Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

War's Waste: Rehabilitation in World War I America

Rate this book
With US soldiers stationed around the world and engaged in multiple conflicts, Americans will be forced for the foreseeable future to come to terms with those permanently disabled in battle. At the moment, we accept rehabilitation as the proper social and cultural response to the wounded, swiftly returning injured combatants to their civilian lives. But this was not always the case, as Beth Linker reveals in her provocative new book, War’s Waste.

 

Linker explains how, before entering World War I, the United States sought a way to avoid the enormous cost of providing injured soldiers with pensions, which it had done since the Revolutionary War. Emboldened by their faith in the new social and medical sciences, reformers pushed rehabilitation as a means to “rebuild” disabled soldiers, relieving the nation of a monetary burden and easing the decision to enter the Great War. Linker’s narrative moves from the professional development of orthopedic surgeons and physical therapists to the curative workshops, or hospital spaces where disabled soldiers learned how to repair automobiles as well as their own artificial limbs. The story culminates in the postwar establishment of the Veterans Administration, one of the greatest legacies to come out of the First World War.

299 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 2011

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Beth Linker

4 books5 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
17 (45%)
4 stars
17 (45%)
3 stars
2 (5%)
2 stars
1 (2%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
Profile Image for Ashley.
501 reviews19 followers
March 7, 2012
As someone who tends to think that the American Civil War explains everything you could ever want to know about the United States, I really enjoyed War's Waste. Two issues stood out for me.

On a fundamental level, this book asks us to consider what a soldier is: workman or hero. At the turn of the last century, several different political and social factions had a stake in defining his role. If the nation considers soldiers "employees" in the military, then the government's obligations change. I appreciated the way that Linker drew connections between Progressive Era military/veterans' legislation and the emerging workmen's compensation laws (see 27-30). According to Linker, President Wilson wanted to "build a veterans' compensation system... that would treat soldiers more like laborers than valorized men of the military" (28). Reconfiguring the military as an employer, rather than a "calling," works on a few different levels. For one thing, it does not threaten the equation of work and manhood so important to the Progressives. Second, it allows the military to cover only those injuries that a soldier sustains "on the job" (although, as all the authors we've read point out, defining "on the job" when it comes to the military is incredibly difficult). Third, it implicitly sanctions criticizing veterans and their behavior in a way that the heroic construction precludes.

Second, Linker's text explains the historical roots of the amputee as "ideal" veteran. Although she could have gone into more detail, War's Waste highlights the traits that make for "good" and "bad" wounded soldiers. For our purposes, it might be interesting to consider the traits today that make for a "good" veteran and which ones make for a "bad" veteran. As I thought I about this in light of the Civil War and World War I history in Linker's book, I realized that little has changed since the Civil War. Visible wounds are still "easier" to process and a clear recovery, measured in easy metrics like employment and a heterosexual partnership, still indicate a "return to normal." Plus, it seems like American culture still has not really reconciled the soldier as employee or the soldier as hero. American public discourse still oscillates madly between valorizing the veteran and an obsession with the deficit/federal budget. It occurs to me that perhaps American culture still has not reconciled the soldiers' multiple roles.

Finally, a personal note: I used to live quite near Walter Reed (so near, in fact, that I could see it from my back window). Yet, the only time I ever really thought about the patients at Walter Reed was when I saw amputees around my neighborhood. I never saw amputee soldiers struggling, though. Whenever I saw men (and I almost always saw men) out and about, they were running, biking, or taking the bus (without a cane, wheelchair, or other aid). Obviously, this is because I only saw men well enough to leave the hospital. On another level, though, these men were quite literally "walking PR" for the military-- although I knew full well about the scandal(s) there, whenever I saw those guys I felt impressed--with them and with the military health complex. Linker refrains from saying outright that the military uses recovered soldiers as PR, but she certainly suggests that they make wars seem easier, emotionally and physically. TBI and PTSD just do not lend themselves to that kind of use. Ultimately, that may be a good thing.
Profile Image for Katie.
152 reviews5 followers
November 27, 2022
War's Waste is a fascinating, well written and researched text that examines the policies and ethos that framed disability, rehabilitation, and the American veterans' experience at the end of the Great War. Shifting away from the Civil War's method of veteran's pension (which, by the end of the 19th century, had cost the US government more than the actual war itself), Progressive-era reformers sought to rehabilitate disabled veteran's and return them to "functional" (i.e. working and not living off the dole) citizens - both as a means of decreasing overall war costs and to downplay the devastating and lasting impact the war had on the lives of returning soldiers. Examining early 20th century masculinity, capitalism, and progressive politics, Linker offers a critique of the proposed benefits of rehabilitation by politicians, medical doctors, and army officials versus the actual reality that disabled veterans faced while at Walter Reed (her case study), and how these ideas of "curing" disability neglect the humanity and lived experience of the disabled as means of creating more workers and/or soldiers.
Profile Image for Samuelle Saindon.
153 reviews17 followers
November 4, 2020
Read this for a history assignment! I won't write much since the assignment is basically a review for this book, but this was incredibly well written and well-researched.
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews