What do you think?
Rate this book
Hearts of Faith #3
Rebellious Heart
In 1763 Massachusetts, Susanna Smith has grown up with everything she's ever wanted, except one thing: an education. Because she's a female, higher learning has been closed to her, but her quick mind and quicker tongue never back down from a challenge. She's determined to put her status to good use, reaching out to the poor and deprived. And she knows when she marries well, she will be able to continue her work with the less fortunate.
Ben Ross grew up a farmer's son and has nothing to his name but his Harvard education. A poor country lawyer, he doesn't see how he'll be able to fulfill his promise to make his father proud of him. When family friends introduce him to the Smith family, he's drawn to quick-witted Susanna but knows her family expects her to marry well. When Susanna's decision to help an innocent woman no matter the cost crosses with Ben's growing disillusionment with their British rulers, the two find themselves bound together in what quickly becomes a very dangerous fight for justice.
Ben Ross grew up a farmer's son and has nothing to his name but his Harvard education. A poor country lawyer, he doesn't see how he'll be able to fulfill his promise to make his father proud of him. When family friends introduce him to the Smith family, he's drawn to quick-witted Susanna but knows her family expects her to marry well. When Susanna's decision to help an innocent woman no matter the cost crosses with Ben's growing disillusionment with their British rulers, the two find themselves bound together in what quickly becomes a very dangerous fight for justice.
385 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 15, 2013
282 people are currently reading
3920 people want to read
About the author
Jody Hedlund
104 books4,712 followersJody Hedlund is the best-selling author of over fifty books and is the winner of numerous awards. She writes sweet historical romances with plenty of sizzle. Find out more at jodyhedlund.com.
Jody lives in central Michigan with her husband, five busy children, and five spoiled cats. When she’s not penning another of her page-turning stories, she loves to spend her time reading, especially when it also involves consuming coffee and chocolate.
Jody lives in central Michigan with her husband, five busy children, and five spoiled cats. When she’s not penning another of her page-turning stories, she loves to spend her time reading, especially when it also involves consuming coffee and chocolate.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 325 reviews
September 14, 2021
Oh my goodness. I was totally taken off guard by how good this story was!! I haven’t read much Jody Hedlund and expected this to be pretty good but this story was VERY good. I literally read this in 1.5 days, I couldn’t put it down. The story was really captivating and I was so interested to see ‘what happens next’ … the friendship/romance that blossomed between the two main characters was really sweet and romantic, the suspense and mystery was so intriguing as well. Definitely one of my favorite stories I’ve read recently!
March 13, 2020
Inspired by John and Abigail Adams Ms Hedlund sculpts a tale of two very different people set in the Pre-Revolutionary War era.
Ben Ross, an attorney and resister to the crown, comes from a farming family. Not much money, but enjoyed a loving relationship with parents who scrimped in order to send Ben to college to better his future. The view to his character showed when his conscience pricked at him as he reluctantly pursued a woman of higher means, then seemingly relieved when her affection turned to another man.
Susanna Smith was a rule follower, loyal to the crown, taught from a young age that she would marry well in order to maintain the standard of living to which she was accustomed. A man like Ben Ross was unacceptable, and her mother would continually steer her away from any such attachment. But a moment in her childhood past haunted her. She recalled being haughty, rebuffing Ben’s help when she was hurt and let him know he was beneath her.
Because her sister fell in love with Ben's best friend their paths crossed often, not always the most comfortable of moments. His disdain of the crown and her loyalist stance created an antagonist relationship....until the day Susanna needed his help.
*******************************************
Thoughts...
Overdone, incongruous kissing scenes and excessive memories of shared kisses had my eyes rolling often. Those could have been left out entirely. But I enjoyed the adversarial relationship between Susanna and Ben, becoming friendly as they grew to appreciate their differences then common goals, then realizing they truly cared for each other.
Loved the faith messages from the household slaves. They truly lived their faith.
All in all, though, it was a good story.
Other characters:
Evil, cruel Lieutenant Wolfe, Redcoat hunting runaways
Dotty: indentured servant, abused and ran away
Tom and Phoebe: Smith's slaves, very content in their life
Sergeant Frazel, red-headed young soldier with a good heart
Richard Cranch: Ben's best friend
Mary Cranch, née Smith: Susanna's sister
Ben Ross, an attorney and resister to the crown, comes from a farming family. Not much money, but enjoyed a loving relationship with parents who scrimped in order to send Ben to college to better his future. The view to his character showed when his conscience pricked at him as he reluctantly pursued a woman of higher means, then seemingly relieved when her affection turned to another man.
Susanna Smith was a rule follower, loyal to the crown, taught from a young age that she would marry well in order to maintain the standard of living to which she was accustomed. A man like Ben Ross was unacceptable, and her mother would continually steer her away from any such attachment. But a moment in her childhood past haunted her. She recalled being haughty, rebuffing Ben’s help when she was hurt and let him know he was beneath her.
Because her sister fell in love with Ben's best friend their paths crossed often, not always the most comfortable of moments. His disdain of the crown and her loyalist stance created an antagonist relationship....until the day Susanna needed his help.
*******************************************
Thoughts...
Overdone, incongruous kissing scenes and excessive memories of shared kisses had my eyes rolling often. Those could have been left out entirely. But I enjoyed the adversarial relationship between Susanna and Ben, becoming friendly as they grew to appreciate their differences then common goals, then realizing they truly cared for each other.
Loved the faith messages from the household slaves. They truly lived their faith.
All in all, though, it was a good story.
Other characters:
Evil, cruel Lieutenant Wolfe, Redcoat hunting runaways
Dotty: indentured servant, abused and ran away
Tom and Phoebe: Smith's slaves, very content in their life
Sergeant Frazel, red-headed young soldier with a good heart
Richard Cranch: Ben's best friend
Mary Cranch, née Smith: Susanna's sister
September 28, 2013
I must admit that as I read Rebellious Heart this past week, my husband had to listen to me say numerous times, “Oh, I am sooo enjoying this book!” Another phrase he heard me repeatedly say was, “This is so good!” Finally, as I finished this story that is set amid the first grumblings of the American Revolution, I uttered, “Oh, that was wonderful! I wish it never had to end!”
With a well written plot and admirable characters, Rebellious Heart caught me up in its grasp right from the start and pulled me into the developing relationship of Susanna Smith and Benjamin Ross. These two characters have so much to recommend them. They care for others, love God and are deep thinkers. But can either of them give up on the idea that they must marry primarily to improve their positions in society? The attraction between Susanna and Ben sizzles. Throw in some heinous murders, Red Coats and a runaway indentured servant and you have a beautiful blend of romance and excitement.
I would recommend Rebellious Heart to all readers who love historical fiction and romance.
I received a complimentary copy of Rebellious Heart from the author and Bethany House Publishers in exchange for an honest review, which I have given.
You can read this review on my blog at: http://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.co....
With a well written plot and admirable characters, Rebellious Heart caught me up in its grasp right from the start and pulled me into the developing relationship of Susanna Smith and Benjamin Ross. These two characters have so much to recommend them. They care for others, love God and are deep thinkers. But can either of them give up on the idea that they must marry primarily to improve their positions in society? The attraction between Susanna and Ben sizzles. Throw in some heinous murders, Red Coats and a runaway indentured servant and you have a beautiful blend of romance and excitement.
I would recommend Rebellious Heart to all readers who love historical fiction and romance.
I received a complimentary copy of Rebellious Heart from the author and Bethany House Publishers in exchange for an honest review, which I have given.
You can read this review on my blog at: http://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.co....
December 26, 2015
I read this right after "Hearts Made Whole" and again had a very hard time pausing to do anything else. This book is most definitely suspense, with a serial killer stalking down young runaway girls...and a heroine who just might have gotten in his way. I kept thinking things would be better or would work out for Ben and Susanna, but things keep getting worse...and worse...and worse...and worse! They're in a situation with no way to win, and only a miracle can save them. Will Susanna regret risking all their lives by trying to help Dotty, a poor runaway?
Thanks to my friends who said "You have to read this book" more than once! :)
16+ for violence (begins with a description of branding for a murderer, etc...murders mentioned.)
Thanks to my friends who said "You have to read this book" more than once! :)
16+ for violence (begins with a description of branding for a murderer, etc...murders mentioned.)
June 30, 2015
If you were alive in the tinderbox of years leading up to the Revolutionary War, would you continue to follow the status quo or would you risk everything to fight tyranny? Rebellious Heart asks this and more. As a historical romance novel, it has the perfect blend of romance & history. Hedlund really excels at keeping the balance between the two. Everything from the setting, to the language to the customs really pulled me into Colonial America of 1763. The pre-cursor activities and events that led up to complete rebellion by the American people made for a very intriguing atmosphere for the story.
I love how the main characters, Susanna Smith & Benjamin Ross, are based on a real-life couple, John & Abigail Adams. I felt that Hedlund created a plausible back story for them. Benjamin isn't an aristocratic gentleman but rather a lawyer in the working class who is trying to move up in the world. Susanna is expected to marry well as fitting her "station," but desires to marry not only for love, but even more so someone that values wit and intellect in a wife. I found her inner conflict to be very compelling - does she obey king and country, parents & society or choose her own path in matters of right & wrong? Benjamin's treasonous leanings are already more obvious, and therein lies the fonder for their witty, intellectual and sometimes fiery encounters.
The opening scene of a murder trial is very well done and packs a punch. It provided the perfect set up, serving both the plot & as well as character building. That is one thing that I love about Hedlund's books - there are some gritty events that take place in the story that really add a sense of realness without going overboard with details. The romance is passionate and real without being too revealing. The historical aspect abounds so as not to be overshadowed by the romance.
All in all, Rebellious Heart offers a winning story of history, romance and suspense that kept me in it's grip, reading late at night and in every spare moment I could find during the week. I heartily recommend it if you're in the mood for a romantic historical.
This review is my honest opinion. Thank you to Bethany House & Jody Hedlund for a complimentary copy of the book.
I love how the main characters, Susanna Smith & Benjamin Ross, are based on a real-life couple, John & Abigail Adams. I felt that Hedlund created a plausible back story for them. Benjamin isn't an aristocratic gentleman but rather a lawyer in the working class who is trying to move up in the world. Susanna is expected to marry well as fitting her "station," but desires to marry not only for love, but even more so someone that values wit and intellect in a wife. I found her inner conflict to be very compelling - does she obey king and country, parents & society or choose her own path in matters of right & wrong? Benjamin's treasonous leanings are already more obvious, and therein lies the fonder for their witty, intellectual and sometimes fiery encounters.
The opening scene of a murder trial is very well done and packs a punch. It provided the perfect set up, serving both the plot & as well as character building. That is one thing that I love about Hedlund's books - there are some gritty events that take place in the story that really add a sense of realness without going overboard with details. The romance is passionate and real without being too revealing. The historical aspect abounds so as not to be overshadowed by the romance.
All in all, Rebellious Heart offers a winning story of history, romance and suspense that kept me in it's grip, reading late at night and in every spare moment I could find during the week. I heartily recommend it if you're in the mood for a romantic historical.
This review is my honest opinion. Thank you to Bethany House & Jody Hedlund for a complimentary copy of the book.
July 12, 2019
Prior to this, I had never read a book by Jody Hedlund. To be honest, I found this book for a discounted price online and only bought it because I saw that it had good reviews. The title, nor the cover, really intrigued me and it sat in a pile of unread books for months. When it was time to select my next book, I decided I wanted something ‘light’ and not overly action-packed. So I picked this one. Boy did this book exceed my expectations! I was hooked from chapter 2 on. It was so well written and had a lot more suspense than I’d expected. This story has great characters, great romance, and a healthy dose of suspense. To top it all off, it’s based on a true story. Jody Hedlund was well researched and wrote the storyline with much expertise. The book built up well, right to the end, and didn’t have that “lull” 2/3-3/4 of the way through that I find so many novels have. All this to say that I am now officially a fan of Jody Hedlund and have added other books of hers to my list. If you’re in the mood for a good Christian romance novel, I strongly recommend this one!
August 17, 2021
2021 Reread: Wow. Such a good, well rounded novel! I love the romance & chemistry between the main characters & the mystery surrounding local murders & a runaway indentured servant. It’s got a social class divide romance most people will enjoy. Their love story felt very real & the reader gets a hefty dose of delicious dialogue between the two throughout the entire story. The book is very romantic ❤️❤️❤️.
September 22, 2013
What I Loved
Susanna was quite the conversationalist--her stubborn nature and quick wit was a delight to read. Despite only being able to pursue her love of learning by listening at the door while her brother worked with his tutor, Susanna is whip-smart and not afraid to show it.
Which not only quickly captured Ben's attention but put the sparks between the two of them flying.
And yet Susanna goes through such growth in this book. At the beginning, she thinks she knows it all--it's the king's way or the highway, and she must snag some wealthy suitor. But she quickly figures out that all is not as it seems. Ben, least of all.
Ben himself changes, too. Still dealing with the snubbing of certain upper class acquiantences even after having established himself as a Harvard-educated lawyer, Ben must deal with prejudice in his own heart.
Did I mention that their love story is set against the backdrop of the pre-Revolutionary colonies and that danger and deception mix into this story in a way that makes it a page turner?
Why I Recommend This Book
History buffs (like me) who love the freedom-flaring of late 18th century America will fall for this fictionalized look into the early love story of John and Abigail Adams.
Also, I've said before that I love when social issues weave their way into novels such as this, and Hedlund does an extraordinary job of not only making the era come alive, but leaving the reader with a taste of what it is to fight for the freedom of those who cannot fight themselves.
A sincere thank you to Harvest House for providing me with a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Susanna was quite the conversationalist--her stubborn nature and quick wit was a delight to read. Despite only being able to pursue her love of learning by listening at the door while her brother worked with his tutor, Susanna is whip-smart and not afraid to show it.
Which not only quickly captured Ben's attention but put the sparks between the two of them flying.
And yet Susanna goes through such growth in this book. At the beginning, she thinks she knows it all--it's the king's way or the highway, and she must snag some wealthy suitor. But she quickly figures out that all is not as it seems. Ben, least of all.
Ben himself changes, too. Still dealing with the snubbing of certain upper class acquiantences even after having established himself as a Harvard-educated lawyer, Ben must deal with prejudice in his own heart.
Did I mention that their love story is set against the backdrop of the pre-Revolutionary colonies and that danger and deception mix into this story in a way that makes it a page turner?
Why I Recommend This Book
History buffs (like me) who love the freedom-flaring of late 18th century America will fall for this fictionalized look into the early love story of John and Abigail Adams.
Also, I've said before that I love when social issues weave their way into novels such as this, and Hedlund does an extraordinary job of not only making the era come alive, but leaving the reader with a taste of what it is to fight for the freedom of those who cannot fight themselves.
A sincere thank you to Harvest House for providing me with a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
February 13, 2015
Rebellious Heart is not surprisingly another satisfying novel by Jody Hedlund. The year is 1763 and Susanna Smith believes the English government has the best interest of its subjects living in Massachusetts. It is satisfying to see Susanna's eyes open as she finds perhaps everything isn't quite what she first thought.
The novel has an element of mystery in addition to romance. Susanna and Ben are both likable characters and it was rewarding to see their growth.
I especially enjoyed the author's afterward explaining the foundation for the novel.
Rebellious Heart is recommended for fans of historical Fiction.
The novel has an element of mystery in addition to romance. Susanna and Ben are both likable characters and it was rewarding to see their growth.
I especially enjoyed the author's afterward explaining the foundation for the novel.
Rebellious Heart is recommended for fans of historical Fiction.
July 22, 2017
What a great story. Absolutely loved the main characters, and I could definitely relate to the whole idea of putting one's fears behind them and taking risks for the greater good. I honestly have nothing bad to say about the novel, and it's probably my favourite Jody Hedlund book to date. I don't know what else she's written that's going to beat this one. 4 stars.
UPDATE
I JUST FOUND OUT THIS IS A SERIES. OH MY GOODNESS MY HEART IS SO HAPPY RIGHT NOW
UPDATE
I JUST FOUND OUT THIS IS A SERIES. OH MY GOODNESS MY HEART IS SO HAPPY RIGHT NOW
January 8, 2022
3.5 stars for this pre-Revolutionary War story set in 1763 Massachusetts. I liked that the overall story was inspired by John and Abigail Adams and I liked the theme of standing against the law for God’s higher purposes. This was more of a murder mystery than I was expecting, and I doubted if some things were even close to being period accurate, but it’s still a good read.
July 26, 2017
All I can say is that it was a good thing that I read Rebellious Heart by Jody Hedlund while I was on vacation sitting by a pool because it afforded me time to keep my pages turning with little interruption. In usual “Jody Hedlund style” we are given a wonderful Historical Fiction novel inspired by the courtship of John (2nd president)and Abigail Adams. She creates two characters that mirror a lot of the same situations that John and Abigail faced- parental disapproval, the Colonial time frame, etc. As always with Jody Hedlund books we get strong characters, an interesting storyline as well as some pretty exciting moments along the way.
Susanna Smith is a smart and well bred young woman whose been raised to understand that she need to make a profitable connection when it comes to marriage. And so when she first meets Benjamin Ross as a young girl she informs him that he is a “nobody, a Farmer and a shoemaker’s son and she would never marry anyone that is from the middling class, her mother wouldn’t allow it.” Thus sets the stage for Benjamin Ross ,years later, a poor country lawyer when he meets up with Susanna again. HIs thoughts of her are that she is still a snobby rich girl thinking herself above everyone. But as Benjamin gets to know Susanna a bit better by happening upon her at a party, he finds her socked away in a room “reading Milton”. He slowly comes to see that Susanna has grown up a bit since he’s seen her last and not only is she a beautiful woman, but she’s smart and kind as well, with a bit of gumption thrown in . Susanna’s heart is huge and she ends up getting involved in helping a runaway indentured servant escape a very cruel master. There is much danger involved with this situation as of course it is illegal to harbor an indentured servant. Susanna gets in a bit over her head and Ben comes to her rescue more than once. As he helps her escape one bad situation after another their relationship as well as their understanding and respect for each other just continues to grow.
I have to say that I really enjoyed this book. It was nice to read a book in this time frame, just pre-revolutionary war as I haven't read many historical fiction that have been written during that time. The characters were interesting and compelling and when I realized, after I finished the book, that it was loosely based on the courtship of the real couple - John and Abigail Adams -that made it even more captivating for me. I think that those that enjoy a great and well researched historical christian novel with engaging characters, some twists and turns and a stand up and cheer ending, will definitely enjoy this one, please pick up Rebellious Heart- great read!
5 stars
I was given a free copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Susanna Smith is a smart and well bred young woman whose been raised to understand that she need to make a profitable connection when it comes to marriage. And so when she first meets Benjamin Ross as a young girl she informs him that he is a “nobody, a Farmer and a shoemaker’s son and she would never marry anyone that is from the middling class, her mother wouldn’t allow it.” Thus sets the stage for Benjamin Ross ,years later, a poor country lawyer when he meets up with Susanna again. HIs thoughts of her are that she is still a snobby rich girl thinking herself above everyone. But as Benjamin gets to know Susanna a bit better by happening upon her at a party, he finds her socked away in a room “reading Milton”. He slowly comes to see that Susanna has grown up a bit since he’s seen her last and not only is she a beautiful woman, but she’s smart and kind as well, with a bit of gumption thrown in . Susanna’s heart is huge and she ends up getting involved in helping a runaway indentured servant escape a very cruel master. There is much danger involved with this situation as of course it is illegal to harbor an indentured servant. Susanna gets in a bit over her head and Ben comes to her rescue more than once. As he helps her escape one bad situation after another their relationship as well as their understanding and respect for each other just continues to grow.
I have to say that I really enjoyed this book. It was nice to read a book in this time frame, just pre-revolutionary war as I haven't read many historical fiction that have been written during that time. The characters were interesting and compelling and when I realized, after I finished the book, that it was loosely based on the courtship of the real couple - John and Abigail Adams -that made it even more captivating for me. I think that those that enjoy a great and well researched historical christian novel with engaging characters, some twists and turns and a stand up and cheer ending, will definitely enjoy this one, please pick up Rebellious Heart- great read!
5 stars
I was given a free copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
September 23, 2013
Wow what an amazing story! I had no idea that "Rebellious Heart" was based on the famous Abigail and John Adams! I left this novel having a new found respect for this couple who had such a great affect on history! Jody did a wonderful job of weaving a beautiful history lesson with plenty of surprises!
I loved the characters Susanna and Ben who represented this amazing couple! They definitely were a perfect match for each other from the very beginning since they both had a heart of compassion for the poor and disadvantage. It greatly encouraged me to continue to keep putting my “love glasses on” as the singer Beckah Shae sings and help the people around me. There might be times where the government says that I can’t help so-and-so, but as these beautiful characters portray to us that helping others is never wrong. However with that being said I hope that I don’t have to stand trial such as a few of the characters almost did!
However, my favorite character hands down was Mr. Cranch! I can see why Ben liked him because he has such a good humor and cheer anyone up. I was really glad that he was included in the story, but was definitely not happy about the Lieutenant! Jody did amazing job of having the reader (in my opinion) despise the bad guy! He was horrible and I just wanted him to get in trouble with his superiors because of his ruthlessness and anger! Also, Grandmother Eve was a second favorite of mine with her compassionate ways!
My only complaint is that I wish every history lesson was given in the same inspiring, romantic, and suspenseful way that Jody had told this one! "Rebellious Heart" was an extremely insightful novel into history (even if some of it was fictional) and left me on the edge of my seat for most of the duration! The romance itself was fantastic (as always)! I strongly recommend it!
Thank you Jody for letting me be an influencer for this amazing novel as well as receiving a free novel in exchange for my honest opinion!
I loved the characters Susanna and Ben who represented this amazing couple! They definitely were a perfect match for each other from the very beginning since they both had a heart of compassion for the poor and disadvantage. It greatly encouraged me to continue to keep putting my “love glasses on” as the singer Beckah Shae sings and help the people around me. There might be times where the government says that I can’t help so-and-so, but as these beautiful characters portray to us that helping others is never wrong. However with that being said I hope that I don’t have to stand trial such as a few of the characters almost did!
However, my favorite character hands down was Mr. Cranch! I can see why Ben liked him because he has such a good humor and cheer anyone up. I was really glad that he was included in the story, but was definitely not happy about the Lieutenant! Jody did amazing job of having the reader (in my opinion) despise the bad guy! He was horrible and I just wanted him to get in trouble with his superiors because of his ruthlessness and anger! Also, Grandmother Eve was a second favorite of mine with her compassionate ways!
My only complaint is that I wish every history lesson was given in the same inspiring, romantic, and suspenseful way that Jody had told this one! "Rebellious Heart" was an extremely insightful novel into history (even if some of it was fictional) and left me on the edge of my seat for most of the duration! The romance itself was fantastic (as always)! I strongly recommend it!
Thank you Jody for letting me be an influencer for this amazing novel as well as receiving a free novel in exchange for my honest opinion!
August 12, 2014
Review on Amazon: http://www.amazon.com/review/RF1YLUPH...
Review on my blog (to be posted 8/26): http://christianbookshelfreviews.blog...
Rebellious Heart was another lovely read from Jody Hedlund. Having read and enjoyed three of her previous novels, I wasn't surprised that this was also a good book. I thought the characters were great and I really liked how the romance story played out.
The book starts off fabulously and grabbed my attention from the first sentence -- "He's guilty of murder." I loved the suspenseful aspects of Rebellious Heart and the moments that got your heart racing because of the danger characters faced.
Overall, a wonderful book that I loved reading! I also enjoyed reading the Author's Note at the end of the book and finding out the story was inspired by President John Adams and his wife, Abigail. That made the story even more special, knowing certain things that happened in this story took place in real life. I recommend this book to fans of historical romance.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
Review on my blog (to be posted 8/26): http://christianbookshelfreviews.blog...
Rebellious Heart was another lovely read from Jody Hedlund. Having read and enjoyed three of her previous novels, I wasn't surprised that this was also a good book. I thought the characters were great and I really liked how the romance story played out.
The book starts off fabulously and grabbed my attention from the first sentence -- "He's guilty of murder." I loved the suspenseful aspects of Rebellious Heart and the moments that got your heart racing because of the danger characters faced.
Overall, a wonderful book that I loved reading! I also enjoyed reading the Author's Note at the end of the book and finding out the story was inspired by President John Adams and his wife, Abigail. That made the story even more special, knowing certain things that happened in this story took place in real life. I recommend this book to fans of historical romance.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
December 28, 2013
Setting: Revolutionary Massachusetts.
3 1/2 Stars
Though newly minted attorney Benjamin Ross has pulled himself up by his bootstraps to attend Harvard, he fears he'll never be anything more than the poor cobbler's son in the eyes of his neighbours in colonial Massachusetts. Just the sight of the seemingly haughty Susanna Smith reminds him of his humble beginnings and her childish taunts years ago. But Susanna's heart is now infused with a woman's compassion and faith, and when she shelters an indentured servant on the run from a sadistic British officer, she turns to Benjamin for advice and protection. Now that they are thrust together as co-conspirators in a hanging offence, they begin to realize they have more in common than they ever thought. The author really did a good job with creating three dimensional,deeply human and realistically flawed characters in this tale set in Revolutionary Massachusetts.
Though it's moments of high drama may not appeal and seem forced to some readers, I felt the plot steamed along at a good enough pace for me.
3 1/2 Stars
Though newly minted attorney Benjamin Ross has pulled himself up by his bootstraps to attend Harvard, he fears he'll never be anything more than the poor cobbler's son in the eyes of his neighbours in colonial Massachusetts. Just the sight of the seemingly haughty Susanna Smith reminds him of his humble beginnings and her childish taunts years ago. But Susanna's heart is now infused with a woman's compassion and faith, and when she shelters an indentured servant on the run from a sadistic British officer, she turns to Benjamin for advice and protection. Now that they are thrust together as co-conspirators in a hanging offence, they begin to realize they have more in common than they ever thought. The author really did a good job with creating three dimensional,deeply human and realistically flawed characters in this tale set in Revolutionary Massachusetts.
Though it's moments of high drama may not appeal and seem forced to some readers, I felt the plot steamed along at a good enough pace for me.
November 29, 2021
Set in the years shortly before the Revolutionary War began but British push for control was already rumbling in Massachusetts, this story was based on the courtship of John Adams and Abigail Smith. Susanna was a wonderful female MC with her strength and courage to do what was right along with her desire for education. Neither trait common in that time period. Ben Ross had pushed beyond his upbringing to attend college and become a lawyer supported by his farmer father. Each of them becomes involved in different ways in the beginning of the patriot cause which may in the end cost them their lives. Thoroughly enjoyed this pre-Revolutionary War story from start to finish.
Hedlund's afternotes explaining the correlation between the story and the courtship of John Adams and Abigail Smith were very enlightening and helpful.
Excellent read for those who are interested in the Revolutionary War time period. This is one of three books in Hedlund's Hearts of Faith series, but each can be read as a stand alone.
Hedlund's afternotes explaining the correlation between the story and the courtship of John Adams and Abigail Smith were very enlightening and helpful.
Excellent read for those who are interested in the Revolutionary War time period. This is one of three books in Hedlund's Hearts of Faith series, but each can be read as a stand alone.
September 2, 2015
This wasn't my favorite from Jody Hedlund but it was still a good read. More romance than I enjoy reading. The first part kept me very interested and 3/4 of the way through it just turned into paragraphs of longings for each other and I got a little bored. Susannah and Ben were great leads though it just got a little too mushy and ended up distracting me from the plot!
May 4, 2018
I dislike giving books only two stars. In reality, this book was closer to 2.5 stars, but Goodreads doesn't give me that option yet, so I had to give it 2 and list it on this review as 2.5.
What I Liked: Jody Hedlund is definitely a very talented author. She painted such a vivid picture of life in the 1760's, both the good things and bad things. I felt for every single character that I was supposed to like and I learned several new things about this time period that were quite shocking. I knew punishment for certain sins was quite severe, but I didn't realize just how severe.
But I don't want to focus on the negative and sad parts of that time period for this whole review, there are also some very lovely aspects of this time period portrayed in the story. I loved how Susannah and her mother sought to care for the widows in their community who desperately needed help and how Susannah graciously taught younger girls. I really liked that.
Something else I really appreciated was how this author depicted Susannah's relationship with her mother. Even though Susannah did not agree with her mother on several issues and was quite frustrated several times, she was not characterized by showing disrespect to her mother. I liked how Susannah strived to remember the good attributes of her mother instead of always focusing on the negative.
All of the characters were very well developed and I felt like I could picture everyone very well. I also really enjoyed the growth of both Susannah and Ben as they grew in their relationships with the Lord. I so enjoyed how Susannah turned to the Lord and truly sought to grow in her faith.
What I Didn't Like: This is not an aspect of the review that I like to write, but yet, I did have to give this book 2.5 stars for a reason. I will try to list these issues as succinctly as possible without being too negative.
The main complaint I had with this book and that kept taking stars away from the end rating of this book was the romance. I do not mind romance in books if they are handled in a pure and tasteful way. I believe God is the author of love and He created marriage between a man and woman, but when I'm reading in the book how this couple is constantly wanting to kiss each other, as well as noticing each other's physical facial features all the time, then that's just too much for me. God designed love is supposed to be about growing in your faith together and being selfless, and while Ben and Susannah were definitely selfless, their physical attraction to one another was focused too much in this book for me, especially for a couple not even married yet. (Though this is my humble opinion. Someone might have a completely different opinion than mine.)
Other than that, I really can't say that I had any major disputes about this book.
I give this book 2.5 stars for an interesting look into the 1760's and for enjoyable, well formed characters that grew in their relationships with the Lord.
What I Liked: Jody Hedlund is definitely a very talented author. She painted such a vivid picture of life in the 1760's, both the good things and bad things. I felt for every single character that I was supposed to like and I learned several new things about this time period that were quite shocking. I knew punishment for certain sins was quite severe, but I didn't realize just how severe.
But I don't want to focus on the negative and sad parts of that time period for this whole review, there are also some very lovely aspects of this time period portrayed in the story. I loved how Susannah and her mother sought to care for the widows in their community who desperately needed help and how Susannah graciously taught younger girls. I really liked that.
Something else I really appreciated was how this author depicted Susannah's relationship with her mother. Even though Susannah did not agree with her mother on several issues and was quite frustrated several times, she was not characterized by showing disrespect to her mother. I liked how Susannah strived to remember the good attributes of her mother instead of always focusing on the negative.
All of the characters were very well developed and I felt like I could picture everyone very well. I also really enjoyed the growth of both Susannah and Ben as they grew in their relationships with the Lord. I so enjoyed how Susannah turned to the Lord and truly sought to grow in her faith.
What I Didn't Like: This is not an aspect of the review that I like to write, but yet, I did have to give this book 2.5 stars for a reason. I will try to list these issues as succinctly as possible without being too negative.
The main complaint I had with this book and that kept taking stars away from the end rating of this book was the romance. I do not mind romance in books if they are handled in a pure and tasteful way. I believe God is the author of love and He created marriage between a man and woman, but when I'm reading in the book how this couple is constantly wanting to kiss each other, as well as noticing each other's physical facial features all the time, then that's just too much for me. God designed love is supposed to be about growing in your faith together and being selfless, and while Ben and Susannah were definitely selfless, their physical attraction to one another was focused too much in this book for me, especially for a couple not even married yet. (Though this is my humble opinion. Someone might have a completely different opinion than mine.)
Other than that, I really can't say that I had any major disputes about this book.
I give this book 2.5 stars for an interesting look into the 1760's and for enjoyable, well formed characters that grew in their relationships with the Lord.
September 23, 2013
It is so hard to pick a favorite author because there are so many good authors out there and I love so many different books. But one of the authors that I have found to like every single one of their books is Jody Hedlund. She has yet to disappoint me.. and I doubt she ever will! Each of her books have gripped my emotions and torn at my heart-strings. The romance she writes sets my heart pumping and the characters she creates have all become my friends. Each setting is full of history lessons that come to life through the fiction stories she writes. I love the poetic way she writes her stories and each book leaves me smiling and sighing happily.
With all that being said, Rebellious Heart was everything and more that I wanted it to be. Have you ever just stared at the cover of a book, wanting to read it but waiting because you know this is the only time you will experience the book for the first time? That’s what I did with Rebellious Heart. I just had to hold it for a while, soaking in the freshness of the story, the mystery of what it held. But as I opened this book, I was whirled away to the 18th Century where I fell in love with these characters.
Susanna Smith has everything she wants. That is, except for a higher education. Living in a world where women do not receive that kind of education, Susanna does what she can to soak in any kind of education she can find. She is determined to marry well and help the less fortunate with their needs. Susanna also believes herself to be loyal to the crown.
Ben grew up as a farmer’s son and despite his Harvard education, still finds himself looked down on for his poor background. As a lawyer, Ben is also eager to help the less fortunate. When he meets Susanna, he is quickly drawn to her, though he knows she intends to marry well.
While the two hold opposing views on the king and the crown, they find themselves needing the other’s help and one of them finds their view on the crown wavering.
Rebellious Heart was written as a fictional account of the courtship between John and Abigail Adams. I loved the history found in this book and I love the details that Jody Hedlund weaved into this story. There is nothing about that book that I didn’t like except the fact that it ended. I felt the emotions that these characters felt. I lived right beside them as I entered their world. I couldn’t decide if I wanted to read this book slow and soak it all in or read it fast so I could find out what happened next. I think I did a little bit of both. If you are looking for a sigh-worthy romance that will get your heart racing and tug at your emotions, definitely pick up Rebellious Heart. You will not be disappointed.
I received a free copy of this book from the author and Bethany House Publishers in exchange for my review. I received no compensation for this review and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions stated are my own.
Leah B.
Must Love Books
mustlovereading.wordpress.com
With all that being said, Rebellious Heart was everything and more that I wanted it to be. Have you ever just stared at the cover of a book, wanting to read it but waiting because you know this is the only time you will experience the book for the first time? That’s what I did with Rebellious Heart. I just had to hold it for a while, soaking in the freshness of the story, the mystery of what it held. But as I opened this book, I was whirled away to the 18th Century where I fell in love with these characters.
Susanna Smith has everything she wants. That is, except for a higher education. Living in a world where women do not receive that kind of education, Susanna does what she can to soak in any kind of education she can find. She is determined to marry well and help the less fortunate with their needs. Susanna also believes herself to be loyal to the crown.
Ben grew up as a farmer’s son and despite his Harvard education, still finds himself looked down on for his poor background. As a lawyer, Ben is also eager to help the less fortunate. When he meets Susanna, he is quickly drawn to her, though he knows she intends to marry well.
While the two hold opposing views on the king and the crown, they find themselves needing the other’s help and one of them finds their view on the crown wavering.
Rebellious Heart was written as a fictional account of the courtship between John and Abigail Adams. I loved the history found in this book and I love the details that Jody Hedlund weaved into this story. There is nothing about that book that I didn’t like except the fact that it ended. I felt the emotions that these characters felt. I lived right beside them as I entered their world. I couldn’t decide if I wanted to read this book slow and soak it all in or read it fast so I could find out what happened next. I think I did a little bit of both. If you are looking for a sigh-worthy romance that will get your heart racing and tug at your emotions, definitely pick up Rebellious Heart. You will not be disappointed.
I received a free copy of this book from the author and Bethany House Publishers in exchange for my review. I received no compensation for this review and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions stated are my own.
Leah B.
Must Love Books
mustlovereading.wordpress.com
September 24, 2013
•°o•:*¨¨*:•. RATED R: Violent/Disturbing Images.•:*¨¨*:• o°•
Ch. 1 - Rated R for violent and disturbing images, is what I would say if this were a movie. Crab Tree Joe is most likely innocent, but following sentence we are given the gruesome details of his unfortunate and brutal punishment as it is served upon him.
Ch. 2 Pg.26-27 Susanna is only 5-6 and Ben is 15. Her words chilled him. "If he had ever held any admiration for Mrs. Quincy's granddaughter, even just briefly from a distance..." Really? SHE IS FIVE! This is perverse.
Ch. 2 Ben does not see Susanna again for 13 years. At 28, he observes her for the first time when she is in the balcony of the court room. That evening he attends a party given by her grandmother. His VERY FIRST interaction with her is alone in a sitting room where he immediately eggs her on, and after a few brief exchanges, gets close enough to feel her ragged, warm breath on his wrist as he caresses the long slender line of her jaw (pg.28). Hmmm…it is 1763 and apparently neither has any sense of propriety.
SO FAR, I AM UNIMPRESSED AND WOULD RATHER NOT READ ON....But, I am going to give it a fair chance and continue.
I put the book down for a couple of weeks, just not into it. I finally picked it back up and completed it. The story is interesting, but the romantic relationship is so heavily condensed. It felt forced to me. Of course they have their ups and downs, but it was still rushed. Part of the story line has to do with one individual’s VERY disturbing criminal activity towards women, as well as violent tendencies towards anyone he feels is beneath him. It reminds me of the very violent content found in the TV series “Criminal Minds”. After a couple of episodes, I determined I could not watch it because it is so vile and perverse, and I found this book to be similarly aligned. Therefore, I really did not enjoy that aspect of the story.
The author states in her notes that her story is inspired by John and Abigail Adams relationship. Although, there is no historical reference for most of their early years, she is “attempting to loosely recreate that time in their courtship” and adds snippets of details within her work of fiction. Had I not read her notes at the end, I would have had no idea this was the case. Overall, the disturbances of this book bothered me more than the story itself, so I can not, in good conscience, recommend this book.
I give it 2 out of 5 stars and would recommend not it to others.
You can read more about this author at: JodyHedlund.com
Included at the end of the book: Author’s Notes
This copy was purchased by me and I am offering my honest opinions for no compensation.
376 Pages
Bethany House Publishing © 2013
Read Sept.3 – Sept. 16
Reviewed September 24, 2013
Ch. 1 - Rated R for violent and disturbing images, is what I would say if this were a movie. Crab Tree Joe is most likely innocent, but following sentence we are given the gruesome details of his unfortunate and brutal punishment as it is served upon him.
Ch. 2 Pg.26-27 Susanna is only 5-6 and Ben is 15. Her words chilled him. "If he had ever held any admiration for Mrs. Quincy's granddaughter, even just briefly from a distance..." Really? SHE IS FIVE! This is perverse.
Ch. 2 Ben does not see Susanna again for 13 years. At 28, he observes her for the first time when she is in the balcony of the court room. That evening he attends a party given by her grandmother. His VERY FIRST interaction with her is alone in a sitting room where he immediately eggs her on, and after a few brief exchanges, gets close enough to feel her ragged, warm breath on his wrist as he caresses the long slender line of her jaw (pg.28). Hmmm…it is 1763 and apparently neither has any sense of propriety.
SO FAR, I AM UNIMPRESSED AND WOULD RATHER NOT READ ON....But, I am going to give it a fair chance and continue.
I put the book down for a couple of weeks, just not into it. I finally picked it back up and completed it. The story is interesting, but the romantic relationship is so heavily condensed. It felt forced to me. Of course they have their ups and downs, but it was still rushed. Part of the story line has to do with one individual’s VERY disturbing criminal activity towards women, as well as violent tendencies towards anyone he feels is beneath him. It reminds me of the very violent content found in the TV series “Criminal Minds”. After a couple of episodes, I determined I could not watch it because it is so vile and perverse, and I found this book to be similarly aligned. Therefore, I really did not enjoy that aspect of the story.
The author states in her notes that her story is inspired by John and Abigail Adams relationship. Although, there is no historical reference for most of their early years, she is “attempting to loosely recreate that time in their courtship” and adds snippets of details within her work of fiction. Had I not read her notes at the end, I would have had no idea this was the case. Overall, the disturbances of this book bothered me more than the story itself, so I can not, in good conscience, recommend this book.
I give it 2 out of 5 stars and would recommend not it to others.
You can read more about this author at: JodyHedlund.com
Included at the end of the book: Author’s Notes
This copy was purchased by me and I am offering my honest opinions for no compensation.
376 Pages
Bethany House Publishing © 2013
Read Sept.3 – Sept. 16
Reviewed September 24, 2013
August 21, 2023
I’d be hard pressed to name my favorite Jody Hedlund book. But it might be this one. I first read Rebellious Heart a few years ago, and as I’ve read a lot of Jody’s books since, so I wanted to reread and remind myself why I love this one so much, and find out if it’s still at the top of my list.
It’s 1763. Young country lawyer Benjamin Ross is trying to make his corner of Massachusetts a better place. That takes several forms… defending the innocent in court, helping with local smuggling operations to help poor families survive England’s taxes, and discussing the issues with like-minded patriots.
Susanna Smith has a sharp mind and a sharp wit- but being a girl she’s always been denied the education she longs for. She plans to marry well so that she can continue to help the poor in the community. When Ben’s best friend becomes Susanna’s sister’s suitor, Susanna and Ben find themselves unlikely friends. Ben is drawn to Susanna’s intelligence and willingness to do verbal battle with him, but he knows her family would never permit his suit.
Susanna struggles to understand the dissent against England until Ben opens her eyes to the injustice around them. She still clings to her loyalty until faced with protecting the life of a runaway indentured servant and the unbelievable cruelty of British Lieutenant Wolfe. Entering a new world in her quest for mercy, Ben becomes her confidant and advisor. But the closer she grows to Ben, the more Susanna finds that her world has grown dangerous as she navigates secret rebellion in the years leading up to the Revolution.
My favorite aspect of Jody’s writing is that she takes real history and weaves it into fiction. A large part of this fictional story is actually the origins of the real love story between John and Abigail Adams! I love reading the author’s notes to find out what’s real and what was just story. I love Susanna’s character and her real emotions and struggles. I love Ben and his strong stand. The cruelty in Lieutenant Wolfe eerily reminds me of Captain Simcoe in the (excellent) TV series TURN about Washington’s spies. As modern Americans, most lovers of history have questioned ourselves as to which side we would have chosen if we had been there. We like to believe we would have been Patriots, but Jody brings the questions of loyalty to our rulers as believers into the conversation. What does it take to turn a loyal heart to rebellion? How much cruelty and injustice can we take before being called by God to stand for change?
This is why I LOVE this novel. This is why it might truly be my favorite amongst favorites. Because there is a lovely romance, but it stands alongside deeper questions that speak to the heart of every history loving American and every Christian.
It’s 1763. Young country lawyer Benjamin Ross is trying to make his corner of Massachusetts a better place. That takes several forms… defending the innocent in court, helping with local smuggling operations to help poor families survive England’s taxes, and discussing the issues with like-minded patriots.
Susanna Smith has a sharp mind and a sharp wit- but being a girl she’s always been denied the education she longs for. She plans to marry well so that she can continue to help the poor in the community. When Ben’s best friend becomes Susanna’s sister’s suitor, Susanna and Ben find themselves unlikely friends. Ben is drawn to Susanna’s intelligence and willingness to do verbal battle with him, but he knows her family would never permit his suit.
Susanna struggles to understand the dissent against England until Ben opens her eyes to the injustice around them. She still clings to her loyalty until faced with protecting the life of a runaway indentured servant and the unbelievable cruelty of British Lieutenant Wolfe. Entering a new world in her quest for mercy, Ben becomes her confidant and advisor. But the closer she grows to Ben, the more Susanna finds that her world has grown dangerous as she navigates secret rebellion in the years leading up to the Revolution.
My favorite aspect of Jody’s writing is that she takes real history and weaves it into fiction. A large part of this fictional story is actually the origins of the real love story between John and Abigail Adams! I love reading the author’s notes to find out what’s real and what was just story. I love Susanna’s character and her real emotions and struggles. I love Ben and his strong stand. The cruelty in Lieutenant Wolfe eerily reminds me of Captain Simcoe in the (excellent) TV series TURN about Washington’s spies. As modern Americans, most lovers of history have questioned ourselves as to which side we would have chosen if we had been there. We like to believe we would have been Patriots, but Jody brings the questions of loyalty to our rulers as believers into the conversation. What does it take to turn a loyal heart to rebellion? How much cruelty and injustice can we take before being called by God to stand for change?
This is why I LOVE this novel. This is why it might truly be my favorite amongst favorites. Because there is a lovely romance, but it stands alongside deeper questions that speak to the heart of every history loving American and every Christian.
February 16, 2015
WOW! I completely loved this book. It is such a good read.
I was completely immersed in the plot, the characters, and the history that was packed into this novel. This book is beautifully written.
Susanna Smith is a compassionate and independent woman. She has a love for education and reading, but she has limited access to learning. Benjamin Ross is a poor lawyer who has a passion for speaking the truth and standing for justice. He desires to prove himself and do something important with his life.
Susanna believes in following the law and respecting authority. But, when she meets a runaway indentured servant, her beliefs are thrown into disarray. She struggles between following the law and having compassion for this woman. Will she break the law in the name of doing what is right? And will Ben’s influence on her be good or bad?
In a past encounter when they were children, Susanna made a hurtful and cutting remark to Ben that has been etched in both their memories. This provides for quite an interesting and amusing first interaction in the book, when, as adults, their lives intersect again. Ben wants to push Susanna’s buttons and see how she will react to him now that they are adults. From this scene, it is immediately apparent that Susanna and Ben will have dynamic interactions throughout the book.
I think this quote is the most perfect way to describe Ben, and also what it is like to read his and Susanna’s scenes together:
“He was infuriating and intriguing and altogether likable at the same time” (63).
Ben and Susanna’s relationship was my favorite part of this book. It was always exciting and entertaining to read their scenes together, whether they were arguing, discussing important topics, or becoming close friends. I completely loved them together and they had a chemistry that jumped off the page. Their time together was always filled with intelligent conversation, romance, and tension.
In their relationship, Ben and Susanna challenged each other, and through their conversations, they were able to sharpen each other and make each other better. It reminded me of this verse:
“As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another.” Proverbs 27:17, NIV
This seriously has to be one of my favorite literary couples. Their chemistry and the tension between them provided for a dynamic relationship.
A wonderful book- I loved it. One of my favorites of the year and I can’t wait to read it again.
*I received a free copy of this book from Bethany House in exchange for my honest review.*
I was completely immersed in the plot, the characters, and the history that was packed into this novel. This book is beautifully written.
Susanna Smith is a compassionate and independent woman. She has a love for education and reading, but she has limited access to learning. Benjamin Ross is a poor lawyer who has a passion for speaking the truth and standing for justice. He desires to prove himself and do something important with his life.
Susanna believes in following the law and respecting authority. But, when she meets a runaway indentured servant, her beliefs are thrown into disarray. She struggles between following the law and having compassion for this woman. Will she break the law in the name of doing what is right? And will Ben’s influence on her be good or bad?
In a past encounter when they were children, Susanna made a hurtful and cutting remark to Ben that has been etched in both their memories. This provides for quite an interesting and amusing first interaction in the book, when, as adults, their lives intersect again. Ben wants to push Susanna’s buttons and see how she will react to him now that they are adults. From this scene, it is immediately apparent that Susanna and Ben will have dynamic interactions throughout the book.
I think this quote is the most perfect way to describe Ben, and also what it is like to read his and Susanna’s scenes together:
“He was infuriating and intriguing and altogether likable at the same time” (63).
Ben and Susanna’s relationship was my favorite part of this book. It was always exciting and entertaining to read their scenes together, whether they were arguing, discussing important topics, or becoming close friends. I completely loved them together and they had a chemistry that jumped off the page. Their time together was always filled with intelligent conversation, romance, and tension.
In their relationship, Ben and Susanna challenged each other, and through their conversations, they were able to sharpen each other and make each other better. It reminded me of this verse:
“As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another.” Proverbs 27:17, NIV
This seriously has to be one of my favorite literary couples. Their chemistry and the tension between them provided for a dynamic relationship.
A wonderful book- I loved it. One of my favorites of the year and I can’t wait to read it again.
*I received a free copy of this book from Bethany House in exchange for my honest review.*
September 9, 2013
Every book that I have read by Jody Hedlund has been placed on my favorites shelf, Rebellious Heart will now be joining the rest of them.
Rebellious Heart brought me back in time to 1763, the brink of the Revolutionary War. There are whispers in the wind of unfair taxation, underground organizations of smuggling over taxed items, but to some, it a fluke, their king would not treat his people across the ocean so unfairly. They were all one. Susanna Smith is one of these people who couldn't believe that their king could be unjust. Susanna had been raised to respect and follow authority, so by her thinking, the king is only taxing what is truly needed.
When Benjamin Ross comes back to town, after returning from law school and represent the town's hermit for a brutal murder in the area, Susanna is placed in Ben's path many times. In their encounters, she learns that Ben's leanings are not of her own thoughts and fears that his treasonous thoughts could be harmful for her, however when Dotty, a runaway indentured servant finds Susanna at her home, Susanna starts to think about things that Ben has spoken about in regards to freedom.
Jody Hedlund has yet again taken historical fact and has weaved with fiction to bring such a compelling story that is hard to put down. It is fantastic to read Ben and Susanna's story and find the true historical details of the couple that this is loosely based around.
The characters jump off of the pages. The passion that Ben carries with him, impassioned me and it was easy to root for him and his endeavors through the book. As Susanna pressed on with her learning's and understanding, I wanted to cheer for her and urge her to keep going. And with the villain of the book, Jody Hedlund can create fantastic monster. It kept me guessing who it really was and had me rooting for justice in the end.
Thank you to Bethany House, I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest opinion.
Rebellious Heart brought me back in time to 1763, the brink of the Revolutionary War. There are whispers in the wind of unfair taxation, underground organizations of smuggling over taxed items, but to some, it a fluke, their king would not treat his people across the ocean so unfairly. They were all one. Susanna Smith is one of these people who couldn't believe that their king could be unjust. Susanna had been raised to respect and follow authority, so by her thinking, the king is only taxing what is truly needed.
When Benjamin Ross comes back to town, after returning from law school and represent the town's hermit for a brutal murder in the area, Susanna is placed in Ben's path many times. In their encounters, she learns that Ben's leanings are not of her own thoughts and fears that his treasonous thoughts could be harmful for her, however when Dotty, a runaway indentured servant finds Susanna at her home, Susanna starts to think about things that Ben has spoken about in regards to freedom.
Jody Hedlund has yet again taken historical fact and has weaved with fiction to bring such a compelling story that is hard to put down. It is fantastic to read Ben and Susanna's story and find the true historical details of the couple that this is loosely based around.
The characters jump off of the pages. The passion that Ben carries with him, impassioned me and it was easy to root for him and his endeavors through the book. As Susanna pressed on with her learning's and understanding, I wanted to cheer for her and urge her to keep going. And with the villain of the book, Jody Hedlund can create fantastic monster. It kept me guessing who it really was and had me rooting for justice in the end.
Thank you to Bethany House, I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest opinion.
December 3, 2015
Why is it every time I read a piece of fiction set in colonial times I wind up feeling extremely relieved I didn’t have to live in that era? Why must you crush my fantasy colonial dream with all your stinking reality! Sigh.
The character development of the main characters in this novel is quite well done, I think. At first I really had a hard time liking either of them and thought they really deserved each other. But you gradually get to see their good qualities and realize how much they need each other. The plot is well developed and well executed. And the themes are expertly woven in, though not entirely resolved (at least not to my own personal satisfaction), which I think is probably deliberate considering the nature of them.
There really isn’t much wrong with the book except that it’s just not subjectively my “cup of tea.” I begrudgingly enjoyed it.
The character development of the main characters in this novel is quite well done, I think. At first I really had a hard time liking either of them and thought they really deserved each other. But you gradually get to see their good qualities and realize how much they need each other. The plot is well developed and well executed. And the themes are expertly woven in, though not entirely resolved (at least not to my own personal satisfaction), which I think is probably deliberate considering the nature of them.
There really isn’t much wrong with the book except that it’s just not subjectively my “cup of tea.” I begrudgingly enjoyed it.
May 15, 2023
A compelling tale of a young woman in 1760s Massachusetts coming to terms with her pride and situation and facing the lengths we must go to help those in need and fight for the ones we love.
Very well written and moving story from Jody Hedlund.
Very well written and moving story from Jody Hedlund.
August 26, 2013
Ten years ago, Susannah Smith was rather rude towards cordwainer’s son Benjamin Ross, but now he’s a Harvard-qualified lawyer and eligible bachelor—eligible in the opinion of almost everyone. But not her mother. Susannah’s sister, Mary, is courting Benjamin’s best friend, which brings the four of them together and Susannah discovers there is more to the adult Benjamin than her childhood self knew.
The story starts in 1763, as the American colonists are beginning to rebel against their English rulers, and their harsh taxes, used to fund foreign wars. They also object to the presence of the Redcoats, for whom they have to provide free accommodation on request, despite struggling to feed their own families. Benjamin and Susannah’s relationship is originally rocky, as they have contrasting opinions on the role of the English and the morality of issues such as smuggling.
There is also an underlying mystery: the story opens at the trial of Hermit Crab Joe for the vicious murder of an unknown young woman. Benjamin Ross is speaking in his defence, convinced Joe isn’t the real murderer. But if he isn’t, who is? And when Susannah discovers a runaway, a mistreated indentured servant, she knows Benjamin is the person who will be able to help.
I liked both Benjamin and Susannah as characters. They were intelligent, opinionated and committed to doing what they believed was right. One character I didn’t related to was Susannah’s mother: I didn’t really understand why the wife of a pastor, a woman who spent a lot of her time helping the poor widows of the parish, would be so against her daughter marrying Benjamin Ross (and how she could be so unlike her own mother). After all, he’s a lawyer. Ross might not have a lot to offer now, but his future looks secure. (And, as this story is loosely based on the courtship of President John Adams and his wife, Abigail, he turns out very well indeed).
Some of the language is very formal (e.g. “But inexplicably she couldn’t maintain her feelings of insult,”). I can see it's attempting to portray the formality of life and speech in 1763 but I prefer the style of Hedlund's earlier novels. However, there were also words of wisdom from several of the characters, including this gem from Susannah’s Grandmother:
’Tis exceedingly easy to get caught up in the way things have always been done and never question if that’s the way they should continue.
I didn’t enjoy this as much as The Noble Groom, but it’s still one I’d recommend for lovers of historical fiction and historical romance.
Thanks to Bethany House and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.
The story starts in 1763, as the American colonists are beginning to rebel against their English rulers, and their harsh taxes, used to fund foreign wars. They also object to the presence of the Redcoats, for whom they have to provide free accommodation on request, despite struggling to feed their own families. Benjamin and Susannah’s relationship is originally rocky, as they have contrasting opinions on the role of the English and the morality of issues such as smuggling.
There is also an underlying mystery: the story opens at the trial of Hermit Crab Joe for the vicious murder of an unknown young woman. Benjamin Ross is speaking in his defence, convinced Joe isn’t the real murderer. But if he isn’t, who is? And when Susannah discovers a runaway, a mistreated indentured servant, she knows Benjamin is the person who will be able to help.
I liked both Benjamin and Susannah as characters. They were intelligent, opinionated and committed to doing what they believed was right. One character I didn’t related to was Susannah’s mother: I didn’t really understand why the wife of a pastor, a woman who spent a lot of her time helping the poor widows of the parish, would be so against her daughter marrying Benjamin Ross (and how she could be so unlike her own mother). After all, he’s a lawyer. Ross might not have a lot to offer now, but his future looks secure. (And, as this story is loosely based on the courtship of President John Adams and his wife, Abigail, he turns out very well indeed).
Some of the language is very formal (e.g. “But inexplicably she couldn’t maintain her feelings of insult,”). I can see it's attempting to portray the formality of life and speech in 1763 but I prefer the style of Hedlund's earlier novels. However, there were also words of wisdom from several of the characters, including this gem from Susannah’s Grandmother:
’Tis exceedingly easy to get caught up in the way things have always been done and never question if that’s the way they should continue.
I didn’t enjoy this as much as The Noble Groom, but it’s still one I’d recommend for lovers of historical fiction and historical romance.
Thanks to Bethany House and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.
April 19, 2018
Set in 1763, this novel is loosely based on the courtship of John & Abigail Adams. In typical Jody Hedlund style, you should be warned that this book is of the "I can't put this down!" variety. I loved going to Colonial Massachusetts and being reminded of what our founding fathers faced before the United States was its own nation.
Susanna Smith is a young woman very interested in education, and feels slighted that girls are not given the same opportunities for learning that their brothers are. She's very idealistic when it comes to the British rule over the colonies, until her views are challenged by a runaway indentured servant who was badly mistreated by her master. Feeling the laws of God are higher than the laws of man, Susanna agrees to secretly shelter the girl, but enlists the help of lawyer Benjamin Ross to see if they can find a way to legally protect the victim.
Ben is facing an uphill battle to earn the respect of his peers. The son of a simple farmer, Ben feels he must make an advantageous match in order to increase his social standing and make people take him seriously. Susanna doesn't have the inheritance to match his aspirations, but he is taken with her beauty, the depth of her thoughtfulness, and the fact that she trusts him with her secret. Ben is also outraged over the increasing taxes the British are imposing upon the colonists, and is doing what he can to find ways around the unjust laws. His activities have him under close surveillance by the local troops, and his main worry about being friends with Susanna is bringing her into the danger that dogs him.
At first I wasn't sure I would like the portrayal of either main characters. They are both rather proud, and Ben would use sarcasm in very hurtful ways. But as they got to know each other and understand where the other was coming from, everything came together. I also thought the story was heavy on the romance, but no more so than other Jody Hedlund books. They are definitely historical romance rather than just historical fiction. I do recommend her books, with a dose of discretion alongside. I will certainly be following her future releases!
I received my copy from the publisher in exchange for this honest review. All opinions are my own.
This review originated at http://reviewsbyerin.livejournal.com
Susanna Smith is a young woman very interested in education, and feels slighted that girls are not given the same opportunities for learning that their brothers are. She's very idealistic when it comes to the British rule over the colonies, until her views are challenged by a runaway indentured servant who was badly mistreated by her master. Feeling the laws of God are higher than the laws of man, Susanna agrees to secretly shelter the girl, but enlists the help of lawyer Benjamin Ross to see if they can find a way to legally protect the victim.
Ben is facing an uphill battle to earn the respect of his peers. The son of a simple farmer, Ben feels he must make an advantageous match in order to increase his social standing and make people take him seriously. Susanna doesn't have the inheritance to match his aspirations, but he is taken with her beauty, the depth of her thoughtfulness, and the fact that she trusts him with her secret. Ben is also outraged over the increasing taxes the British are imposing upon the colonists, and is doing what he can to find ways around the unjust laws. His activities have him under close surveillance by the local troops, and his main worry about being friends with Susanna is bringing her into the danger that dogs him.
At first I wasn't sure I would like the portrayal of either main characters. They are both rather proud, and Ben would use sarcasm in very hurtful ways. But as they got to know each other and understand where the other was coming from, everything came together. I also thought the story was heavy on the romance, but no more so than other Jody Hedlund books. They are definitely historical romance rather than just historical fiction. I do recommend her books, with a dose of discretion alongside. I will certainly be following her future releases!
I received my copy from the publisher in exchange for this honest review. All opinions are my own.
This review originated at http://reviewsbyerin.livejournal.com
September 14, 2013
- Received a free copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Susanna is the typical young lady to be found in the Americas just before the Revolutionary War. The daughter of a clergyman, she seeks to do good as the Lord desires, treating the downtrodden with compassion, but still maintaining loyalty to England. That is, she is loyal until young lawyer Benjamin Ross begins planting thoughts in her head, thoughts she would rather not have, of liberty from the oppressive British soldiers. It isn't until Susanna finds herself in the situation of helping a runaway indentured serving girl that she realizes some rules must be broken because God's laws are higher than man's. And perhaps she'll be fortunate enough to find love along the way.
This book is amazing, from start to finish. I could barely put it down. Susanna is the ideal heroine because you see her make decisions and not just believe everything thrown at her. She has to see proof before she changes her mind and the fact that she isn't easily swayed is appealing to me. She is not so stubborn as to be irritating, rather she is a darling young woman with a genuine compassion for those less fortunate than herself. Throwing Benjamin Ross into the mix was pure genius. He is vocal where Susanna might be quiet, passionate where she is calm. They are the ideal mix and the passion within their relationship is breathtaking.
So, I loved it. Jody Hedlund paints a clear picture of life in the colonies before the Revolution. And what's more she adds mystery and intrigue in the most frightening of ways. The one thing I would have changed is the background history of the villain. It just does not jive with his behavior. No one could possibly fall so far into evil just because an evil blow was dealt him. So, in that regard, I didn't entirely buy the motives of the villain, but the hero and heroine far make up for that flaw.
My next goal is to devour as many of Ms. Hedlund's books as possible because she is a marvel!
Susanna is the typical young lady to be found in the Americas just before the Revolutionary War. The daughter of a clergyman, she seeks to do good as the Lord desires, treating the downtrodden with compassion, but still maintaining loyalty to England. That is, she is loyal until young lawyer Benjamin Ross begins planting thoughts in her head, thoughts she would rather not have, of liberty from the oppressive British soldiers. It isn't until Susanna finds herself in the situation of helping a runaway indentured serving girl that she realizes some rules must be broken because God's laws are higher than man's. And perhaps she'll be fortunate enough to find love along the way.
This book is amazing, from start to finish. I could barely put it down. Susanna is the ideal heroine because you see her make decisions and not just believe everything thrown at her. She has to see proof before she changes her mind and the fact that she isn't easily swayed is appealing to me. She is not so stubborn as to be irritating, rather she is a darling young woman with a genuine compassion for those less fortunate than herself. Throwing Benjamin Ross into the mix was pure genius. He is vocal where Susanna might be quiet, passionate where she is calm. They are the ideal mix and the passion within their relationship is breathtaking.
So, I loved it. Jody Hedlund paints a clear picture of life in the colonies before the Revolution. And what's more she adds mystery and intrigue in the most frightening of ways. The one thing I would have changed is the background history of the villain. It just does not jive with his behavior. No one could possibly fall so far into evil just because an evil blow was dealt him. So, in that regard, I didn't entirely buy the motives of the villain, but the hero and heroine far make up for that flaw.
My next goal is to devour as many of Ms. Hedlund's books as possible because she is a marvel!
September 19, 2013
I've read and own all Jody Hedlund's books. I especially enjoy how she bases all her books on real people and events.
She shines brightly in this novel. Rebellious Heart swept me away totally. She does impeccable research on all her novels and that impresses me because I love history. It is so fascinating reading about peoples' lives in times past.
Susannah Smith comes from a well to do family and she is expected to marry well. Susannah loves caring for those less fortunate than her and when she makes a decision to help an ill treated indentured servant, her own life could hang in the balance.
Ben Ross grew up very poor, but his father sacrificed to sent him to college to become a lawyer. His desire is to help others, but he has a secret life that could also cause his own life to hang in the balance.
Ben and Susannah are thrown together during this perilous time in the life of our young country, although we weren't free from Britain's rule yet. They face heartbreak, danger and illness together.
Will they be able to overcome what is expected of them and build a life together or will they bow to the wills of others and what is expected of them?
Jody Hedlund writes of a time in our nation's not yet infancy that is compelling to read. She writes with a heart for God as well, in the lives of her characters.
Don't miss this one. It's worth every cent you spend.
She shines brightly in this novel. Rebellious Heart swept me away totally. She does impeccable research on all her novels and that impresses me because I love history. It is so fascinating reading about peoples' lives in times past.
Susannah Smith comes from a well to do family and she is expected to marry well. Susannah loves caring for those less fortunate than her and when she makes a decision to help an ill treated indentured servant, her own life could hang in the balance.
Ben Ross grew up very poor, but his father sacrificed to sent him to college to become a lawyer. His desire is to help others, but he has a secret life that could also cause his own life to hang in the balance.
Ben and Susannah are thrown together during this perilous time in the life of our young country, although we weren't free from Britain's rule yet. They face heartbreak, danger and illness together.
Will they be able to overcome what is expected of them and build a life together or will they bow to the wills of others and what is expected of them?
Jody Hedlund writes of a time in our nation's not yet infancy that is compelling to read. She writes with a heart for God as well, in the lives of her characters.
Don't miss this one. It's worth every cent you spend.
October 4, 2013
“Rebellious Heart” is a new passionate historical hitting store (and personal) book shelves now and I think many readers are going to be swept away in this dramatic retelling of life several hundred years ago.
Sometimes it can be hard to read about experiences from a different period, romanticized or not, because of the accuracy the author puts behind the words. To know that such horrible things could and would happen to people during such a time makes it difficult, but also fascinating.
Talk about a love story! Susanna and Ben certainly cross more than a few lines for the expected and acceptable of their society standings of their day and in more ways than just their romance. But oh boy, the attraction and sizzle on the page when they were even in the same room together. Talk about great tension!
I didn’t find this one title my favorite, and I can’t really put my finger as to why to be honest. The story was good, the characters well fleshed out, and plenty of action to fill the 360 pages. Maybe it was the slightly disturbing history, maybe it was the combination of a deadline I needed to reach - either way, I still give high marks to the book and encourage historical reader fans to pick it up.
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the publishers for my copy to review.
Sometimes it can be hard to read about experiences from a different period, romanticized or not, because of the accuracy the author puts behind the words. To know that such horrible things could and would happen to people during such a time makes it difficult, but also fascinating.
Talk about a love story! Susanna and Ben certainly cross more than a few lines for the expected and acceptable of their society standings of their day and in more ways than just their romance. But oh boy, the attraction and sizzle on the page when they were even in the same room together. Talk about great tension!
I didn’t find this one title my favorite, and I can’t really put my finger as to why to be honest. The story was good, the characters well fleshed out, and plenty of action to fill the 360 pages. Maybe it was the slightly disturbing history, maybe it was the combination of a deadline I needed to reach - either way, I still give high marks to the book and encourage historical reader fans to pick it up.
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the publishers for my copy to review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 325 reviews