***SPOLIER ALERT***THIS REVIEW CONTAINS SPOILERS***
I really enjoyed this book, but I initially came away from it feeling like I had missed something or didn't catch on to something that was implied. This bothered me enough that I read some other reviews to see how other readers perceived the story and sure enough, several brought up something I hadn't really considered. First, some backstory. I read this book with the view that everything that was happening to and around Dovey was real. However, if that were the case certain things in the book just don't make sense. Dovey was taking pills to keep her from seeing the demons and distal servants all around her, but the first time she sees Carly she is still taking the pills, thus she shouldn't have seen Carly at all. When she's not taking the pills she is able to see all things demon, but at the end of the book when she sees her father in the hospital, he doesn't appear to be a demon until he purposely reveals some demonic traits to her, which she should have been able to see consistently, not just at his whim. There are a few characters in the book, like Gigi and the girl who directs them to the pirate captain ghost, whose larger purposes are hinted at but never really explained, and we never get to revisit these characters. At the end of the book Isaak, a part demon part human, apparently turns into a full-on demon with no explanation or follow-up. Also at that point in the story Baker is revealed to be part demon part human as well. Again no explanation, just a quick revelation. And the distal servant logic is flawed. It's said that the demon has to have your distal in it's possession as well as your soul in a dybbuk box. It's also said that if the soul is freed from the dybbuk box then the spirit is free. This would make having the distal irrelevant because if the soul has been set free, well, it's free. I can see needing the distal prior to a death in order to take the soul, but after that it seems like the real issue is just the soul in the dybbuk box. Basically, by the end of the book I was confused. I couldn't find anything to indicate this is the beginning of a series (which is fine with me, I like reading stand-alone novels), and it just leaves so many unanswered questions. That's when I started reading other reviews. Until then, I honestly hadn't considered that the story was an exploration of Dovey's mental illness after witnessing the death of her best friend. Once I looked at it that way, everything fit perfectly, because madness doesn't make sense. Antipsychotics, which Dovey was supposedly taking, can lose their effectiveness over time, so if she needed a change in her dose that would explain hallucinations like seeing Carly the first time. And stopping them completely could lead to a complete breakdown. So the real question is, were the demon related events real? Or imagined in the grip of madness? I'm leaning toward madness, but either way I was entertained by the story. It was a bit over-long at times and the end is very abrupt but overall it was worth the read and I plan to check out other titles by this author.