Berry's latest political thriller asks the reader to suspend reality just enough to posit, 'could all of this be true?' all while enjoying Cotton Malone in his latest adventure. The day that Lincoln took over the White House, he was passed a letter from his predecessor, James Buchanan, outlining a secret that all presidents before him had held and passed along to their successors. Now, at a time when the country was set to split apart and the Mormon Church was poised to choose to support the South, Lincoln met with Prophet Brigham Young and entrusted him with a document to hold and keep secret, if only for a time. As the Mormon Church continues its rise, some within the US Government begin crafting a plan, based on the White Horse Prophecy, an ancient prediction made by Joseph Smith. In order to bring it to pass, this secret letter and its contents must be made public. While no US Administration has known the content of the letter, musings abound. Enter Cotton Malone and the rest of the Magellan Billet, who are tasked with not only learning about the Prophecy, but ensuring no harm comes to the fifty states as they presently stand. Add to this, Malone's love interest, Cassiopeia Vitt, who has a secret or two she's been keeping from Malone, which will turn the tables on this entire mission. Berry ramps up the interest and may offend some down to their Celestial Robes, but hooks the reader to the core and keeps the action going.
As I read, I could see certain groups flying off the handle with this book, though no foundation for such expressions exist, in my mind. This is the second novel I have read in the last handful of months to put a wary eye on the Mormon Church and its practices, though Berry does so in a much more refined way than Azrieli did in THE MORMON CANDIDATE. Criticism of the Church and its beliefs is not a reason to wail and spin Berry out to be some gentile Satan. Enough of his work (and that of a plethora of other authors) have criticised and analysed the Catholic Church. Do people complain? Surely! Are there inaccuracies? Likely! Does it shed light on number of truths that some within the organisation wish to hide under the Celestial rug? Most definitely, and this is one the best reasons to write such books. It's fiction, and while there is going to be a degree of literary freedom, there is a lot of truth in a great deal of what Berry writes, as he takes precious time to research his work and shows his hand in the author's note, as he does in all his books. I am sure constitutional scholars are also pulling out their proverbial hair for some of the freedoms Berry takes, but we all roll with the punches. It is those who complain the loudest that have the most to hide, I have come to believe.
Whatever your take on the content or premise of the book, there are a number of powerful ideas presented within the plot. Character development, always a forte of Berry's, continues here with more depth and emotion facing some of the recurring characters, as well as newbies on the scene. Berry is also able to capture the political drama and constitutional foundations in order to really force the reader to ask, 'what if?' and 'could it be?'. These are wonderful tools, especially when woven together so effortlessly by so talented an author. Regular series readers will surely enjoy this and newbies can appreciate the talent Berry has, and will likely want to return for many more doses of Cotton Malone, if only to finally learn the history behind the name. And what a great end to the book, how it leaves threads hanging that series regulars will scream until the release of the next novel.
Kudos, Mr. Berry for this wonderful and controversial novel. Keep it up and you're sure to enrage more with the truths you uncover.