Really, 3.5 stars. This is a fun, must read for all the Pretty Ladies in Charlotte. And Atlanta. And Columbia, Camden, Charleston...well, maybe there is a different book about Charleston!! Charla Muller has written a very pointed and honest book about the reality of society life in a Southern city - the expectations, the stress, the judging, the "who's your daddy" mentality of placing someone in a category based on their family, or more realistically these days, their looks. So she suggests we all get busy on our own definition of pretty should look like on ourselves.
Wait, WHAT?
Yeah, ok, I got my back up several times reading this book. Muller really does tell us to get it together because appearances matter. Now, when I turned 45 I sort of decided I didn't really care if I went to Harris Teeter without makeup on and it was so freeing!! I am pretty inside but you just can't see it because no I did not brush my hair 100 times this morning. Humph. But when I calmed down and thought about it, of course she is kinda sorta embarrassingly right. It shouldn't matter, but it does. We all judge each other. She was right to tell that mom at the private school that even though she has chosen not to wear a wedding ring and her husband did, she better start wearing one or else the rumors are gonna fly. Last week my husband walked up to the second pew in our very packed church (we're still on summer schedule with only one traditional service, so we are packing two services into one, which I am sure Father Paul says is a great problem to have, but not when you are used to two-wheeling it in 3 minutes before church starts and getting to sit up front) and left me and my 2 kids in the "penalty box" at the back of the church. I wasn't about to get up during the readings!! The nerve!! Within an hour I had two texts from friends wanting to know what happened. So, I get it.
So.....people are watching, whether they want to admit it or not, and if you begin to "not care" too much about what people think, you never know what kind of wild story you'll hear about yourself in the Queen City (or any other city for that matter - don't get me started on small town social politics! I grew up in one, I KNOW how it works.).
I loved how Muller was unapologetic about these realities. I love her newly coined (at least to me) and descriptive phrase of the "Volunteer Mafia." Watch out that you don't look TOO capable else you'll find yourself on 12 committees and leading 8 of them. She tells personal stories of fashion disasters that have happened to her that I can totally relate to. Here's one of her best lines, and there were many:
"There I was, with the incredible fashion burden of dressing for an Oscar de la Renta event on a Target budget and with an octogenarian's fashion sense. I was so hosed."
HAHAHA, right? We have all been there at some point. And we have all struggled with being true to our selves and fitting in. And we all admire those (from afar) who have managed to really accomplish being who they are and to hell with the Rules. Rules are safe. Rules we know. Being ourselves? Humph #2.
She says you have to dress the part. She should know. Remember that book a few years back about the crazy woman who gave the gift of intimacy to her husband - for a WHOLE YEAR? Yep, this is her. Well, she went on all sorts of talk shows, including Oprah, and got totally blasted....for her looks. Not her writing, or her skill, but for her sweater sets. Yikes. The scary thing is, those of us reading her book now? Yeah, guess who we are? The same ones who judged her.
For Shame.
Well, she got hers in the end because this is a cute, funny, and direct book. My big problem is that she is so focused on looks. Probably because WE are so focused on looks. Her experience of being in the nationally public eye was not a good one for her, but it led to some serious introspection (and another contract). Her last chapters left me curious though, with a conundrum. She talks about the importance of being interesting. Ok, that sounds good, no one wants to be the wet rag at the party. But the whole book is telling you to be pretty, to work on yourself outwardly because that is all that people really see (sad).
So, Charla, would you rather be pretty, or interesting??? I personally think you are pretty interesting, and that is enough for me. Please come to my book club - and bring your awesome friend Cyndee because I want to steal her. ;-)