This one, provided by the publisher through netgalley, was pleasant enough, but ultimately failed to really inspire much interest, which is always a bit disappointing.
What did I like?
- The plot was somewhat different. A heroine finally summons the courage to just live after years of repression and well-meaning, but overbearing, concern. She had a pretty rotten time of things, but remains much more than a shadow of herself, and this evolves quite nicely as the book progresses. The plot also takes place over a journey across Europe, which is hardly ever included in historical romances but really, was a very common occurrence during the time period.
- This was actually one of a series, but I didn't know that up-front, and honestly, it didn't minimize my enjoyment or ruin the book for me at all. It focused totally on the story at hand, not on the stories before or after, apart from one or two mentions which were needed to prod the plot along.
- The writing is fairly good. There's no ridiculously stupid errors, nobody doing really silly things, and no significant errors of historical accuracy (apart from referring to the King as "His Grace" instead of "His Majesty" - a Duke is referred to as "His Grace"... which is absolutely minimal, but it's a bit of an issue with me)
What didn't I like so much?
Well, the plot and the story are pretty decent, if formulaic, but really this summed up the whole book. The settings, the characters, even down to their physical appearances, were all far too similar to those I've read a hundred times before, and even though there was nothing offensive in this I find as a result it all felt a bit blah.
The hero is tall, big, dark and handsome, the heroine is all flashy green eyes and bright red hair and a gorgeous body (how often have I read that recently - I'm sure the genetic predisposition to green eyes/red hair in the general population isn't as high as all that..). She's suffered her way through an abusive marriage and is essentially dramatically over-protected by her brothers, but she's a strong person underneath all that, and they can't keep their hands off each other etc. etc. etc.
Now, this is just fine for an easy read on the beach, when you don't really want to have to concentrate too hard to keep track of the plot after over-indulging in the pina coladas the evening before, but for your average romance reader, who has read a few romances, there are similar books, with similar plots and more interesting bits than this one. It just came across as nothing special to me.
So 3 stars. I liked it, but nothing more.