Sasahara Nagi pracuje dorywczo jako model w Akademii Sztuk Pięknych, gdzie poznaje Kajiego ? przystojnego rysownika, który rzuca mu wieloznaczne spojrzenie. Gubiący się w domysłach Nagi nawet nie zauważa, kiedy zakochuje się w swoim nowym znajomym. Traci jednak nadzieję na wzajemność, bowiem odkrywa, że Nagi dorabia w nocnym klubie przebrany za kobietę. Mimo początkowych zabawnych nieporozumień, ich związek w końcu rozkwita. Jednak po czterech miesiącach bycia razem nadal ograniczają się tylko do niewinnych pocałunków. Okazuje się, że Kaji również skrywa pewną tajemnicę?
Takanaga Hinako (高永ひなこ) is a Japanese author of Boys' Love manga. She has also provided illustrations for several BL light novels by other authors, including The Guilty by Katsura Izumi. Her first manga story, 合格祈願 (Goukaku kigan, Prayers for a passing grade?), was published by Hanamaru Comics in 1997; it was later reworked as the first chapter of Challengers. Most of her works have been translated into foreign languages. She was a guest at YaoiCon 2007, invited by Juné, the US publishers of her popular series Little Butterfly. When not making Boys' Love manga, she spends her time collecting Wallace & Gromit merchandise and playing Final Fantasy. Takanaga doesn’t like beer and people who are ignorant.
She comments that her biggest influence on her art and writing-style was KOUGA Yun, a famous shoujo manga artist whose works she read as a teenager.
I read this one when it originally came out in German in 2006 and wow, twelve years make a huge difference. Not only was I bored out of my mind, I found the characters tedious, the plot thinner than water and the problems badly covered. So Uke (no, that's not his name, but that's what I call him because let's be real, the names don't matter with these paper cut-out characters) is working as a model for art students during the day and in a "transvestite" show during the night. He identifies as a "transvestite" because he's a gay man and thinks his only way of being with a man is to be a woman himself. Not in itself an impossible situation but...I think this reflects old attitudes on homosexuality because even for 2006 this is kind of an out-dated idea. Anyhow, the arc is handled poorly.
The Uke loves the Seme because. I mean, they never talk before the manga starts so I guess both confuse sexual attraction with love and I mean, sure, date someone because you like them physically, who cares. But don't confuse attraction with love.
The plot relies on misscommunications and a really sensitive, ill-tempred, whiny Uke who sees attacks in everything. Instead of talking, Uke easily spirals towards an emotional meltdown, saying that Seme doesn't really love him, screaming at him, falling down crying, throwing tantrums for not going out enough (Seme's a fucking starving art's student...HE AIN'T A BILLIONAIRE, BITCH, CHILL). Seme's not in a relationship with an adult but with an insecure brat. I don't think his cuteness compensates for his characters...
Also, Uke's co-workers at the club are evil bitches. Seriously, the guy has been unhappy for months and years and as soon as Uke shows a smither of happiness, they resent him and become abusive. That's not funny. It just leaves me behind with a huge WTF.
To be honest, I started skimming after the first few pages. It's unreadable for me now. It has the depth of wet toilet paper and the zest of mushy oatmeal.
Takanaga has always been a hit or miss author for me. I love her art, but many of her stories are either too silly or too graphic, and yet she's managed to deliver some really nice works that prove she can do better. Corquis isn't really either; it's neither silly nor graphic but it's also not a good story.
As a collection of short stories, it already has the issue that it doesn't have enough time to deliver any kind of meaningful story. The main story fills about half of the book and its the main part that drags this collection down. Besides having an insufferable main character, I find that sexuality is treated very oddly here. The main character Nagi claims to be gay but at the same time works in a crossdresser bar but also wants to have an operation to become a female. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but crossdressing, being transsexual or gay are three entirely different things. His reasoning for wanting to become a girl purely because he likes men seems a bit odd to me and the fact that this story is so short means there is no room to further explore these themes. I can't decide whether this story was just a bit ignorant of the subject at hand or simply didn't bother to go beyond the surface. Even if the subjects had been better explored though, we'd still be stuck with the fact that I found Nagi wholly unlikeable and I saw no chemistry between him and the love interest.
The remaining three short stories were nicer and surprisingly more thoughtful given that they were much shorter. However, they were all rather sad and I wish there had been sequels to give us some form of happy ending. The remaining stories are unfortunately not enough to make up for the mess that is the main story.
Disappointing. From the synopsis on the back, I thought it would be a romance with a trans character rather than just a circumstantial gender bender--or at least there would be some neat examination of the ways gender and sexuality cross under the stern gaze of society, but...basically no.
Even if I set aside my hopes for something interestingly queer, the romance was dull and disappointing.
Oh, and what's with all the German words thrown in?
Mam DUŻE zastrzeżenia co do tej pozycji, nie podoba mi się pewien aspekt w głównej historyjce, no nie... A tak poza tym to można przeczytać jak już masz na półce/widzisz w bibliotece, ale jak chcesz specjalnie kupić, aby to zrobić.. to odpuść.
Não, não funcionou para mim. Essa história é chata e por mais que eu me esforçasse e tentasse comprar algumas ideias, em nenhum momento consegui me conectar com os personagens. O romance acabou sendo maçante e decepcionante e o contexto geral é um desserviço.
Nagi is a model at an art school during the day and a drag queen at a club at night. He was never a lucky guy with relationships, but noticed that Kaji, one of the students of the art school, had his eyes on him more than necessary lately.
Kaji is a very talented student, but there is something about painting Nagi that unleashes Kaji’s inspiration to new levels. Can he convince Nagi that they may work outside of the artistic world as well?
Will Nagi finally find himself a good boyfriend?!
The Analysis Just remembering that those were my impressions and opinion as a reader :)
Despite the fact that Croquis was released in 2010, I only met it last June. I was at a comic book event and saw that beautiful cover over there and ran to do a quick investigation online, to see if it was worth a shot. Oh boy, I’m so glad that I found it! This one shot was sweet, funny and, at the same time, talks about real problems inside gay relationships such as self-acceptance, couple adaptation, the importance of communicating with your partner, etc. I loved it and really wished it wasn’t just an one shot :( Five stars nevertheless!
The narrative pace was slow and really thoughtful. Nagi overthinks even his own breathing and this can be a little tiring, as he is very insecure in the beginning. Later, we get to see more action and less thinking, but anyway, haha! It worked for me in this title. Kaji doesn’t have many parts of his own point of view, but it is part of the magic, so the reader doesn’t know what’s up with him, just like Nagi doesn’t.
The plot was very simple and basic. It’s a daily life title, as we follow Nagi and Kaji’s routines and getting used to themselves as a couple. It’s not remarkable or brilliant, but it works fantastically. It’s a light and heart-warming read :D
I have to admit that I didn’t really liked Nagi. I’m not into books/mangas/comics which have very gay men, the ones that wished they were women. I like males that, instead of making out with the girl in the bar, just go making out with the other male next to him. No fuss made, no crossdressing. I’m not against it on real life, this is only a literary preference in my readings!
Point is, Nagi is a drag queen and he wants to be a girl. That is one of their main problems as a couple, as Kaji seems hesitant with Nagi’s wishes. Kaji, in the other hand, was such a gentleman all the time! I loved him and just felt sorry for not seeing much sheets action, if you get my drift.
The art of Hinako Takanaga sensei was amazingly beautiful. I’ve read another title from her, called Tyrant Falls in Love, and she’s the kind of person that has the ability to draw both insanely beautiful men and regular boy-next-door men.
Overall, it’s a good yaoi to pass time if you are not specifically looking for hot sex scenes, haha! I’d recommend it to all of you that appreciate a “shoujo” yaoi style of manga.
It was very cute and sweet. There really isn't much else I can say that hasn't already been said about this one. It was nice that the focus was on accepting who you are, as you are. There is always that anxiety about improving or changing yourself to keep the other interested when in relationships. The reassurence was nice to hear, no matter who you are.
On the transgender issue, I was surprised that the desire for surgery was social acceptance. Normally it's changing the outward appearance to match how you feel on the inside. So I'm glad that under that cirrcumstance that surgery was not followed through in this insistance.
The art is beautiful as always but the primary storyline betrays a fundamental misunderstanding of the difference between "gender" and "sexuality" (for those wanting a warning, the main character is saving for breast augmentation surgery but so far as I can tell is in fact cis and wants to transition solely in order to be able to date men...?) and two out of the three short stories that follow have sad endings. Not here for it. Next!
Eh, the stories were cute (On My First Love is so frustratingly sad), but I don't like how Nagi's transgender/transsexual issues were just...dropped (Oh, Kaji likes me as I am, so all my issues are gone now! Seriously?)
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
i waited since 2009 To read this book, and i was extremely irritated when it ends so abruptly and that it was so short. i wasted a big part of my life wondering about this book. annoying thats all i have to say.
Loved it. I also liked the extra stories in the back. Naji wants to be a drag queen and kaji doesn't know. Story is super cute and loving. Art is awesome.
Skizzen der Liebe ist ein Kurzgeschichtenband mit sensiblen, melancholischen, aber auch witzigen Erzählungen über die Liebe zwischen zwei Jungen.
In der Titelgeschichte finden der Maler Shinji Kaji und sein androgynes Model Nagi zusammen. Nagi arbeitet nachts noch in einem Transvestitenclub, weil er Geld braucht. Eines Tages will er sich nämlich in eine Frau umoperieren lassen. Kann Shinjis Liebe ihn von diesem Vorhaben abbringen?
Die anderen Geschichten erzählen von bitter-süßen Erinnerungen an die erste Liebe und davon, wie die Sterne einen eigenwilligen Trotzkopf und einen fanatischen Astronomieliebhaber doch noch zusammenbringen können.
Cover:
Das Cover fand ich eigentlich recht niedlich. Zu sehen sind hier die beiden Protagonisten Kaji und der Nagi, wobei Nagi durch seine androgyne Art wirklich wirkt wie ein Mädchen und ich das auch erst als solchen Manga angesehen habe. Als ich den Inhalt dann gelesen habe, war ich schon ein bisschen enttäuscht, hatte mir aber doch eine schöne Liebesgeschichte erhofft…
Eigener Eindruck:
Der androgyne Nagi wirkt auf viele Betrachter wie ein Mädchen, weshalb er als Modell in einer Kunstschule jobbt. Dort trifft er auf den Kunststudenten Kaji, der sich scheinbar für ihn zu interessieren scheint. Während der Arbeit kommen sich die beiden immer näher und scheinen sich auch so sehr gut zu verstehen. Umso skeptischer ist Kaji, als er erfährt, dass Nagi auch noch in einem Nachtclub arbeitet, um sich eine Operation zur Frau leisten zu können. Das hat er nicht nötig, findet Kaji und versucht Nagi davon zu überzeugen…
Diese Geschichte und weitere Kurzgeschichten finden sich in diesem Einzelband wieder. An sich finde ich Geschichten über eine homosexuelle Liebe nicht schlimm, aber der Mangaka hat mir mit so vielen Übertreibungen um sich geworfen, dass ich einfach nur froh war, als die Geschichte vorbei war. Da haben wir sehr kindliche Ansichten, überdramatisierte Begegnungen. Das ist nicht meins. Außerdem sind die Zeichnungen in dem Manga entgegen dem detaillierten Cover recht billig gemacht und nehmen so dem Betrachter den Spaß. Da sich die Hauptgeschichte den Platz mit weiteren Kurzgeschichten teilen muss, fehlt es hier an Details und die Geschichten sind allesamt sehr sprunghaft und wirken dadurch sehr wirr. Das ist schade und hätte meiner Meinung nach besser gestaltet werden können. Etwas mehr Ernsthaftigkeit hätte der Glaubwürdigkeit der Geschichte nicht geschadet.
Fazit:
Konnte mich leider allein schon wegen der schlechten Zeichenqualität nicht begeistern. Schade.
Lui crede che l'unico modo per riuscire ad amare un uomo sia quello di operarsi per avere un seno. Poi conosce Lui^2 che gli dice: «No, non operarti: sei bellissimo così!».
I due s'innamorano in tre pagine, Lui cambia idea ma Lui^2 non si decide ad andare oltre il bacio.
Non è una storia: sembra essere un insieme di stereotipi un po' datati.
Neanche le altre storie si salvano. Forse solo quella che si intitola Il mio primo amore, con un tocco di pessimismo che non sempre si trova nei manga.
Tratto molto sporco se paragonato ad altre mangaka.
Na verdade eu já tinha lido esse mangá antes, mas como não anotei em lugar nenhum, acabei lendo inteiro de novo. E assim como na primeira vez, eu gostei muito! Achei o casal fofo e a história bonitinha, tirando a questão
Quanto às one-shots no final, gostei de todas também, apesar de uma delas ter um fim triste. No geral, um bom mangá!
Não funcionou muito para mim esse mangá, a história principal me deixou bem confusa e bem pouco interessada nos personagens.
Maaasss, para não dizer que foi tudo ruim, gostei das duas outras histórias, achei que elas foram melhor elaboradas, os personagens me agradaram bem mais e as narrativas também.
Talvez não fosse o melhor momento para lê-lo também, não sei. Ou só esperei muito dele.
Mas espero que você que leia se divirta e curta ;)
The star of this one is actually a duo of shorter stories at the end - On My First Love 1 and 2 which tells the friendship turned "one-sided" feelings of love between two high school boys - a popular happy go lucky guy named Kamota and a studious book lover named Torii. 1 & 2 are told from either perspective as they meet again at a high school reunion and reflect on their feelings.
Croquis, na verdade, é uma coletânea de histórias. A que dá nome ao volume ocupa mais da metade das páginas, mas, na minha opinião, é a mais fraca. O personagem principal quer se tornar uma mulher trans simplesmente por que como um garoto gay ele não consegue namorado. No momento em que ele consegue um (que não apoia a decisão dele de colocar seios), ele, simplesmente, desiste. Mais sem opinião própria e personalidade que isso impossível. Acho até um pouco de desserviço com a comunidade trans. Mas a história de ‘Do meu primeiro amor’ me pegou de jeito! É uma história mais dramática e com um final agridoce, mas é linda! Eu recomendaria ler esse volume só pelos dois capítulos dessa história. A terceira história do volume é melhor do que a ‘Croquis’, mas ainda sim foi bem qualquer coisa.
I wasn't too crazy about the main storyline involving Nagi and Kaji, but the storylines with Tori and Kamota ("Of My First Love") and Sei and Daiki ("Wish On a Star") were heartbreaking and sweet. Those two brief stories made the entire book in my opinion.
Jesus… um lixo é melhor do que isso. Só dei 2 estrelas porque tem umas cenas eróticas que eu achei engraçadas. Mas sério esse manga é um desserviço. Burn it