What do you think?
Rate this book
Making The Cut
"Tidak apa-apa jika kamu takut. Saat dirimu ketakutan, serahkan tanggung jawab pada yang lain. Mintalah pertolongan. Tidak ada yang lebih buruk dari seorang dokter yang lebih mementingkan egonya di atas keselamatan pasien”.
Seorang dokter muda yang melakukan pembedahan pertamanya dan diejek oleh gurunya. Seorang wanita tua diselamatkan dari kematian, sedangkan dia tidak ingin hidup lebih lama lagi. Seorang dokter bedah terkenal mengalami stres akibat tumor otak yang ganas. Seorang ibu dari seorang anak penderita leukimia yang mulai merasa putus asa …
Dalam memoar yang ditulis dengan detial dan indah ini, Mohamed Khadra menceritakan kisah-kisah dari kehidupannya sebagai seorang dokter bedah, dari tahun-tahun menjalani pelatihan melelahkan sampai malam-malam menguras tenaga untuk memenuhi panggilan tugas. Dia mengenang kembali para dokter dan pasien yang telah membentuk kariernya: keberanian, kesedihan, kekaguman, dan kebencian yang telah berlalu di bawah pisau operasinya: dan kehidupan para dokter yang hancur, terkalahkan oleh tekanan dari pekerjaannya.
Seorang dokter muda yang melakukan pembedahan pertamanya dan diejek oleh gurunya. Seorang wanita tua diselamatkan dari kematian, sedangkan dia tidak ingin hidup lebih lama lagi. Seorang dokter bedah terkenal mengalami stres akibat tumor otak yang ganas. Seorang ibu dari seorang anak penderita leukimia yang mulai merasa putus asa …
Dalam memoar yang ditulis dengan detial dan indah ini, Mohamed Khadra menceritakan kisah-kisah dari kehidupannya sebagai seorang dokter bedah, dari tahun-tahun menjalani pelatihan melelahkan sampai malam-malam menguras tenaga untuk memenuhi panggilan tugas. Dia mengenang kembali para dokter dan pasien yang telah membentuk kariernya: keberanian, kesedihan, kekaguman, dan kebencian yang telah berlalu di bawah pisau operasinya: dan kehidupan para dokter yang hancur, terkalahkan oleh tekanan dari pekerjaannya.
474 pages, Paperback
First published October 1, 2009
8 people are currently reading
178 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews
September 12, 2016
I understand what others meant now by the author being arrogant. He certainly does have a really arrogant way of writing and his narcissism really turned me off. Also he made a lot of niggling misogynistic and transphobic comments- he really does sound like an old fogey and this really grated on me the entire book. I like to read surgical/medical memoirs as I am a medical student but if I compare this book to something by someone who has had similar experiences (immigrant born to poor parents becomes amazing surgeon and then writes memoir about it) such as Atul Gawande, it really doesn't compare. Atul Gawande's voice as a writer doesn't come across as sexist and narcissistic, this one does and it bothered me too much to really enjoy the stories the author was telling.
July 29, 2011
Great book, gives a insight into what is required by those who choose this path, and the awful events that occur around him at times.
Fantastic insight into why our health system is failing in parts, and I can't agree more with his views on the nursing profession.
(which is why I want to leave it)
Fantastic insight into why our health system is failing in parts, and I can't agree more with his views on the nursing profession.
(which is why I want to leave it)
February 3, 2012
Excellent book, written with authority and ability. Khadra covers a multiple of topics and does it well, even if you may have differing views to his. I also admire his ability to point out flaws in the system that got him to where he was, something that does not always occur from the top. Well presented and well read.
February 2, 2009
I think I can cross surgical specialisation off my list too. Very depressing read from my point of view about the hours and commitment. Appears to be a LOT of pain for incommensurate gain, but that's probably just me being lazy. Having said that, I'm not sure it was so much the hours that frightened me off but the end product; the sort of people that are attracted to surgery (or maybe it's what happens to you after the training process) are unappealing.
Having said that, the book was well written and very easy to read - I felt I had a good sense of the author's personality and style as well as his journey/growth as a person through the somewhat chronological ordering of the book.
Having said that, the book was well written and very easy to read - I felt I had a good sense of the author's personality and style as well as his journey/growth as a person through the somewhat chronological ordering of the book.
October 13, 2017
After finishing this book, I realized I liked Khadra's stories as much as I disliked his personality. This is an honest, gritty account of personal sacrifices and the toll a surgical career takes. It is a collection of Khadra's memorable cases, and the evolution of his surgical career as each patient and life milestone shapes him. I appreciated the unapologetically raw narrative that left a bad taste in my mouth.
December 14, 2011
Harrowing, appalling, fascinating, riveting account of the work of a surgeon in the underfunded, over-burdened, Australian public health system. Dr Khadra's philosophical, poetic and humanitarian insights are awe-inspiring. (I also intend never to set foot in a hospital again, God willing!)
September 18, 2013
Fascinating book, but I think I will wrap myself in cotton wool so I can avoid doctors for the rest of my life :) I wouldn't read it if you're stuck in hospital, but if you're healthy, it's an interesting read.
January 16, 2016
Riveting and enlightening.
War stories from becoming and being a surgeon and stories of his patients. This is a book you cannot put down, it is so compelling. Also I learned a lot about what makes surgeons the way they are.
War stories from becoming and being a surgeon and stories of his patients. This is a book you cannot put down, it is so compelling. Also I learned a lot about what makes surgeons the way they are.
November 27, 2024
Really enjoyed this book. Realistic, poignant and even spiritual at times.
An insight into the Australian medical and surgical hospital system as well as a humble yet accomplished surgeon.
Great read.
An insight into the Australian medical and surgical hospital system as well as a humble yet accomplished surgeon.
Great read.
December 5, 2016
When i saw this book I knew I had to read it. After all I am a Medical Secretary and I love a few good memoirs. I really liked this book because, although following a sequence, it was written in short stories about the patients- meaning you could pick it on a whim and not have to think too much about story progression.
This book was sad, educational and entertaining all at the same time. It gave a little insight in various aspects of a surgeons life that many people know very little about. Not only was the subject matter very good, this guy is a good writer and I found it very readable. The only reason I did not give it 5 stars was because I found the second half a bit crude and I did not think it was all necessary. Otherwise a good read that makes you think about issues you might not have otherwise thought about in a way you never would have before.
This book was sad, educational and entertaining all at the same time. It gave a little insight in various aspects of a surgeons life that many people know very little about. Not only was the subject matter very good, this guy is a good writer and I found it very readable. The only reason I did not give it 5 stars was because I found the second half a bit crude and I did not think it was all necessary. Otherwise a good read that makes you think about issues you might not have otherwise thought about in a way you never would have before.
April 24, 2008
Mediocre with occasional moments of luminous clarity. Medicine is portrayed as terrifying and author is much too scarily superior for his success story to be of any reassurance.
February 13, 2024
Fantastic, should be read by all budding medical professionals- nurses, drs, carers alike.
The system we have is broken.
Florence would be rolling in her grave, the lack of care given to patients is horrifying, and the excuse is money or computers or rules.
The first and foremost rule is 'do not harm', the lack of care by modern day medicos (drs & nurses) leaves much to be desired, and will inevitably do harm.
Professor Khadra writes in a very easy way, describing his time as a surgeon the issues he faced and how he managed to survive what he knows to be wrong.
The system we have is broken.
Florence would be rolling in her grave, the lack of care given to patients is horrifying, and the excuse is money or computers or rules.
The first and foremost rule is 'do not harm', the lack of care by modern day medicos (drs & nurses) leaves much to be desired, and will inevitably do harm.
Professor Khadra writes in a very easy way, describing his time as a surgeon the issues he faced and how he managed to survive what he knows to be wrong.
September 27, 2022
Really interesting insight into a surgical career, particularly one who was an immigrant to our country and seemingly had to work even harder to succeed. I really enjoyed it and it was easy to read and comprehend.
March 29, 2021
The book starts with early years experience and matures. An honest story of self...
BTW I read the translation of the book in Marathi ..
BTW I read the translation of the book in Marathi ..
June 17, 2021
Really interesting & well written.
September 25, 2023
Buku yang sangat berharga untuk lebih mendalami sisi manusiawi seorang dokter bedah, hanya saja saya jadi parno membacanya
August 5, 2024
Engaging because of its honesty
October 12, 2025
"Sometimes the most humane course is to allow nature to deal with its own."
August 7, 2023
Dr. Mohammed Khadra's 'Making The Cut' is a tour de force, providing an unflinching view into the life of a surgeon, intricately weaving themes of race, career choices, and the daunting reality of the medical profession. As a nascent medical student, the book has served as an invaluable guide, enriching my understanding of the path I have chosen to undertake.
'Making The Cut' uncovers the harsh realities surgeons face and highlights the courage required to surmount the challenges within this demanding profession. The narrative delves deep into Khadra's personal struggles, revealing the immense obstacles he confronted due to racial prejudices. These profoundly personal experiences offer a poignant reminder of the enduring presence of discrimination, even in sectors as critical as healthcare.
The book also illuminates the career choices that often shape a medical professional's life. Khadra's decision to leave a secure job in Sydney to work in a remote country town, for instance, provided insights into the sacrifices often required in the pursuit of a fulfilling medical career. His determination to serve communities with limited access to healthcare is a testament to the selflessness and resilience integral to the medical profession.
Moreover, as an aspiring doctor, 'Making The Cut' has granted me an unprecedented view into the life of a surgeon. It's a rare glimpse into the heart of the operating theatre; the challenges surgeons face, the choices they make, and the profound impact they have on their patients' lives. From the careful precision of each cut to the weighty responsibility inherent in each decision, Khadra's experiences have unveiled the fascinating, often daunting, world I am about to enter.
In essence, 'Making The Cut' stands as an illuminating guide, enriching my understanding and amplifying my passion for the medical field. Dr. Khadra's journey—rife with challenges, triumphs, and undeniable resilience—resonates profoundly, making it a must-read for anyone embarking on a journey in medicine. Indeed, this is a book that has secured its place among my all-time favourites.
'Making The Cut' uncovers the harsh realities surgeons face and highlights the courage required to surmount the challenges within this demanding profession. The narrative delves deep into Khadra's personal struggles, revealing the immense obstacles he confronted due to racial prejudices. These profoundly personal experiences offer a poignant reminder of the enduring presence of discrimination, even in sectors as critical as healthcare.
The book also illuminates the career choices that often shape a medical professional's life. Khadra's decision to leave a secure job in Sydney to work in a remote country town, for instance, provided insights into the sacrifices often required in the pursuit of a fulfilling medical career. His determination to serve communities with limited access to healthcare is a testament to the selflessness and resilience integral to the medical profession.
Moreover, as an aspiring doctor, 'Making The Cut' has granted me an unprecedented view into the life of a surgeon. It's a rare glimpse into the heart of the operating theatre; the challenges surgeons face, the choices they make, and the profound impact they have on their patients' lives. From the careful precision of each cut to the weighty responsibility inherent in each decision, Khadra's experiences have unveiled the fascinating, often daunting, world I am about to enter.
In essence, 'Making The Cut' stands as an illuminating guide, enriching my understanding and amplifying my passion for the medical field. Dr. Khadra's journey—rife with challenges, triumphs, and undeniable resilience—resonates profoundly, making it a must-read for anyone embarking on a journey in medicine. Indeed, this is a book that has secured its place among my all-time favourites.
June 8, 2021
I enjoyed the book I just had to try and ignore the author's arrogant and transphobic comments.
December 27, 2009
this book has two parts the training and the practice. ireally enjoyed reading espicaally the training part .i highly recommende it to every one in the medical field . yet, am sure any non medical can also enjoy it.it was one of my favourite books.
March 8, 2011
Great read, couldn't put it down.
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews