I found this garish looking paperback anthology buried in the basement of a local Chicago bookstore, and I almost passed it by, as I already had a big stack of horror fiction I planned on buying. I'm glad I didn't, as there were some absolute gems in here I probably never would have come across otherwise.
Editor Hugh Lamb decided to try and bring more exposure to lost or forgotten ghost/strange stories from authors both well-known and not, mostly from the early 20th century, and it's surprising to me that some of these stories are not considered classics of the genre. While most all are worth reading, here are the four that rose above the rest for me:
"Celui-la" by Eleanor Scott, an atmospheric slow-burner that brings to mind M.R. James' "Oh Whistle and I'll Come to You, My Lad," in that a man staying in a small coastal village in Brittany comes across "a sinister, mysterious object" on the beach that, once found, brings forth an ancient evil;
"Marjorie's On Starlight" by Charles Birkin, whose non-supernatural contes cruels are upsetting and depressing enough to me that I can only read him in extremely small doses, about a 10 year-old girl who loves nothing better than to torment her adopted sister, and goes perhaps too far one day while they're out riding horses. Very disturbing;
"The Wishing Well," by E.F. Benson, an excellent, sad story of witchcraft and curses that I can't believe I've not come across yet, as I went on a Benson binge not too long ago after scoring, and loving, his Horror Horn and Other Stories paperback from the mid-70s. Definitely top-notch horror here;
and, without a doubt my favorite, L.A. Lewis' "The Child," a truly forgotten tale that should be a classic that all horror fans know, but unfortunately isn't, about a traveler who decides to stop and stay at an old, woodsy English village, where there's a local legend about a woman who murdered her children and still haunts the surrounding woods, and who is blamed for the farm animals that frequently go missing. The man investigates and finds the truth much more horrible than anyone could have ever imagined. Truly a chilling story.
There are no duds here, though the flowery language of some of the earlier-written stories would occasionally cause my eyelids to weigh ten pounds if I was reading late at night, but overall this was a great find filled with stories that should be more well-known than they are. Worth getting if you come across it for a reasonable price.
4.0 Stars