I understand how controversial J.O is & I don’t want to make the mistake of condemning him or insulting his character while critiquing his book, but I do intend on calling a spade a spade.
One of the most heartbreaking things about a book like this is that it creates a false sense of hope in the reader that isn’t grounded in the Word of God. Joel uses his signature “positive thinking” & “positive speaking” approach to teach people that they can change their lives by changing their attitude towards life; he gives a number of examples & stories of people—not from the Bible, of course— who have had positive outcomes with his “positive confession theology,” which plants an unhealthy seed of thought in your mind that could make you believe the problems your are facing in life is your fault & the blessing you are not receiving in life is your fault also; everything bad that happens is not from God & everything God has in store for you is only good. This sort of theology is damaging, misleading, unloving, man-centred, God dishonouring & unbiblical in many ways.
Can man declare & decree something that God hasn’t already? The Bible teaches us that we cannot—“Who can command things to happen without the Lord’s permission? Does not the Most High send both calamity and good?”
Lamentations 3:37-38 NLT. So why would Joel want you to believe that you have the power to change a bad situation with your words? Did Joesph, a just & honest man, have the power to get out of the pit his brothers threw him into? (Gen 37:23-24). Was he sold to the merchantmen & eventually to Potiphar because he had negative thoughts? (Gen 37:28, 36). Was he unjustly put into to prison on the premise of false allegations & locked up for two years, forgotten by the cup bearer & baker, because Joseph didn’t know how to command & declare thirty one positive declarations? (Gen 39:20, 41:1).
If you study Joseph’s life in detail, you’ll notice that Joseph was a seventeen year old boy when all his problems started (Gen 37:2) & he was thirty when he became ruler of Egypt (Gen 41:46), which means thirteen years passed by before his rollercoaster of disappointing circumstances could end. Most preachers today would use this story as an example for how waiting for God’s “blessing” like Joseph did is for everyone! The notion is problematic, because not everyone can become the ruler of Egypt; secondly, this was never about Joseph or God blessing & rewarding Joseph with a comfortable life for patiently enduring the tests, this has always been & always will be a story about how God used a man like Joseph—a man who loved & depended on God—and against all odds preserved Jacobs family, while keeping His promise to Abraham, from who’s family the Messiah was to come from, eventually being a blessing to the entire world (Gen 12:3). The evil that Joseph’s brothers intended for him wasn’t completely stopped or averted by God, but it was eventually turned into good (Gen 50:20; compare with Romans 8:28).
This book does spread a lot of positivity, but it’s more a “self-help” book than a Christian book; it’s more about me than it is about God; it’s more about what God can do for me that what God can do through me or what I can do for God. A pastor in the church I was in during my college days recommended this book & I had no idea who J.O was & how heretical his teachings were, so being a book nerd I decided to give it a read. I wouldn’t read this book again, and furthermore, I wouldn’t recommend this book to anyone; particularly those that are hurting & looking for a miracle during challenging times. My prayer for you—whoever is reading this—is for you to know God’s sovereignty in your life & your circumstances.
“The king's heart is a stream of water in the hand of the Lord; he turns it wherever he will.”
Proverbs 21:1 ESV
“But our God is in the heavens; He does whatever He pleases.”
Psalms 115:3 NASB
“And we know that all things work together for good to them that love God, to them who are the called according to his purpose.”
Romans 8:28 KJV
Ps: If you’re looking for a book, other than the Bible, that would encourage you during difficult times, I would recommend Joni Eareckson Tada’s autobiography.