Accompanying her father and their guide to the planet Tanin and the country of the bell trees, Jenny explores the ruins of an ancient civilization, in a land where nothing is as it seems
Over the course of her twenty-three-year career as a writer, H.M. Hoover won eight awards for her writing, including three Best Book for Young Adult designations from the American Library Association and two Parent's Choice Honor Awards. Another Heaven, Another Earth received the Ohioana Award in 1982.
H.M. Hoover lived in Burke, Virginia. Her last published work was The Whole Truth - And Other Myths: Retelling Ancient Tales, in 1996.
Hoover changed her pen name to H.M. Hoover before Children came out because there was already a children's author named Helen Hoover.
A fifteen year old girl of privilege goes with her father (in a far distant future for humanity) to track down the source of a strange alien artifact. She meets the discoverer of the artifact, a wild child of a boy, spiritual and attuned to his planet in ways most of the adults aren't, and they discover odd and beautiful and terrifying artifacts galore. This includes the titular bell tree, which rings like bells when it rains.
There is so much going on in this layered book. There's a critique of colonialism, an ecological message, questions posed about who is more or less civilized, a plot that includes the impossibility of communicating across the species divide with another intelligent civilization. Just a LOT going on. And yet it is a page-turner of book, peopled with likeable and complex characters. Elegiac at times, poetic at times, it's a quick read that you won't put down.
I can't say enough good about this author, and I plan to read everything by her. I muse about the years she wrote--late 70s through the 80s--and how hard things were for women then, and how she was in two ghettos in SF--the kiddie lit ghetto and the one her sex put her in. (and probably a third, the one her age put her in.) But oh, the wisdom she had, the world building skill, the language, the ability to plot and create wonderful characters and depict perfectly nuanced coming of age tales. I don't know to what extent she was ignored back then, but we should resurrect her work now, for it's marvelous stuff.
I love all of Hoovers books! This one is good for boys. It has adventure and makes you think too! I would recommend this for 5th grade and above. Warnings: Drugs: no Sex: no R&R-aliens Language-no Violent- no
I feel confused, and while a state of genteel bemusement is not unknown for me, it has more to do with this novel than my incipient dementia. What is it all about? At first I thought that it was one of those 1980s science fiction stories that promote environmentalism by showing that humans have the knack of disrupting or destroying the natural world – wherever that world may be. But as the book progresses that fits less and less.
To begin with we have Dr Sadler and his daughter Jenny on a trip to the planet Tanin. Tanin seems to have been chosen as a base for corporations to establish their food and crop research laboratories away from the searching eyes of Earth's authorities. Dr Sadler is a senior player in one of those corporations: the Silas P Sadler Research Institute, while Jenny is a rather subdued rebellious teenager ready to disagree with almost anything the adult world suggests. Environment scandal seems to be written there in capital letters – then, not a great deal happens with that.
Instead Dr Sadler and Jenny go off to search for ancient ruins with Eli as their guide. Eli's confusing. When he first comes on the scene he is introduced as: “[Jenny] sat quietly and waited, hoping to see a potoo [a native Tanin bird, like an ostrich]. To her disappointment, a man appeared,” later he turns out to be and behaves more like a boy, presumably around Jenny's age, and we get the beginnings of a teenage romance.
When they find some ancient cliff dwellings Jenny is surprised by a very large and angry local carnivore, hungry and not at peace with the world - imagine confronting a polar bear that has heard about global warming - and only just avoids becoming a meal. Her father's attitude, instead of retreating to a safe distance with his daughter, is to enter the dark alien tunnels alone. As with Abimelech at Thebez, he was asking for it. What follows then is old fashioned science fiction high adventure, with intelligent aliens described as bipedal giant ants and equally large threatening guinea pigs, from which Jenny and Eli have to rescue Dr Sadler.
By this time the author seems to have lost interest in preserving the environment. In the course of the adventure Dr Sadler has found a cache a gems, which he says are worth a fortune on Earth, and he is willing to share them with Jenny and Eli. Strangely Eli, who all along has been posing as the planet's protector, jumps at the chance of untold wealth and gaining a rich man's daughter. It is as if American astronauts found a hotel and golf course complex on Mars when Donald Trump was in Houston visiting NASA. Eli couldn't have moved more quickly.
The story is OK as far as it goes, but it does have the feel of a pot-boiler.
This on was just O.K. It's a pretty typical example of the soft sci fi for young readers that proliferated during the 1980's. The themes are anthropological and environmental. The book reads as a way-too-long short story. There's no real character or plot development. Some stuff just happens, and then it ends.