The Novitiate. It sounds like a holy place, doesn’t it? Believe me, in Brian Freeman’s novella, “Turned to Stone,” its sanctity has been violated. My first clue was the pentagram on the cover in the “o” of the word “Stone.” Something terrible happened at the abandoned, burned-out building near Shawano, Wisconsin, which formerly housed an order of Catholic brothers.
Lieutenant Jonathan Stride is travelling through southeastern Wisconsin on his way home to Duluth one dark, cold April night when he is inexplicably drawn into the town of Shawano toward the cemetery where his mother is buried. As he prepares to leave her gravesite, a police car pulls in, and the unthinkable happens. Before Stride can react, the man shoots himself. Stride soon finds himself sucked into a case where he is not wanted, except that the man’s widow wants an explanation. Kelli Andrews is the survivor of that horrible ordeal at the Novitiate four years earlier, and the dead cop was known as the hero who saved her and subsequently married her.
But soon there is another body, and Stride can’t help himself. Even though he knows he is way out of his territory, he can’t just walk away. I couldn’t either. Part one ended with a single word: “Teufel.” In German, it means, “devil.” I gasped and then found myself holding my breath.
Stride believes in evil all right, but he knows the devil didn’t commit this murder. This was the work of a human. What about the victim of the kidnapping and torture, Kelli Andrews? What does she believe? Freeman did a masterful job of casting suspicion and then turning around and creating doubt. I had bits of this puzzle figured out but not all of it. The characterization, as usual, is superb. If you’re expecting more of Serena and Maggie in this one, put those thoughts out of your head. Jonathan Stride is single and regretting his mistakes, but in this story, he is only focused on the task at hand. You’d think that in a small town like Shawano there would be no secrets, but there are. Some of Freeman’s characters in this book have deep, dark secrets.
Der Teufel, the devil, is a theme that snakes through the entire novella like a cold, unseen shadow, casting fear and loathing like a dank cloud that smothers the light. I must add here that I have a fear and hatred of snakes, and the frequent use of the word to describe the wind’s affect on the blowing snow caught my eye; then I realized that Freeman was doing it on purpose, as another symbol of the devil. Freeman is so adept at creating mood in his writing through the use of scenery and weather. In “Turn to Stone,” he draws on a real place, adds the snow, damp, and chill of the early Wisconsin springtime, and mixes it with his own unique imagination. The result is a wickedly good thriller that held me spellbound.
5 stars