Like Snow Falling on Cedars, a stirring tale of wartime love
April, 1944. The quiet rural village of Stark, New Hampshire is irrevocably changed by the arrival of 150 German prisoners of war. And one family, unexpectedly divided, must choose between love and country.
Camp Stark is under the command of Major John Brennan, whose beautiful daughter, Collie, will serve as translator. Educated at Smith and devoted to her widowed father, Collie is immediately drawn to Private August Wahrlich, a peaceful poet jaded by war. As international conflict looms on the home front, their passion blinds them to the inevitable dangers ahead.
Inspired by the little-known existence of a real World War II POW camp, The Major’s Daughter is a fresh take on the timeless theme of forbidden love.
April 1944 Stark, New Hampshire. German prisoners of war arrive and a young American girl is torn between a forbidden love, love of country and family.
Francis did a wonderful job with historical references. The two young women serving as main characters - Collie and Estelle along with the time period and war references were very well done. The reader felt the environment of the 1940's and the upheaval and uncertainty of wartime. The feelings of people from both sides were addressed with realism. Francis has a lovely writing style, slightly poetic, definately not overdone especially for a love story. Her words paint the emotional difficulty faced by the characters, her prose enhanced the reading experience.
Francis created an interesting narrative of forbidden love. The manner in which Collie and August meet, and feelings develop was sentimental. The premise of the societal and family propriety during this era was heartbreaking. Nationalities, religion and social status all contributed to forbidden love and many heartbreaks. Familial expectations, duty, obligation reigned in matters of the heart and love. The narrative gives a wonderful glimpse of the prejudices and boundaries experienced during this time in history.
I found the novel quite enjoyable, I appreciated the emotional and difficulty love during wartime and the 1940's presented. This is a love story without the syrupy tone most romance narratives carry. I prefer my romance genre to be tragic and painful, where love and joining together is a painful road. Yes I do enjoy a HEA but I prefer painful, longing love. < I know terrible!
Historical fiction fans will want to give this a read, the romance aspect, time period and all the characters contribute to its appeal. The ending tied the story together in such a complimentary manner. Wonderful debut from Francis.
I won this one from Library Thing. I'll basically try anything set in WWII and I thought this premise sounded promising. Unfortunately, by the third chapter, I'm bored by the writing and all of the characters. I've read what reviews are available and the main draw seems to be the writing style, which I find distancing. One of my goals this year is to waste less of my reading time on books that haven't caught my attention one way or another, so I'm done here.
I'd been so excited to read "The Major's Daughter" based on the cover and the blurb and the idea of forbidden love between a German POW and the daughter of an American Major, and all of it happening on American soil. However, in the end I was disappointed, even upset by the way in which the stories wrapped themselves up.
In many ways, there are two separate books within the chapters. We not only follow Collie, the American girl who falls for August, the German POW, but also Estelle, who is Collie's best friend from college. Estelle has her own forbidden love back home in Ohio, an Indian man by the name of Mr. Kamal who runs a flower shop. She is both intellectually and physically attracted to him, but this is 1940s Ohio, so you can imagine there will be difficulty with that attraction. I felt as though Estelle's story ended up being more fleshed out than Collie's, that her voice was stronger, and it appeared to me that the author was much more comfortable in writing for her than he was for Collie. In fact, part of me had wished it was a different story entirely... I quite enjoyed it... but it felt world's apart from Collie, and I got the sense Collie's story suffered because of the telling of Estelle's.
I will put the rest of my review in spoiler tags...
I received a copy of The Major’s Daughter by J.P. Francis, from NetGalley for a honest review.
When I read the synopsis for this book and saw that it was similar to Summer of my German Soldier, I was excited start reading. My expectations were high because of my love of Summer of my German Soldier. However, I was sadly disappointed. I found this book depressing and blah. It was depressing because I figured either way would end up in heartache for Collie, our heroine. Unfortunately, I was correct in that since, but I won’t share any more details.
The whole set up seemed a bit unbelievable to a point, the daughter of a major falling in love with a German prisoner at a prisoner of war camp in America in the 1940s. First off, I find it difficult to see how the prisoner and the girl would end up crossing paths enough times for them even to fall in love. Regardless, the author did a good job of setting up the meeting and falling in love of August, the German soldier, and Collie.
Aside from the unlikely set up, the author did a great job with the historical elements, such as the girls, Collie and Estelle, the time period, and information about the war. The whole dating process of the girls is just what one thinks of when thinking about the social scene of the 1940s and 1950s. Also, the author’s writing was just amazing. J.P. Francis has excellent command of the English language. Some of her sentences were just beautifully written and were a joy to read. The ending of the book felt a bit rushed, especially since the rest of the book went at a slow pace. I wish we, the readers, were given more about the Collie’s life after she tried to escape with August. That would have really rounded out the book, other than just giving us a short glimpse into her life after the POW camp.
Despite enjoying the author’s writing, I found this book to be blah and unmemorable.
I would not recommend this book because of it is dull and forgettable.
You know, I should just forbid myself from reading historical fiction altogether. I am one of those people who looks for -- and finds -- so many anachronisms and cultural discrepancies that it affects my experience of the book.
Point number one, in this entire story that takes place in the US during the later years of World War II, there is not one single reference to coffee, sugar, or fuel rationing. Yet in the novel people drink coffee and lemonade and drive to dances without a second thought. Omitting details of these deprivations seems like an egregious oversight in a wartime setting.
Point number two, why are two German POWs drinking beer and toasting each other by saying "Skoal" (Germans say "Prosit")? Not to mention, how is it believable that an Austrian man in the 1920s or 30s names a dog "Chowder"? How would a German-speaking person pronounce that word, even if they somehow knew of its existence?
But clearly not every reader gets bogged down in small details like I do. So, I should put those things aside and talk about the story. It's a dual coming of age story, a wartime take on Romeo and Juliet, with shades of Tennessee Williams thrown in. The young women are well-written, and you would not suspect the author is male until it comes to a scene where a group of girls covertly watch the barely clad, muscular young POWs soaking wet and cavorting in the rain. I'm afraid the author is stymied by how to describe the particular feelings this situation might awaken in the girls, so it is instead described in somewhat stodgy prose, which will certainly disappoint fans of romance.
This book was slightly too long, and it got very draggy towards the end. I'm glad I read it, even though some parts were not easy to digest. Would I recommend this book to others? I'm not sure. Maybe if you're from northern New England, not committed to Hollywood happy endings, are rather relaxed in your approach to authenticity, and enjoy coming of age stories of star-crossed lovers set in the war years? If any or all of that appeals to you, by all means, read this book.
I love this book so much. It's the kind of good that makes me hesitant to start reading something else right away because I feel like whatever I read next is going to be a disappointment in comparison.
This book really pissed me off! Be back to add more to review when I’m done ranting and raving!
Okay back.....
First of all, why the hell did Joseph Monninger use different name especially female sounding name. By the time I was 4th or 5th chapter, it dawned on me, there is no way it was written by a female. I literally had to look his name up only to find out he has another name.
Secondly, I thought it was supposed to be a story about the Major’s daughter? Apparently not. It became three stories, only to have me wondering what was the purpose if all of these stories are not wrapped up. For example, what’s the purpose of having Henry and Amos in the story if you don’t have the ending for them?
Thirdly, the way the story end......with a bang? Then adding 2 or 3 pages of Collie in her old age? Seriously, WTH?? It was too rushed at the end. It could’ve been better.l
Oh yeah, another thing, Spanish Influenza? It happened beginning 1918 and died out in 1919. There is no way it hit one gal (isolated case)during WWII and not spread to others in a small town. Give me a break!!
Another thing, where did coffee and lemonade, hot dogs, and etc come from? Thought there was a major shortage of them during WWII?? Food were rationed for that reason! There was hardly any sugar or coffee at that time. I could go on and on but I’m done here.
The book still pisses me off!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
By Joseph Monninger writing under J. P. Francis Publisher: Plume release (July 29, 2014) Like Snow Falling on Cedars, a stirring tale of wartime love
April, 1944. The quiet rural village of Stark, New Hampshire is irrevocably changed by the arrival of 150 German prisoners of war. And one family, unexpectedly divided, must choose between love and country.
Camp Stark is under the command of Major John Brennan, whose beautiful daughter, Collie, will serve as translator. Educated at Smith and devoted to her widowed father, Collie is immediately drawn to Private August Wahrlich, a peaceful poet jaded by war. As international conflict looms on the home front, their passion blinds them to the inevitable dangers ahead.
Inspired by the little-known existence of a real World War II POW camp, The Major’s Daughter is a fresh take on the timeless theme of forbidden love.
I won this book, but I have would have read it anyway…written by Joseph Monninger as J P Francis.
This book takes place during WWII at a prisoner camp in NH, German soldiers were sent there to cut trees & such & work for the paper mill. The major in charge of the camp has his lovely daughter with him & she develops a friendship with one of the German soldiers. I loved the gentleness of the story, even in war time there seemed to be such a calm in NH, a gentle way of life, removed from the war that was going on.
Parts of it made me very sad, Collie's college friend, Estelle, settled in life instead of following her heart & Collie did follow hers, but in the end, who had more sadness, hard to say…..
I learned about this little known prisoner of war camp in Stark,NH. The story was gripping and held my interest throughout the book. The poignancy of the love between Collie and August was sweet and real and hopeful.
Major Brennan was a kind and responsible man, father and camp commandant. He was a living father to Collie.
The secondary love story between Estelle and Mr. Kamal and the path that storyline took added to the overall plot. Choices. Both couples make choices that determine the paths their lives would take.
Honestly, I was unsure until the end what would be the outcome for Collie and August. I've read dozens of historical novels including many about WW II. This was a unique story well told and well worth reading.
I can't wait to read Joseph Monninger's newest book. This will make my 4th one to read!
***What a coincidence! The book prior to this one was Snow Falling on Cedars that I read! That book is 20 years old. Crazy sometimes the little synchronicities of life.
If there's a book about someone falling in love with a German POW during WWII, you know I'm going to read it. I was excited to start this book (even though I don't usually read books set in America), but it fell flat.
Right from the start, I found it difficult to get into it. The writing couldn't hold my interest and there was too much description of the most basic things. There were so, so many descriptions by every single male character about how Collie was uncommonly beautiful and graceful. There was nothing she was bad at and she was praised for the smallest things.
To me the dialogue seemed... off? Like when Collie and her friends discussed men, they sounded like fourteen-year-old girls. But some of the way the characters spoke read like Victorians, if I'm making any sense. Collie's dialogue especially felt very wooden to me.
This is supposed to be a love story, but I wasn't feeling any love between Collie and August. They made sure to state that it wasn't just attraction, but that's all I was getting. (Okay, and this is nitpicky of me, but Collie notices that all the POW's uniforms are baggy and ill-fitting - except August's. His fits him perfectly. Ugh.)
I didn't really see the point of Estelle's part of the story. It didn't add much. Really, there were a lot of characters who didn't add anything to the story.
Having done my own research on POW camps (albeit ones in England), I couldn't get over the leniency towards Collie there. She was openly allowed to wander through the camp and interact with the prisoners. Her father even teases her about August when the German gives her a poem. Um, what?
I nabbed this book in my library's second-hand book sale. I live in New Hampshire and really love historical fiction, so I thought this was right up my alley. Unfortunately, I would call this more of a romance book than a historical fiction. Yes, it is set at Camp Stark, a prison for Germans during World War II, but there was much more about romance than about the camp.
The story is about Collie, the daughter of the camp commander, who works in the office and acts as a translator as she knows German. She is attracted to one of the prisoners, August, and they eventually establish a relationship. Collie also has a friend from college, Estelle, and the two women and their romantic choices are juxtaposed throughout the book. While I understood why the author needed this juxtaposition, I think far too many pages were devoted to Estelle and it detracted from the story.
There is a prominent family, the Heights (obvious symbol there) that owns a mill. The prisoners' work of cutting trees goes to that mill. There are two sons, Henry, who is sweet on Collie, and his vile older brother, Amos. There are some disturbing scenes with Amos and I was hoping he would get his due by the end of the book. He was simply dropped at some point and I felt that this was a loose end. I'm guessing the author wanted him in the book as a comparison to Henry, but he didn't add much to the story except to show how corrupt he was.
There are some historical details in this about the camp that make this book worthwhile, but I think you can learn them from other sources and not have to slog through the longing for unrequited love and then the eventual kisses.
Collie (short for Colleen) Brennan has moved back home after two years at Smith College and lives with her father in Stark, NH. The Second World War is in its final years and a German POW camp is being established in Stark. Collie’s father is the military officer overseeing the camp. Collie does administrative work as well as, having some German knowledge, translates her father’s messages to the prisoners. She finds herself attracted to one of the soldiers, August, and he to her. For a while, she tries to ignore her feelings, knowing it’s an impossible situation, but can’t completely. As the war winds down, they’ll be faced with a decision. What will they do? A Goodreads suggestion from other WWII books read. A look at the war from the home front. I certainly didn't know that there had been German POW camps here in the States during the war. While the setting is historical, the characters are completely fiction. An enjoyable read but I don't know if I would seek out any other books by this author.
In the later years of WW2, a POW camp was created in Stark, NJ for captured German soldiers. It is here that we meet Collie Brennan, whose father is the camp commanders. Since Collie is home from college and has a functional grasp of German, she works for her father as both an office assistant and translator. It is in her role as a translator that she meets and falls in love with August, a German POW.
I enjoyed the setting of experiencing the war from the States and even though we lived in New Hampshire for four years, I never knew there had been a German POW camp there. I must admit that the setting in NH was about 75% of the reason I chose to read this book. It was a bit on the slow side; great side story of Collie's friend in love with a Sikh back in Ohio; great to visit the beautiful state of NH. While I enjoyed most of the book, it was sluggish so I don't think I'll seek out this author anytime soon.
I recently read The Cherry Harvest, which is a similar story about German POWs on American soil during WWII, and was excited to read another. Unfortunately, The Major’s Daughter fell completely flat for me. For a book that is almost 400 pages long, hardly anything interesting happened. The story seemed to drag out, full of side stories and characters that didn’t really bring anything to the table.
Another issue I had was how depressing this book is. I understand a book about WWII is not going to be all sunshine and rainbows, but good grief, couldn’t the author have given us a little something? Marie dies, August ends up shot to death moments from freedom, and Estelle ends up in a loveless marriage to a mean alcoholic. Maybe all that sadness wouldn’t have bothered me so much if the writing had been tightened up and edited down some, but as it was, I was glad to get to the end of it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
The Major’s Daughter by J.P. Francis is an excellently-written piece of historical fiction about a little known fact in American history. During WWII, German soldiers were held at a prison camp called Camp Stark in New Hampshire and put to work as loggers. In this novel, the major’s daughter, Collie falls in love with an Austrian-born prisoner who is the camp’s translator. She, in turn, speaks German and often translates her father’s message to the soldiers.
Her best friend from Smith College, Estelle has a similar plight when she falls in love with the local florist in her hometown in Ohio. He is an East Indian. She plays it safe and marries her childhood friend though the marriage is not a happy one. Collie, on the other hand, chooses to help her young soldier, August, escape and they flee and head towards Canada. Will they make it? Pick up a copy and see!
I enjoy books with some historical information which is why I selected this book . It was about the quiet village of Stark, New Hampshire which became a work camp for Prisoners of War from Germany. The main story however was about the Major's Daughter, her friends and her infatuation and later love for one of the German soldiers. Her father ran the camp and since she knew German; she was his right hand. The story was a disappointment for me as it became a soap opera of sorts about loves, loves lost, taking risks....the info about the camp itself was very sparce ...the book revolved around Collie; her friends, their issues and her infatuation...I felt I was reading a teen novel...
I like the way some authors weave a story around historical facts & this was no exception. Who knew there was a German POW camp in northern New Hampshire during the last year of World War II? It was a nice love story but rather implausible that the commandant's daughter would be allowed enough contact with a prisoner for them to fall in love. That being said, the contrast between the romances of Corrie & her friend Estelle was interesting in one "settling" for what was expected of her & the other risking her life for love. I wish the two characters had been developed more fully, but all in all, I enjoyed it anyway.
I really would give this bok a 4.5. I was entranced by the characters and found myself thinking of them as people just living their lives where I left off and continuing on as I read more. This is for sure a love story. While it is historical fiction, it 100% is mushy and centered around love. That said I enjoyed that part of it!
I didn't know that Camp Stark was a real place and that is fascinating some I lived in New Hampshire for ten years. I look forward to learning more about it and to go and visit the area some day.
2.5 for me. I wanted to read this because I have an interest in Camp Stark in New Hamspshire where my father grew up. I have to say the book was a bit of a disappointment. It was kind of a slog to get through. It definitely had promise but while some of the characters were interesting the the story as a whole was very lackluster. Also as a history teacher myself I found the author did not do his research very well. Some of the conversations as well of the actions of some of the characters would not have been pausible in the 1940's which was irritating to me.
April 1944 a small quiet rural village in New Hampshire is changed by the arrival of 150 German prisoners. The camp is under the command of Major Brennan and his daughter Collie becomes the translator, Collie is well educated and devoted to her widowed father but she is immediately drawn to one of the prisoners who happens to speak English and has a love of poetry. Even though they are opposite sides these two young people are drawn together in a forbidden relationship
I liked that this novel took place in a real place, an interment camp in NH during WW II, that I had never heard of. It was interesting to find out more about what happened here during the war. The story line was okay, but somehow (can't quite put my finger on it) it didn't quite capture me. It was worth reading, I thought.
Sweet, beautiful book. The descriptions make you feel like you are there. Having grown up in the general area, it was very easy to picture "home" from the author's descriptions. Reading about WW2 from "this side" of the ocean was a different perspective. The historical facts were fascinating and the love story was very well-written.
This was one of those books that I thought was going to be pure fluff but I found it a much better read. Well-written about a romance between the major's daughter & a German soldier in a POW camp in Minnesota, gosh, I even shed some tears. Also describes the time period very well with regards to women's roles & decisions.
This book had great well developed characters and an interesting historical perspective of World War Two. I did not think that the conclusion was where this book was headed. I know it's the author's choice but there was no way it should have ended the way it did
Historical fiction, a little piece if American history I was unaware of previous to seeing this book. I enjoyed the story line, good characters. Although it wrapped up Collie's story I felt it left me hanging with Estelle's story. Overall an enjoyable read.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Dull and unforgettable The plot is contrived and slow moving. We add in characters that have no real contribution to the overall plot...which we do not know until the end. The end is rushed, the plots left unfinished.
I started reading this for book club and ran out of time to finish it. I read about 70 pages. I liked it well enough but it also seemed to follow a similar plotline as many of the books we read in my book club. I wouldn't be against finishing it, but I also have lots of other books to read.
I lived there his book. Stark NH holds a secret. It is the site of a German POW station. Prisoners are treated fairly, but work is difficult in the logging industry. The woods holds adventure, bears, and opportunities for escape.