What do you think?
Rate this book


474 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2001
New York, 1902. Francesca Cahill is young, fabulously wealthy, and naturally far more concerned with the plight of the less fortunate than anyone else in her privileged circle. A socially conscious heiress determined to right the world's wrongs. How wonderfully original. To me, it feels like the obligatory premise designed to make a sheltered, privileged young lady both sympathetic and credible when she takes up detective work and goes head-to-head with an experienced, brooding detective. And yet, despite this unpromising introduction, Deadly Love is a genuinely enjoyable read.
The mystery offers enough intrigue to keep the pages turning, but the real attraction is turn-of-the-century New York, from its glittering high society, rigid conventions and delicious scandals to its impoverished neighbourhoods and stark social inequalities.
Joyce weaves the setting beautifully into the story. The social rules, the contrasts between classes, the expectations placed upon women and the rather inconvenient things that happen when someone refuses to observe them all give the investigation its particular flavour. I enjoyed following Francesca through this world far more than I worried about identifying the culprit.
Francesca herself can be rather naïve and immature in her judgements, despite the author's efforts to establish her as a strong, independent heroine. But then, she's only beginning to discover the world beyond her comfortable upbringing. This is the first book in a series, after all, and I'd be disappointed if she had nothing left to learn. The court will reserve judgement.
There's romance, too, although I must confess Rick Bragg did very little to win me over. Fortunately, the romantic thread takes its time, and I was particularly pleased that it didn't follow the most obvious route. It's refreshing to find a heroine whose romantic future isn't settled the moment an eligible gentleman walks into the room, however determined the gentleman may be to make an impression.
As for the prose, it's nothing special, but it's perfectly adequate when the characters, the intrigue and, above all, the historical setting are doing the heavy lifting.
An enjoyable start to a series, with a mystery worth following and a New York society worth revisiting. I may not yet approve of all Francesca's acquaintances, but I'm quite prepared to accept another invitation into her world.