Science fiction has always been one of my top two favorite genres, and now that I almost exclusively read YA, I absolutely love YA sci-fi. Ms. Weavil’s sophomore effort is an excellent addition to the genre, and it was a 4-star read for me, which means I think it’s great!
I have to first mention the cover – I loved it from the minute I saw it, but having read the book I now appreciate it even more. It’s a *perfect* representation of Eco, the dusty planet on which the story takes place. It can be hard to find a sci-fi cover that is different from the norm, but this one definitely is, and I just love it. It’s great when a cover matches or suits the story inside so well.
As for the story, I think Ms. Weavil did an excellent job of describing why these people exist on this terraformed planet, Eco, and not on Earth. The science behind it was very sound – how they exist when the planet doesn’t support vegetation (hydroponics for crops and climate-controlled domes for animals), how they keep from becoming an inbred population (very, very strict rules and careful planning about when and to whom children will be born), etc. I appreciate any author taking the time to give some explanation for those questions that naturally arise in a reader’s mind as they learn about the new world the author has created. Without explanations, we cannot suspend disbelief and immerse ourselves in the story, and Ms. Weavil did an A+ job!
I also really liked the characters, particularly Ann, her best friend, and the boy who loves her and who everyone assumes she will marry. I liked that Ann was strong-willed and independent, yet her family is very important to her, dysfunctional as it is. I think Ms. Weavil challenged us to think outside typical norms and maybe give the characters some slack when they do things that might be distasteful to us; I’m thinking especially of Ann’s mother and how she rebels against the strictures of her marriage, a marriage that she didn’t especially want in the first place. Similarly, I was a little frustrated with Ann regarding the love triangle, but the more I thought about it the more I understood where she was coming from. I mean, if you’ve only known less than 10 people your age for your whole life, and you know there’s not going to be anyone new magically appear, when someone your age does unexpectedly pop up, you’d naturally want to explore that person. And even if Dace had never shown up, it’s clear that Ann is chafing against the inevitability of her marriage to Raid, which I did understand the more I thought about it. After all, who wants to just settle??
Although the romance aspect wasn’t my favorite, I did really enjoy the discovery that Dace and Ann make and thinking through the implications of it for the people of Eco. I admit that I was fascinated by the idea of the Cybers, and I could’ve read a whole book just around that issue! I have no idea if there is a sequel planned, but if there is, I hope that we will learn more about the Cybers and their struggles. I thought that was a fascinating aspect to the story.
Overall, if you like YA sci-fi, or are willing to give it a try, I definitely recommend this book from Vicki Weavil. Her writing style is engaging and accessible, and she engages with issues that we are currently grappling with in our society today (eg, what does it mean to be “human”?). I loved this book and highly recommend it! Thanks to Ms. Weavil and Month9Books for allowing me to read an early copy, and to Chapter by Chapter for having me as part of the blog tour!