SUMMARY
At the start of the book, we follow three plotlines, the most important of which concerns Captain Alton Blackwell in Afghanistan, who has been injured in a bomb blast that has ended his chosen career. The other two plots are liberally interspersed like intermissions in Alton’s story, and by the end of the book, these three plotlines converge into a single unit, just in time for the Big Reveal.
We were expecting a typical war novel, but it surprised us. It is actually a mystery and thriller, one which just happened to be set in the Middle East: Alton matches wits with various terrorists and ends their machinations to kill people. We liked this combination of genres, and the emphasis on strategy rather than violence and the “whodunit” qualities of this book made for an enjoyable read. However, the first half of the book itself reads more like a series of interrelated short stories, and it shifts gears in the middle, changing the scene from Afghanistan to the United States. Consequently the mood shifts too, becoming far less War Novel and far more Mystery. Fortunately for the reader, the cast of characters remains the same, and they are all likeable and fun to read, all the way to the end.
THE GOOD...
1) Beautiful simplicity
Looking back, the best thing about this novel is its simplicity. This author has obviously worked very hard on honing his writing style, and we could definitely appreciate it. The writing flows wonderfully and it is possible to read whole paragraphs without having to pause to digest, simply because it connects with the reader so readily. It was a pleasure to read something with so little effort on our part. The book works to simplify things to only the most important elements, giving the reader only what we need, and allowing our own imaginations to make up the rest. It was nice to be trusted by the author in this way.
2) Great sense of the “little moments”
There is action in this story--the beginning contains a bomb, for example--but one aspect that we really enjoyed was the little “slice of life” moments woven throughout. These often contained wonderful nuggets of understated emotional truths. In discreet ways the author tells us everything we need to know about these characters’ emotional states, without pulling out a long list of complicated adjectives and metaphors to explain things. There was a lot of space to breathe in this story, and it has a really good sense of pacing, allowing us to connect with the characters in-between the action scenes. As a result, we gave a damn about them whenever they were in danger.
3) Likeable characters
There are a couple dozen characters in here, and the author does a fine job of fleshing them out. Of course, the most 3D character is the hero, Alton Blackwell, with whom we spend most of the time and from whose head we get the most thoughts. Alton was a genuinely likeable guy, altruistic to the core. It’s hard not to root for him whenever he faces adversity. He’s also competent, which is a must for a character in a mystery novel, and which further gives us another reason to like him. His philosophy of “regret avoidance” was great, because giving that to his character added an even further level of depth and helped explain his actions throughout the story. He wasn’t perfect, but was likeable all the more for that.
4) Awesome ending
Sorry. Can’t tell you much, because Spoilers. But we can say that it has a cool ending. It hit all the right notes and left us satisfied.
THE BAD...
1) Could use some more connection at the beginning
At the start of the story, we are introduced to three separate plotlines: a wounded soldier, a colonel who is frustrated by the orders he receives from his NSA contact, and a pharmaceutical company working on a drug. Although these stories eventually became woven together, at the beginning we were hard pressed to see any connection between them. We cared most about Alton, so the other two plots could easily have become annoying distractions. Fortunately, the author seemed to anticipate this, because the story never lingered on them. Still, parts of us wonder if the other two plots couldn’t be cut entirely. In any case, it is what it is, and maybe other readers will like seeing the three plots converge, although we found it a little unnecessary. We would have been happy following Alton all along.
2) Meandering plot
We liked watching Alton and his buddies. But, rather than one whole, complete story with a couple subplots thrown in, this book felt more like a sequence of interrelated short stories. It felt realistic, in the sense that we felt as though we were watching a real person's life, one episode at a time (after all, most people's lives work more like short stories rather than major arcs). We also liked to shift gears every so often, because we don't think that any of these incidents could have been stretched out into a full story. We just wish that the book could have been one or the other: either be a chronological sequence of short stories, or be a full book with a singular plot. We prefer the short story option ourselves, because that makes the most sense.
THE BIZARRE...
1) “Don’t forget your Beretta. There’s a good chance we’ll need it.”
Character A tells Character B to bring his Beretta twice, each time at the end of a chapter. We suppose that it’s meant to be foreboding, in the sense that the characters expect there will be danger and shooting in the future. However, the second time it appears, it cannot be anything but hilarious. We assume this is only a mistake on the author’s part to include this twice, but that does not abate our humor any. It was fun to see a mistake like this in an otherwise well-polished text. Because we’re quirky that way.
For that matter, we also wondered a little bit about the use of guns in the story. These characters are former military personnel, and one is now an FBI agent. Surely they’re both well versed in firearms. And, knowing that there are nasty people out there who want to kill them, surely they would both have guns? Just, you know, for safety’s sake? The bad guys seem to assume that they have guns. Because it makes sense that they would. Except... really, they don’t. Oops. Silly, foolish characters, don’t you realize this has become an action movie? Break out the firepower already!
3) The grapes are listening.
There are little grapes with bugs/listening devices planted in them. This was a fun little detail and we liked it a lot. Keep your eye on the grapes because they're important.
...AND THE VERDICT:
This book is GOOD.
We recommend this book to people who like mysteries, people who want a quick and fun read, and also would recommend it to parents who are looking for something that their sons could enjoy reading. Reading is fun and a book like this definitely demonstrates that sort of thing to a young reader. The heroes are all likeable and relatable, and it’s easy to root for them and cheer whenever they succeed in something. The plot is fast-paced and the reader never feels bored. There are no problems with the prose that make you work hard to understand what’s being said. All in all, this story was a fun yarn, and we're glad we read it.