brilliantly done, creating a setting that really drew me in.

Lydia was a great character. She was a strong heroine, determined to make her quiet living, regardless of the Puritan laws. I thought she was likable. I don't really have anything to say about her other than she was lovely.

I adored Henry. He was so sweet and adorable and so determined to protect his loved ones. He was perfect and I just loved him.

The romance was sweet and there was definitely chemistry between these two right away. I thought it was so sweet how they came to trust and fall for each other. And, the sparks were there from the moment they met. I thought they were lovely together.

The plot was well paced and I was kept interested the entire way through. There was definitely a twist, when we find out how Lydia's past and Henry's past are connected.

So, if I liked all this about the book, why did I rate it 3.5?
Well, it felt kind of incomplete. I felt like there should have been more to it somehow. More about the character, more about the story. It didn't feel all there, if that makes sense. I finished the book feeling vaguely dissatisfied, even though I liked the story. So, that definitely took away from my enjoyment of the book as a whole. But, for the most part, I really liked this book.

Her Wicked Sin was a lovely historical romance. With a unique setting and steamy romance, this is a book romance lovers won't want to miss. I really enjoyed this book and I think others will, as well.

*I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review

[A Voracious Reader (a.k.a. Carol) · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5

*Book source ~ Many thanks to Entangled for providing me with a review copy in exchange for an honest review.

Lydia Colson is a physician/midwife in the town of Salem. One dark night after delivering a baby and she is on her way home she comes across a man thrown from his horse. Getting him to her home and examining him shows several injuries, but none severe. However, in the process of her examination a neighbor bursts in to request her services and sees Lydia in a compromising position with a half-naked strange man. In order to save Lydia from a charge of adultery, Henry Dunham declares himself her traveling husband. As no one has seen Lydia’s husband (since he’s actually dead) the story is plausible. However, malicious people are accusing neighbors of witchcraft and Lydia ends up in their sights. Will Henry be able to save Lydia before she is convicted of being a witch?

A fan of historical romance this is the very first book I’ve read detailing the time of the Salem Witch Trials. I have to say I was fascinated by the way the Puritans lived and completely disgusted by their (some of them anyway) hypocrisy. The mob mentality and the fear of those who want to help the accused but can’t risk being accused themselves…rock meet hard place. I only had a passing lesson in the history of the time and that was a long long time ago. This story put me there, to experience what it was like to be accused and be helpless to disprove the allegation. If History in school could be parceled out in fascinating stories like this one then I might have been more interested in the subject during my school years. LOL

Henry and Lydia are very likeable characters. I wanted them to succeed and I wanted the shitty people in Salem to get their just desserts. Ah, well…one out of two isn’t bad. The mystery surrounding Henry’s brother was a little too neat, but overall this is a wonderfully told story of a time in our history that has not much for us to be proud of.

[E. · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 stars

"Her Wicked Sin" by Sarah Ballance is a book in ‘A Sins of Salem’ series is an intriguing tale of a woman physician/midwife in Salem at the time of the furor about witchcraft. Ostensibly alone because her husband is traveling, Lydia Colson, finds a mysterious stranger injured and alone on a road near her house. Events conspire to force them into an intimate relationship which gets even more complicated as details of their respective pasts start coming to light. The malicious actions of some of her neighbors threaten not only Lydia’s livelihood but perhaps her very life and the stranger may end up not being her salvation as she has become to hope but instead may intensify her danger.



This intriguing read gave a vivid picture of the very different life of those in historic Salem. It was interesting to read about a woman acting as a physician but the presentation of the escalating hysteria about witchcraft was a bit confusing and it was really frustrating to reach the end of the story and discover that there are quite a few threads left dangling. There were unexpected developments that complicated the story and one hopes that there is a sequel that will take care of some of the strange developments that ended the story on a unresolved and pretty unrealistic note. I enjoyed the author’s style but was less than satisfied with the way the story played out.

[Vicki · Rating 5 out of 5]

What a wonderful story! I loved "Her Wicked Sin" from the first page. It is a beautiful story of love and heartache with a touch of mystery/suspense. Lydia is a physician who is fairly new to the village of Salem. She is running from an abusive past and a dead husband. She happens upon a handsome man, Henry, who has fallen from his horse. The little village seems to be on a witch hunt and seem to wrongfully accuse many. This is the first book I have read by Sarah Ballance, and I was not disappointed! I fell in love with her writing and characters. Sarah is able to make you feel as if you are apart of her character by her descriptions of their settings and feelings. I was taken into a new world and on a very interesting journey with Lydia and Henry, one which I could feel all of their love, hurt and compassion. I was so pleased with the flow of this story and how Lydia learns the truth of her past, one that she thought was totally different than she could imagine! Thank you for such a great story Sarah! I will be reading more of your work very soon!

[Andrea Goodell · Rating 5 out of 5]

Normally I'm not a fan of American history, growing up in Europe I know nothing about it and typically it holds no interest for me.
However, 30 pages into Her Wicked Sin I was hooked. Not only was this book a wonderful love story but a fab way of giving a history lesson to ppl like me that normally don't care.
It's about a young lady who has "lost" her husband moved to a new town to start over. She then finds a stranger in need of her help. She is a healer.
The stranger is on a quest of his own, looking for a lost brother. Together they battle their feelings, his family and a small town.
The only downside is I felt it was a little rushed at the end and with that got confusing.
But well worth the 2.99!!!

[Sandra R · Rating 4 out of 5]

A very interesting read that really painted a picture of Salem in the 1600's. The author's words created a nice dark mood and you really felt you were back in that time period. I enjoyed the romance between the hero and heroine, but I also felt the ending was a bit rushed.

My only gripe was the use of the word 'okay' several times. Petty I know, but the author obviously went to a lot of trouble to use old fashioned dialogue and 'okay' was not used until the mid 1800's.

The book did keep me very entertained however and I read it in one sitting because I wanted to know what happened. I look forward to reading more from this author.

[Negar Arvanaghi · Rating 5 out of 5]

**********

First of all a HUGE thank you to Ms. Ballance and Ms. Hightower for getting a copy to me. I loved and adored this book! Historicals are tricky because I often find that the characters use modern language and have modern opinions and feelings. NOT true here. The author has clearly researched the period and uses language that the people of the time would have used. As for the story itself, go read it yourself!!

[Tracey Mele · Rating 3 out of 5]

✨ WITCHY HISTORICAL ROMANCE REVIEW ✨

for the ENTANGLED INSIDERS monthly challenge (historical romance), I obviously had to go witchy… and this one dropped me straight into the chaos of the Salem witch trials 👀

this was my first time reading this author and I am already curious for more

the writing style stands out right away. it feels very intentional to the time period, which makes the story more immersive and honestly adds to that eerie, suspicious atmosphere

we follow Lydia Colson, a widowed midwife who ends up in a compromising situation with Henry Dunham… and suddenly they are forced into a marriage of convenience

but what starts as fake does not stay fake for long

the tension builds quietly at first, then you start to feel it shifting
the looks mean more
the connection feels real
and you are just waiting for everything to unravel

and then the fear creeps in

because this is Salem
and being a woman with knowledge is dangerous

Lydia becomes the target of whispers and accusations of witchcraft, and the story really leans into how terrifying that time was
gossip is not just gossip here
it is a weapon
it is survival
it is life or death

there is this constant sense that no one is truly safe
neighbors turn on each other
“friends” feel one accusation away from betrayal
and you can feel the desperation in every interaction

I also loved that there was a mystery layered in so subtly you do not even realize it is building until everything clicks into place

the pacing is quick, which works for the story, but I will say I wanted more
more depth
more time in this world
more of Lydia and Henry once things start to feel real

overall this was such an interesting and atmospheric read with a unique setting that we do not see nearly enough in romance

if you love
✨ marriage of convenience
✨ slow burn tension
✨ historical settings with dark edges
✨ witchy vibes with real danger

this is one to pick up

and now I need a deeper dive into this world because I am not ready to leave it 🖤

shorter and not structured like a poem

For the Entangled Insiders historical romance challenge, I went full witchy and picked a Salem witch trials setting… and I’m glad I did.

This was my first book by this author and I really enjoyed it. The writing style feels very true to the time period, which adds a lot to the atmosphere. Lydia Colson, a widowed midwife, is forced into a marriage of convenience with Henry Dunham after they’re caught in a compromising situation… and of course it starts to feel a little too real.

What I loved most was how tense everything felt. This isn’t just romance, it’s survival. The fear of being accused of witchcraft hangs over every interaction, and the way gossip spreads through the town makes it feel like no one is safe. It really captures how dangerous that time was, especially for women like Lydia.

There’s also a subtle mystery woven in that you don’t fully notice until everything clicks, which I thought was really well done.

My only complaint is that I wanted more. The pacing is quick, but I would have loved a deeper dive into the world and more time with the characters once their relationship develops.

Overall, a really atmospheric, witchy historical romance with high tension and a unique setting.

[Fizza · Rating 3 out of 5]

I liked it. It's interesting enough and characters are also good. But the story was quite predictable in many ways. Yet it ended well so that's good. Writing style is very unique. I think the author has tried to stay true the time period and that did make it more interesting to read.

Lydia has been living in Salem for over an year now. She is used to being alone and the only purpose of her life is to help sick people. It is her duty as a physician. However, trouble seems to have found her at last. When she finds a stranger in the woods and decides to help him things starts to get out of hand. First, a local woman she considered as friend starts spreading rumors about her. Then rich spoiled kids decides that she must pay for not helping them with their deceit. And let's not forget a stranger who has been asking about her around town. All this added up and Lydia finds herself in jail, accused to witchcraft.

Henry is looking for his brother and somehow ends up finding his true love. It all sounds too good to be true. His happiness may not last long. There is danger lurking around the corner as a stranger follows the happy couple. One thing is for sure though, he is willing to make this marriage work.

It's a good enough story. I think historical fiction fans will enjoy it.

[Katrina Berry · Rating 2 out of 5]

Her Wicked Sin has lots of potential that attempted to tap into a pretty much untouched and interesting part of our history, The Salem Witch Trials. This is not your average lighthearted historical romance; it is a bit dark with a mysterious/suspenseful twist.

Hooked after reading the description, I was really looking forward to stepping inside the pages of this historical romance, however after delving into this read, I found it lagged most of the way through causing me to lose interest, not be engaged and the like. The insta~love/insta~lust between Henry and Lydia were also a bit of a brow raiser considering Lydia’s past which caused more distance to be placed between myself, the characters and the story. Definitely disappointed in the outcome.

Please note that an ARC was generously provided in exchange for an honest review of which this is both honest and completely voluntary.

[Mimi · Rating 2 out of 5]

Set in the time of the Salem witch trials. It's written in the old Puritan style. Good story, but the dialogue makes it hard to stay in the story.

[Patty McKenna Van Hulle · Rating 4 out of 5]

Sarah Ballance

Witchcraft is afoot within Salem, with rumors, jealously, a black "Devil" horse & 2 people who can't keep their hands off & clothes on one another!

Lydia Colson is a woman with many secrets & lives in the Salem Village. She talks of a hubby who travels for work, helps with all the ladies functions & works as a midwife & doctor if needed. The truth is her abusive husband is dead by her own hands, so she keeps her head down within the Puritan community & lives her life alone.

Henry Dunham is from a rich family, but he is on a mission to find his half brother for his mother, before she gets any sicker. Plus he has become disillusioned by the whole rich world & would love to live a simpler life. As he is traveling with his huge & misbehaving steed, Willard, the big boy gets spooked & now Henry is laying on the ground with his foot caught in the stir up.

That is how these two lonely people meet, as Lydia calms Willard, untangles him & helps the injured Henry to her home to heal. When they get to her simple home, he knows she is lying about a husband, questions her & she confesses that he is dead. Lydia examines him, half unclothed, as the village busybody, Rebecca Mather, storms into her home! Henry listens to words like adultery & death, opens his mouth & claims to be her traveling husband. Lydia is shocked, but has no time to fix it because a young mother needs her help.

Henry will not allow her reputation be ruined, so they talk about handfasting, he claims her as his wife & with hesitation, she claims him as her husband. They do have an amazing chemistry & Henry can't keep his hands, lips, teeth & his third leg away from her. In Salem there is "so called" witchcraft afoot & with a helpful gossiping & jealous wife, 4 spoiled sisters, Lydia riding Willard, the huge "Devil" horse, through the village, their decadent passions released, a revenge filled enemy from both their pasts & a mysterious stranger looking for Lydia to make their worlds explode with untruths. With all the false witchcraft accusations, will Lydia be safe? What will Henry be willing to lose for his Lydia? Can Lydia's past destroy her new love? Who will slap Rebecca Mather upside her head? Oh, PICK ME!

This is my 1st Sarah Ballance book & it takes place in a world that I that loved to explore in my high school years. Salem was a town filled with bullies, greed, spoiled & scared children, racism & gossip galore, not so Christian to me. Ms. Ballance brought this world to life for me, with the Goody this & Goodman that & all the untruths flying around. Lydia was an abused woman, but she discovered her deep inner strength. Henry is a great rich boy hero with a heart for a simpler life & that takes a strong person to walk away from money for happiness. This may of been Salem, but even they had passions & desires & these two had the straw mattress in flames. Now the gossiping harpy, Rebecca, made me so mad that now I have dent in my Kindle, from pulling her head thru the screen to slap her hard! This my 1st 1600s American historical romance & I loved this unique world. Ms. Ballance showed the hateful side of Salem, but she also showed the warm friendships & the neighborhood of helpful hands that many historians forget. I also want to THANK her for bringing back my high school days & the many library memories! I left my 1800s reading COSMOS, find a Salem world of friends & rumors & DISCOVERED a new voice in romance that I enjoy! Ms. Balance gets a score of 4 fingers up & 7 toes & I can't wait for the next book.

This book received for my honest review.

[Angie · Rating 4 out of 5]

I received an ARC through NetGalley.

Historical Romance in the Puritan era? I've gotta try that! Her Wicked Sin definitely didn't disappoint! Lydia Colson is a relative new comer in Salem Village. She arrived about a year prior and has taken over the job as the village physician and midwife after leaving her own home town in the wake of...murder! Lydia killed her husband and needs a fresh start where no one knows of her past, and the neighbors just think her husband is a merchant off at sea. Then one night she stumbles upon a man who has fallen off his horse in the woods. Henry can't make it to town in his condition, so Lydia brings him to her own home in order to tend his wounds. And then a neighbor lady bursts in due to an emergency and screams "adulterer!" Luckily, Henry is a quick thinker and claims to be her husband back from his travels. Unfortunately for Lydia, pettiness among her village soon also screams out "witch!" A death sentence in those times.

I love this time in history, but haven't read many books set in it. I was a bit worried since Her Wicked Sin is a romance, and Salem in 1692 doesn't exactly sound romantic, but I wanted to give it a try. I'm certainly glad I did, because Lydia and Henry don't hold anything back! They don't immediately jump into bed. They actually talk some, but the attraction is obvious. I absolutely adored all of the historical boner banter! There's some good lines in there! The sex scenes are also pretty good. Nothing too wild or exciting there, but it fits the period.

While the romance was good, I enjoyed the plot even more. Lydia is trying to blend into Puritan society, but everything about her brings questions. None of the neighbors know her history, and would probably stone her on the spot if they found out she killed her husband. Then of course, there's her "husband" mysteriously being able to find her despite her moving away. Plus, a petty housewife is spreading rumors of witchcraft since her own husband can't keep his eyes of Lydia! And on top of that, a strange man has been looking for her! Her Wicked Sin does take on a slightly suspenseful tone toward the end with Lydia's trial and stalker. It's all resolved fairly quickly given the page length, but there was still a great twist at the end!

I really liked Her Wicked Sin. It's refreshing to read a Historical Romance that isn't Regency (although I do love those). There's also a great plot and admirable characters. Lydia isn't the typical woman of the time. She takes care of herself and offers her help to others. Henry is a good man who steps up to his responsibilities without compromising his values. The romance is sweet and steamy, and the plot is engaging. What more do you need?

Read more of my reviews at Pinkindle Reads & Reviews.

[Julianne Redmon · Rating 5 out of 5]

I've always been curious about this part of American history. There has never been anything definitive written as to what actually happened, what truthfully started it all. I've read many different interpretations of the events and have not really been completely satisfied with them.

I love the fact that Sarah has taken this well known time in history and based a fictional story around it. At first I was nervous because I wasn't sure if I could mesh a "paranormal" romance into the historical setting, but she took a completely different road with this book focusing on the people involved rather than the events. I also like how she made sure to adhere to the strict puritanical rules that reigned in Salem at the time. You can't have your heroine be openly strong and feisty without reprimand in such a society.

Meet Goodwife Colson...a physician with a secret sin in her past. Lydia is truly a good person put in dire circumstances. When her instincts told her that she really shouldn't stop and help Henry the physician in her won over. She just wanted to help people and saw virtue in the truth, although she was hell bent on hiding her own violent past. Henry Dunham, looking for his long lost brother, runs into trouble on the road and a kindly Puritan physician stops to help him. He is a good man and his main goal is not to sully her reputation anyway. But in need of assistance he sees no other alternative than to stay the night in her home. Both love and the blooming evil in Salem take over from there...

Pros: Sexual tension electrifies the air around Henry and Lydia so the book is HOT without being explicit. The book has a different take on the witch trials and I like the direction that it goes. The antagonists of the story are VERY well written, I mean as soon as I read Rebecca's or any of the Abbott's names on the page I had a "grrrrrrrrrrrr" going through my head. Unexpected twist at the end (don't worry I won't spoil it!) had me flipping back pages and going "aaaahhhh I see what you did there!"

Cons: I wanted those Abbott girls and their little henchwoman Rebecca to get what they deserve! Now I have to see what the rest of the series brings...oh darn! LOL

[Sara · Rating 4 out of 5]

I wasn’t sure what to expect when I started this, as I’m not a big fan of historical romance. I’m happy to say, I was pleasantly surprised. It may be about puritans, but there isn’t anything pure about it, if you know what I mean (wink, wink).
Set in Salem during the Puritan days, Henry is a mysterious stranger thrown by his horse on the road and saved by Lydia. Lydia is trying to start a new life in Salem and questions about her absent husband are causing problems, not to mention they are caught in a compromising position, so she and Henry fake a marriage. Things heat up when the chemistry between them is undeniable and the vows they’re faking take on a new meaning (nudge, nudge). But, the Salem Witch hunt soon turns its sights on Lydia, threatening not only Henry and Lydia’s blooming love, but Lydia’s life as well.
I was captivated by this book. As I said, I’m not much for historical romance, but this was a very exciting read. The backdrop of Salem in the 17th century just adds to the allure of the overall story. And Henry is quite simply dashing…yeah, that’s right. He had ripped abs before ripped abs were cool. Plus, he’s the classic “I will fight you to the death for the love of my woman” kind of hero. Like I said: dashing.
What I liked most about this book was the way the town and people were described. They really jumped from the page and made it easy for me to become invested in what was happening. This is a fairly short read, but full of action, love and of course, sex. And the sex scenes I found to strike the right balance of romance and just plain old fashioned boning...and not the kind found in a corset, but corsets were involved. I’m a fan, Sarah Ballance. I’m a fan.
Lydia was such an interesting and multi-faceted character as well. She was a trained midwife trying to escape an abusive past and a dead husband. She is a very strong and independent woman, and I like to think that even though in this time period women were second-class citizens to men, there were really women like Lydia around. She rocks.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book. I hope that there are more in this series; I will snatch those up right away! 4.5 stars!

[Snarky Mom · Rating 4 out of 5]

I have to admit - I'm not usually one to go for the historical romances. It just smacks too much of having to "think" for me. But you know, many people LOVE historical romances - it gives you insight into another time and way of life, which like fantasy romances, can offer a true unknown escape. However, since I first learned about the Salem Witch Trials in elementary school, I have just found them fascinating. Just the concept that a society would allow bullies to hide behind religion in order to strike against people they may not like on a personal level - oh, wait - that's just a really good representation of how if we don't learn from the past, we'll find ourselves repeating the mistakes in the future, right?

It took me a few pages to get into this book; after all, it's based in a Puritanical society, so it's "Goodwife" and formal speech, and it took me a bit to get into the rhythm of the book. "Her Wicked Sin" is just over 150 pages and was just really neat to read, on so many levels. First, there are many accurate historical facts and our characters interact with some of the well known participants in the Salem Witch Trials. Second, there's an edge to the book and while I won't provide any spoilers, I will say that this does skirt the suspense genre, too. It was also incredibly interesting to see how the accusations affected the people and community because the main character is accused and you have her thought processes.

Overall, I was incredibly impressed with Sarah Ballance's immersion in the time period and mind set, and it came through in the text of "Her Wicked Sin". Oh, and yeah - there was a great love story, too. (Sorry for history-geeking out on you!)

Please note: I received a copy of this book in exchange for an unbiased review. This review was previously published on Snarky Mom Reads.

[Nicky Peacock · Rating 4 out of 5]

I haven’t read many historical romances and, after reading Her Wicked Sin, I’ve discovered that I’ve really been missing out. It was written in an old fashion style that gave it real credence and felt like I was reading a new classic, rather than a straight modern historical romance novel (I know, how many oxymorons can I get into this post!)

I decided to read it because it was set amidst the Salem Witch trials and it really did capture the tension and fear that must have been felt at that time. Poor Lydia, the protagonist, seems dogged with bad fortune and terrible timing. Worst of all, she’s beautiful in a time when plainness is considered Godly. The Puritan odds are certainly stacked against her, which makes for a romance with a hearty string of tension.

I’ve always had a strange fascination with this time period, which all started when I read The Crucible at school. Her Wicked Sin feels almost like an extension of Arthur Miller’s work and proves how easy it was back then to get into trouble and be accused of something that could literally take your life. All it took was a jealous wife or a wicked child with a grudge with the ear of the town.

The romance is sweet, albeit a little predictable – but hey, that’s okay; in a modern world where romance is like a half-finished roller-coaster, sometimes it’s nice to have a bit of predictability.

The front cover really doesn’t do the book justice and personally I’d have liked to have seen some more markers to show the time period – although a half-naked chiselled man is always a crowd pleaser!

Overall I’d give Her Wicked Sin 4 out of 5 stars – whether you’re a seasoned historical romance junkie or a newbie like myself – read this book.

[My Book Addiction and More MBA · Rating 5 out of 5]

I loved HER WICKED SIN, a romantic story set in 1692 in Salem, MA. It was suspenseful at times and also had a few twists I didn’t see coming (I think it’s great when that happens!). I experienced a range of emotions as I read this story. Anger that children and adults could be so downright nasty and mean spirited. Distressed at the accusations directed at Lydia. I also felt Lydia’s anguish, her strength, and then her joy with Henry. That the author made me feel these emotions is a tribute to her writing ability.

The characters the author created were well developed and the story flowed at a good pace. I thought the language to be appropriate for the time period which demonstrates, to me, that Ms. Ballance did her research. The intimate scene was extremely well-written and totally in keeping with the setting and story. It was very moving.

HER WICKED SIN did not disappoint this reader’s expectations at all. I will be reading this book again and I am eagerly awaiting the next book in the series. I would recommend this book to fans of historical romance and readers who love a good story. I’ve followed Ms. Ballance’s career and I only see her star shining brighter with each book she writes.

Rating: 5

Heat Rating: Mild

Reviewed by: Karen C

Review Courtesy of My Book Addiction and More

[Sheri · Rating 4 out of 5]

Lydia moved to Salem Village to get away from her past and was quickly accepted as the town's new midwife/physician. However, those were dangerous times to live in Salem, with every move you made scrutinized and judged, and if someone did not like what you said or did you were accused of witchcraft. Lydia's carefully crafted world starts to crumble after she reaches out to help a stranger.

Lydia was a great female lead, strong and independent, brave and spirited, but content to live within the restrictions put on her by the time period in which she lived. She had a good heart and wanted nothing more than to help others. Henry was a great guy – and the two of them together was a lot of fun.

Set in the era of the Salem Witch Trials, this historical romance was very well written. The language, setting, and details of the story all fit right in with the timeframe in which the story occurred. It was eerily accurate, at least to my untrained eye, including the way Lydia was accused and the town's actions. Overall, a great story that was fun to read.

I received a copy of this book from the publisher/author in exchange for an honest review.

[Geri · Rating 4 out of 5]

I can remember learning about the witch trials but reading this book made things so much more interesting! I loved how the history was written into the story, but was woven throughout it. Lydia and Henry were wonderfully written characters and the passion between them was something that you could actually feel. The suspense of what happened with Lydia's ex-husband kept you wondering if it would come back to haunt her. This book had a little bit of everything including romance, passion, longing, suspense, history, and of course gossip that leads to back-stabbing. The way the witches were suspected of being witches was something that you could see happening not only back then, but even today because of gossip and false accusations. This was an entertaining read which held my interest throughout. The love scenes were tastefully written and anything but boring. The whole story stayed true to the time period it was set in and the only thing I would have liked to have seen changed is the length of the ending. I hoped the HEA would have been more detailed, but it didn't stop me from liking this book very much.