Read this to get some ideas in case reading with my rising 4-year-old doesn’t go as smoothly as it did with my 6-year-old. 5 stars for the phonetic approach and using word families (I didn’t see that term used in the book, but that’s what is used).
I am not a fan of all the scripting, particularly when learning letter sounds. It isn’t a very fluid or fun way of teaching, at least not for me. But if you aren’t sure where to start or you’re an ESL homeschool parent, this book gives you exactly what to say.
It essentially teaches sounds, digraphs, etc. in the same order and manner as BJU Press. I prefer the BJU techniques of “hear the [a] sound in the [A] words…” to all the little rhymes and jingles in this book, but it’s not that the ones here are bad. I also prefer BJU Press’ use of characters (Mrs. Short, Mr. Short, Uncle Short, Miss Long, Marker E, Miss Silent, Bossy R) to recognize and remember sounds—it seems a more efficient method than expecting a child to remember rules for pairs of letters—but this book is still teaching new readers to look for these patterns.
There were some other specific things not explained as well as I’d prefer. E.g. Lesson 42 - no mention that the /k/ sound is spelled as “ck” after a short vowel and just “k” after an “n.” I’d teach those concepts at the same time. I found it strange that -ed and other endings (BJU “bad cats” -ing, -er, -est, etc.), contractions, and a few other things weren’t taught until the end of the book (lessons 200+). Also that multi-syllable words are left for Lesson 215; phonetically—and knowing that each syllable must have a vowel—a young reader can sort out these words much sooner. Interesting that they feel “ey” can be spoken as /ǐ/ or /ē/ (Lesson 201). I did like how “rule breaker” words are grouped together in a meaningful way (e.g. Lessons 128-129: O standing alone as /ǔ/ in son, won, ton, from, some, come, love, dove, etc).
I’d have to read more closely to critique further or argue any of the points above—they are just personal notes—but I don’t feel the need.