Don't judge a book by its title, I guess. The title of the final book in the May Bird series is a bit cringe, but the inside does not match. In fact, the chapters always have clever titles, usually something intriguing or ironic. I am not sure why the author agreed to the title "warrior princess" in the first place, especially given that she clearly has a knack for good titles. (Not to mention that May is usually referred to as a "warrior queen".)
This entire series should be a staple of the "charming horror" genre. I am honestly surprised by how little recognition it has gotten. Charming horror is something that is rarely executed this smoothly in literary form. Although there are many great examples in film, not many books have pulled this off quite so effortlessly because the charm of this genre often comes in the little details of the world and the characters, the kind of details you don't want to give too much narrative attention to lest they negate the terror. Whereas the plot gets to focus on the horror, the smaller details provide the charm. In film this can be things played out in the background or small details in the corner of the screen. Unfortunately, in literature it is not so easy to do too many things at once.
Like always, Anderson finds the perfect balance, providing just the right amount of both. The threat of the monsters is never minimized because the author doesn't let the lighter elements of her story take over.
And yet, although the story was good and the world building top tier, I think I was expecting more...
My journey with this book has been an interesting one. When I was about 11 I was half way through the second book when my parents intervened. Although my parents had never cared about what I chose to read before, I had recommended the series to a friend who had very strict parents, and apparently they had complained. Long story short, I was told I wasn't allowed to keep reading.
Thus, I have had years of my life to wonder whether May Bird made it back to the world of the living. One might say that the ending of this series was one of the great mysteries of my childhood.
I came back as an adult to see how it ends.
Anderson did it all. She created a spooky thrilling world, a mostly relatable protagonist with two great side kicks, and a dark lord to strike fear into the hearts of kids. And yet at the end of the day it falls short. Maybe it would have been different if it hadn't taken me years to get here. But in the end it just felt too easy. All this build up, and then the battle ends in a flash.
Nevertheless, I will always respect Anderson's style. The first book in this series is the only book that ever kept me awake at night as a kid, not because I was reading (I stayed up late reading a lot), but because I was terrified of what would come next.
In the world of children's literature, nothing is ever as scary as it seems. But I would have liked it to have been. The big boss that loomed over May (and me) for so long should have been scarier when she finally met him face to face.