Little Star started strong but petered out for me. I guess it's because, rather than following a linear narrative the whole way through, Lindqvist divides the story into two separate sections each about the life of a different little girl - Theres, who's born a psychopath, and Teresa, who becomes one - before bringing them together for a terrible, blood-soaked finale. Unfortunately, while I found Theres's story deeply unsettling and morbidly fascinating, Teresa's story mostly fell flat.
It's hard to mess up the story of a psychopath (just add gratuitous violence) but even so Theres's story is something else. The appeal's almost immediately apparent, Lindqvist has a way of writing that's just so incredibly unsettling, somehow reading I just knew something was off, even if there wasn't anything out of the ordinary about the way Theres's parents treat her at first after her father finds her in the woods, well, except for the hiding her in the basement part. Average, everyday activities like shopping or dinner just didn't feel right, and that's before Lindqvist piles on the psychologically twisted details that made me realize there's just something very very wrong with these people. But most of all, it's the way Lennart and Laila can carry on with their mundane lives, yet, all of a sudden, do something so shockingly disturbing but at the same time appear so calm and rational that's most memorable - I had to reread paragraphs just to confirm, did they really just do that? Those bizarre interludes of violence, treated just as matter of factly as any other activity, are just so dark and disturbing I could not stop reading.
Then I get to Teresa's story. I have to say, after Theres's, it's kind of a letdown. Theres is completely crazy, Teresa I would say is quirky yet sane. Yeah, Lindqvist hints Teresa's different from most other people, but after how good Theres's story was, Teresa's really started to drag despite a few sections of dark humor here and there. As the story of a budding psychopath, I get Teresa isn't supposed to have the kind of abnormal childhood Theres had, isn't supposed to be exposed to all the random acts of violence Theres was, but the way Linqvist develops her character, as this lost girl looking for her purpose in life then getting picked on because she apparently looks like a pig until she finally breaks, it's not much different from the stereotypical pop culture psychopath childhood. Wasn't really impressed.
So it comes down to, after Little Star becomes more the story of a girl slowly descending into violent madness rather than the story of a girl already murderously insane, I started to like this book less and less because Teresa's story just isn't as dark, compelling, well-paced, or unique as Theres's. It’s like Lindqvist exhausted his best material on Theres and the rest of the book’s running on fumes. When Teresa finally breaks, I guess I was more indifferent than shocked or appalled because what happens is so trite and cliched I really was expecting more. And the ending, it all depends I guess on how much gore one can take too, after the craziness of Theres's story I was actually pretty much desensitized to all the violence so even though it was pretty outrageous and bloody, eh, didn't shock me as much as what Lennart, Laila, and Theres did before.
I guess Lindqivst couldn't have written an entire book just about Theres, it'd be gory yet engrossing but wouldn't have much of a plot except mindless violence, but adding Teresa detracted from the story because her part just wasn’t at the same caliber as Theres's. After that first section, I was pretty much disappointed by everything that came after.