Much of Karl Marx's most important work came out of his critique of other thinkers, including many socialists who differed significantly in their conceptions of socialism. The fourth volume in Hal Draper's series looks at these critiques to illuminate what Marx's socialism was, as well as what it was not. Some of these debates are well-known elements in Marx's work, such as his writings on the anarchists Proudhon and Bakunin. Others are less familiar, such as the writings on "Bismarckian socialism" and "Boulangism," but promise to become better known and understood with Draper's exposition. He also discusses the more general ideological tendencies of "utopian" and "sentimental" socialisms, which took various forms and were ingredients in many different socialist movements.
Hal Draper (born Harold Dubinsky) was an American socialist activist and author who played a significant role in the Berkeley, California Free Speech Movement. He is known for his extensive scholarship on the history and meaning of the thought of Karl Marx.
Draper was a lifelong advocate of what he called "socialism from below", self-emancipation by the working class, in opposition to capitalism and Stalinist bureaucracy, both of which, he held, practiced domination from above. He was one of the creators of the Third Camp tradition, a form ("the form", according to its adherents) of Marxist socialism.
This book is valuable mainly as a corrective, a setting the record straight about what made Marx and Engels different from those around them, in contrast to later myths (ex: that they were statists). And, in this respect it’s valuable.
Besides that, this book raises some interesting historical facts and details which give a very different picture of Marx and Engels’ political careers, and what they were up against, especially within ‘their own’ organizations.
This book also makes Lassalle out to be a total egoist dickhead lmao.
However, besides that this book felt quite empty, and Draper tends to fixate on surface-level differences between these tendencies (ex: whether they believed that Bismarck would hail socialism for them) - which is a big downgrade from Volume 1, where I thought that his discussion of Hegelianism was quite easy to understand yet interesting.
I do think that the one practical area is the discussion of Boulanger: specifically, Engels insisted that socialists oppose both the populist wanna-be dictator and the alliance, in defense of the republic, with the liberals, and instead put forward their own candidate and go their own way. That feels relevant, although even from Drapers account it doesn’t seem like Engels had any actual idea of how to do that…
What you mean socialism is not a universal definition??? Um yeah, what do you think Marx was doing? Just looking at the chapter heads makes a person politically more informed the next time some nutter claims "socialism."