So this is a graphic novel I got from my local library and had never heard anything about before borrowing it. I was intrigued by the artwork, but didn't have a clue what the book itself was all about. I ended up really enjoying the storyline and the first artist's work, but the second artist's drawing style didn't really 'click' with me as much and I found I liked the last sections with that art style less sadly.
This is the story of Joe Fitzgerald who is a man with a past. As you read through the graphic novel you start to unravel the various problems that Joe has not only faced in his past involving death, despair, heaven and hell, but continues to face in his present. He's a doomed man, doomed to live alone, and doomed to work for angels in exchange for a 5minute visit to his lover every time he dies (yeah, he dies and comes back a lot!).
I loved the idea that angels and demons were involved in this storyline because it meant that I not only found myself hooked pretty quickly (religion, particularly with supernatural angels and demons, is something I find fascinating in stories) but also sucked into the complications of Joe's life and world. He really doesn't have it easy and as you go further through you discover more about him and how he came to be the way he is and mixed up with the supernatural creatures who haunt him.
In terms of the story, this was fab. I had some moments where I was LOVING seeing where it was going and wondering about what he could do next. It's certainly a bit brutal at times, maybe more than necessary, but it's a dark and gritty kind of story and it's told very, very well.
As for the artwork I enjoyed seeing Ben Templesmith's artwork a lot more than I did that of C. P. Smith. Whilst Templesmith did the first #4 issues Smith finished up issue #5 & #6 and I have to say it was a disappointment to lose the rugged, scratchy and visually dark style I was enjoying so much from Templesmith. I felt like the first style worked well with the story and although I don't always love a more scratchy art style, this one was with good reason and fitted the rugged character of Joe.
The second art style was far more 'computer generated' in style and whilst I appreciate that it is a bit clearer, it also makes the character look totally different and far worse in my opinion. I understand that we're venturing to a new part of the worlds in these issues, but even so I really disliked the art work and it, sadly, made the writing suffer a bit too as I couldn't help but to be distracted by the lesser quality and clunky ugliness of the second art style.
I think if I can find out that Templesmith does more of Volume 2 then I would certainly pick it up because I did like the story a lot, but if it's all Smith's work then sadly I'm not so interested. This had a fabulous potential and started out so strong making me think it could have been at least a 4* read, but sadly it ended up simply getting a 3.5* which is mostly due to the art shift. I'd love to hear your thoughts :)