Werewolves and vampires and a fight to the death. It sounds like a promising idea. For good reason, too. While I can't make too many comparisons to Twilight, it would be hard to ignore the parallels between the arena portion of this book and The Hunger Games. That's not necessarily a bad thing, either, since that was what made me pick The Arena Wars up to start with.
From the start, the book didn't go easy on the exposition. For pages at a time, Alanna lectured about life as a werewolf, her sister, that sort of thing. And if Alanna wasn't telling us, then someone else would be, through the dialogue. This really slowed the pace at times. The story would have flowed much more smoothly if crucial information was given out more naturally, rather than hitting all at once like a ton of bricks.
The action scenes, on the other hand, weren't slow at all. I really did enjoy them. Toward the beginning, there was a fight between Alanna and a vampire. I think that scene was what hooked me, even through the exposition overload.
Aside from the overall pace, there were a few other major hangups for me. For one, Quinten's blindness. It didn't hinder him much at all, which seemed pretty unrealistic. At one point he was able to track Alanna through the woods on his own, while she was trying not to be found, and he even managed to find her in time to save her from Roger. It was explained away by his incredible hearing and perception, but I'd think those must have been supernatural for him to do as well as he did. I thought that overall, he was a good, sympathetic character, and other than that I really liked him. He and Jax were my favorites, and a less legitimate complaint would be that Jax didn't play very much of a role in the plot... but I digress.
The plot itself left me scratching my head. It was almost like two entirely separate novels. The first half was about Alanna trying not to mate with Roger, then suddenly in the next half she and Quinten were transported to the Arena Wars and there was nothing left over from the first part. The antagonist from the beginning was only ever mentioned again in passing, if that, and there was someone new to take his place. The entire plot shifted to the fights, and Alanna's brand new struggle against a brand new bad guy. The resolution wasn't much better, and it was never explained exactly how the rescue happened. It just did. As in the first half of the book, nothing was mentioned about what happened to the antagonist afterward. Nothing was mentioned again about the arena, or the other people that Alanna met there. They just disappeared.
I do have another good thing to say, and I should probably warn about a smallish spoiler in this paragraph. During Alanna and Quinten's first arena fight, Alanna was forced to finish off a twelve year old kid. It was a disturbing moment, and I have to say that I think the author handled it really well. Alanna's reaction was well written, and it had me choked up while I read that entire scene.
Overall, this book had its good points and bad points. I wasn't quite hooked enough to read the sequel, unfortunately. But who knows. There's definitely promise here, and I'm sure that one day I'll be reading a book by this author and giving it a full five stars.