Overall rating: 2.25/5 stars
I read this because some of my students are reading this for a book club and I wanted to check out the type of advice it gives since I also host financial literacy lessons for my students. This started out okay with some basic info on the importance of financial literacy and the necessity of emergency funds and the like, but there became just too many things that didn't set well with me as I read on. To be fair, I think this is a decent enough book for young adults despite it being generally undetailed and elementary. However, there were a few things in here that are not my approach to finances and not what I would teach the average student.
Firstly, I can appreciate the insights on budgeting and how it can be an important tool for people who struggle with overspending. However, I felt the description does not align with how I view budgets. This book seemed to approach them as a limiting factor, even quoting that the most important part of having a budget is not going over it. Yes, one must absolutely know their fixed costs and ensure they have the funds to pay them, but I prefer to think of money in terms of freedom, not limitation. Ramit Sethi has a great take on "budgets" but he calls them conscious spending plans and states that you should be aware of where your money is going, but don't let certain pre-set categories limit you from spending your money as you wish. I also think tracking every dollar sets them up to, again, focus on the wrong things when their vision is so granular. I'd hate for young adults to start their money journey with feelings of restriction instead of opportunity.
Secondly, it mentions that credit cards should be used only when absolutely necessary. This directly negates what I teach students about building credit and responsible credit use. They can be educated on the risks of credit card debt but also encouraged to use credit cards to their benefit. I think this book missed a big chunk of knowledge here.
My next point is kind of weird, but it suggested using royalty earnings as an additional stream of income. I know that's a real thing, but what young adult just starting in the personal finance world is parlaying in royalties?
My last concern is how this book addressed investing. I'm not sure if this was intended, but there's a little bit of negative language around 401k and the S&P 500 specifically. If I didn't know better as a beginner I'd think I shouldn't be investing in those, but again, that's not the case.
Overall this was okay but not a resource I'd readily recommend to young adults. I feel there are much better sources I'd direct them to instead (Ramit Sethi, Tori Dunlap, & Bogleheads to name a few).