I would like to give this book three and a half stars.
It is clear that the author wants to help people; it's just as clear that she often substitutes "prophetic words" for common sense. That is my biggest issue with this book.
So you can understand where I'm coming from: I grew up in a fairly conservative family. I've had charismatic friends and some of them are wonderful people. I am not, overall, comfortable with "Charismatic," but I can get along with people who are Charismatic if we can agree to differ; I don't see it as a friendship-threatening issue at all though if marriage were concerned certain things should be hammered out beforehand.
Anyway, to cite the three worst "sticking points:"
-the author believes in and participates in receiving "prophetic words:" specific words "from God," that are not in the Bible, spoken by another person. I am currently in the "I really don't know, it could be okay, but I haven't studied the issue and I need to before accepting/rejecting it; in the meantime I am leery" zone.
Going on those prophetic words, she then takes dreams and coincidences as further signs and confirmations. The most extreme examples: certain digits in a guy's number (indicating that he was "supposed" to call her), license plate numbers, name tags next to each other on a store rack. Why not play with Tarot cards while you're at it.
She admits that she has been burned by these practices at times and advises caution.
-ZERO COMMON SENSE ABOUT THE BASIC WORKINGS OF MALE/FEMALE RELATIONSHIPS. This bugged me the most! If she had gotten a copy of "All The Rules" and put at least some of it into practice, it would have done her more good than twenty prophetic-word meetings! Worst example: she allows a guy she's interested in to keep her on the phone for THREE HOURS -- get this -- the very FIRST TIME he calls. As it turns out, he's far more enthusiastic about wasting her time and using her as a teddy bear than reciprocating her interest.
It gets worse; she talks about "the five guy 'best friends'" she had before she met her husband -- and how much pain and confusion they caused her. Five. Slow learner.
I have been there: I have wasted hours on the phone (and hundreds of dollars in long-distance bills) on a guy who did not care about me and wasted ten years of my life, insisting right on up til he found someone else to marry that he loved me as much as 'he ever had.' I was young and dumb too. So it makes me angry to read about this woman well into her thirties who hasn't learned the basics of fending off parasites -- and instead of handing her a "how guys play with you if you let them" manual, her fellow Christians give her prophetic words to chase after. Very helpful.
-she says at one point that in her oft-mentioned screenplay "Never the Bride," she writes God showing up -- in human form. Whoa. I'm not sure this is allowed? I'm not going to go into "why you shouldn't draw God" here, just mention that I was not comfortable with the concept; she doesn't specifically say she had "Christ" show up in her screenplay, which would still be pushing it, she just says "God."
I agree with the basic premise of the book, trusting that God loves you and truly wants what's best for you and waiting on Him. Her faith in this area is touching, and I did identify with her struggles (similar age -- but I'm still single). One line that caught me was about how Satan will strike in the area of our deepest hunger if he can, dangling poisonous counterfeits of what we long for. It helped explain to me some of the things that happened in my life that were especially painful.
Her husband's guest chapter is more concise and sensible than the rest of the book.
The book is definitely worth reading. Just be aware of the aforementioned issues.