First of all, despite the title this is not a book set in 2016! That would be such a great title for a novel about that year. What this book is about though is a zombie apocalypse of sorts, with “zombies” being in quotation marks (not actual undead but a minor distinction at best to those who have to contend with them).
The book has a brief prologue, relating how a massive pandemic near the turn of the century seemed to be associated with the arrival of a comet. Many people afflicted basically became comatose, falling into a sleep they could not wake from, though others were decidedly quite awake though not themselves and were a danger to themselves and others. Dubbed variously encephalitis lethargica or its victims la nona or the living dead, no definitive cause or any type of cure was ever found and the existence of the disease faded from the popular consciousness.
Fast forward to 2014, about a hundred years later. We meet our main character, John Cruz, who abruptly and to the surprise of those around them awakens from a type of walking coma. Semi-incarcerated in a mental hospital for several years (John had committed a violent act and then entered his coma-like state in 2011), John finds that the hospital is nearly deserted, with only two other patients, a man who had suffered brain damage who goes by the name Scooter and a not very nice man by the name of Lanny (full name Landon Caine). Apparently around the world people who were in comas or had suffered from several mental illnesses (including debilitating ones) were suddenly and inexplicably cured. Most had been released; Lanny was due to be released and pending some tests John is released as well.
Scooter however is not released, as he becomes violently aggressive and practically mindless and has to be restrained. In fact, just as the world’s mental patients were going into some sort of spontaneous remission, new patients were appearing, their number growing every day. Some go into comas and cannot be woken up, some freeze into what John later calls “human trees,” basically becoming statues with their backs, arms, and necks seemingly permanently bent at uncomfortable poses, and the rest…become crazies, deranged people who lose all sense of self preservation and who try to kill and eat anyone they see.
Set against the backdrop of a general worldwide rise in violence (deliberate plane crashes, terrorism, and the threat of nuclear war overseas) and the appearance of a massive comet, John has only one thought; get his wife Maria and make it to a cabin owned by his relatives far out in the New Mexico countryside and await the coming crisis as civilization starts to fall. Along the way they deal with crazies, other people immune to the epidemic (this time around dubbed sudden onset psychosis syndrome or SOPS), and just finding food, weapons, ammunition, working vehicles, and shelter.
One other point, the name of the novel comes from a journal kept by John, a suggestion by John’s mental health caregiver, Dr Madesh Patel. It goes from being a mental health exercise to a chronicle of the calamity to a testament to those who survive the apocalypse.
That all sounds pretty good right? Maybe a fairly standard zombie (or “zombie”) novel, though the comet and the rise in worldwide violence are nice touches and original. At times, the book wasn’t bad, with fairly well done action scenes and parts of the buildup to the actual apocalypse were riveting and the opening chapters were quite good, but the book had so much wrong with it.
The single biggest problem the book had was pacing. Again and again scenes just dragged and dragged. What was an interesting concept or interaction just seemed to go on two, three, four times longer than it should and my attention just lagged and I found myself skimming. A conversation between John and Dr. Patel about the tests they run on him goes for pages and pages with too much unnecessary detail. Several times John goes on at length about gun rights or the virtue of various guns again and again. Flirting and romance between John and his wife Maria, once they are reunited at home following his release, just seems to go nowhere for a page after page and just kills the momentum of the book. Maria and John watch press conferences and news reports, not a bad way to do an info dump I suppose, but the events are described in a very lengthy chapter that could have had a much brisker pace with the main characters basically just passively watching TV. Too many times the book veers from decent action and build up for the apocalypse into massively overly long exposition or informational sections that just could have been cut at least in half.
Another problem was missed opportunities or at least misunderstood actions. Dr. Patel is built up as a fairly major character in the hospital, is shown again as an expert while John and Maria watch TV (!) but then…nothing. He doesn’t figure into the book again (sorry if that is a spoiler). We meet Otis, a delightful very intelligent cat owned by John and Maria, a cat who Maria remarks seems to get more and more intelligent as time pasts, a cat who seems to understand English to an astonishing degree and almost sort of talks sometimes. Does this mean the comet is doing something to animals? I don’t have any answers, because the Otis element is basically limited to Otis with very little development other than his presence as an interesting sidekick. The briefly mentioned nuclear conflict does produce late in the book a bit of a predicament, one that should have seriously changed the rest of the novel…but it is hand waved away in a matter of paragraphs. It almost felt as if an ever better book was in there but this was the first draft I am reading, that some interesting plot threads just never really fully got explored, the concept proposed and then just never fully developed.
A third problem was too many coincidences. Sorry if I enter spoiler territory, but the novel doesn’t have a lot of named individuals but after the world appears to end John still encounters them in the middle of nowhere. I sort of understand why they are out and active, but the odds of John encountering not one but two individuals from earlier in the book? That strained credulity with me.
The character Lanny wasn’t interesting, as important as he turned out to be. He is just a jerk to be a jerk, no real motivation. He simply appears to have decided he hates John and that is the end of things. Definitely not a fully explored bad guy.
I wanted to like the book. I definitely have a soft spot for a well written zombie thriller. I certainly understand writing is hard (been working at for years and years myself). This book just didn’t deliver. I never hated it enough to put it down and at times it was good but it just had so much unrealized potential.