What do you think?
Rate this book
The Gentleman's Madness
"An imprisoned heart finds escape in forbidden love. "
No pride. No privacy. No hope.
Academic John Gilliam thought being caught embracing another man was the worst that could happen. Until he agrees to "treatment" at an asylum, where a vicious attack leaves him shaken and afraid.
But having all means of writing or reading taken from him... "That" is a serious threat to his sanity. Then a moment of kindness from an asylum attendant begins to restore his dignity.
Sam Tully feels sorry for the patient everyone calls "the professor," but with a back injury that cost him his job on the docks-and without the education that would have bettered his position-he tries to keep his head down, and a tight lid on his attraction to men.
As John prays for freedom, he grows closer to the gentle, innately intelligent Tully. In spite of themselves, forbidden attraction leads to touches, kisses, and more. But there's something other than curative treatments going on at the asylum. When John and Tully uncover a heinous conspiracy, their very lives are in danger.
Warning: Contains heinous crimes and frightening treatments-oh, and some sweet and loving sexy times between two healthy, not-crazy men.
No pride. No privacy. No hope.
Academic John Gilliam thought being caught embracing another man was the worst that could happen. Until he agrees to "treatment" at an asylum, where a vicious attack leaves him shaken and afraid.
But having all means of writing or reading taken from him... "That" is a serious threat to his sanity. Then a moment of kindness from an asylum attendant begins to restore his dignity.
Sam Tully feels sorry for the patient everyone calls "the professor," but with a back injury that cost him his job on the docks-and without the education that would have bettered his position-he tries to keep his head down, and a tight lid on his attraction to men.
As John prays for freedom, he grows closer to the gentle, innately intelligent Tully. In spite of themselves, forbidden attraction leads to touches, kisses, and more. But there's something other than curative treatments going on at the asylum. When John and Tully uncover a heinous conspiracy, their very lives are in danger.
Warning: Contains heinous crimes and frightening treatments-oh, and some sweet and loving sexy times between two healthy, not-crazy men.
227 pages, ebook
First published December 31, 2013
16 people are currently reading
432 people want to read
About the author
Summer Devon
62 books225 followersSummer Devon is the pen name writer Kate Rothwell often uses. Whether the characters are male or female, human or dragon, her books are always romance.
You can visit her facebook page, where there's a sign up form for a newsletter (she'll only send out newsletters when there's a new Summer Devon or Kate Rothwell release and she will never ever sell your name to anyone).
Her blog is available here.
She also has a blog with Bonnie Dee, a frequent co-author. It's mostly just announcements, but we might do good give-aways on occasion.
You can visit her facebook page, where there's a sign up form for a newsletter (she'll only send out newsletters when there's a new Summer Devon or Kate Rothwell release and she will never ever sell your name to anyone).
Her blog is available here.
She also has a blog with Bonnie Dee, a frequent co-author. It's mostly just announcements, but we might do good give-aways on occasion.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 97 reviews
May 16, 2018
Is that man a vampire? Does that manic gleam in his eyes mean he is about to feed? The blurb didn’t indicate there were vampires in this story, so I promptly put the cover picture out of my mind. I do love the title, however, and was thrilled to get the opportunity to read this historical romance set in London in 1887.
John Gilliam is a learned professor. He is also homosexual and damned lucky “buggery” was no longer punishable by death. It was, however, still illegal. John was unfortunate to be caught with another man during a surprise visit by his father and a few friends and willingly submitted to treatment at a mental institution. Because John comes from a wealthy family, his living conditions are not nearly as bad as others. But he still had to endure isolation, humiliation and crude treatments such as hydrotherapy and twirling chairs which were of no help to mentally ill patients. During his incarceration, he meets Sam Tully, a kindly attendant who suffers from the same “perversion” that John does.
What is really scary is these crude and dangerous treatments lasted right up until the 1970’s.
http://www.davidmixner.com/2010/07/lg...
I have some mixed feelings about this story. While I loved the slow burn of John’s and Sam’s relationship, their very different backgrounds, and the authentic historical details, I wish there were more vivid descriptions of the patients and their treatments. I am very interested in the history of mental health and wish that this story spent more time on the important subjects it touched on in a superficial way. Because of Tully, I never really felt that John was in any danger, and that eliminated a lot of tension from the story.
It was still a compelling and leisurely read, and I’m glad both men got their happy ending. While not a perfect story, I enjoyed it sufficiently and plan to try another by these authors.
*Book provided by author in exchange for an honest review.
John Gilliam is a learned professor. He is also homosexual and damned lucky “buggery” was no longer punishable by death. It was, however, still illegal. John was unfortunate to be caught with another man during a surprise visit by his father and a few friends and willingly submitted to treatment at a mental institution. Because John comes from a wealthy family, his living conditions are not nearly as bad as others. But he still had to endure isolation, humiliation and crude treatments such as hydrotherapy and twirling chairs which were of no help to mentally ill patients. During his incarceration, he meets Sam Tully, a kindly attendant who suffers from the same “perversion” that John does.
What is really scary is these crude and dangerous treatments lasted right up until the 1970’s.
http://www.davidmixner.com/2010/07/lg...
I have some mixed feelings about this story. While I loved the slow burn of John’s and Sam’s relationship, their very different backgrounds, and the authentic historical details, I wish there were more vivid descriptions of the patients and their treatments. I am very interested in the history of mental health and wish that this story spent more time on the important subjects it touched on in a superficial way. Because of Tully, I never really felt that John was in any danger, and that eliminated a lot of tension from the story.
It was still a compelling and leisurely read, and I’m glad both men got their happy ending. While not a perfect story, I enjoyed it sufficiently and plan to try another by these authors.
*Book provided by author in exchange for an honest review.
April 14, 2019
Wow! 😱 I have no words for how amazing this book is! 😍 I’m a huge fan of Summer Devon and Bonnie Dee and I know these duo can write. And I love their historical romances with swoon-worthy heroes and mostly angst-free, feel-good stories. So I was thinking I’m getting my usual fluffy historical romance with this book. 😌 I couldn’t be more wrong! 😳 I was just blown away by how refreshing and intriguing this book is! 💜
John is being locked up in a mental asylum to get cured from his unnatural desires. (If you know what I mean 😅) And as a scholar who’s used to getting his way, John is beyond frustration and on the verge of going mad for real. He was assaulted at the first asylum he was committed to and nobody believed him. So he thought his second prison wouldn’t be any different. Then he met Tully, the gentlest soul who truly listens and cares for him and shares the same desires he harbors. The irony is that while John is being locked up for the desires he has for the same sex, Tully is working as a care-giver at the same mental asylum John is being committed to as a free man. 🙂 These two formed a very unlikely friendship and started to show affection and care for each other. Meanwhile, the havoc and conspiracies are unraveling in the asylum. The asylum isn’t what it seems on the surface. And if John and Tully’s affair is ever discovered by the others, their very lives could be threatened. 😱 Now these two men from different worlds have to work together using all their wits and intelligence to escape this prison once and for all.
From the very first page, I didn’t know what I was getting. 😳 I mean what kind of positive outcome can you expect from a romantic affair between the patient of a mental asylum and his caregiver. But somehow, somehow these two amazing writers managed to do just that. 👏 The relationship development between John and Tully was slow, sensual, heartwarming and realistic. ❤️ You can’t help but keep rooting for these two men. And the subtle erotic acts of these two! That was hot! 🔥 And the thriller aspect of this book, wow, I mean it wasn’t that unique or new twist of a story but the way these two authors crafted this story, my heart was in my throat most of the time. 😁 And I was sweating cold sweat honest to goddess! 🥶 Especially the last few chapters, I thought I was going to faint from excitement! 😱 And I knew I was going to love Mark James’ narration but he outdid himself with this one. 💙 Such a flawless, nuanced and beautiful performance. 👏 His portrayal of John and Tully was spot on! What has already been an excellent story was elevated to a whole other level of awesomeness because of his stellar narration. 😍 I loved, loved, loved listening this book. It was such a phenomenal experience! 😊 I recommend anyone who’s even slightly into audios to pick up this book in audio format rather than reading it. Trust me, you are going to be so grateful to me. 😉 And that epilogue was just icing on a very yummy cake! 😋 Couldn’t recommend enough! Deserve a full five stars! ⭐️
5 A misfortune can be true love in disguise stars
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Audio rating
Story - 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Narration - 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Performance- 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Overall - 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Disclaimer: An audio copy of this book was provided by the authors for an honest and unbiased review.
John is being locked up in a mental asylum to get cured from his unnatural desires. (If you know what I mean 😅) And as a scholar who’s used to getting his way, John is beyond frustration and on the verge of going mad for real. He was assaulted at the first asylum he was committed to and nobody believed him. So he thought his second prison wouldn’t be any different. Then he met Tully, the gentlest soul who truly listens and cares for him and shares the same desires he harbors. The irony is that while John is being locked up for the desires he has for the same sex, Tully is working as a care-giver at the same mental asylum John is being committed to as a free man. 🙂 These two formed a very unlikely friendship and started to show affection and care for each other. Meanwhile, the havoc and conspiracies are unraveling in the asylum. The asylum isn’t what it seems on the surface. And if John and Tully’s affair is ever discovered by the others, their very lives could be threatened. 😱 Now these two men from different worlds have to work together using all their wits and intelligence to escape this prison once and for all.
From the very first page, I didn’t know what I was getting. 😳 I mean what kind of positive outcome can you expect from a romantic affair between the patient of a mental asylum and his caregiver. But somehow, somehow these two amazing writers managed to do just that. 👏 The relationship development between John and Tully was slow, sensual, heartwarming and realistic. ❤️ You can’t help but keep rooting for these two men. And the subtle erotic acts of these two! That was hot! 🔥 And the thriller aspect of this book, wow, I mean it wasn’t that unique or new twist of a story but the way these two authors crafted this story, my heart was in my throat most of the time. 😁 And I was sweating cold sweat honest to goddess! 🥶 Especially the last few chapters, I thought I was going to faint from excitement! 😱 And I knew I was going to love Mark James’ narration but he outdid himself with this one. 💙 Such a flawless, nuanced and beautiful performance. 👏 His portrayal of John and Tully was spot on! What has already been an excellent story was elevated to a whole other level of awesomeness because of his stellar narration. 😍 I loved, loved, loved listening this book. It was such a phenomenal experience! 😊 I recommend anyone who’s even slightly into audios to pick up this book in audio format rather than reading it. Trust me, you are going to be so grateful to me. 😉 And that epilogue was just icing on a very yummy cake! 😋 Couldn’t recommend enough! Deserve a full five stars! ⭐️
5 A misfortune can be true love in disguise stars
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Audio rating
Story - 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Narration - 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Performance- 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Overall - 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Disclaimer: An audio copy of this book was provided by the authors for an honest and unbiased review.
July 1, 2019
I had no idea what to expect from Bonnie Dee and Summer Devon’s historical novel The Gentleman’s Madness. What sounded like a dark, emotional story of a gay man submitting to treatment for his so-called perversion in London in the late 1800s, turns out to be a moving social commentary, a fabulous mystery, and an erotic and passionate romance all wrapped up in one gorgeous book.
Yes, the look inside the facility is disturbing. The variety of treatments provided to those suffering from mental illness are horrific, and the lack of control patients have over their fate is the stuff of nightmares. While these descriptions do set the stage for the story, thankfully the authors move quickly into the mystery and romance portion of the novel.
When we meet John Gilliam, he’s reached his lowest point. The victim of a sexual assault at his first institution, John is transferred to Fairpark Asylum where he is stripped of his personal effects, his rights, and his dignity. An educated man, he can see that none of the treatments are going to “cure him of his desires”, and furthermore he recognizes his attraction to men is a natural part of who he is. Submitting to a turn in the sanatorium was intended to appease his father and relieve some of the social stigma to his family, but now he wants OUT!
When attendant Sam Tully offers John a bit of kindness, the men form a friendship which blooms into a deep and passionate connection. Unfortunately, their relationship draws the attention of a boorish and violent attendant who tries to blackmail them…. Puzzled by the man’s behavior, and a few strange events, they uncover proof of some heinous activities at Fairpark Asylum.
The mystery portion of the story is clever and unfolds perfectly. I enjoyed watching John and Tully work together as they uncover clues and figure out what’s been going on. It’s easy to see their initial attraction turn to mutual admiration, and finally evolve into a loving relationship as they find their happily-ever-after.
Adding even more power to the story is Mark James’ stunning narration of The Gentleman’s Madness, whether he is expressing the choked back emotion of John, trying to hide his passionate reactions from the staff, or the sheer joy and laughter of Tully as he discovers the pleasures of freely interacting with his lover. From the words of love they share, whispered furtively in the dark cell of the sanatorium, to the madness of some of the residents confined within, Mr. James gives his all and infuses every emotional scene with the highs and lows intended by the authors.
As well received as this book was after its original release in 2013, I can only exclaim over the added power of Mark James’ narration. A truly meaningful, heartfelt love story, and a look back at a sad and unfortunate time in history, The Gentleman’s Madness is a novel not to be missed.
an audiobook copy of The Gentleman’s Madness was provided to me by the authors for the purpose of my review
Yes, the look inside the facility is disturbing. The variety of treatments provided to those suffering from mental illness are horrific, and the lack of control patients have over their fate is the stuff of nightmares. While these descriptions do set the stage for the story, thankfully the authors move quickly into the mystery and romance portion of the novel.
When we meet John Gilliam, he’s reached his lowest point. The victim of a sexual assault at his first institution, John is transferred to Fairpark Asylum where he is stripped of his personal effects, his rights, and his dignity. An educated man, he can see that none of the treatments are going to “cure him of his desires”, and furthermore he recognizes his attraction to men is a natural part of who he is. Submitting to a turn in the sanatorium was intended to appease his father and relieve some of the social stigma to his family, but now he wants OUT!
When attendant Sam Tully offers John a bit of kindness, the men form a friendship which blooms into a deep and passionate connection. Unfortunately, their relationship draws the attention of a boorish and violent attendant who tries to blackmail them…. Puzzled by the man’s behavior, and a few strange events, they uncover proof of some heinous activities at Fairpark Asylum.
The mystery portion of the story is clever and unfolds perfectly. I enjoyed watching John and Tully work together as they uncover clues and figure out what’s been going on. It’s easy to see their initial attraction turn to mutual admiration, and finally evolve into a loving relationship as they find their happily-ever-after.
Adding even more power to the story is Mark James’ stunning narration of The Gentleman’s Madness, whether he is expressing the choked back emotion of John, trying to hide his passionate reactions from the staff, or the sheer joy and laughter of Tully as he discovers the pleasures of freely interacting with his lover. From the words of love they share, whispered furtively in the dark cell of the sanatorium, to the madness of some of the residents confined within, Mr. James gives his all and infuses every emotional scene with the highs and lows intended by the authors.
As well received as this book was after its original release in 2013, I can only exclaim over the added power of Mark James’ narration. A truly meaningful, heartfelt love story, and a look back at a sad and unfortunate time in history, The Gentleman’s Madness is a novel not to be missed.
an audiobook copy of The Gentleman’s Madness was provided to me by the authors for the purpose of my review
July 17, 2014
4.5* rounded up to 5*
Buddy read with Lisa Henry and Joan. I think we all three agree on that this story is a truly well-researched historical. For me it was tone-perfect, in fact the prose often reminded me of Sherlock Holmes as written by Sir Conan Doyle. The worldbuilding was also extremely well done, not erring towards ok-homo, and not overdoing things. The plot worked smoothly and without any typical romance tropes (e.g. the separation and threat to the couple was from outside, and not some misunderstanding). The side characters were, for such a short book, also well-rendered and totally believable. I was engaged while reading.
I would have loved me some more in-depth descriptions of treatments and first tentative/rudimentary electroshock treatments, more time with the inmates of all classes, but that would have needed a far longer book than what it was.
All in all: very recommended, very fresh reading material.
Buddy read with Lisa Henry and Joan. I think we all three agree on that this story is a truly well-researched historical. For me it was tone-perfect, in fact the prose often reminded me of Sherlock Holmes as written by Sir Conan Doyle. The worldbuilding was also extremely well done, not erring towards ok-homo, and not overdoing things. The plot worked smoothly and without any typical romance tropes (e.g. the separation and threat to the couple was from outside, and not some misunderstanding). The side characters were, for such a short book, also well-rendered and totally believable. I was engaged while reading.
I would have loved me some more in-depth descriptions of treatments and first tentative/rudimentary electroshock treatments, more time with the inmates of all classes, but that would have needed a far longer book than what it was.
All in all: very recommended, very fresh reading material.
December 30, 2013
*3.75 stars*
I’ll be honest, I was scared going into this book. I had previously read a book which told the story of a gay man being admitted into a mental hospital for treatment. It was one of the most disturbing things I have ever read. I had no interest in putting myself through that much emotional upheaval again. On the other hand, I had also previously read a historical romance co-authored by Summer Devon and Bonnie Dee. It was The Gentleman and the Rogue, and I really enjoyed that book. I wanted to read another book by them, so I went into this book hoping for the best. I think I got exactly that.
John is a young man who voluntarily committed himself for treatment after his father caught him with another man. I don’t think he had any confidence the treatment would work, but he was willing to give it a try. At worst he thought he might waste a few months of his life, and at best it would be a way for his family to move beyond the embarrassing incident. Either way, he thought he would go, get the treatment, get out, and then go about his normal life. It wasn’t as simple as he originally thought, and what he found within the hospitals confines was so much worse than he ever expected.
The book begins with John going through the monotonous existence that is daily life for him within the mental hospital. John doesn’t experience any of the nightmarish therapy I had feared. John is mostly kept in seclusion with only brief escapes from his locked room for hydrotherapy treatments. For an intellectual and scholar like John, the lack of human interaction and mental stimulation is enough to drive him to madness. John is starting to lose hope of ever being released when he meets Tully.
Tully is far from being an intellectual, but he is a caring and compassionate man. He is the first attendant John has ever encountered to treat him like a human being worthy of basic rights and respect. Tully also has a little glimmer in his eye which lets John know they may be more alike than different.
The slow build from attraction to love between Tully and John was sweet. I try to avoid using that word but it’s the only word I can think of to describe them. I say that because they went into their relationship with genuine affection for one another. The dangerous environment forced them to be so careful that they really thought through every small touch or smile they shared. They knew the consequences for getting caught and were not going to take that risk just to satisfy their lust.
While the environment of the mental hospital made for a lovely slow-burn romance, it also caused me a lot of anxiety. Every time John and Tully threw caution to the wind, I was was worried for them. There were people in the hospital with secrets they would kill to keep hidden. Tully and John were getting a bit too close to uncovering those secrets, and someone very dangerous was watching their every move just waiting for them to make a mistake. As much as I loved the heartwarming romance, I was also plagued by anxiety through most of this book.
Probably the biggest hurdle for me was at the end. All throughout the book, there were a thousand obstacles in the way of Tully and John being together and only a very slim chance of them finding happiness. I hate to say it, but the almost perfect end result was almost a letdown for me. Don’t get me wrong, I was thrilled for them to be together and happy. I was just a little irritated that I spent most of the book being worried about things which never happened, only to see that everything fell neatly into place. I may not have been sold on the too perfect conclusion, but I was very excited by where they ended up. It was so open to possibility and would be a great starting point for another book. I would love to see what becomes of the life Tully and John have made for themselves.
I’ll be honest, I was scared going into this book. I had previously read a book which told the story of a gay man being admitted into a mental hospital for treatment. It was one of the most disturbing things I have ever read. I had no interest in putting myself through that much emotional upheaval again. On the other hand, I had also previously read a historical romance co-authored by Summer Devon and Bonnie Dee. It was The Gentleman and the Rogue, and I really enjoyed that book. I wanted to read another book by them, so I went into this book hoping for the best. I think I got exactly that.
John is a young man who voluntarily committed himself for treatment after his father caught him with another man. I don’t think he had any confidence the treatment would work, but he was willing to give it a try. At worst he thought he might waste a few months of his life, and at best it would be a way for his family to move beyond the embarrassing incident. Either way, he thought he would go, get the treatment, get out, and then go about his normal life. It wasn’t as simple as he originally thought, and what he found within the hospitals confines was so much worse than he ever expected.
The book begins with John going through the monotonous existence that is daily life for him within the mental hospital. John doesn’t experience any of the nightmarish therapy I had feared. John is mostly kept in seclusion with only brief escapes from his locked room for hydrotherapy treatments. For an intellectual and scholar like John, the lack of human interaction and mental stimulation is enough to drive him to madness. John is starting to lose hope of ever being released when he meets Tully.
Tully is far from being an intellectual, but he is a caring and compassionate man. He is the first attendant John has ever encountered to treat him like a human being worthy of basic rights and respect. Tully also has a little glimmer in his eye which lets John know they may be more alike than different.
The slow build from attraction to love between Tully and John was sweet. I try to avoid using that word but it’s the only word I can think of to describe them. I say that because they went into their relationship with genuine affection for one another. The dangerous environment forced them to be so careful that they really thought through every small touch or smile they shared. They knew the consequences for getting caught and were not going to take that risk just to satisfy their lust.
While the environment of the mental hospital made for a lovely slow-burn romance, it also caused me a lot of anxiety. Every time John and Tully threw caution to the wind, I was was worried for them. There were people in the hospital with secrets they would kill to keep hidden. Tully and John were getting a bit too close to uncovering those secrets, and someone very dangerous was watching their every move just waiting for them to make a mistake. As much as I loved the heartwarming romance, I was also plagued by anxiety through most of this book.
Probably the biggest hurdle for me was at the end. All throughout the book, there were a thousand obstacles in the way of Tully and John being together and only a very slim chance of them finding happiness. I hate to say it, but the almost perfect end result was almost a letdown for me. Don’t get me wrong, I was thrilled for them to be together and happy. I was just a little irritated that I spent most of the book being worried about things which never happened, only to see that everything fell neatly into place. I may not have been sold on the too perfect conclusion, but I was very excited by where they ended up. It was so open to possibility and would be a great starting point for another book. I would love to see what becomes of the life Tully and John have made for themselves.
January 29, 2014
As my "final" book for my personal MM historical challenge this month, once again, I got help from Heather C who rec'd this. Since I loved the first book that I tried from this author, The Gentleman and The Rogue, I thought, why not...
In the beginning, I was quite shocked to find out that the story took place at an asylum. Truthfully, I didn't even read about the blurb, I just picked it out because Heather rec'd it. So it immediately brought me anxiety. I couldn't help it -- the idea of men being 'treated' in those places, with electrical shock and ice-bath treatments, it BROKE my heart. I was worried that the story would go to dark and sad path, and I didn't know if I would be ready for it. With the setting in asylum like so, I don't know if my heart could take it!!
However, THANKFULLY, the story didn't offer heavy depression or torture. It did have melancholy tone to it -- with John being a patient, who longed for his freedom, who savored the friendship and kindness from Tully. I fell in love with both characters who compliment each other so perfectly. John with his hunger for academia and research and science while Tully has a more grounded compassion towards other humans. The slow-build from friendship to love was written wonderfully
The story also offered some dangerous situations, especially when John and Tully decided to pursue a more physical relationship. I was on the edge of my seat, being scared for the two of them. Unfortunately, with that kind of suspense, the resolution for this was a bit of a let-down. I was a bit annoyed with the easy way out in form of discovery of files that became proof about what went wrong at the asylum. I was content with John and Tully's happy-ever-after, but I wished it was more, uhm, difficult than that. That way the ending could feel more rewarding.
Having said that, it was still a beautiful and engaging tale. I guess, my January personal challenge is finished with a high note.
Personal MM historical challenge January 2014: story #7
In the beginning, I was quite shocked to find out that the story took place at an asylum. Truthfully, I didn't even read about the blurb, I just picked it out because Heather rec'd it. So it immediately brought me anxiety. I couldn't help it -- the idea of men being 'treated' in those places, with electrical shock and ice-bath treatments, it BROKE my heart. I was worried that the story would go to dark and sad path, and I didn't know if I would be ready for it. With the setting in asylum like so, I don't know if my heart could take it!!
However, THANKFULLY, the story didn't offer heavy depression or torture. It did have melancholy tone to it -- with John being a patient, who longed for his freedom, who savored the friendship and kindness from Tully. I fell in love with both characters who compliment each other so perfectly. John with his hunger for academia and research and science while Tully has a more grounded compassion towards other humans. The slow-build from friendship to love was written wonderfully
The story also offered some dangerous situations, especially when John and Tully decided to pursue a more physical relationship. I was on the edge of my seat, being scared for the two of them. Unfortunately, with that kind of suspense, the resolution for this was a bit of a let-down. I was a bit annoyed with the easy way out in form of discovery of files that became proof about what went wrong at the asylum. I was content with John and Tully's happy-ever-after, but I wished it was more, uhm, difficult than that. That way the ending could feel more rewarding.
Having said that, it was still a beautiful and engaging tale. I guess, my January personal challenge is finished with a high note.
... The two of them were well matched after all. John like a bright schooner balancing lightly on the waves of life, and Tully the harbor where he found safety and shelter and rest
Personal MM historical challenge January 2014: story #7
January 6, 2014
I just couldn't wait to get my hands on The Gentleman's Madness; the latest Bonnie Dee and Summer Devon collaboration. These two are at the top of my auto-buy list when it comes to historical romances.
As you already know, in most gay historical romances, the characters are able to keep their considered "deviant behaviors" behind closed doors and away from discovery. But what happens to that man who has been caught in a compromising and perverse situation? The man who has been incarcerated for his so-called "illness"? Its London 1887, and John Gilliam is that man; a young academic committed to an insane asylum by his wealthy family to be "cured". After being assaulted at the first facility, John has been moved to the wealthy wing of Fairpark under the care of Dr. McAndrew. There he meets Sam Tully, the big muscled, uneducated attendant who has been hiding his secret attraction towards men since gaining a job at Fairpark. Of course, both men are immediately attracted to each other and John takes on sweet, gentle Tully as his new student. The attraction between them soon sparks a dangerous affair...one that could be the end of them if ever discovered...
The setting: I think the biggest thing that stands out for me in this book is the setting; I've never read an actual romance set entirely in an insane asylum. It was dark and scary, and not a place to stimulate a romance, but it worked. A very sweet and beautiful romance develops during the midst of all the dark undertones.
The characters: I adored both John and Tully. John has been so traumatized and his despair from losing his freedom has nearly broken him. And then Tully arrives to bring some light back into his days and even darker nights. John comes from a rich influential family, and Tully comes from the docks; John is highly intelligent with a very active mind, and Tully is a laborer who is used to "smarter" people telling him how and what to think. Two men as opposite as can be...but equal in so many ways that nobody sees. Such intense chemistry between them. I loved these two soooooo much!
The dialogue: So much beautiful dialogue here. I had numerous passages highlighted on my Kindle but this statement from Tully never left me: "You mistake me, I think. That sort of thing, that talking beautifully, is rarer than what you call normal life around here. I imagine it comes from all those books you read."
The pace: It took me until about 10% before I really got hooked into this one. Its not a rushed setting and the romance is very slow burn...two things that I LOVE! Also, there isn't a lot of sex in this one compared to what I'm used to reading from these authors. While all those things may not work for some people, it worked 100% for me this time.
The mystery: There was bit of mystery surrounding some dark secrets going on at Fairpark; its not too difficult, nor too surprising, but it did have me guessing there for a while.
The ending: I felt that the "big reunion" between John and Tully near the end was cut off too abruptly! But when I saw "Two years later...", I was a little more relieved. Plus, it was a beautiful and sweet HEA, but I still wanted more from that reunion.
In summary, I really loved this story. It definitely ranks up there along with my love for The Gentleman and the Rogue, another story I highly recommend from these two authors.
4.5 Stars
Review can also be found at The Blogger Girls
As you already know, in most gay historical romances, the characters are able to keep their considered "deviant behaviors" behind closed doors and away from discovery. But what happens to that man who has been caught in a compromising and perverse situation? The man who has been incarcerated for his so-called "illness"? Its London 1887, and John Gilliam is that man; a young academic committed to an insane asylum by his wealthy family to be "cured". After being assaulted at the first facility, John has been moved to the wealthy wing of Fairpark under the care of Dr. McAndrew. There he meets Sam Tully, the big muscled, uneducated attendant who has been hiding his secret attraction towards men since gaining a job at Fairpark. Of course, both men are immediately attracted to each other and John takes on sweet, gentle Tully as his new student. The attraction between them soon sparks a dangerous affair...one that could be the end of them if ever discovered...
The setting: I think the biggest thing that stands out for me in this book is the setting; I've never read an actual romance set entirely in an insane asylum. It was dark and scary, and not a place to stimulate a romance, but it worked. A very sweet and beautiful romance develops during the midst of all the dark undertones.
The characters: I adored both John and Tully. John has been so traumatized and his despair from losing his freedom has nearly broken him. And then Tully arrives to bring some light back into his days and even darker nights. John comes from a rich influential family, and Tully comes from the docks; John is highly intelligent with a very active mind, and Tully is a laborer who is used to "smarter" people telling him how and what to think. Two men as opposite as can be...but equal in so many ways that nobody sees. Such intense chemistry between them. I loved these two soooooo much!
The dialogue: So much beautiful dialogue here. I had numerous passages highlighted on my Kindle but this statement from Tully never left me: "You mistake me, I think. That sort of thing, that talking beautifully, is rarer than what you call normal life around here. I imagine it comes from all those books you read."
The pace: It took me until about 10% before I really got hooked into this one. Its not a rushed setting and the romance is very slow burn...two things that I LOVE! Also, there isn't a lot of sex in this one compared to what I'm used to reading from these authors. While all those things may not work for some people, it worked 100% for me this time.
The mystery: There was bit of mystery surrounding some dark secrets going on at Fairpark; its not too difficult, nor too surprising, but it did have me guessing there for a while.
The ending: I felt that the "big reunion" between John and Tully near the end was cut off too abruptly! But when I saw "Two years later...", I was a little more relieved. Plus, it was a beautiful and sweet HEA, but I still wanted more from that reunion.
In summary, I really loved this story. It definitely ranks up there along with my love for The Gentleman and the Rogue, another story I highly recommend from these two authors.
4.5 Stars
Review can also be found at The Blogger Girls
April 24, 2018
After reading Kim Fielding's haunting "The Tin Box," I was hesitant to read this historical about John Gilliam, found in flagrante delicto by his father and placed in a sanitarium to be cured of this " deviant sexual practice [...] likely caused by congenital inversion during the birth.”
John willingly goes to a sanitarium to humor his father, but ends up being assaulted and moved to a more restrictive sanitarium and subjected to cold water baths, straitjackets and solitary. He meets attendant Tully, who shares John's dangerous predilection and their relationship moves from teacher/student into a touching love story.
Despite some shocking revelations and dangers, Bonnie Dee steers her characters from the worst of "what could have been" and I liked how she crafted their HEA. 4 stars.
John willingly goes to a sanitarium to humor his father, but ends up being assaulted and moved to a more restrictive sanitarium and subjected to cold water baths, straitjackets and solitary. He meets attendant Tully, who shares John's dangerous predilection and their relationship moves from teacher/student into a touching love story.
Despite some shocking revelations and dangers, Bonnie Dee steers her characters from the worst of "what could have been" and I liked how she crafted their HEA. 4 stars.
June 23, 2020
The initial idea was very intriguing and I enjoyed the book up until the halfway mark when things became somewhat rushed and not very compelling.
The ending is also rather abrupt.
The ending is also rather abrupt.
January 18, 2014
This well-written story paints a realistic picture of a gentleman imprisoned in an asylum for "treatment" of his "perversion." John Gilliam is an academic. He is also a homosexual in Victorian England. His father discovers his deviance and John agrees to treatment to cure his unnatural desires. This is commensurate with the time period. (Though still an issue in some locales today!)
In his second asylum (the first where he had been brutally attacked and nearly raped by staff) John experiences compassion from one of the attendants, a burly man named Sam Tully. In recognition of his kindness, John seeks to educate Tully--both in reading and numbers. Their acquaintance grows into a friendship and attachment, and more.
During his 'treatment' small moments loom large. A gentle brush back of his hair, a reassuring pat on the shoulder, tiny stolen touches that pull John from despair into happiness. And for Tully, who strives to hide his own unnatural predilection, John is all he could hope for. The men become intimate, under the cover of darkness or during Tully's lessons.
Unfortunately, the other attendants aren't so moral--or kind. Jenkins, a habitually drunk and derelict attendant, seeks to blackmail both John and Tully for pooftery. Though he has no direct proof of their interactions, an accusation will undoubtedly cost Tully his job and keep John a patient indefinitely.
Recognizing that there is something fishy about Jenkins employment, John urges Tully to investigate. Learning the history of indiscretions that have occurred in the asylum, the possibility to get John out safely seems small. Tully and John each have their battles to gain John's freedom.
And what then? Can a gentleman and a laborer find happiness with each other? Would the world accept their companionship?
I loved this one. A steady build of tension throughout helped develop the clandestine love affair. The subject matter--human experimentation, institutional greed, homosexuality as a mental illness--were handled with due gravity. The love scenes were quiet, but poignant. Dual viewpoint really allowed the reader to experience both sides of the story.
I was gifted a free review copy through Goodreads Don't Buy My Love program.
In his second asylum (the first where he had been brutally attacked and nearly raped by staff) John experiences compassion from one of the attendants, a burly man named Sam Tully. In recognition of his kindness, John seeks to educate Tully--both in reading and numbers. Their acquaintance grows into a friendship and attachment, and more.
During his 'treatment' small moments loom large. A gentle brush back of his hair, a reassuring pat on the shoulder, tiny stolen touches that pull John from despair into happiness. And for Tully, who strives to hide his own unnatural predilection, John is all he could hope for. The men become intimate, under the cover of darkness or during Tully's lessons.
Unfortunately, the other attendants aren't so moral--or kind. Jenkins, a habitually drunk and derelict attendant, seeks to blackmail both John and Tully for pooftery. Though he has no direct proof of their interactions, an accusation will undoubtedly cost Tully his job and keep John a patient indefinitely.
Recognizing that there is something fishy about Jenkins employment, John urges Tully to investigate. Learning the history of indiscretions that have occurred in the asylum, the possibility to get John out safely seems small. Tully and John each have their battles to gain John's freedom.
And what then? Can a gentleman and a laborer find happiness with each other? Would the world accept their companionship?
I loved this one. A steady build of tension throughout helped develop the clandestine love affair. The subject matter--human experimentation, institutional greed, homosexuality as a mental illness--were handled with due gravity. The love scenes were quiet, but poignant. Dual viewpoint really allowed the reader to experience both sides of the story.
I was gifted a free review copy through Goodreads Don't Buy My Love program.
August 14, 2017
4.25 stars, ebook, novella: 164 pages
Bonnie Dee and Summer Devon have a distinct style. Once you're familiar with it, you know exactly what you'll get each time with their historical mm books, and yet all their stories keep their individuality, their freshness. And they never write tragedies, thank you. As Susan Elizabeth Phillips says, "Life's too short for 'dead-baby books.'"
Here, with The Gentleman's Madness, the heroes each have their own inner struggles, told compellingly, believably, and with which I connected mentally and emotionally. I adored the contrast--and conflict--of their social positions, backgrounds, physicality, and especially their personalities, one all enthusiasm, emotion, energy and the other, steady, down-to-earth, care-taking.
The plot is suspenseful (will they be caught?! will their differences be too much?) and the sexual tension is snap and sizzle, building gradually and steadily. The doctor and blackmailing attendant are briefly but believably drawn; I could see them as real people, not placement types for story progression. Same with the father, although briefly drawn, he had the material of realness.
That's my only criticism: the brevity of everything. But, the way the surface was offered--those damn inner struggles that make a novel--I *knew* the berg beneath was there. Then again, that's part of the Devon-Dee package: not an in-depth, lengthy exploration of character and place, but a quick novel that is a delight for the mind and senses, that has me thinking and feeling, exploring on my own, after I'm done reading.
And, always, a HEA, that is refreshing, surprising and still believable--I clenched and nail-bit my way through wondering how our authors would get these two men out of their mess! Ah, sweet satisfaction.
Bonnie Dee and Summer Devon have a distinct style. Once you're familiar with it, you know exactly what you'll get each time with their historical mm books, and yet all their stories keep their individuality, their freshness. And they never write tragedies, thank you. As Susan Elizabeth Phillips says, "Life's too short for 'dead-baby books.'"
Here, with The Gentleman's Madness, the heroes each have their own inner struggles, told compellingly, believably, and with which I connected mentally and emotionally. I adored the contrast--and conflict--of their social positions, backgrounds, physicality, and especially their personalities, one all enthusiasm, emotion, energy and the other, steady, down-to-earth, care-taking.
The plot is suspenseful (will they be caught?! will their differences be too much?) and the sexual tension is snap and sizzle, building gradually and steadily. The doctor and blackmailing attendant are briefly but believably drawn; I could see them as real people, not placement types for story progression. Same with the father, although briefly drawn, he had the material of realness.
That's my only criticism: the brevity of everything. But, the way the surface was offered--those damn inner struggles that make a novel--I *knew* the berg beneath was there. Then again, that's part of the Devon-Dee package: not an in-depth, lengthy exploration of character and place, but a quick novel that is a delight for the mind and senses, that has me thinking and feeling, exploring on my own, after I'm done reading.
And, always, a HEA, that is refreshing, surprising and still believable--I clenched and nail-bit my way through wondering how our authors would get these two men out of their mess! Ah, sweet satisfaction.
January 30, 2014
Historical books in M/M carry an extra weight, because despite all the issues of inequality that we still deal with, things have been worse in the past. It was only in 1973 that the American Psychiatric Association removed homosexuality as a psychological disorder category. For much of history, being gay could not only get you harmed by those who disliked you, it could also get you incarcerated in a mental institution by those who loved you, and who felt they were doing the best thing for you. Given the quality and practices of asylums through much of history, this is tantamount to being handed over to be tortured for your blue eye color by your brown-eyed parents, in the loving hope that your eye color could be forcibly changed. Reading about those times is always painful, no matter what the story carries along with that pain.
That's what has happened to John Gilliam. After being found on his knees in front of another man by his father and his father's friends, John agreed to go into a mental institution, partly to appease his father's dismay, and partly in the vain hope that he can perhaps be cured of his unfortunate proclivities. But he has quickly realized three things - the "treatments" amount to torture and have no effect on his preferences; - it is one thing to agree to be committed, a far, far more difficult thing to get out again; -and the doctor who runs the asylum is not as disinterested and well-meaning as he seems, and has multiple reasons to keep his wealthier patients incarcerated.
John is close to despair at the powerlessness of his situation, but the impersonal kindness of an attendant gives him new hope. That hope becomes something else when the attendant, Tully, turns out to also be gay.
There were parts of this story that I really appreciated. The asylum setting was a looming evil, all the worse because it was reality for so many people, not just gay men but "hysterical" women and others who were committed in an age when that was often a one-way trip into a dark hole. If anything, the situation is downplayed here, enough to keep hope and some optimism alive in the story. Tully is a great character, as a somewhat simple, kindly man who has a desire to help the unfortunates in his care, and comes to see that simply following doctors' orders and doing his best may not let him do that. His joint disillusionment and growing awareness of his own potential is well done.
There is a real mismatch between John and Tully, in almost every aspect. They are different in size, experience, education, class, body type, family history, and resources. Sometimes opposites attract, but I really wished this book was a bit longer, in before the epilogue. I was not fully persuaded by this as a love match, and I think a bit more exposition in that gap of time could have gone some way to fixing that.
The plot device that got John out also felt a little contrived. I applaud the writers for avoiding melodrama. At the same time, I wasn't totally convinced by the way it all went down. So this story didn't keep me immersed and contented to the degree that some others by this writing team have done. Still worth a read, and the epilogue pulled it back firmly into 4-star territory for me.
I closed it thinking of all those who have suffered for being different, or considered inferior, in so many venues and under so many power structures. Historically and today, xenophobia and lack of compassion are two of humanity's besetting sins.
That's what has happened to John Gilliam. After being found on his knees in front of another man by his father and his father's friends, John agreed to go into a mental institution, partly to appease his father's dismay, and partly in the vain hope that he can perhaps be cured of his unfortunate proclivities. But he has quickly realized three things - the "treatments" amount to torture and have no effect on his preferences; - it is one thing to agree to be committed, a far, far more difficult thing to get out again; -and the doctor who runs the asylum is not as disinterested and well-meaning as he seems, and has multiple reasons to keep his wealthier patients incarcerated.
John is close to despair at the powerlessness of his situation, but the impersonal kindness of an attendant gives him new hope. That hope becomes something else when the attendant, Tully, turns out to also be gay.
There were parts of this story that I really appreciated. The asylum setting was a looming evil, all the worse because it was reality for so many people, not just gay men but "hysterical" women and others who were committed in an age when that was often a one-way trip into a dark hole. If anything, the situation is downplayed here, enough to keep hope and some optimism alive in the story. Tully is a great character, as a somewhat simple, kindly man who has a desire to help the unfortunates in his care, and comes to see that simply following doctors' orders and doing his best may not let him do that. His joint disillusionment and growing awareness of his own potential is well done.
There is a real mismatch between John and Tully, in almost every aspect. They are different in size, experience, education, class, body type, family history, and resources. Sometimes opposites attract, but I really wished this book was a bit longer, in before the epilogue. I was not fully persuaded by this as a love match, and I think a bit more exposition in that gap of time could have gone some way to fixing that.
The plot device that got John out also felt a little contrived. I applaud the writers for avoiding melodrama. At the same time, I wasn't totally convinced by the way it all went down. So this story didn't keep me immersed and contented to the degree that some others by this writing team have done. Still worth a read, and the epilogue pulled it back firmly into 4-star territory for me.
I closed it thinking of all those who have suffered for being different, or considered inferior, in so many venues and under so many power structures. Historically and today, xenophobia and lack of compassion are two of humanity's besetting sins.
January 6, 2014
ARC Review: The Gentleman's Madness A historical M/M romance, apparently well researched and written with the proper language of the times as well as creating the right setting. John Gilliam has been sent to an insane asylum after being discovered by his father in a compromising position with another man, something not done in 1880's England. John's account of the treatment he receives at the facility, and his mental and physical suffering are somewhat glossed over, but when the reader is given insight to John's musings, a clear picture emerges.
Samuel Tully is one of the asylum's attendants and "suffers" from the same affliction. The two men grow beyond the patient/attendant relationship, and I liked the slow burn of their affections. Their escape from the asylum was also well done, though I found John's father to be rather dull and wishy-washy, and somewhat unrealistic in his dealings.
The writing is what kept me interested, and the characterization of John Gilliam was rather well done. The relationship between John and Sam progresses slowly enough to be realistic, though both men are in fear of discovery. The processes of the therapy and the methods employed were also described in realistic ways, and it was clear that the author had done research on these things.
The author managed to make me care about the characters, and I was happy to see them happy by the end. The two MCs seemed well suited to each other, and their relationship didn't appear fake or contrived, nor did it smack of John being simply grateful to Sam. The two men forged a relationship out of a terrible situation, but progressed beyond it in the epilogue.
Not bad. Not bad indeed.
PS: The cover is hideous. The image is a stock photograph that I've seen on other books and it doesn't do this book any favor to use it. Please, please, do a better job on choosing an image.
** I received a free ARC from the publisher via Author's HQ. A positive review was not promised in return. **
Samuel Tully is one of the asylum's attendants and "suffers" from the same affliction. The two men grow beyond the patient/attendant relationship, and I liked the slow burn of their affections. Their escape from the asylum was also well done, though I found John's father to be rather dull and wishy-washy, and somewhat unrealistic in his dealings.
The writing is what kept me interested, and the characterization of John Gilliam was rather well done. The relationship between John and Sam progresses slowly enough to be realistic, though both men are in fear of discovery. The processes of the therapy and the methods employed were also described in realistic ways, and it was clear that the author had done research on these things.
The author managed to make me care about the characters, and I was happy to see them happy by the end. The two MCs seemed well suited to each other, and their relationship didn't appear fake or contrived, nor did it smack of John being simply grateful to Sam. The two men forged a relationship out of a terrible situation, but progressed beyond it in the epilogue.
Not bad. Not bad indeed.
PS: The cover is hideous. The image is a stock photograph that I've seen on other books and it doesn't do this book any favor to use it. Please, please, do a better job on choosing an image.
** I received a free ARC from the publisher via Author's HQ. A positive review was not promised in return. **
January 3, 2014
I've always been interested in turn-of-the-century insane asylums. I adored Kim Fielding's "The Tin Box" and so when I saw this brand new release from Summer Devon and Bonnie Dee (whose other historical romances I've quite liked), I had to get it and read it AT ONCE.
As usual, this writing duo did not let me down. This story is historically accurate, with a strong sense of place and time. If I'm going to read a historical, I appreciate if it introduces me to a world I don't know much about, and feels legit and well-researched, rather than just glossing over the details. This one achieves that. Most of this story is set in an insane asylum where one of the MCs has been 'sentenced' for a 'cure' after his father discovers him in flagrante delicto with another man. The other MC is a staff member at the asylum.
The romance was well-done, with lots of UST building up to the giving in to desires. There was some angst, but it wasn't terribly dark, which I appreciate. The ending HEA was very satisfying.
Definitely recommended if you like m/m historicals. Nice job, Bonnie and Summer!
As usual, this writing duo did not let me down. This story is historically accurate, with a strong sense of place and time. If I'm going to read a historical, I appreciate if it introduces me to a world I don't know much about, and feels legit and well-researched, rather than just glossing over the details. This one achieves that. Most of this story is set in an insane asylum where one of the MCs has been 'sentenced' for a 'cure' after his father discovers him in flagrante delicto with another man. The other MC is a staff member at the asylum.
The romance was well-done, with lots of UST building up to the giving in to desires. There was some angst, but it wasn't terribly dark, which I appreciate. The ending HEA was very satisfying.
Definitely recommended if you like m/m historicals. Nice job, Bonnie and Summer!
January 14, 2014
No one does historical like these ladies. Every story I read by them just sucks me in and I fall in love. This one. Wow. We know men were put in asylums for their "unnatural proclivities" for a long time but you never truly stop and think about it. I thought this was a great look into it, as always with flawless research and a wonderful feel for the era. I could feel poor John's desperation and it hurt. And Tully, I couldn't help but fall in love with him. Wonderful.
January 21, 2014
*I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.*
I've read a few books by these authors before so when I read the blurb for this one I was very excited to read it. I've always been terrified of (and fascinated by) insane asylums, so I was a bit afraid this was going to rip my heart out and make me go cry in a corner, but it was actually fairly light given the setting. Things could have been much much worse for John. Not that I wanted to bawl my way through this book, but I think a little more darkness would have served to highlight how much joy John's relationship with Tully brought him.
I liked John and Tully as a couple. Tully was very empathetic and kind toward all the patients, and I enjoyed the way John encouraged him to open up his mind and think for himself about the treatments the patients were receiving. The novel was fairly light on the sex side, which I also enjoyed. It was very sweet and seemed to fit the time period, when sodomy was a very dangerous act to engage in.
The suspense plot didn't work as well for me. I felt it came a little late in the story and some of John's attempts to trick the doctor read a little over the top to me. By this point I also had no worries that Tully was going to save John somehow, so I wished the plot had been able to scare me a little more on that front.
I usually struggle a little with HEAs in historicals, since I think they are so hard to write realistically, but this one actually pulled it off. I think the time period of the 1880s helped with that, as well as neither character being part of the aristocracy. It was much more believable that they could give up their jobs to live together somewhere safe.
As I've come to expect from these authors, this was a well written, enjoyable, and accurate (as far as I can tell) historical. However, The Gentleman and the Rogue remains my favorite by this duo.
I've read a few books by these authors before so when I read the blurb for this one I was very excited to read it. I've always been terrified of (and fascinated by) insane asylums, so I was a bit afraid this was going to rip my heart out and make me go cry in a corner, but it was actually fairly light given the setting. Things could have been much much worse for John. Not that I wanted to bawl my way through this book, but I think a little more darkness would have served to highlight how much joy John's relationship with Tully brought him.
I liked John and Tully as a couple. Tully was very empathetic and kind toward all the patients, and I enjoyed the way John encouraged him to open up his mind and think for himself about the treatments the patients were receiving. The novel was fairly light on the sex side, which I also enjoyed. It was very sweet and seemed to fit the time period, when sodomy was a very dangerous act to engage in.
The suspense plot didn't work as well for me. I felt it came a little late in the story and some of John's attempts to trick the doctor read a little over the top to me. By this point I also had no worries that Tully was going to save John somehow, so I wished the plot had been able to scare me a little more on that front.
I usually struggle a little with HEAs in historicals, since I think they are so hard to write realistically, but this one actually pulled it off. I think the time period of the 1880s helped with that, as well as neither character being part of the aristocracy. It was much more believable that they could give up their jobs to live together somewhere safe.
As I've come to expect from these authors, this was a well written, enjoyable, and accurate (as far as I can tell) historical. However, The Gentleman and the Rogue remains my favorite by this duo.
July 23, 2016
John's ability to find ways to believe he will be freed from the hell hole in which he finds himself is admirable. I was not always so convinced. I was so glad when he found Tully, a gentle giant of a man, with the same 'unfortunate' proclivities as John.
A mental hospital today is a scary enough thought, but one back in the 1880s would have been unbearable. The narrative doesn't get too bogged down in too much depression or depravity, just enough to give us the sense of John's desperation and melancholy.
And if the conclusion was just a bit too happy, well, sue me for being glad that these two brave and resourceful fellows were given an appropriate HEA.
Enjoyed this.
A mental hospital today is a scary enough thought, but one back in the 1880s would have been unbearable. The narrative doesn't get too bogged down in too much depression or depravity, just enough to give us the sense of John's desperation and melancholy.
And if the conclusion was just a bit too happy, well, sue me for being glad that these two brave and resourceful fellows were given an appropriate HEA.
Enjoyed this.
January 29, 2014
I've really enjoyed the other historical titles I've read by Summer Devon and Bonnie Dee, so when I heard they had released a new title I snapped it up right off.
And this one doesn't disappoint---it compares very favourably to their other collaborations. The story does make you think about how lucky we are to be living during this time period, considering how forced incarceration in mental hospitals for "reparative therapy" was so common in the past.
It's an uplifting story, and the obligatory happy ending manages to be period-appropriate as well. Recommended for those who enjoy gay-themed historicals.
And this one doesn't disappoint---it compares very favourably to their other collaborations. The story does make you think about how lucky we are to be living during this time period, considering how forced incarceration in mental hospitals for "reparative therapy" was so common in the past.
It's an uplifting story, and the obligatory happy ending manages to be period-appropriate as well. Recommended for those who enjoy gay-themed historicals.
April 6, 2014
I was hoping for something like this:
I got this instead:
[image error]
Set at the end of the 18th century, the book tells the story of John Gilliam, an academic locked up in an asylum for his homosexuality and Sam Tully, an attendant who is attracted to John. Gilliam’s stay in the asylum felt like a holiday in a low cost resort . Too happy and angst free for my taste.
Read
January 4, 2014A solid, well-researched historical with a nice dose of helplessness thrown in. Of course John's not mad, and of course he doesn't need to be cured. Society disagrees.
Buddy read with Steelwhisper and Joan. See the comments in Steel's review
I'm not terribly in love with the cover though. For some reason it screams "paranormal" to me. I was half-expecting John to turn out to be a vampire.
Buddy read with Steelwhisper and Joan. See the comments in Steel's review
I'm not terribly in love with the cover though. For some reason it screams "paranormal" to me. I was half-expecting John to turn out to be a vampire.
January 24, 2014
The blurb ended up being much better than the book - OR - I was expecting more of this story than I was given. The cover didn't help either... I thought that the hero would be an intense, tortured semi-psycho or it would head toward some type of paranormal element.
April 4, 2014
Think Maurice, but in an insane asylum.
Cambridge graduate John Gilliam has been committed by his rich father to the Fairpark asylum to cure his unnatural urges. Lower-class Adam Tully is working as an attendant at Fairpark to earn enough money to buy his own ailing father a home for his waning years.
Unlike the egotistical and narrow-minded doctors at Fairpark, however, Tully is gentle and compassionate. He is the go-to guy when a disturbed patient needs soothing. Tully, unlike Gilliam, has successfully suppressed his illegal desires, and seeks only to care for the inmates as best he can.
Until he meets John Gilliam.
The classic British tradition of crossing class lines for love is alive and well in The Gentleman’s Madness. The expert team of Dee and Devon offer their readers chilling insight into the mental health practices of late Victorian England. The carefully outlined details of life in the madhouse, as well as the appalling treatments that were presumed to be effective in curing nervous disorders, suggest that the authors did their homework.
Oddly enough, Fairpark Asylum reminds me of Dr. John Seward’s upscale asylum in suburban London in Dracula; all medieval torture disguised as modern-day medicine. Bram Stoker’s famous 1897 novel is in essence a metaphor for the survival of evil in spite of scientific discovery and modernization.
But at Fairpark, the fearsome monster is no ancient vampire, but simply the human condition that Havelock Ellis charmingly described in 1896 as “sexual inversion.” Thus The Gentleman’s Madness becomes its own kind of metaphor for the survival of love in the face of cultural bigotry and blind faith in the infallibility of scientific method.
It is no mean feat to create a tender romance in the context of the social and medical nightmares that homosexuality could trigger in the late 1880s. To show the burgeoning feelings of affection between two men, fully aware of the risk their feelings posed for them, takes a delicate touch. Dee and Devon create intense, loving portraits of these two men, drawn to each other at first by the need of one to care for a wounded soul; but later by the growing mutual attraction that, were it to be noticed, would endanger both of their lives.
While there are bad men in this book, they are not simply evil; this is a world in which good intentions and honorable beginnings can stray down evil paths. The portrayal of Gilliam’s parents is particularly disturbing, because it is clear that they are all but helpless to act in any way other than they do, because of the social pressures and cultural conventions of their class and culture.
All of this makes for plenty of anxiety on the part of the reader, as we watch Tully and Gilliam move inexorably toward the very emotional climax that we, as m/m fiction fans, expect and demand.
The Gentleman’s Madness maintains a period authenticity and a sense of historical precision that makes it a rewarding read, above and beyond the romance. The great nineteenth-century British novels were all romances as well, and Dee and Devon can be proud of their efforts to walk in the august footsteps of Dickens and Trollope.
Keep it up, ladies.
January 21, 2014
4.75
(Free review copy provided by the authors in exchange for an honest review through the GR MM Romance Group DBML program.) This well-written story set in 1887 England could have been depressing, but it isn’t thanks to the beautiful writing style and the indomitable characters of John, who is feisty and exuberant, and Tully, who is calm and steady. John is an intellectual and professor from a wealthy family, who is sent to an insane asylum for a “cure” after his concerned family catches him having sex with another man. Tully is from the working class, a former dock worker who finds his calling as a strong and compassionate attendant at the asylum.
They come together through an act of kindness on Tully’s part when John is at his lowest ebb, having been observed as a patient by a former friend from his own social class who is now practicing medicine. John feels like all his dignity has been stripped away, but Tully treats him with respect and kindness when taking him back to his room, and even manages to get him some writing materials which John is allowed to use under Tully’s supervision so he won’t potentially stab himself with a pen.
This starts a teacher-student relationship between John, who is desperate to share his knowledge, and Tully, who never had much schooling before he had to start working as a child. John and Tully become friends, but soon they recognize attraction between them, which is very dangerous in the asylum where John has been confined to be “cured” from desiring men. Tully has been hiding his attraction to men for his entire life and has reached such a state of loneliness and need that he cannot resist John’s subtle flirtations. Soon the men are having a secret affair afterhours, but they are stalked and watched by an attendant Jenkins who suspects their relationship.
John knows he must get out of the asylum, but the only one with power to secure his release is his father who is confusedly deferring to the asylum doctor, and there is something weird going on with the doctor that is worse than his obvious desire to delay the release of his patients for as long as possible to keep the money coming for their treatments. Tully must
I think an opportunity might have been missed to make the story really white-knuckled suspenseful because both the doctor and Jenkins are never quite as evil as they could have been. Also, the epilog might be slightly too long. But these are tiny things, and overall I couldn’t put this story down until I’d read through to the end. There is so much good about this story like the perfect dialog that sounds 1887 British, and all the period details that make the story come alive. And the characters are two men who deserve their happy ending and have a lot of personality. I think most readers, especially those who like historical fiction, will love this book.
(Free review copy provided by the authors in exchange for an honest review through the GR MM Romance Group DBML program.) This well-written story set in 1887 England could have been depressing, but it isn’t thanks to the beautiful writing style and the indomitable characters of John, who is feisty and exuberant, and Tully, who is calm and steady. John is an intellectual and professor from a wealthy family, who is sent to an insane asylum for a “cure” after his concerned family catches him having sex with another man. Tully is from the working class, a former dock worker who finds his calling as a strong and compassionate attendant at the asylum.
They come together through an act of kindness on Tully’s part when John is at his lowest ebb, having been observed as a patient by a former friend from his own social class who is now practicing medicine. John feels like all his dignity has been stripped away, but Tully treats him with respect and kindness when taking him back to his room, and even manages to get him some writing materials which John is allowed to use under Tully’s supervision so he won’t potentially stab himself with a pen.
This starts a teacher-student relationship between John, who is desperate to share his knowledge, and Tully, who never had much schooling before he had to start working as a child. John and Tully become friends, but soon they recognize attraction between them, which is very dangerous in the asylum where John has been confined to be “cured” from desiring men. Tully has been hiding his attraction to men for his entire life and has reached such a state of loneliness and need that he cannot resist John’s subtle flirtations. Soon the men are having a secret affair afterhours, but they are stalked and watched by an attendant Jenkins who suspects their relationship.
John knows he must get out of the asylum, but the only one with power to secure his release is his father who is confusedly deferring to the asylum doctor, and there is something weird going on with the doctor that is worse than his obvious desire to delay the release of his patients for as long as possible to keep the money coming for their treatments. Tully must
I think an opportunity might have been missed to make the story really white-knuckled suspenseful because both the doctor and Jenkins are never quite as evil as they could have been. Also, the epilog might be slightly too long. But these are tiny things, and overall I couldn’t put this story down until I’d read through to the end. There is so much good about this story like the perfect dialog that sounds 1887 British, and all the period details that make the story come alive. And the characters are two men who deserve their happy ending and have a lot of personality. I think most readers, especially those who like historical fiction, will love this book.
July 22, 2016
A free copy of this book was provided by the authors in exchange for an honest review.
This is the first book I’ve read by Summer Devon or Bonnie Dee. I’m generally reluctant to step out of my comfort zone, which often means I tend to stick with authors and genres I’m familiar with. Eventually, it was the summary that convinced me to take a chance and introduce myself with two new authors and a subgenre that I’m relatively foreign to.
John Gilliam, aka the professor, is caught in imprudent and shameful act with another man by his father and is sent to an asylum to get proper help and treatment for his unfortunate condition and “illness”. It is during his “recovery” that he meets Sam Tully, a caring and gentle attendant who first becomes a means to John’s aim and then slowly evolves into something much more.
The story begins in 1887. I’m pathetically clueless when it comes to history, but even I can put one and one together and realize that any relations beyond a brotherly hug between two men were strongly forbidden during that time. The subject as a taboo was strongly portrayed throughout the story and I liked how John explored his own feelings and desires through an academic mind instead of an emotional one. He was very rational and analyzed his conclusions to the finest details. Even his attraction towards Sam starts off sort of clinical, almost as a science experiment where the goal was to lead their relationship from that of a patient and an attendant to something resembling a friendship.
On many levels Sam is the exact opposite of John. He’s rather uneducated, lacking the faculty of introspection which comes naturally for John and he often resigns into believing what is said, especially if the message comes from someone on the higher rank in the society. This sort of blind faith must’ve been the general way of thinking in societies such as theirs and however pliable Sam might be, he’s not stupid. He has a good head on his shoulders and an ability to feel with all of his heart which I felt John couldn’t always do.
There are many things I liked in this book; the chemistry between the characters, the plot, the loyalty to the values of the particular time the story is set in. The wording and language used in the book is genuine and devoted to not only the timespan but to the characteristics of both the characters and the flow of the story. The authors did an amazing job in spinning a clever web of lies and secretiveness around a world and place which should serve safety and care. The mystery unravels slowly and I felt it was a very natural part of the story, not forced or something seperate from the main-story but simply blended softly into the unconventional lovestory between Tully and the professor.
Now, having read Gentleman’s Madness, I’m glad I introduced myself to new authors and a new type of stories. I enjoyed this read and I will no doubt read more from these two authors.
This is the first book I’ve read by Summer Devon or Bonnie Dee. I’m generally reluctant to step out of my comfort zone, which often means I tend to stick with authors and genres I’m familiar with. Eventually, it was the summary that convinced me to take a chance and introduce myself with two new authors and a subgenre that I’m relatively foreign to.
John Gilliam, aka the professor, is caught in imprudent and shameful act with another man by his father and is sent to an asylum to get proper help and treatment for his unfortunate condition and “illness”. It is during his “recovery” that he meets Sam Tully, a caring and gentle attendant who first becomes a means to John’s aim and then slowly evolves into something much more.
The story begins in 1887. I’m pathetically clueless when it comes to history, but even I can put one and one together and realize that any relations beyond a brotherly hug between two men were strongly forbidden during that time. The subject as a taboo was strongly portrayed throughout the story and I liked how John explored his own feelings and desires through an academic mind instead of an emotional one. He was very rational and analyzed his conclusions to the finest details. Even his attraction towards Sam starts off sort of clinical, almost as a science experiment where the goal was to lead their relationship from that of a patient and an attendant to something resembling a friendship.
On many levels Sam is the exact opposite of John. He’s rather uneducated, lacking the faculty of introspection which comes naturally for John and he often resigns into believing what is said, especially if the message comes from someone on the higher rank in the society. This sort of blind faith must’ve been the general way of thinking in societies such as theirs and however pliable Sam might be, he’s not stupid. He has a good head on his shoulders and an ability to feel with all of his heart which I felt John couldn’t always do.
There are many things I liked in this book; the chemistry between the characters, the plot, the loyalty to the values of the particular time the story is set in. The wording and language used in the book is genuine and devoted to not only the timespan but to the characteristics of both the characters and the flow of the story. The authors did an amazing job in spinning a clever web of lies and secretiveness around a world and place which should serve safety and care. The mystery unravels slowly and I felt it was a very natural part of the story, not forced or something seperate from the main-story but simply blended softly into the unconventional lovestory between Tully and the professor.
Now, having read Gentleman’s Madness, I’m glad I introduced myself to new authors and a new type of stories. I enjoyed this read and I will no doubt read more from these two authors.
July 26, 2016
A free copy of the book was provided to me by the author in exchange for an honest review.
I love m/m historical stories, so when The Gentleman's Madness became available for review as part of the Don't Buy My Love program, I jumped at the chance to read it. This book, however, is different than many romances set in the same time period (late 1800s) in that most of the story takes place in an asylum for the mentally ill. One of the MCs is a member of society, but there are no balls, social calls, hunts etc. This made the book interesting and also educational - albeit about a difficult subject - how the supposed mentally ill were treated at the time. I felt the authors walked a fine line with their handling of the treatment of the patients (or inmates as Gilliam calls them) and the various methods used to "cure" them. They provided enough information for the reader to understand what was happening, but not so many horrifying details as to make it too distressing to read.
The first part of the book focuses on the growing relationship between attendant Sam Tully and patient John Gilliam as well as each of their back stories. These two men were at the opposite ends of the social spectrum, but found common ground with reading and discussion. I loved how they became friends and confidants before anything physical happened between them. Gilliam's genuine interest in helping Tully with reading and in his opinions on various topics coupled with Tully's kindness and strength made for a wonderful couple (even under the terrible circumstances). There is not a ton of sex in the book, but the stolen times they find are quite exciting, maybe even more so because of the real danger involved if they were caught.
About a third of the way through, the story dragged a bit for me. It was tough to have Gilliam's hopes dashed so often. However, it picked up quickly as the mystery regarding attendant Jenkins and Dr. McAndrew started to unravel. I was on the edge of my seat at that point as John and Sam took many risks to help each other and the other patients.
I loved the last chapter of the book. Maybe it was a bit to HEA for some people, but the guys deserved it. And, the direction they decide to take their lives is wonderfully fitting.
I love m/m historical stories, so when The Gentleman's Madness became available for review as part of the Don't Buy My Love program, I jumped at the chance to read it. This book, however, is different than many romances set in the same time period (late 1800s) in that most of the story takes place in an asylum for the mentally ill. One of the MCs is a member of society, but there are no balls, social calls, hunts etc. This made the book interesting and also educational - albeit about a difficult subject - how the supposed mentally ill were treated at the time. I felt the authors walked a fine line with their handling of the treatment of the patients (or inmates as Gilliam calls them) and the various methods used to "cure" them. They provided enough information for the reader to understand what was happening, but not so many horrifying details as to make it too distressing to read.
The first part of the book focuses on the growing relationship between attendant Sam Tully and patient John Gilliam as well as each of their back stories. These two men were at the opposite ends of the social spectrum, but found common ground with reading and discussion. I loved how they became friends and confidants before anything physical happened between them. Gilliam's genuine interest in helping Tully with reading and in his opinions on various topics coupled with Tully's kindness and strength made for a wonderful couple (even under the terrible circumstances). There is not a ton of sex in the book, but the stolen times they find are quite exciting, maybe even more so because of the real danger involved if they were caught.
About a third of the way through, the story dragged a bit for me. It was tough to have Gilliam's hopes dashed so often. However, it picked up quickly as the mystery regarding attendant Jenkins and Dr. McAndrew started to unravel. I was on the edge of my seat at that point as John and Sam took many risks to help each other and the other patients.
I loved the last chapter of the book. Maybe it was a bit to HEA for some people, but the guys deserved it. And, the direction they decide to take their lives is wonderfully fitting.
August 13, 2016
I was given a free copy of this book by the author for an honest review.
Ok so my heart broke on the first page before I even knew the main characters' name...then I was on pins and needles the rest of the book. But by the end my heart was mended and I was able to relax (thank goodness).
For those who may think it is difficult being in a "non-traditional" relationship in this day and age think again...try having that same relationship in the 1800's. John and Tully were brave beyond words. I mean really, you are in an insane asylum for no other reason than being gay! And you don't let that stop you from following your heart...BRAVE! Or better yet your job is take care of a patient who suffers from this "affliction" knowing you have the same "affliction" and could easily go from guard to patient in a blink of an eye AND you still follow your heart...BRAVE!
John is a patient who was voluntarily committed to be cured of his perversions. Tully is a gentle giant of an attendant who just wants to take care of the patients. They met when Tully had to restrain John after an episode and showed John the first real kindness he'd seen since being admitted. Over time their feelings for each other start to grow but of course with those growing feelings come growing problems. The fear of being caught is just one of the problems...
What can I say forbidden love, murder, water torture oops I meant treatment. It's a good read try not to have a panic attack like I almost did :-)
Ok so my heart broke on the first page before I even knew the main characters' name...then I was on pins and needles the rest of the book. But by the end my heart was mended and I was able to relax (thank goodness).
For those who may think it is difficult being in a "non-traditional" relationship in this day and age think again...try having that same relationship in the 1800's. John and Tully were brave beyond words. I mean really, you are in an insane asylum for no other reason than being gay! And you don't let that stop you from following your heart...BRAVE! Or better yet your job is take care of a patient who suffers from this "affliction" knowing you have the same "affliction" and could easily go from guard to patient in a blink of an eye AND you still follow your heart...BRAVE!
John is a patient who was voluntarily committed to be cured of his perversions. Tully is a gentle giant of an attendant who just wants to take care of the patients. They met when Tully had to restrain John after an episode and showed John the first real kindness he'd seen since being admitted. Over time their feelings for each other start to grow but of course with those growing feelings come growing problems. The fear of being caught is just one of the problems...
What can I say forbidden love, murder, water torture oops I meant treatment. It's a good read try not to have a panic attack like I almost did :-)
January 9, 2014
#O_O that cover #omg what is this #am i actually staring at a clockwork orange? #seriously, look at those eyelashes #help alex was reborn and now he's staring at me and I'm just a little bit scared #oh god oh god I'm going to die
post-read
This was...too...happy. Cheerful. Not-dark-enough. It was...benign. I mean, I didn't exactly hate it, but everything went too well for the MCs. I dunno what I was expecting. Some more The Tin Box, maybe? Or something a bit more bleak, which would make Tully more of a light in the darkness, that sort of thing. Didn't happen. The epilogue was weird, too. I won't say much, since I did skim through most of the last part.
Eh. It was...well, it wasn't quite meh, but it's getting there. It's too...not-dark, actually. That lack made it lack depth. We're told of some dark stuff, apparently, in passing, but they don't seem to be too big of issues and they don't really affect the now. They just kind of, you know, existed, once.
I mean, this book isn't bad. It's just...so...benign...
The insides totally belie the cover.
post-read
This was...too...happy. Cheerful. Not-dark-enough. It was...benign. I mean, I didn't exactly hate it, but everything went too well for the MCs. I dunno what I was expecting. Some more The Tin Box, maybe? Or something a bit more bleak, which would make Tully more of a light in the darkness, that sort of thing. Didn't happen. The epilogue was weird, too. I won't say much, since I did skim through most of the last part.
Eh. It was...well, it wasn't quite meh, but it's getting there. It's too...not-dark, actually. That lack made it lack depth. We're told of some dark stuff, apparently, in passing, but they don't seem to be too big of issues and they don't really affect the now. They just kind of, you know, existed, once.
I mean, this book isn't bad. It's just...so...benign...
The insides totally belie the cover.
January 5, 2014
I have to be honest and say that when I started reading this I was in my element. Beautiful writing, fabulous characters, hints of real angst.... and then -
Well, it continued to be a beautiful story. Plenty of tender moments, a decent sub-plot and a fairly satisfactory ending, although a little bland. All the awfulness of the past erased, everything hunky-dory and perfect.
But it left me disappointed in a way. The angst was glossed over, the ending rushed. It lacked something. I was going to give it 3 stars, but it is a book I will re-read, even if it is to sigh over the missed opportunities.
(loved the cover!)
Well, it continued to be a beautiful story. Plenty of tender moments, a decent sub-plot and a fairly satisfactory ending, although a little bland. All the awfulness of the past erased, everything hunky-dory and perfect.
But it left me disappointed in a way. The angst was glossed over, the ending rushed. It lacked something. I was going to give it 3 stars, but it is a book I will re-read, even if it is to sigh over the missed opportunities.
(loved the cover!)
March 31, 2019
~AUDIO REVIEW~
What a trio!
Bonnie Dee, Summer Devon, and Mark James did an amazing job.
Poor John voluntarily puts himself into an insane asylum in 1887 because he is caught with another man by his father. Sam is an attendant working on John’s floor. He too is gay but keeps it a secret as he knows the consequences of coming out.
The two men long for each other not knowing the other feels the same.
I loved the slow burn and angst the two men endured. They are both in a place where people watch each other and it’s hard to get alone time giving me a rollercoaster of emotions. I wanted the two to be together, but I didn’t want them to get caught. At times they weren’t so secretive with their feelings or with being physical. There was another attendant, Jenkins, who was a mean drunk and always kept a close eye on John and Sam.
I enjoyed the mystery as well. Another time my emotions were on high alert and I enjoyed every minute of it.
Mark James does another wonderful job and I can’t wait to hear him again. His voice is clear, smooth and the emotions just come alive when he speaks.
What a trio!
Bonnie Dee, Summer Devon, and Mark James did an amazing job.
Poor John voluntarily puts himself into an insane asylum in 1887 because he is caught with another man by his father. Sam is an attendant working on John’s floor. He too is gay but keeps it a secret as he knows the consequences of coming out.
The two men long for each other not knowing the other feels the same.
I loved the slow burn and angst the two men endured. They are both in a place where people watch each other and it’s hard to get alone time giving me a rollercoaster of emotions. I wanted the two to be together, but I didn’t want them to get caught. At times they weren’t so secretive with their feelings or with being physical. There was another attendant, Jenkins, who was a mean drunk and always kept a close eye on John and Sam.
I enjoyed the mystery as well. Another time my emotions were on high alert and I enjoyed every minute of it.
Mark James does another wonderful job and I can’t wait to hear him again. His voice is clear, smooth and the emotions just come alive when he speaks.
January 7, 2014
4.5 Stars
This novel The Gentleman's Madness by Summer Devon and Bonnie Dee is an MM Historical novel set in the 1880's where being gay was considered to be deviant!
John Gilliam was an academic who thought the worst thing was being caught loving another man until he found out the hard truth that it wasn't! He agreed to enter an asylum for what they called a deviant behaviour where he endured vicious attacks and painful procedures to rid him of being gay. His only pleasure in life was his writing and reading but they were stripped from him. The doctors and attendants gave him a hard time and whenever he tries to stand up for himself he is mistreated or worse, that is until an attendant gives John a friendly hand.
Sam Tully is the attendant that is sympatric to John's plight in the mental facility and he also related to the feelings that John has for other men but he keeps those feelings to himself in fear of what could happen to him. Sam is not an educated man, just someone who wants to do this job without any conflicts. The two men have some much in common, yet are so different. Sam wants to help John with his time in the facility and John wants to help Sam with his reading and writing.
I simply love the relationship that is slowly developing between these men as they have feelings for each other but could never act on it considering where they are and the time they are in. They do have those stolen glances, soft touches and forbidden kisses even though Sam is tormented, trying to be professional, he can't deny the feelings he has for John. This is such a beautiful and rare novel where loving another man is forbidden but true love can't be denied no matter what the outside forces are doing. Trying to find a way to love each other is not the only problem that these men encounter, they have uncovered a heinous conspiracy which could endanger their lives. Will John and Sam survive the cover-up or will they pay the ultimate price and will they both find a way to be together and love each other no matter what society tells them! I highly recommend this beautiful and intelligent story of forbidden love and conspiracy for anyone who wants to see what life was like for a gay man in 1880's!
I received a complimentary copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
Reviewed by Paul at Crystal's Many Reviewers!
This novel The Gentleman's Madness by Summer Devon and Bonnie Dee is an MM Historical novel set in the 1880's where being gay was considered to be deviant!
John Gilliam was an academic who thought the worst thing was being caught loving another man until he found out the hard truth that it wasn't! He agreed to enter an asylum for what they called a deviant behaviour where he endured vicious attacks and painful procedures to rid him of being gay. His only pleasure in life was his writing and reading but they were stripped from him. The doctors and attendants gave him a hard time and whenever he tries to stand up for himself he is mistreated or worse, that is until an attendant gives John a friendly hand.
Sam Tully is the attendant that is sympatric to John's plight in the mental facility and he also related to the feelings that John has for other men but he keeps those feelings to himself in fear of what could happen to him. Sam is not an educated man, just someone who wants to do this job without any conflicts. The two men have some much in common, yet are so different. Sam wants to help John with his time in the facility and John wants to help Sam with his reading and writing.
I simply love the relationship that is slowly developing between these men as they have feelings for each other but could never act on it considering where they are and the time they are in. They do have those stolen glances, soft touches and forbidden kisses even though Sam is tormented, trying to be professional, he can't deny the feelings he has for John. This is such a beautiful and rare novel where loving another man is forbidden but true love can't be denied no matter what the outside forces are doing. Trying to find a way to love each other is not the only problem that these men encounter, they have uncovered a heinous conspiracy which could endanger their lives. Will John and Sam survive the cover-up or will they pay the ultimate price and will they both find a way to be together and love each other no matter what society tells them! I highly recommend this beautiful and intelligent story of forbidden love and conspiracy for anyone who wants to see what life was like for a gay man in 1880's!
I received a complimentary copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
Reviewed by Paul at Crystal's Many Reviewers!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 97 reviews