In this innovative fusion of practice and criticism, Jeremy Scott shows how insights from stylistics can enrich the craft of creative writing. Focusing on crucial methodological issues that confront the practicing writer, Creative Writing and - Introduces key topics from stylistics - Provides in-depth analysis of a wide range of writing examples - Includes practical exercises to help develop creative writing skills Clear and accessible, this invaluable guide will give both students and writers a greater critical awareness of the creative possibilities of language.
This text has good ideas, but you have to wade through the academic speak to get there. Inaccessible to younger readers, I would have completed tossed this text in my younger academic days. I find it appalling that someone can write a textbook about writing and use an eight-line sentence that could essentially have driven home the same point in six words. Only read this book if you have to (e.g. for a class).
Some good information but needlessly complicated. He kept clarifying himself. "That is to say..." It would be easier to read if he wrote it clearly once and moved on.
This was a great text book and really applicable to the course I read it for, which is surprisingly rare. I am a linguist so I appreciated the author's linguistic approach, but found the writing a bit inaccessible and pretentious at points.
My textbook for a class. I finished reading it. But now I have to do some exercises, the most important one is writing out my. entire plot, because I have three drafts of this book, and seeing if I want to change the structure. I will probably do more on who sees and who tells, too. There is a lot of language in this book that is just new except to those getting a masters or PhD and of course that is confusing but in this revised and expanded edition, much of that is cleared up. This is one of those books where LITERALLY, you are going to find "God in the Details." The very tiny ones. This is about knowing what you are doing as you write, sentence by sentence, with serious intent, and becoming nuanced and detailed in your own thinking as you write. In fact, you are going to do as much thinking as writing.
The other day I read where the two geniuses who wrote BIG MATH, a book that just came out ended up writing the book four times. I am going to be writing my book four times or MORE. Because I already have written it three times. I know it is not right. What I came to understand in this book and by reading some of the books suggested in another book, Meander, Spiral, Explode IS on form and how to anchor time changes. I am very interested in time and memory and how our geography in our lives creates their own conflicts and tensions. You have to learn how to shift from memory to present to past, to creation of history by more than just a concrete object, — by sensory detail. I cannot do that well enough to suit me.
Also, this teaches much about what you lose in writing a big novel in present tense, things I have never thought about previouslly to reading this book. I have heard other authors talk about it. I heard it in a workshop. It's not that you can't use it. It's what kind of narratives work best for that tense. Not just any story does. Also, nonlinear novels do not work well for just any story, too. This book tells you why in the little details. That is, if you make the imaginative leap of seeing the big picture. That's hard too. Writing a novel is not really a democracy, it is an neurotic act of self indulgence in my mind, to spend most of lives creating other people, other worlds, a narrative, the center of story, and what for? Why are we doing this? What does language teach us. How is language so damn powerful?
I am a big rewriter. I like to play. Because process is everything for me. The act of doing the writing. Like the act of painting. Sure I want to sell a book and have a reader, but that is not my first motivation. Perhaps one does that when they are younger and very hungry for validation. I don't know. This book is not about that but it shows you how to write things differently, to see how the process works. That is what this creative approach is all about. And if you don't love to play and rewrite and throw things away and create more and more, then the book is not for you. It is definitely not. I gave this book 5 stars, not because it was the best book I have ever read on writing. Believe it or not, that is a book by Donald Maass —The Emotional Craft of Fiction: How to Write the Story Beneath the Surface, where I did every freaking exercise and transformed myself in a better writer. That said, I learned over a dozen new things reading this book that I had not thought seriously about, little details, which all added up to how I look at my own work. There are many ways, and I learned that reading this book. After I do a few exercises, I know I am going to be pleased. Writers build tool boxes to write with, just like I built skills and tools to paint with over the years. Reading good books and looking at them through the lens of books like this and many others AND THEN PRACTICING is where writers learn to be good writers. I did not say great. I said good. This is a good book.
A great resource, but almost impenetrable because of the writer's unnecessarily complicated writing style. If you believe that most great writers are great by instinct, reading this book is like taking a trip inside the sausage factory. This book's premise is that, like an aspiring artist, an aspiring writer can learn and use the stylistic tools of the trade (character development, narrative structure, figurative language, etc.) with practice and an academic understanding of what she is doing. Who am I to dissuade anyone from his beliefs?
Incredible. Scott brings linguistics and psychology into many techniques commonly discussed in creative writing in a way that is nuanced and original. He is also tongue in cheek and a clever narrator, which makes the text a joy to read despite the sophistication of the subject matter. I loved this and learned so much.
The pretentious academia speak is hard to navigate. Although it provides a lot of good ideas and key vocabulary for the writer, it's absolutely inaccessible for most readers.
This book is a fantastic source for those looking for the advanced fundamentals of writing. It is very difficult to understand if you are just starting out in the literary world, and the author goes off on many tangents that make it difficult to keep track of what he's really saying. I honestly wish this book was not the textbook of choice by my most recent instructor.
Grad school theory textbook. A bit pedantic and full of himself, but overall a good look into writing and stylistics. I don't recommend it unless you're really into writing.