In a word: An adventure full of Celtic mythology, a wonderfully human and flawed main character, lots of sly references to Harry Potter, but not quite enough danger for me.
I couldn’t wait to start reading Scion of the Sun, mostly because of the gorgeous cover that really drew me in. And Scion starts off very strong, as we are introduced to MC Holly, who is telling the story. One of the best ways to throw your characters into uncomfortable situations is to send them to a new place. In this case, Holly is about to start boarding school at the Clique of Unique Luminary Telepathies (try saying that out loud!), or C.U.L.T. for short. C.U.L.T. takes in students with psychic powers of one sort or another and helps them develop those powers. (Sound familiar?) Holly has just started having visions, and they’re freaking her out, and she’s hoping someone at the school will be able to help her understand them.
But even though she meets new friends Quinn and Raven when she arrives, Holly still feels like an outsider. And when she accidentally teleports to another place and meets a group of teens that belong to the Sorority of the Sun, Holly realizes her visions may be a clue to her true purpose in life: to help the Sorority fight a man named Cadifor who is trying to obliterate the world. Holly, it turns out, is a descendant of the Celtic sun-god Belenus, and is the Scion of the Sun.
Holly was by far my favorite part of Scion of the Sun. She’s a typical sixteen-year-old girl who crushes on cute boys and simply wants to fit in. Her voice is sarcastic and snarky, yet you can tell she lacks confidence in herself. Her Nan, the woman who’s been taking care of her for years, has just gone into a coma, and Holly thinks she is responsible. When she is told that she’s the person who can save the world from the evil Cadifor, Holly has a hard time believing it. She reminded me a lot of Buffy, but without the cute clothes.
Marsh does give us a love triangle, of sorts, when Holly meets the hot (naturally) and enigmatic Joss in Eiros, the secret place located in New York City where Holly goes when she teleports. Joss calls himself her “warrior” and is sworn to protect her. But from what? Holly of course doesn’t want his protection at first, but there seems to be a strong connection between them that she’s having a hard time explaining to herself, and when things start to get dangerous in Eiros, Holly realizes that she needs him more than she thinks. And then there’s Quinn back at C.U.L.T., who is cute and funny and likes Holly a lot. Holly can tell that Quinn is developing a crush on her, but she can’t explain her frequent disappearances to Quinn and Raven, because her involvement with the Sorority must remain a secret.
The story jumps back and forth between the school and Eiros, as Holly must keep up appearances with her friends at school, and learn how to control her powers in Eiros. I actually preferred the scenes that took place in Eiros, when Holly begins to learn who she really is and what she must do as the Scion. Marsh adds lots of mythology to the story, and although at times I felt there was information overload with all the intricacies of Celtic beliefs, I was fascinated by the symbols and rituals that Holly had to learn in order to fulfill her destiny. The story actually became uncomfortable during the scenes at school, when Holly must lie to her friends in order to keep her doings in Eiros a secret.
A few things didn’t work as well for me. For example, Marsh introduces several characters that only make one appearance in the book and never show up again, like a mysterious boy named Drake that greets Holly at the entrance to the school on her first day. I was intrigued by Drake, but disappointed later when he never made it back into the story.
I was also confused by the lack of danger related to the character of Cadifor, who is after all, the “bad guy.” Holly seems overly melodramatic when her visions show him manhandling a woman by pushing and shoving her, and it almost felt as if the author was censoring the story so that it wouldn't be too violent for young readers. I’m not saying I need death and blood and violence in everything I read, but I would have been more engaged with the story if Marsh had upped the stakes and made the danger more intense. Also confusing was something called "Arwen" that both Holly and Cadifor are searching for. I wasn't sure whether Arwen was a person or an artifact (or maybe I just missed that detail when I was reading), but more information would have made me care more whether or not Holly located this elusive "thing" before Cadifor did.
But I loved the sweet scenes when Holly worries about her Nan in the hospital. She clearly has lots of history with her and cherishes her memories in Nan’s house and gardens. I also loved the frequent references to Harry Potter and Twilight, and I appreciated the author poking fun at herself, since the book is partly about a school of magic. Scion of the Sun is a strangely appealing mixture of old world Celtic lore populated with modern teens who are just trying to fit in. Holly shines as a reluctant girl who is destined to save the world, but like her counterpart Buffy, isn’t sure she really wants to.
Many thanks to the publisher for supplying a review copy.