What do you think?
Rate this book
Sister of Odysseus #1
The Girl from Ithaca
A Spartan war ship sails into Ithaca and two men arrive to demand the fulfillment of an oath. When Odysseus joins the Greek alliance against Troy, his little sister, fourteen-year-old Neomene, is thrust into a world she knows little about.
Amid the secrecy and plots, Neomene befriends the women who are forced to survive alongside warriors such as Achilles, Ajax and Agamemnon. As the war drags on and heroes die, she finds romance and faces dangers vastly different from the battles on the Trojan Plain.
Readers not familiar with the tales of Troy will find The Girl from Ithaca a story in its own right and an exciting introduction to Mycenaean culture, the Greek myths and the Trojan War. For those already acquainted with Homer's version, read on to discover the heroes as you've never seen them before.
It all starts on the island of Ithaca...
This is the first book in the series, which concludes with The Walls of Troy.
A Gold-medal winner from Authonomy (Harper Collins).
Amid the secrecy and plots, Neomene befriends the women who are forced to survive alongside warriors such as Achilles, Ajax and Agamemnon. As the war drags on and heroes die, she finds romance and faces dangers vastly different from the battles on the Trojan Plain.
Readers not familiar with the tales of Troy will find The Girl from Ithaca a story in its own right and an exciting introduction to Mycenaean culture, the Greek myths and the Trojan War. For those already acquainted with Homer's version, read on to discover the heroes as you've never seen them before.
It all starts on the island of Ithaca...
This is the first book in the series, which concludes with The Walls of Troy.
A Gold-medal winner from Authonomy (Harper Collins).
345 pages, Paperback
First published August 1, 2013
71 people are currently reading
1206 people want to read
About the author
Cherry Gregory
3 books16 followersCherry Gregory grew up on a farm in Nantwich, Cheshire. She now lives on the Shropshire/ Welsh border with her husband and daughter.
Her hobbies include history, cycling and walking.
Her hobbies include history, cycling and walking.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 53 reviews
July 16, 2015
Rating: 2.5
---Spoilers---
Synopsis
After Paris charmed Helen and took her home, the Greek army did not tarry to follow. Princes and kings sailed to Troy either for glory, wealth, fame, or love. This novel relates the events as they unfold from Odysseus’ jolt until the first death of a prince.
Thoughts
I really do not know what this novel was about exactly. Was it about the Trojan War, or was it about the girl from Ithaca? One may argue that they belong to one another as Neomene found herself in the Ithacan camp with her brother Odysseus fighting a war which is not hers.
The story is at times a boring retelling, and other times it is clumsily renewed. It felt as if the author could not decide which comes first: relating how and why the Trojan war was provoked (sometimes authentically sometimes with little twists), or following the personal struggles of Lady Neomene. I assume that the author was inspired by the only sister of Odysseus whom I know as Ctimene (and if I am mistaken please correct me) to build her main character. Neomene. Neomene was a problem for me because she was an attempt at being both original and faithful to the real events. She was at the same time like a broken string and a daring step. She fills wrong because she does not feel real to me, and she is a good attempt at originality because we get to have a woman's voice in a men's world.
Neo’s character is a very unstable one. She is a historical puppet in the sense that she relates to me historical events that I already know (though some are fabricated). There is no life in her, no freshness, no deep study of her as an individual, and as a woman. Neo changes from a frail naïve girl to a protector, a friend, a healer, and a lover. Her love affair shadows everything else at some point; even when receiving news about the war, she concentrates on Antiochus and forgets all about her brother.The author attempts to bring something out of her but it is trapped between a submissive sister and a devoted lover and friend. Sometimes too devoted. She is Lady Neoneme yet she only fulfills the role of a servant. Sometimes even servants order her around. She was given a central role only when she was
(spoiler show)
But oh not everything was bad in this novel. It shows how it is possible to have fun in the middle of the war. In fact most of the novel concentrates on anything but the war. Death has no grip in the events. Soldiers go and don’t come back but that’s the last of Neo’s worries. I don’t understand why the author has made her take medical lesson if we only get to know about her skills as a nurse when she rarely needs to know how the war is going (and btw she was instructed during one day and was splendid in her work!). I guess Agamemnon was taunting her by ordering her to help the wounded, still she could have become a devoted nurse, and do something better with her life and just wash clothes and wait for her brother while gossiping with wounded soldiers and servants.
I give The Girl from Ithaca 2.5 stars. It is meant for readers who like YA, and who would like to be introduced to the Trojan War, but the fact that it could be introductory does not mean that it was accurate, (sometimes not even closely so). It is very short and only describes the minimum of the first years of the war. Still one can at least pick some names and go from there.
Will I read the sequel? Hmmm Maybe, maybe…
---Spoilers---
Synopsis
After Paris charmed Helen and took her home, the Greek army did not tarry to follow. Princes and kings sailed to Troy either for glory, wealth, fame, or love. This novel relates the events as they unfold from Odysseus’ jolt until the first death of a prince.
Thoughts
I really do not know what this novel was about exactly. Was it about the Trojan War, or was it about the girl from Ithaca? One may argue that they belong to one another as Neomene found herself in the Ithacan camp with her brother Odysseus fighting a war which is not hers.
The story is at times a boring retelling, and other times it is clumsily renewed. It felt as if the author could not decide which comes first: relating how and why the Trojan war was provoked (sometimes authentically sometimes with little twists), or following the personal struggles of Lady Neomene. I assume that the author was inspired by the only sister of Odysseus whom I know as Ctimene (and if I am mistaken please correct me) to build her main character. Neomene. Neomene was a problem for me because she was an attempt at being both original and faithful to the real events. She was at the same time like a broken string and a daring step. She fills wrong because she does not feel real to me, and she is a good attempt at originality because we get to have a woman's voice in a men's world.
Neo’s character is a very unstable one. She is a historical puppet in the sense that she relates to me historical events that I already know (though some are fabricated). There is no life in her, no freshness, no deep study of her as an individual, and as a woman. Neo changes from a frail naïve girl to a protector, a friend, a healer, and a lover. Her love affair shadows everything else at some point; even when receiving news about the war, she concentrates on Antiochus and forgets all about her brother.The author attempts to bring something out of her but it is trapped between a submissive sister and a devoted lover and friend. Sometimes too devoted. She is Lady Neoneme yet she only fulfills the role of a servant. Sometimes even servants order her around. She was given a central role only when she was
(spoiler show)
But oh not everything was bad in this novel. It shows how it is possible to have fun in the middle of the war. In fact most of the novel concentrates on anything but the war. Death has no grip in the events. Soldiers go and don’t come back but that’s the last of Neo’s worries. I don’t understand why the author has made her take medical lesson if we only get to know about her skills as a nurse when she rarely needs to know how the war is going (and btw she was instructed during one day and was splendid in her work!). I guess Agamemnon was taunting her by ordering her to help the wounded, still she could have become a devoted nurse, and do something better with her life and just wash clothes and wait for her brother while gossiping with wounded soldiers and servants.
I give The Girl from Ithaca 2.5 stars. It is meant for readers who like YA, and who would like to be introduced to the Trojan War, but the fact that it could be introductory does not mean that it was accurate, (sometimes not even closely so). It is very short and only describes the minimum of the first years of the war. Still one can at least pick some names and go from there.
Will I read the sequel? Hmmm Maybe, maybe…
August 22, 2015
As a lover of the Greek myths I was immediately attracted to this book and then absolutely delighted by the unique way in which this well-known legend was related.
The adventure is recounted through Princess Neomene, the fourteen-year-old sister of King Odysseus. She’s a feisty tomboy who loves her country, and is fiercely loyal to her family.
The plot begins to unfold as Neomene is playing on the headland. She sees Spartan ships approaching the Ithaca shores and rushes to warn her brother. They know why the Spartans are coming, and have a plan, but it’s to no avail. Despite their best efforts, the support of Odysseus and his army is demanded by Agamemnon in his campaign to wage war against Troy and Paris. The goal is to win back the beautiful Helen, who is wife to his own son Meneleus.
With battle preparations underway, Neomene is appointed as special envoy to one of Agamemnon’s daughters. Neomene travels to Sparta and is horrified as she witnesses the death of her charge and the wickedness displayed by the king in honour of the Gods. Odysseus quickly removes Neomene from the potential dangers, and they sail with his troops to Troy to set up camp on the hostile territory. From here the adventures involving intrigue, passion and courage unfold. This is the story of Troy.
Cherry Gregory has a terrific writing style. Her ability to describe places, people and emotions are captivating, and immediately draw the reader into the story. In this book she excels in this as she brings several well-known mythical characters to life, and gives them a new dimension and personality. I especially liked her treatment of Neomene (whose name is changed in this book). She is portrayed as a practical, gutsy young girl, unaffected by her royal heritage, who is intent on supporting her brother and help the troops. The book contains humour and pathos, and ends in great drama. I was engrossed throughout, and am already looking forward to reading the sequel.
I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys Greek myths and adventures.
The adventure is recounted through Princess Neomene, the fourteen-year-old sister of King Odysseus. She’s a feisty tomboy who loves her country, and is fiercely loyal to her family.
The plot begins to unfold as Neomene is playing on the headland. She sees Spartan ships approaching the Ithaca shores and rushes to warn her brother. They know why the Spartans are coming, and have a plan, but it’s to no avail. Despite their best efforts, the support of Odysseus and his army is demanded by Agamemnon in his campaign to wage war against Troy and Paris. The goal is to win back the beautiful Helen, who is wife to his own son Meneleus.
With battle preparations underway, Neomene is appointed as special envoy to one of Agamemnon’s daughters. Neomene travels to Sparta and is horrified as she witnesses the death of her charge and the wickedness displayed by the king in honour of the Gods. Odysseus quickly removes Neomene from the potential dangers, and they sail with his troops to Troy to set up camp on the hostile territory. From here the adventures involving intrigue, passion and courage unfold. This is the story of Troy.
Cherry Gregory has a terrific writing style. Her ability to describe places, people and emotions are captivating, and immediately draw the reader into the story. In this book she excels in this as she brings several well-known mythical characters to life, and gives them a new dimension and personality. I especially liked her treatment of Neomene (whose name is changed in this book). She is portrayed as a practical, gutsy young girl, unaffected by her royal heritage, who is intent on supporting her brother and help the troops. The book contains humour and pathos, and ends in great drama. I was engrossed throughout, and am already looking forward to reading the sequel.
I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys Greek myths and adventures.
November 9, 2013
Prior to reading this book my knowledge of Greek mythology was pretty much limited to having supposedly read “The Odyssey” in high school Latin class forty-five years ago. I’d forgotten a lot of Homer’s tale, and had only half read it anyway, but a lot of the characters and events came back to me as I read this, and I learned a lot of new things as well.
I believe Homer did not make up his stories from whole cloth, but developed characters and stories that were being told at the time, some of which were probably based upon historical fact. Similarly, author Cherry Gregory takes Homer’s tales and develops them further, giving them an added dimension through the creation of a new character named Neomene, who is Odysseus’s little sister, and also the narrator, so the story is told through the eyes of a fourteen year old girl.
This narrative device makes the story come alive. Neomene is a likable character with an engaging voice, and also a keen observer. How she ever talks her brother into letting her tag along with the Greek army trying to rescue Helen is a story in itself, and though it sounds improbable, it’s actually fully believable as told.
I might have liked a bit more of Neomene’s personal story (perhaps relating to her coming of age), even at the cost of losing some of the peripheral characters and events of the larger historical and mythological story. Still, a fun and interesting novel, and I thoroughly enjoyed this book cover to cover. I think Homer would approve.
The book ends during the siege of Troy, before the Trojan Horse, and I was hoping that would be in the book. A sequel is in the works, so most likely it will be in there.
I believe Homer did not make up his stories from whole cloth, but developed characters and stories that were being told at the time, some of which were probably based upon historical fact. Similarly, author Cherry Gregory takes Homer’s tales and develops them further, giving them an added dimension through the creation of a new character named Neomene, who is Odysseus’s little sister, and also the narrator, so the story is told through the eyes of a fourteen year old girl.
This narrative device makes the story come alive. Neomene is a likable character with an engaging voice, and also a keen observer. How she ever talks her brother into letting her tag along with the Greek army trying to rescue Helen is a story in itself, and though it sounds improbable, it’s actually fully believable as told.
I might have liked a bit more of Neomene’s personal story (perhaps relating to her coming of age), even at the cost of losing some of the peripheral characters and events of the larger historical and mythological story. Still, a fun and interesting novel, and I thoroughly enjoyed this book cover to cover. I think Homer would approve.
The book ends during the siege of Troy, before the Trojan Horse, and I was hoping that would be in the book. A sequel is in the works, so most likely it will be in there.
October 16, 2013
Let me preface this review by saying I love historical fiction. That said, I can objectively say, that in spite of this being one my favorite genres, the author nails it.
Cherry Gregory captures the Greek Mythology period accurately with her intricate attention to detail. Yet still managing to create a new storyline with the backdrop of the Mycenaean culture.
Even if you're not that familiar with this time period, you'll still enjoy this novel. My wife for example loved it,even though she knew little about Greek mythology, yet she turned me on to this book.
Getting reacquainted with this period was alot more fun the second time around than in 10th grade English class.
I look forward to reading the next book(s) in the series.
Cherry Gregory captures the Greek Mythology period accurately with her intricate attention to detail. Yet still managing to create a new storyline with the backdrop of the Mycenaean culture.
Even if you're not that familiar with this time period, you'll still enjoy this novel. My wife for example loved it,even though she knew little about Greek mythology, yet she turned me on to this book.
Getting reacquainted with this period was alot more fun the second time around than in 10th grade English class.
I look forward to reading the next book(s) in the series.
October 2, 2013
The story of Odysseus written from the viewpoint of his young sister. The author brings the ancient world vividly to life and establishes believable and sympathetic characters. Very readable without losing an authentic feel for the period.
I hate Agamemnon. Can't wait for book two when I hope Achilles will give him a really bad time!
I hate Agamemnon. Can't wait for book two when I hope Achilles will give him a really bad time!
July 27, 2020
This felt like Gregory said, hum, you know what would be cool, is a book about the Odyssey but from a girl's perspective! And then she went off and did a ton of historical research, and started writing the world's most boring term paper.
I gave up at 13%. There was nothing at all of interest in Neomene. She was a blank piece of cardboard. I gave up after this:
"Odysseus told me about the two stone lions at the city gates."
Phoebus smiled. "Everyone makes the mistake of calling them lions. But strangely enough, they're lionesses. See for yourself when we get to Mycenae, then you can correct your brother."
Eventually we left the mountain range and joined a track leading through a forest. We rode alongside a river until we reached open land again.
Phoebus tried to make a joke, and we got nothing from Neomene. No laugh, no joke back, no opinion. I have no idea what she thinks of her brother, of the war, nothing. Snoozefest.
I gave up at 13%. There was nothing at all of interest in Neomene. She was a blank piece of cardboard. I gave up after this:
"Odysseus told me about the two stone lions at the city gates."
Phoebus smiled. "Everyone makes the mistake of calling them lions. But strangely enough, they're lionesses. See for yourself when we get to Mycenae, then you can correct your brother."
Eventually we left the mountain range and joined a track leading through a forest. We rode alongside a river until we reached open land again.
Phoebus tried to make a joke, and we got nothing from Neomene. No laugh, no joke back, no opinion. I have no idea what she thinks of her brother, of the war, nothing. Snoozefest.
August 3, 2013
THE GIRL FROM ITHACA
Here is an historical novel to captivate and enthral. Taking a Greek myth and placing the reader in the shoes of a young girl, the author adds her own development to Odysseus's story.
This girl from Ithaca is Neomene, sister of Odysseus. She did well to contemplate the eagle circling as she rushed to warn her brother of the Spartan ships approaching. Much drama lies ahead.
She is only fourteen when she is torn from her roots to escort a bride-to-be to Sparta, only to find there is deadly intrigue involved and is then caught up in the Trojan War.
This story is told in two parts, the exciting sequel, Walls of Troy, taking us on to the point where, years later, she sees her homeland again. In the meantime, Neomene has experienced trauma and hardships of every kind. They test her, but she overcomes immense dangers. It was no easy life for even a high-born woman in those times. Neomene is never just an onlooker while the battles rage on.
The novel gives a very different slant from the conventional re-telling of the myths. The action moves constantly forward while Neomene matures from innocent girl to companion and staunch supporter of her menfolk, never a victim, much as Odysseus’ enemies would wish.
Readers will identify with Neomene’s adventures to the point where they forget that these were Greek myths and this story is fiction.
Here is an historical novel to captivate and enthral. Taking a Greek myth and placing the reader in the shoes of a young girl, the author adds her own development to Odysseus's story.
This girl from Ithaca is Neomene, sister of Odysseus. She did well to contemplate the eagle circling as she rushed to warn her brother of the Spartan ships approaching. Much drama lies ahead.
She is only fourteen when she is torn from her roots to escort a bride-to-be to Sparta, only to find there is deadly intrigue involved and is then caught up in the Trojan War.
This story is told in two parts, the exciting sequel, Walls of Troy, taking us on to the point where, years later, she sees her homeland again. In the meantime, Neomene has experienced trauma and hardships of every kind. They test her, but she overcomes immense dangers. It was no easy life for even a high-born woman in those times. Neomene is never just an onlooker while the battles rage on.
The novel gives a very different slant from the conventional re-telling of the myths. The action moves constantly forward while Neomene matures from innocent girl to companion and staunch supporter of her menfolk, never a victim, much as Odysseus’ enemies would wish.
Readers will identify with Neomene’s adventures to the point where they forget that these were Greek myths and this story is fiction.
May 20, 2014
Somewhat familiar with Greek mythology, I found this novel fascinating, with a cast of colorful characters, and filled with historical accuracies.
The Girl from Ithaca is the story of Neomene, little sister of Odysseus. When Spartan war ships sail into Ithaca, Odysseus joins the Greek alliance against Troy to fulfill an oath. Fourteen-year-old Neomene is asked to escort a bride-to-be to Sparta and finds herself thrown into a world of war—a world she knows little about.
The war drags on for years. Many die. A weary Neomene faces extreme hardships, but is determined to survive and return to her homeland. As she matures into a beautiful and confident woman, she befriends and supports other women and men mired in the raging battle, and finds love amidst the chaos of war.
I highly recommended this beautifully written historical novel.
The Girl from Ithaca is the story of Neomene, little sister of Odysseus. When Spartan war ships sail into Ithaca, Odysseus joins the Greek alliance against Troy to fulfill an oath. Fourteen-year-old Neomene is asked to escort a bride-to-be to Sparta and finds herself thrown into a world of war—a world she knows little about.
The war drags on for years. Many die. A weary Neomene faces extreme hardships, but is determined to survive and return to her homeland. As she matures into a beautiful and confident woman, she befriends and supports other women and men mired in the raging battle, and finds love amidst the chaos of war.
I highly recommended this beautifully written historical novel.
October 15, 2013
This is a wonderful, exciting, and historically accurate tale of Odysseus's little sister, Neomene.
Neomene falls in love, witnesses the sacrifice of Iphigenia by her father, witnesses Achilles's change from a love-struck youth to a brutal warrior, and meets a demi-goddess or two along the way.
Cherry Gregory writes with clear language an entirely accessible story about a very famous, ancient war––all from the point of view of the women. This is a fun read for the YA crowd, but even older adults like me will find it entirely enthralling.
This is Imprintli's first of our YA imprint. Book Two, The Walls of Troy, will be out in September.
Neomene falls in love, witnesses the sacrifice of Iphigenia by her father, witnesses Achilles's change from a love-struck youth to a brutal warrior, and meets a demi-goddess or two along the way.
Cherry Gregory writes with clear language an entirely accessible story about a very famous, ancient war––all from the point of view of the women. This is a fun read for the YA crowd, but even older adults like me will find it entirely enthralling.
This is Imprintli's first of our YA imprint. Book Two, The Walls of Troy, will be out in September.
March 26, 2014
The Girl From Ithaca, told from the perspective of a young fourteen-year-old girl, is a compelling story based on Greek mythology. Filled with suspense, humor, and romance, the book will keep you rivited to your seat racing to get to the end. I'm so glad to hear that there's going to be a sequel. Well done Cherry!
August 25, 2013
I have nothing but praise for this vast, sweeping, yet enjoyably accessible interpretation of the Trojan legend. Ms Gregory has done her Homer-work well, and the result is a fascinating and finely-woven tapestry worthy of Penelope herself!
November 8, 2013
I have always been a Greek Mythology geek.
So I was pleased with Cherry Gregory moderately successful attempt to tackle this difficult genre.
The story takes awhile to take shape but then is fairly interesting.
Because the author is such a good writer using prose seamlessly,she makes it work.
So I was pleased with Cherry Gregory moderately successful attempt to tackle this difficult genre.
The story takes awhile to take shape but then is fairly interesting.
Because the author is such a good writer using prose seamlessly,she makes it work.
November 8, 2013
Loved this book!!!!
November 17, 2013
Really good book , mythology that kept me entertained. Neomene is a character you can get to know, in a personal way. I thought she was very real.
January 12, 2018
This is essentially a YA retelling of The Iliad, told from the point of view of Odysseus's younger sister. Despite how women (well, important ladies) are held on somewhat of a pedestal at that time, she manages to join her brother through the important events of the beginning of the Trojan War. I enjoyed it overall, but I could have done without the last 15% or so being mainly focused on a wedding. Also, some of the characters are very two-dimensional, and there's really no difference in how servants/slaves are depicted versus important figures like Agamemnon. I can't suspend disbelief enough to allow for a captured Trojan slave to be treated as an important person in the Greek camp.
January 14, 2018
Good yarn. I've always enjoyed Greek Mythology. I've read the Iliad and the Odyssey of Homer. This certainly is not in the league of Homer's telling of this tale, but it seems relatively well researched, and adds colorful background of life in the Greek camps on the beaches of Troy as well as insight into Helen's part and potentially her feelings on her seduction or abduction. Was she a victim or an accomplice. You decide.
January 2, 2019
The book was fast paced, and easy to read. The accuracy of the events depicted leaves something to be desired, but it is a fictional account after all. It didn't come across as very realistic. I would've rated the book at four stars had it not been for the story lacking in cohesion. At times, it didn't seem to flow well and the story was all over the place. But, overall, I enjoyed it for what it was and I am picking up the sequel to it soon.
May 28, 2018
An incredibly boring book. It took me so long to get through just to find the end to be a cliff hanger 😱 That made me so upset, yet here I am reading the second book. The second is infinitely better, by the way.
April 30, 2024
Fascinating take on the legends we grew up with.
Entertaining, fast read. So absorbing I couldn't put it down & read it in two days. Already bought the second book.
Entertaining, fast read. So absorbing I couldn't put it down & read it in two days. Already bought the second book.
August 19, 2020
This book covers the first few years of the Trojan War from the perspective of Odysseus’s sister, Neomene. I’ve heard many stories of the Trojan War, but I like this viewpoint of the women, mostly slaves or servants apart from Neomene, in the Greek camp. It depicts some characters differently than I’m used to, like showing Menelaus as kind and Ajax as funny; I also like getting to know some of the other names more personally through this fictional telling. Generally, I enjoy the stories that come from Greek history, and even though I’ve heard this one before, it’s different enough to make it still interesting.
March 11, 2024
This was an enjoyable book for the most part. Easy to read, likable characters, well-constructed world, but I do think a lot more could have done with it. I feel like the book would have benefited from being a little longer to properly flesh out the characters and their relationships, because they were pretty awfully one dimensional. It's true that it would have then lost its quick and easy charm, but the truth is I didn't care deeply about many of the characters and a lot of the relationships presented were also not particularly believable or shown with enough depth to make me really care.
The plot was also not particularly exciting. Obviously we're following the Trojan war, which many know the story of already (myself especially so), but the plot of the characters themselves is seemingly non-existent. There is no trajectory that we follow, no sub-plots, no character development of any importance, despite several years passing often seemingly out of nowhere (at one point, it was stated that they had been at Troy for three years, whereas, the last time I had been aware of the year, they had been there one). All that really happens is several years following the day-to-day lives of Neomene and her friends in the Trojan war with a few plot points stabbed in here and there, but with no real connecting factor. Even what I assume what was meant to be the emotional climax at the end of the book didn't pack much of a punch both because it was very predictable and because I didn't really care about the characters or the relationship involved. In that respect it was somewhat dull.
I also thought this was going to be an interesting adaptation without explicitly using the gods, only having them referenced and talked about in stories and in hearsay, since for example Paris was whisked away not by Aphrodite but by the Trojans in the one-to-one combat, but then about three quarters of the way through we meet an actual nymph who has genuinely met the gods, so I don't know what that was all about.
Character motivations were often all over the place. If Oenone saw Odysseus as a threat to Paris, why did she change her mind so quickly? Why was Neomene so staunchly against going home - the excuse that she'd failed Iphigenia seems pretty weak? Why did she and Antilochus even like one another? We see nothing of their relationship, or even their friendship. It seems to come out of nowhere and therefore not have much of an impact.
There are quite a few loose ends dangling around, like the suspicious Hesta and the yet-to-kick-off fight about Briseis, which I assume will continue in the sequel. (I did rather like the idea of Achilles easily falling in love and Briseis being his latest catch, making the later feud about love rather than arrogance, which is a new take on it.)
I'm not sure if I'll be reading the sequel. Since I own it, I guess I might as well, but this really wasn't a great book and I think my three-star rating might even be pretty generous. Quite enjoyable and a very quick read, but not something I'd read again or recommend.
The plot was also not particularly exciting. Obviously we're following the Trojan war, which many know the story of already (myself especially so), but the plot of the characters themselves is seemingly non-existent. There is no trajectory that we follow, no sub-plots, no character development of any importance, despite several years passing often seemingly out of nowhere (at one point, it was stated that they had been at Troy for three years, whereas, the last time I had been aware of the year, they had been there one). All that really happens is several years following the day-to-day lives of Neomene and her friends in the Trojan war with a few plot points stabbed in here and there, but with no real connecting factor. Even what I assume what was meant to be the emotional climax at the end of the book didn't pack much of a punch both because it was very predictable and because I didn't really care about the characters or the relationship involved. In that respect it was somewhat dull.
I also thought this was going to be an interesting adaptation without explicitly using the gods, only having them referenced and talked about in stories and in hearsay, since for example Paris was whisked away not by Aphrodite but by the Trojans in the one-to-one combat, but then about three quarters of the way through we meet an actual nymph who has genuinely met the gods, so I don't know what that was all about.
Character motivations were often all over the place. If Oenone saw Odysseus as a threat to Paris, why did she change her mind so quickly? Why was Neomene so staunchly against going home - the excuse that she'd failed Iphigenia seems pretty weak? Why did she and Antilochus even like one another? We see nothing of their relationship, or even their friendship. It seems to come out of nowhere and therefore not have much of an impact.
There are quite a few loose ends dangling around, like the suspicious Hesta and the yet-to-kick-off fight about Briseis, which I assume will continue in the sequel. (I did rather like the idea of Achilles easily falling in love and Briseis being his latest catch, making the later feud about love rather than arrogance, which is a new take on it.)
I'm not sure if I'll be reading the sequel. Since I own it, I guess I might as well, but this really wasn't a great book and I think my three-star rating might even be pretty generous. Quite enjoyable and a very quick read, but not something I'd read again or recommend.
September 4, 2014
In The Girl from Ithaca another possible story from the Trojan War is developed with the historical settings, ships, foods, cures, and characters. I liked from the beginning the author's interpretation that the Trojan War wasn't just about Helen, and that it was about women and Greek men. I read the Iliad some years ago, and that interpretation was definitely there, concerning Agamemnon and other men, their claims about women when they weren't really harem kings.
The Iliad was a difficult book, there was little of Helen in it, and it was mostly about battles. I'd say, one of the worst classics I read, only because of my tastes. So Cherry Gregory's telling was readable, usually well-based on the historical story, and it told about Odysseus's sister being part of the war. The idea that women helped those men during the years of the Trojan War is solid.
I liked best the scenes with healing in the Iliad and liked this part of Neomene's role in the war. The book also brings Greek heroes into human scenes while Neomene attempts to be diplomat with Helen, helps to heal the injured, falls in love with a hero, and all the while, shows with the other women caught in the war the ancient woman's options in a treacherous and advancing world where warriors won. Well written and involving, this book was mostly satisfying for one who read the Odyssey and the Iliad. It also retold Greek legends in the story place, inspiration during the war, and this was a pleasant way to learn again.
The Iliad was a difficult book, there was little of Helen in it, and it was mostly about battles. I'd say, one of the worst classics I read, only because of my tastes. So Cherry Gregory's telling was readable, usually well-based on the historical story, and it told about Odysseus's sister being part of the war. The idea that women helped those men during the years of the Trojan War is solid.
I liked best the scenes with healing in the Iliad and liked this part of Neomene's role in the war. The book also brings Greek heroes into human scenes while Neomene attempts to be diplomat with Helen, helps to heal the injured, falls in love with a hero, and all the while, shows with the other women caught in the war the ancient woman's options in a treacherous and advancing world where warriors won. Well written and involving, this book was mostly satisfying for one who read the Odyssey and the Iliad. It also retold Greek legends in the story place, inspiration during the war, and this was a pleasant way to learn again.
November 12, 2015
I’m a bit of a sucker for historical fiction and if you throw Ancient Greece into the mix, well you’ve snagged my attention. The story of Odysseus and the Battle of Troy, told from the female perspective. Not a slave, not a Trojan, but none other Odysseus’ sister Neomene. Many years ago I read the story of Kassandra, daughter of King Priam priestess and seer (I can’t remember the name of the book nor the author which is a shame because I really enjoyed the book) the story gave a different perspective on Kassandra not being mad and it explained centaurs and Amazons in a way that make sense. The Girl from Ithaca is similar in its telling.
There are still the stories of the Gods, the intermingling of Immortals and mortals, but also everyday life in the camp of an invading army. The women remind us that there was so much more involved than just one young stunningly beautiful woman who left her husband for another man. There were (aren’t there always?) so many more layers involved on both sides. And when Gods step in, how much say do mortals have in their own lives? Is free will a real thing? Can a Goddess turn your head and make you forget yourself?
There are still the stories of the Gods, the intermingling of Immortals and mortals, but also everyday life in the camp of an invading army. The women remind us that there was so much more involved than just one young stunningly beautiful woman who left her husband for another man. There were (aren’t there always?) so many more layers involved on both sides. And when Gods step in, how much say do mortals have in their own lives? Is free will a real thing? Can a Goddess turn your head and make you forget yourself?
November 30, 2015
Powerless people can still get things done, and Odysseus’s sister Neomene proves this over and over. She is powerless to stop Agamemnon’s evil scheming and his priest ‘s misled plan, but she speaks for good sense and the right thing over and over as she stands beside her crafty, resourceful brother. Accompanying the Greek armada to attack Troy, she is part of a group offering truce and conditions for peace to the Trojans before Agamemnon’s army arrives, but failing that, she becomes a force for healing, eventually even saving Odysseus’s life when the healer Machaon’s prescription fails. Courage is hers consistently, though not the physical courage. That quality belongs to Achilles, Menelaus, Ajax on the Greek side, and Hector and Medon on the Trojan side. Gods and goddesses’ parts in the drama are minimized in this tale, where the action is determined more fully by the various human qualities of the protagonists in the tale. Gregory follows Homer’s plot pretty closely, just adding accounts of things that a young woman might find herself embroiled in, events both dangerous and fulfilling.
May 6, 2015
You certainly do not have to be knowledgeable in respect of Greek mythology to completely appreciate and enjoy the way the Author Cherry Gregory has written The Girl from Ithaca. You are taken on this journey with Neomene (14) the young Sister of Odysseus. A young woman's view of the Trojan War. The Ithacans, Spartans, Trojans - wow - I am definitely 'hooked'. I can only begin to imagine how much research the Author went into prior to writing this well written book. You really are transported to those mythical times and can almost sense the atmosphere. I highly recommend this book - it's interesting & captivating and also, in my opinion suitable for younger folk in their teens. (My friend's daughter recently read it and loved it - has finished the second book and eagerly awaiting the third.) I am looking forward to reading the second book too - The Walls of Troy.
July 12, 2015
The Girl from Ithaca is a very clever retelling of the story of the Seige of Troy. Neomene is the sister of Odysseus and the events are recounted by her which draws the reader into the heart of the action. As the tale unfolds Neomene finds herself accompanying her brother Odysseus to the outskirts of Troy where the Greeks set up camp. Their aim is to rescue the fair Helen of Troy and return her to Menelaus. Mythical characters such as Achilles and Hector come to life. We see the character of Neomene develop as a courageous and bold young woman. She endures hardship and loss with the passing of the years which makes the reader care about her. Throughout the dialogue is excellent and gives a freshness and vibrancy to the story. I can’t wait to read the next book in the series. I can highly recommend this book.
September 17, 2015
I got this as a free e-book from BookBub, where I find I have the best luck with historical fiction, and sometimes mystery. I'd give this one 3.5 stars if that were an option. I enjoy reading about Greek mythology and history from the point of view of characters as though they were living through it, and I especially enjoyed that the protagonist in this series is a young woman. There were a few typos and dropped words (more the further along the book went), so I think this author should hire me to proofread her texts for her. :-) I do plan to read the next book in the series, _The Walls of Troy_, which I also got free from BookBub.
May 6, 2015
I picked this book up as a result of a "Goodreads" recommendation, and I'm glad I did. I wasn't sure if it would be to my taste, but was pleasantly surprised by it. I haven't touched "The Iliad" since my schooldays, but many of the story-lines and characters were brought back to life by this novel. It is unusual in that the viewpoint is that of a woman, Neomene the sister of Odysseus. There were a couple of times when I my imagination was stretched to the point of disbelief, but generally I found this a good read that never lost pace, and has set me off once again investigating the Iliad. That alone is the mark of what, for me, constitutes a good historical novel.
April 23, 2014
Years ago when I was a child, I was given a book of Greek myths. The magic of those stories has stayed with me all my life. So when I heard that Cherry Gregory had written a historical novel based on the Trojan war, I knew I would have to read it. The Girl From Ithaca hasn't disappointed. Writing it from the point of view of Neomene, the younger sister of Odysseus, Cherry Gregory took on a mammoth task and handled it skilfully. It is a beautifully written book which I thoroughly recommend! I look forward to reading part two of the trilogy, which has just been published.
May 23, 2014
I don't often read historic fiction, because the inevitable historical errors drive me crazy. However, The Girl From Ithaca is so well written, the characters are so real and the descriptions so magical that Cherry Gregory could have had aliens instead of Gods and I wouldn't have minded.
The Girl from Ithaca is the first part of an epic trilogy following the Trojan War, and the quest to wrest Helen from the arms of Paris. Part two has just been published and I can't wait to get my hands on part three!
The Girl from Ithaca is the first part of an epic trilogy following the Trojan War, and the quest to wrest Helen from the arms of Paris. Part two has just been published and I can't wait to get my hands on part three!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 53 reviews