X-Men from the '90s, post-Claremont, gets a lot of grief. And I must admit that I stopped reading it originally in that era. Still, this isn't bad at all. You could certainly argue that Lobdell and Nicieza don't have any original voice. They're mimicking Claremont's storytelling, and they're not as good at it. Nonetheless, this volume shows off why Claremont's X-Men was good. It's got more characterization and down-time than fighting and super heroics. It flirts with continuity while introducing new ideas as well. In general, it's well worth reading, even if it's not directly comparable to the very high-quality writing of more recent authors like Brubaker, Carey, and Fraction.
Intros (Prime, UXM 322). The Prime issue is a somewhat delightful walk through the entire X-Men universe circa 1995, while Uncanny X-Men #322 is classic X-Men, full of subplots and characters. I was surprised to see Onslaught make his first appearance immediately after the Age of Apocalypse [7/10].
Avalon (XM 42-44). I like this continued movement of the Acolytes plot, with the only deficit being the mindless fighting that fills the middle issue. Still, it's a nice spotlight for Cyclops and Phoenix, and a nice end for Avalon [6+/10].
Gene Nation (UXM 323-325). In the early issues of this sequence, I liked the appearance of a new villain for the X-Men. Then in the final issue I really liked the connections to old continuity (even if the climax is a bit repetitive). It made it very appropriate for an anniversary issue. The subplot involving Bobby and Rogue that runs through these issues is also quite good [7/10].
Annual '95. The main story, focusing on Mr. Sinister and the Heir of Apocalypse is a nice character bit for Sinister that also nicely builds on continuity, but it also makes you realize why some people feel the X-mythos is impenetrable [6+/10]. The short story about the romance between Psylocke and Angel is overwritten at times, but overall is a nice view into their lives [6+/10].
Rogue & Gambit (XM 45). This other anniversary issue is a great look at two of the '90s most popular X-Men characters. We get strong characterization for both of them and delightful new mysteries about Gambit [7+/10].
Sabretooth (UXM 326). This issue is great not just for how it demonstrates Sabretooth's potentially changing nature, but also for how it shows the darkness within Gambit, in a way much more visceral than the hints of recent issues [7+/10].
X-Men Unlimited (8). The final story is a nice little look at the X-Men from the outside, but also a little bit After-School Special.