Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Historical Materialism #47

The Preobrazhensky Papers: Archival Documents and Materials: Volume I. 1886–1920

Rate this book
Historians generally recognise E.A. Preobrazhensky as the most famous Soviet economist of the 1920s. English-language readers know him best as author of The New Economics and co-author (with N.I. Bukharin ) of The ABC of Communism.

The documents in this volume, many newly discovered and almost all translated into English for the first time, reveal a Preobrazhensky previously unknown, whose interests ranged far beyond economics to include not only party debates and issues affecting the lives of workers and peasants, but also philosophy, world events, and Russian history, culture and politics. Including moments of triumph and tragedy, they tell an intimate story of political awakening and of commitment to socialist revolution as the path to human dignity.

920 pages, Paperback

First published June 10, 2014

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Yevgeni Preobrazhensky

9 books10 followers
Yevgeni Alekseyevich Preobrazhensky was an Old Bolshevik, an economist and a member of the Central Committee of the Bolshevik faction and, its successor, the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
4 (66%)
4 stars
0 (0%)
3 stars
2 (33%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review
Profile Image for Alexander.
23 reviews
November 17, 2026
I went in this book with the hope of better understanding the theoretical background of Preobrazhensky’s concept of socialist primitive accumulation (the idea that, to build a socialist economy, one needs to exploit/pull resources from other modes of production, akin to how capitalism ripped resources from the third world, the displacement of people, slavery, etc. - that is, primitive accumulation in Marx’s Capital) since it kinda lurks around the topic of Stalin and the Great Turn (i.e. was Stalin inspired by the economic left of the party?). Now I’m not sure if I worked towards that goal all that much, though the FINAL document does speak to the topic directly, and Document No.73 of Part II does arguably relate to the concept.

This book contains a few phenomenal autobiographical sections which I would really recommend: they give you a sense of what it was like to be an early Bolshevik, getting sent into exile, being hunted by police, etc., and there is one that speaks to the CC’s inner political life - describing the group arguing in Trotsky's apartment, since he is sick, huddled up in a blanket. These documents struck similar chords to Isaac Deutscher’s book Lenin’s Childhood, inasmuch as Preobrazhensky was also a child of civil-servant (here a priest) who did well in school, but became disillusioned.

Otherwise, though it takes a lot of time, you can try and derive conclusions about Preobrazhensky’s thought and its evolution - which to a certain extent is a proxy for the party’s.

While I didn’t rate this book very highly, that isn’t to say that this book is ‘bad’: it is after all a book of primary sources. Maybe it’s unfair to judge this book in terms of reading experience … but eh that’s what Goodreads is about for me.

——

From *my* reading I came away thinking that:

1) You can see the development within Preobrazhensky’s thought, undoubtedly connected with the party-life around him, of a certain kind of historical-functionalist cope: because the state is a mechanism of class rule, when ‘we’ made more libertarian demands in the past (ex: for the election of judges) this referred to capitalist society - but now that we live in our state this is unnecessary and actually harmful (for more see the sections in this book of The ABC’s of Communism). Likewise, democratic *structures* are really just not necessary, nor is a structural account of the Soviet state worthwhile, since if you consult the definition of our state it represents you, the worker, and all administrative excesses will disappear shortly. (Its interesting how public administration here is seen a simply the extension of the party’s will, or at other times simply a hostile mass of careerists, rather than a relatively autonomous structure, with its own logic and effects).

2) You also see a growing anxiety over capitalist dynamics and capitalist ‘culture’: by his final articles you see him claim that free-riding (literally speaking) is the result of bourgeois corruption, peasants raising prices offloads taxes onto workers, and he focused on parasitism again and again. Now I do think that capitalism has an effect on people’s behavior (subjectification anyone?) but this is just reductive.

3) Conversely, he also insists that once the working class is both universal (everyone is a worker) and once old vices are cleansed from the earth with time (remember: capitalism is the spawn of all vices?), then communism will be realized - and not even the accounting of products will be necessary (people will just know to work how hard, to take the right amount, etc.), nor will legal punishments be necessary (instead people will compel deviants to make up for a crimes through labor). His view is, in my opinion, a marker of a larger and historically significant mutation in the concept of communism, both in that the transition is overly statified and that its end goal is overly anarchistic.

4) One interesting thing I noticed is that, at least for Preobrazhensky, the Left-Communist position seems to be connected to the experience of the provinces: he argues that, in the outskirts of the country, industry had temporarily revived during the war but if they (the party) allowed capitalism to simply return after the end of the war/Brest Litovsk then such industry would disappear again, and the workers would be dispersed to the countryside - hence, he urges for nationalizations as a way of 'planning' these industries to maintain their relevance. Now, obviously, I would want to follow up on this claim with some more historical research - i.e., where was Left-Communism popular? - but it at least is a thesis that's worth looking into!
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review