Actual rating: 4.5 stars
“Every molecule in my body screams that you are dangerous and that I shouldn’t trust you, but every time I look at you, I forget all logic and hope that you can’t hear my heart beating out of my chest. I fall into your eyes and swear that I catch a glimpse of your soul. You sound like an angel when you speak. You consume my thoughts. I forget to eat because I day dream about your kiss,”
I said and brushed her hair out of her face. “I’m going to tell you something I’ve never told a girl before. I’ve fallen hard—and not just down a rabbit hole.”
You know what, I never expected to like this book this much. I got so frustrated with it at first that I actually thinked twice about continuing with the story. I'm lucky that I still read it though. This book may have had such a slow start but eventually, everything got better.
The Death of a Mad Hatter is a retelling of the classic Alice in Wonderland by Lewis Caroll, just with a more modern and gothic twist to it. Following the king's death, the story revolves around a series of prophecies: the Bleeding Hearts Prophecy, the Backwards Wanderer Prophecy and the Madmen's Prophecy. All of these somehow state or predict what was bound to happen before the reign of terror ends, and what they had to do, for the Queen of Hearts to fall. However, this book does not only take place in Wonderland. The setting of the story basically switches back and forth from one realm to the other, showing how the story interconnects somehow with the life of a senior high school student-who just might be the one they've all been waiting for.
I know what you're thinking. "Prophecies! Ugh, not again. What a cliche." or even, "Pfft, prophecies. Why can't people get over that kind of shit?" Well yes, yes, I know. That's exactly what went through my mind at first. I was so sick and tired of this "chosen one" crap that I didn't know if I could even handle reading a book that contained not only one prophecy but three or more.
BUT let me tell you this, dear friends. I loved how this book turned out, prophecies and chosen ones and all. In the end, I loved how well thought out everything was. All three prophecies plagued my head with questions but everything was eventually made clear. The plot was amazing, and all those predictions also blended well with the storyline.
The world-building was also extraordinary. Sarah J. Pepper managed to take inspiration in Caroll's masterpiece and breathe new life into it. The way she revived Wonderland and all its creatures truly captured me. Not only did she show the readers very vivid images of that very strange realm, she also integrated a more twisted personality to each of the creatures of Wonderland. I found that very cool.
I also loved the character development and romance in the story. I liked Alice Mae's weirdness and also how Riley was that typical teenage guy, going after the hottest girl in school. It was nice having a little sense of ordinariness. I also loved how both of them went from childishly fighting each other to fighting for each other in the end.
Oh, and the writing is also special. It has this dark and gloomy, but at the same time flowery feel to it. I don't really know how to explain it, so I'll show you some of my favorite quotes instead.
""Have you ever wondered why you get a tummy ache after eating a lot of candy?”
He didn’t wait for a reply. “Because too much of a good thing is actually a bad thing.""
"“We all make thousands of wrong choices in life. What matters is what you learn from them,”
I said and kissed her."
Here's my favorite, next to the very first one I quoted.
"Do you believe in ghosts?”
“I believe that some people are haunted,”
I said. “I don’t believe that a misty substance manifests to scare people. But people can be haunted by their past, their family, their upbringing, their future or any number of things.”"
Well, now I think you get my point. Sarah J. Pepper's writing style is beautiful.
Overall, I'm giving this book 4 and a half stars. Almost perfect, but not quite. It just had a rough start, that's all. I should've given it 5 stars otherwise.