Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Case of the German Doctor: A Historical Novel Based on a True Story

Rate this book
He dedicated himself to the survival of his people. Then his family’s secret came out…

When William von Antrim decided to pursue a career as a doctor, working to help Jewish survivors recover from the horrors of World War II, he believed he was doing all in his power to help his people survive. A German refugee himself, William fled to America with his mother after she was accused of being of Jewish descent. William’s father left them with only his estate, his family name, and his legacy.

A legacy that proves to be William’s downfall.


What begins with a shameful truth coming to light forces William to confront not only his family’s past but his own. William’s case threads together one tragic character after A Jewish prosecutor whose life was saved by an unexpected act of kindness; a fragile woman with a shocking story of revenge and betrayal; an ambitious attorney who struggles with morality; and William himself, who faces the dire consequences of his relentless attempts at redemption, regardless of the steep price he must pay.

Evoking questions on the banality of evil, morality, and guilt, The Case of the German Doctor is a deep, page-turning debut novel that will shock readers until the end.

218 pages, Paperback

Published July 6, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Tsuriel Sdomi

4 books2 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
11 (23%)
4 stars
10 (21%)
3 stars
16 (34%)
2 stars
8 (17%)
1 star
1 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews
Profile Image for Linda Galella.
1,209 reviews122 followers
January 24, 2024
Disturbing FICTION historical, rather than traditional HF, Tsuriel Sdomi’s, THE CASE OF THE GERMAN DOCTOR, is a dark novel that will test the boundaries of ethics.

To start with, the translation is good. I’m not great with German and there are no translations for the few phrases from the dialogue passages provided, but even my limited knowledge was able to intuit them. Ninety nine percent of the text is translated into English and it flows well.

For historical purists, there are a few anachronisms, hence my FICTION historical classification: fighter jets, ivf, paternity testing, Fiddler on the Roof - none of these things existed during the time period being written about. A good editor should have picked these up.

Much of the story revolves around a German doctor who is trying to make amends to Jewish women for atrocities committed against them during the war. He is dealing with a sins of the father influence, extended family history and the boundaries of his own morality. To say the storyline is twisted would be an understatement.

Secondary characters have shocking stories that feed into the doctor’s primary arc. They are raw, violent and heartbreaking. Not much relief is found anywhere on these pages making it difficult to read for lengthy periods of time. Sensitive folks may find themselves looking elsewhere by the midpoint.

The last third of the story takes place in a courtroom. For me, that is the most well written section. The dialogue is better and the story moves much better. If the ending included more information about how the doctor fared, I would have considered rounding 3.5 stars up to 4 but as it is, I couldn’t. The anachronisms were a deal breaker for me. It’s too easy to fact check. Just because a book is HF, it’s not license to write false information📚
Profile Image for Píaras Cíonnaoíth.
Author 151 books225 followers
July 25, 2023
A captivating and thought-provoking historical novel...

Tsuriel Sdomi's "The Case of the German Doctor" stands as a captivating and thought-provoking historical novel meticulously crafted around an unfolding true story. Set in the aftermath of World War II, the book traces the journey of William von Antrim, a devoted doctor committed to aiding Jewish survivors in their arduous path to recovery.

William's life takes an unforeseen twist as a long-concealed family secret resurfaces, shattering the façade of his seemingly selfless pursuits. As a German refugee, he grapples with the weight of his family's past and the allegations surrounding his mother's Jewish lineage. The legacy left by his father, once a source of pride, now becomes a turbulent force threatening to dismantle his carefully constructed world.

Sdomi deftly weaves a tapestry of tragedy, intricately interlinking the lives of diverse characters, each carrying their own burdens of survival, vengeance, and betrayal. The life of a Jewish prosecutor, saved by an act of kindness, sets in motion a complex web of connections. The moral fortitude of an ambitious attorney is tested, adding layers of complexity to the unfolding narrative.

Through poignant storytelling and a gripping plot, "The Case of the German Doctor" delves into profound questions about the banality of evil, morality, and the burdensome weight of guilt. As the tale unfolds, readers are kept on the edge of their seats, drawn deeper into the intricacies of human nature and the repercussions of an unwavering quest for redemption.

Sdomi's debut novel proves to be an enthralling page-turner, leaving readers stunned and introspective until the final pages. It serves as a testament to the potency of historical fiction in illuminating concealed truths and probing the intricate layers of human behavior during times of immense hardship.

"The Case of the German Doctor" emerges as a triumph of storytelling, offering an emotionally charged and captivating reading experience. Tsuriel Sdomi's literary prowess shines through, fashioning an exceptional work that resonates long after the final sentence is perused. For those seeking a riveting journey into the shadows of history and the enduring impact of human choices, this novel is an essential read. Highly recommended. I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.
Profile Image for Danilo דניאל Lipisk.
312 reviews3 followers
November 30, 2025
This fictional book is SUPPOSEDLY based on a true story – and that's why I bought the book, and when I finished it, I was left with serious doubts about this "based on a true story" claim.

This interview, with a very "suggestive" sub-paragraph, says:

https://www.ynetnews.com/jewish-world...

"What happens when the son of a German Nazi officer, fluent in Hebrew, tells an Israeli lawyer and writer that in the 1950s he lived in Israel and even donated sperm to Jewish women, including Holocaust survivors unable to have children?"

So, the author, who was in Germany, was surprised by an elderly German man who claims to be probably the father of hundreds of Israelis, because in the 1950s he decided to donate sperm to Jewish women in Israel. And he did it because he wanted to redeem the sins of his father, a Nazi murderer...

And based on this conversation, Tsuriel wrote this fictional book. It sounds very implausible to me.

-Son of a Nazi who came to Israel to donate sperm
-He did it motivated by a feeling of "guilt" because of his father's actions
-Israeli women who were fertilized by foreign sperm when most donors at the time were Israeli and/or Jewish

- "Did this really happen? Am I reading a historical revelation?"

For me, the backbone of the book is an unverified anecdote, transformed into sensationalist narrative.

Ultimately, the fiction itself is totally nonsensical to me.
Profile Image for Mary.
343 reviews2 followers
November 3, 2025
I think I kind of liked this book… I honestly can’t say. It felt like a bunch of short stories with vague ties to each other. I listened to it and kept rewinding to see what was going on. Couldn’t keep track of all the people and how they fit in the story. That being said, I kept listening to see if “I got it” at the end. I did. Kind of.
Profile Image for Vikki Vaught.
Author 14 books160 followers
October 4, 2023
An interesting story with compelling characters. However the ending was way too abrupt for me. A slightly disappointed reader!
412 reviews1 follower
January 27, 2025
Interesting

Guilt or fear? Or revenge? What was William’s motive for working on such a project? One will never know for sure.
Profile Image for Janet Eshenroder.
734 reviews10 followers
October 5, 2023
Originally listed this as four stars. I considered it an interesting read about the interactions and conflicts of being a German and/or a German Jew during and after WWII. A topic I haven’t seen covered before. A painful memory and coming to terms with a period where citizens were divided and turned against each other.
Oddly, on reading it a second time in 2025 (not realizing I had already finished it once), I found it harder to believe the scenario.
Profile Image for Erin.
15 reviews
February 29, 2024
This book creates a narrative that while interesting, is steeped in untruths. Like other reviewers have noted, several of these procedures and things like IVF did not exist at this point in history. It is hard for me to reconcile the good dialogue and characters with the fact the historical details are WAY off. Also the ending was abrupt. But this book is way more fiction than historical so keep that in mind.
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews