Democracy in South Africa turns 20 on 27 April 2014. In A Rumour of Spring, Max du Preez investigates and analyses the progress and lack of progress the country has made during that time. He considers the state of the ANC and the opposition, social cohesion and race, the media, the judiciary, civil society, the economy, poverty and unemployment, land, education, health, and South Africa’s standing in the world.
An honest and balanced account, the book tackles the questions asked by ordinary South Africans every How are we really doing? What is really going on in our country? How should we understand what is happening here? Highly readable, accessible and entertaining – written in the style that has made Max du Preez so popular. It takes a balanced approach, looking at the good, the bad and the ugly, and explores South Africa on several levels, from the leaders in government to ordinary people on the ground.
An excellent analysis of South Africa's current political developments and problems. I was given this as a gift and I'm very glad that I read it because Max du Preez has done a brilliant job of setting out all the major problems that we face as South Africans and providing rational and extremely well-informed discussions of all of them. For anyone who fears what will happen during and after Zuma, who wonders what role whites can play in an ANC-led South Africa, and who wants reassurance that we are not going to end up as a failed state, read this book!
It’s been a few years since I read a political / current events book on South Africa, and it made me nostalgic from when I used to be deep into the happenings of politics there. And this book is from just around that era. So I enjoyed it a lot for that reason; refamiliarizing myself with the old names, events, and intrigues. But it was also a good look at multiple aspects of South Africa circa 2014. It was rather hopeful, too, despite being deep in the Zuma era. I do wonder what he would say for the 30 years after freedom book.
"If there were one thing I would like us South Africans to learn from other countries it would be that the president and the government of the day do not define who and what we are as a people and a country. [...] We might have a weak and ineffectual government and a rather embarassing president right now, but our country and our people are as vibrant and as magnificent as we saw ourselves to be when we won the Rugby World Cup twice and hosted the most spectacular Soccer World Cup in 2010. Let me be frank: there is a lot more to South Africa and South Africans than Jacob Zuma and his present crop of ANC leaders." (p. 265)
Interesting perspectives from Max du Preez, whom I got to know about as editor of "Vrye Weekblad" many moons ago. He is asking many questions that I am also wondering about. The answers or responses that he gives create a sound platform for further debates and discussions. I am pleased that I read the book and I recommend it highly to anyone interested in South Africa's political developments.
Max du Preez succeeds in painting a realistic perspective of modern-day South Africa by using facts, comments and analyses from a broad range of sources. He addresses government issues such as education, health, security, the justice system and Nkandla. How did we get here? he asks. And then he explains it in a context that is easy to understand. A must-read for every South African.
An eyes-wide-open examination of the state of the nation 20 years into democracy. The book doesn't stint on acknowledging the brutalities and legacies of colonialism and apartheid, and devotes a whole chapter to government successes, but the chapters on the racialization of politics since the advent of democracy (beginning during Thabo Mbeki's term) and on the state of the nation in general are scary shit.
Significantly, du Preez doesn't feel SA will ever become a failed state (in the Zimbabwean sense of the word), and I tend to agree. BUT I've maintained for many years now that SA is slipping into a chronic and progressive state of system collapse, authoritarianism and endemic corruption (in the Nigerian mould) and that should be of profound concern to every citizen.
Some of the many things that struck me while reading this book:
GENERAL STUFF
1. "My problem with the present crop of ANC leaders is that they use apartheid as a *excuse* for bad governance rather than as a considered *explanation* for persistent problematic trends."
2. "All of us, but especially white South Africans, should examine the legacies of generations of minority domination and apartheid on our people - on whites too - if we want to understand our society properly."
3. "South Africa is also a 'multiply wounded, multiply traumatised, multiply mourning country'." Sadly, so true.
GOOD STUFF (and some not so good)
1. "(Our Constitution) is a magnificent document and beautifully crafted. It guarantees our freedoms and basic rights, and is the blueprint of how we ought to behave as a nation. It is guarded over by a still credible Constitutional Court."
2. "I think on a person-to-person level we have progressed spectacularly in the way we get along and respect each other ... It is when we operate in groups that we start attacking and defending our racial trenches. Politicians cynically playing the race card are a major source of discord." No kidding ...
3. "Our faith communities are still strong, and there is an almost complete absence of religious intolerance." BIG one that ...
4. "South Africa's fiscal management since 1994 has been exemplary." (Note: 'fiscal', not 'financial'.)
5. "Today South Africa administers the biggest public anti-retroviral treatment programme in the world.
6. "There is a widely held view that black South Africans as a group are as poor today as they were in 1990 and that little is being done for them. The facts contradict this ... The picture is one of a significant increase in living standards, with a general migration from LSM 1-3 to LSM 4-7." LSM = Living Standards Measure.
7. "There is still huge inequality, but good progress has been made."
8. "Government has built 3.5 million sub-economic or RDP (Reconstruction and Development Programme) houses since 1994, not something any government anywhere (apart from China, perhaps) has achieved in recent years."
9. "The most effective weapon against extreme poverty in South Africa is the system of social grants, Towards the end of 2013, a little over 16 million people (approx. 30.7% of the population) were receiving social grants from the state, costing around R113 billion, or more or less 3.4 per cent of GDP." Of course, with only 4.6 million people (8.8% of the population) paying tax, and with only 3.3 million of those (6.3% of the population) paying 90% of all income tax collected (source: Moneyweb), this isn't sustainable.
10. "The people of Soweto have stubbornly overcome the cruelty of the past ... Soweto is the jewel in the crown of the new South Africa. Go visit, and be proud." True dis!
THE OTHER STUFF
1. "Mbeki was a disappointment as a president ... (he) was unnecessarily divisive and did not suppress his clear inner resentment of white South Africans as a group ... YOU DON'T TAKE PEOPLE WITH YOU INTO A NEW, TRANSFORMED SOCIETY IF YOU ACCUSE AND INSULT THEM ALL THE TIME." (Emphasis mine.) Zactly!
2. "Even knowing what I know now in 2013 would not have changed my belief that the ANC had to get into power as soon as possible. I would still have voted for the ANC in 1994 and 1999. I would still have supported the letter and spirit of the Interim Constitution and the 1996 Final Constitution."
3. "I should admit to being naïve. I did not realize how much corruption there was in the ANC during its time in exile." Yep, this was a source of huge debate when I was at university between 1976 and 1980.
4. "I really expected a much different ANC to govern in 2013." Same!
5. "I was puzzled by some of the tendencies in the ANC after 1994 (corruption, cronyism etc.) ... Only after I researched the ANC's years in exile ... did I realize these weaknesses had been part of the culture since the late 1960s ... The custom of branding opponents and personal enemies as spies and apartheid agents has also not died out entirely." Yep ...
6. "If the bad old habits and often Stalinist tendencies of the military and security men were suppressed during the presidencies of Nelson Mandela and Thabo Mbeki, they clearly resurfaced after the former intelligence chief of the ANC in Exile (Jacob Zuma) became our president." Personally I feel Stalinist tendencies were already becoming evident during the Mbeki era (and have existed within the ANC since the 60s), and have since deepened.
7. Re Marikana: "Much of the anger was directed at the ANC that had failed to deliver on their promises over two decades, but the ANC successfully diverted this anger in the direction of whites and 'white minority capital'." Yep ...
8. Re 'economic compromises' made by the ANC in the early 1990s: "My own view is that it was indeed inevitable that the ANC had to embrace a market-related economy with limited state intervention when they took power in 1994. But I'm not so sure that what they did in the years afterwards was wise or inevitable." I agree.
9. "Vast wealth, accumulated with South African labour and from South Africa's mineral resources, was transferred out of the country WITH THE CONSENT OFT HE GOVERNMENT." (Emphasis mine).
10. "It is my considered view that even if the ANC had no choice but to accept a model of fiscal austerity and liberalization in 1994, they could have achieved an awful lot more to benefit the poor and unemployed if they had governed more efficiently and cleanly, and if they hadn't defined black economic empowerment (BEE) so narrowly." Yes!
11. "Perhaps it is time for a new form of people's capitalism." Given the historic failures of both capitalism and communism (state capitalism) I couldn't agree more.
12. "We should make the state, the economy and the nation work more efficiently, live more frugally, and fix our education and skills-training systems and our divided cities." Yes, yes, yes!
13. The whole of Chapter 7, entitled 'Jacob the Survivor' - very scary shit indeed.
14. "The 'willing buyer; willing seller' principle was officially abandoned in 2007 by the Mbeki administration, but five years later it was still being used as an excuse (for the 'failure' of the land redistribution programme). It was again officially rejected by the Zuma administration, but is still used as propaganda by many. The subtext is that white people should get the blame for the fact that not enough black people have been given agricultural land."
15. Quoting Leon Louw of the Free Market Foundation: "Thousands of willing buyers and sellers trade land daily in response to eager sellers, who advertise their willingness to sell. The only failure is that of one, single buyer - the government - which is too unwilling or incompetent to buy readily available land."
16. "Now here is the astonishing truth about land redistribution, the willing buyer, willing seller principle and the target of 30 per cent ... the amount of money spent on land reform since 1994 could have purchased 37 per cent of all farmland at market value ... even if the state had been forced to use the willing buyer, willing seller guideline and never expropriated any land, we would have been well beyond the target for redistribution by now if the money had been used properly. THE ONLY CONCLUSION: BILLIONS MUST HAVE BEEN LOST THROUGH BUREAUCRATIC BUNGLING, BAD MANAGEMENT AND CORRUPTION." (Emphasis mine.) And there's the rub on the land redistribution issue ...
17. "Any analysis of the root causes of our high rate of violent crime should start in our violent past." I agree with this 100% - violence breeds violence. (Other causes mentioned by du Preez: democracy has failed to live up to the dreams of ordinary people, gross inequality, the racial overtones of the divide between rich and poor, failures in policing and the justice system).
18. Anthony Altbeker: "Violence in comtagious." So is corruption ...
19. (In stats released on 19 September 2013): " ... the murder rate was up by 4.2 per cent to 16 259 cases (31.2/100,000), OR FORTY-FIVE MURDERS A DAY. This is four-and-a-half times higher than the global average of 6.9 per 100,000 people." (Emphasis mine.) And in places like the UK, the US, China, Japan, Taiwan, Cuba, Canada, Argentina, Chile, Uruguay, Malaysia, Singapore, India, Cyrus, Israel, Oman, Qatar, most of both Eastern and Western Europe, Ireland, Australia and New Zealand, the annual intentional murder rate is much, much lower than the international average, which puts SA's murder rate into sobering perspective.
20. "It is possible to undermine the essence of the Constitution, the independence of the judicial system and even the rule of law without changing the wording of the Constitution. THAT IS THE DANGER SOUTH AFRICA FACES RIGHT NOW." (Emphasis mine.)
21. " 'IT IS BECOMING MORE ACCEPTABLE FOR BLACK SOUTH AFRICANS TO SCORN AND ABUSE WHITES OPENLY AS A RACIAL GROUP,' remarked The Economist on 24 June 2011. If anything, that was an understatement, at least by 2013." (Emphasis mine.)
22. "There is a danger that this anger (about the past) is not always righteous; that it or some of it has its roots in something other than the evil past. SOMETIMES IT'S SIMPLY RACIST ABUSE." (Emphasis mine.)
23. "If you truly want to move towards equality, you appeal to people's sense of justice, fairness and humanity; you don't simply lump them all in one group of evil racists and accuse and insult them. The result is inevitable: they will resist and withdraw."
And on that note, may I suggest that every eligible voter reads this book before the upcoming general election ...
Sad. Its leftist optimism mixed with disillusioned reality in the governing ANC. Now 6 years later the rumour of spring was just that. A rumour. No spring but winter has dawned. Max was a proponent of the new dispensation and now it has gone full spiral degrading a dysfunctional state to a failed state. Soon there will be only the pieces of ozzymandias' empire left for observers to see.
I really liked this book. The book details the contemporary society of South Africa post 1994. How a country steeped in Apartheid can become a non-racial democracy and an important world player in African region, what are the nation's strengths and weaknesses and what lies in the future, these are some if the questions detailed in the book.
Written in an amusing manner, every fact and figure in the book is taken from reliable sources so there is little room for doubt. An amazing book if one wants to understand South African society and politics.
This was probably the most lucid and insightful depiction of contemporary South African politics that I've read, and was a very useful guide as an expat living in South Africa. He explains in detail the dynamics of everything from crime to land redistribution to the Marikana massacre. Anyone interested in getting a fresh picture of how South Africa has evolved since the end of apartheid should read this book.
Very well researched and written book on both the pros and cons of the South African government. The writer ensures he reminds us of all we have to be grateful for. However he does wrap the book up with some real warnings signs of where the country is headed given our current governmental attitude. Well worth the read.
Max du Perez writes with the zeal of a patriot. Someone who believes rather than giving in much more can be made by shouting ‘ things must change ‘. Reading this several years down the line with the knowledge of the rise of the EFF, the spectre of State Capture and of load shedding this book burnishes a much needed optimism.
Very interesting read. Well-written, including a lot of information and combining various topics without being too academic. Important book for South Africans who want to be well-informed about the (true) state of our democracy.
Well balanced review of where we are and how we got there. Provides useful discussion of the dynamics of the ANC in exile that provide some insight into current political dynamics.
A nice way to figure out what has been happening in South Africa for the past 20 years. There was a decent mix of optimism and reality checking that was refreshing.
well written, its amazing how all this time I was ignorant in regards to South African politics. This book has made me to have some interest in the country's politics