I have not read The Returned, so I have no idea what that book is like. I picked this (and two other) audiobooks up for free from Audible because I like having something quick and short to listen to while I clean or run errands etc.
So, coming into this story, I didn't know what to expect - horror, most likely - but I was surprised at how... mundane it was. I don't necessarily mean that in a bad way, though. I actually like when an author can show the mundane aspects of life and make me believe it, and feel it. I don't know if this story quite got to that level, but I appreciated what it was trying for. I actually came close to tearing up a couple times... but I think that it was me, more than the story, which contributed to that reaction. I have an overactive empathy gland, and I can stick myself into any situation and imagine how I'd feel going through it. I was really touched by the thought of Emily feeling like she needed to apologize for the past year. I can imagine how, in that situation, moving on would feel like a betrayal.
But the story didn't really convey that... It was kind of bare-bones "she felt this" and "he thought that", etc. The style was geared more toward telling than really SHOWING us the emotional turmoil this event has caused, and in a small way, I did think that it was a little emotionally manipulative. For a story this short, I'm not sure how it could NOT be and still focus on the romance.
But I did like it overall. I liked that it just... happened. Dead people return. Alrighty then. What now? Oh, bureaucracy. Of course. I do wish that that aspect was fleshed out a little more. They question Edmund, and keep him quarantined... but that's about it. I would like to see a little more of the ethics of how one handles a no-longer-dead person. Do they regain their rights? Their property? Is it OK to experiment on them?
Also, it seems to me that Edmund didn't just return - he reverted to his post-death self. He showed no signs of the bus accident that killed him... it was as though he had never died. I'm interested in the logistics of that.
These questions are actually enough to pique my interest in the book to see if they are answered, and if so, if they are treated consistently.
So, for a 33 minute audiobook, it was good. It did what it was supposed to do, which is to make me look twice at the novel, even though I probably stuck my hook in the wrong worm and am interested in logistics and data rather than the personal aspect. Go figure. ;)