It was the title and small blurb that quickly intrigued me to this book, and while there was indeed a gothic flare and some elements of fantasy, a fairytale I think not. The novel was based loosely around a well known fairytale and love story, Beauty And The Beast, but my experience with this story ends at the Disney version. The story starts with our protagonist, Catherine, being in a shipwreck and ending up on a mysterious island that seems not only to be separated from the rest of the world but also lost in time. It is there, wrecked on the beaches of the island, the master, Gerard, finds her and takes her in to heal her wounds. The master is a very mysterious man, who disappears during the day and only comes out at night, who can heal people from death’s door, and appears to have two sides; one dominant and controlling, the often soft and nurturing. There is a small village where people go about their lives, but they have lived for over a hundred years, still reeling from the disaster that caused their current predicament. Catherine needs to find a way off the island to return to her life, but there are a number of things stopping her, including the enigmatic Gerard who she appears to be falling in love with, and a beast that lurks the island watching Catherine’s every move.
This book is set in the 1800’s where women are still treated as second class citizens and are known by the name of their husband, but Catherine is a strong willed woman who will not take any nonsense and will fight for what she believes to be right. This is the reason that Gerard finds her so intriguing, the fact that she fights back, even though she is terrified of him for most of the time. This was something I could never really get over, the fact that Gerard keeps Catherine like a prisoner, he often yells at her and threatens to take over her mind and control her and she still falls in love with him. She is the first person to wash up on their shores in over 100 years, so I can understand that he is intrigued, but it never seemed more than simple lust to me. I mean Gerard proposed to Catherine because she refused to sleep with him as they were not married, and while her will was really strong and she still stuck to her values above anything else, this is a clear demonstration of his controlling behaviours. Catherine kept talking about how beautiful he was and how strong he seemed, but other than initial attraction, there didn’t really seem to be anything between them. While he protected her and tried to steer her away from her thoughts of leaving, I couldn’t help but think that the next pretty thing to wash up on the shores he would try to seduce as well. Seeing as almost every man on the island appeared to be only interested in women for one thing, which may have been a sign of the times I don’t know, the fact that Gerard may change in the next 100 years would not surprise me at all. But Catherine appears too spellbound to really think about it, and only made her decision to be with him as he was dying in her arms.
Moving on, the writing was very beautiful and definitely earned the word ‘gothic’ in the title. The island was dark and gloomy, the master’s mansion was old and foreboding, and the village and cemetery was a nice touch. There is a fog that rises over the island before night falls, in which the beast often stalks, and these passages were quite dark in their tone and added a horror element which could have been more prominent. Catherine and Gerard were well built and strong characters, with even the bit characters seeming to fill the story up more. I liked the fact that due to the old fashioned nature of the time, the villagers and Catherine stick to customs, and Catherine expects everyone to stand on ceremony, which is why Gerard frustrates her, because he refuses to conform to the rules of her day.
Catherine’s past is filled with death and sorrow, and while I understood what the writer was trying to do with Death at the end, I really don’t feel that this came through enough, and could have been used so much more when Catherine is retelling her tales of being a nurse during the war and losing her husband and daughter to an illness that she brought in. I do not understand Death’s fascination with Catherine and why he has chosen her and what he asks of her to save Gerard seems a little odd. I would have liked a bit more on the end as well, as it did seem like the story cam to an abrupt halt. I wanted to know what would happen after the death of another man was discovered, especially since everyone on the island appears to be immortal, how the vicar reacted to the beast, and whether Catherine would suffer any ramifications for her choice. The ending was not profound enough to end when it did, and since the whole story was around Catherine and Gerard and her loving him for his human side as well as the beast within, I expected there to be something else to indicate where they would go to from here.
In the end, this was a well written story with a few confusing plot elements and a love story that didn’t really place any emphasis on love between the characters. While it was entertaining and I did enjoy reading it, I felt that it could have been so much more by just making a few things clearer and exploring the relationship forming between the beauty and her beast.