This book is a pretty fascinating read, although – as others have remarked – the language is rather dry and at times boring. The writer is too much of a scientist, and too little of a storyteller. The history of the ancient Delphi is exciting and fascinating and that’s why I in no way regret reading the book. The book tells the story of Delphi in chronological order. I summarize and give some of my thoughts on the lecture.
Chapter 1 gives an impression of how the Oracle of Delphi ‘worked’ and what rituals surrounded it. The fact that the Oracle was active only 9 days a year was a big surprise to me, as was the fact that during the winter months Apollo was ‘on holiday’ and that another Greek god, Dionysus, took his place as it were (for me it raises questions about the relationship between these two Olympic gods). Also an eye-opener was that the Oracle did not really answer questions about the future: she was not as much a seer as an ‘ancient management consultant’, as Scott puts it. The Oracle actually stimulated wise decision-making in difficult matters instead of blind belief.
(My thoughts on this: visiting the Oracle – from distant places in the Greek world – in itself already gave the time to think things over, apart from the answer that the Pythia would give. By analogy: when you go on a pilgrimage to Santiago, you would be crazy not to visit the Cathedral and the grave of St Jacob once you got there; but the true learning happens on the road. It’s a pity the author hardly makes use of these kinds of ‘modern’ parallels and analogies, to make his account more vivid and understable for modern readers.)
Chapter 2 discusses the origins of the Delphi Oracle. It presents the different ancient myths of the god Apollo and how he came to be Apollo Pythios. Important is the account in the Homeric Hymn to Apollo (6th c. B.C). Other accounts include those of Alcaeus, the tragic writers Aeschylus and Euripides, and Ephorus. The myths appear products of their own times (7th to 5th c. B.C.), in which the oracle had already become an incredible successful phenomenon.
Chapter 3 makes clear that the Oracle was often used regarding colonisation issues. Before taking on the adventure, a Greek city would go to Delphi to visit the ‘colonisation god’ Apollo. The Oracle was used by city states and individuals, by Greek tyrants and Eastern kings. All these people brought donations and made offerings: tripods, kettles, shields, statues, etc. Delphi became a rich and wealthy settlement, but still small and relatively unprotected.
(My thoughts on this: the great richness sacred Delphi gathered reminds me of the Catholic Church, and many more parallels with Catholicism can be drawn. And by that I do not only mean the material wealth as a result of a multitude of offerings and donations and the building of great monuments and shrines, but also – as told in Chapter 5 – the spiritual richness, consisting of several cults and numerous ‘saints’, so that everybody can have their own religious experience and devotion. As Delphi grew and gained popularity, the number of gods and heroes that were venerated increased with the amount of visitors).
Chapter 4 tells the story of the birth of the Amphictiony, the religious alliance of cities that – from now on – guarded and protected the Delphic Shrine. They were also the founders of the Pythian Games (591-590 B.C). The combination of (oracle) shrines and games made Delphi more and more attractive for visitors to come. In this period the first Temple of Apollo was built. Famous Athenians like Solon and Cleisthenes visited the Delphic Oracle and asked advice. But the most famous story concerns the Lydian King Croesus. Croesus doubted whether he should take up arms against the Persian Empire. The Oracle answered that if he did, he would destroy a great army. Croesus was already imagining the defeat of the Persian army, but unfortunately the Pythia had meant his own. Around 570 B.C. the people of Naxos donated one of the most famous monuments to the Delphic Shrine, a giant marble Sphinx. It also became popular to build large treasure houses, in which stunning golden and silver gifts could be stored.
Chapter 5 is about the destruction of the Shrine by fire in 548 B.C. The Amphictiony, who undertook the rebuilding project, made the new Shrine larger and more spectacular. The project was finished not until 506 B.C. In this period the Oracle became involved in the rivalry between two powerful aristocratic families from Athens: the Alcmaeonids and the Peisistratids. The Alcmaeonids increased – by large donations – their influence in Delphi during the second half of the 6th century. Peisistratus on the other hand, much unlike other Greek tyrants, never made any donations. It’s intriguing that, whenever the Spartans in these years visited the Oracle, the Pythia ordered them in clear language to liberate Athens (from its tyrant). How easy the Oracle could be manipulated or even bribed is a question that reoccurs and fascinates.
In this period Delphi became more and more international. Accordingly Delphi became a place where an increasing number and variety of gods, goddesses and heroes was venerated (as Athena, Dionysus, Gaea, the Muses, Heracles, etc). The inhabitants of the isle of Sifnos donated one of the most exuberant treasure houses Delphi had ever seen. Other cities did not want to stay behind, and thus began a weird competition in years to come to build even larger and more abundant monuments. During the Persian Wars (490-479 B.C.) Delphi seems to have had a pro-Persian mindset. (Why that should have been the case does not become clear to me from the storyline.) Famous is the answer the Pythia gave to the Athenians, that they should trust their wooden walls. Themistocles, the Athenian general, concluded that the Athenians should use their mighty fleet to beat the enemy.
Chapter 6 recounts how after the Persian Wars Delphi really became the centre of the Greek world. Every city wanted to commemorate their role in the battle by means of a monument. Delphi became the place to write history, but also the place to re-write it: some cities collaborated with the Persians but now presented themselves as victors. This process of rewriting history by means of art is a really exciting one. Meanwhile the Pythian games were expanded with painting, dancing and acting. The poet Pindar became famous with his victory odes and hymns. In this period Athens dominated the Greek world. In Delphi they also had a lot of influence. During the Pelopponesian War between Athens and Sparta (431-404 B.C.) Delphi stood on the side of Sparta and the Peloponnesian Bond. The Athenians were very disappointed about this. In Athenian tragedies and comedies of this period we find a lot of sarcasm towards oracles in general. The Spartans started to build great monuments in Delphi to overclass those built earlier by their Athenian enemies.
Chapter 7 shows that the Delphic community was very dependent on the oracle, and therefore easy to manipulate: the Spartan general Lysander wanted the Pythia to proclaim that the king should be appointed by election and not by descendence (so that he could be king hemself). Where Lysander did not succeed, another Spartan, king Agesilaus, successfully manipulated the Oracle to receive support for his attack on Argos. In the year 373 B.C. Delphi was hit by a huge earthquake. The temples of Apollo and Athena were destroyed. It took the oracle a century to recover. In 356 B.C. the inhabitans of Phocis – in a feud with Thebe – decided to take hold of the Delphic shrine. They were driven out by Philippus of Macedonia, who was celebrated as liberator and who soon gained power over Greece.
Chapter 8 is about the changes after the death of Alexander the Great – Philippus’ successor. His empire fell apart and in his place came Hellenistic monarchs, who had absolute power and did not need such things as oracles. They also didn’t make any donations to the shrine, so that it lost its prominent position. The oracle was now taken over by the Aetolians (from the north of Greece), who would control the oracle for more than a century.
Chapter 9 shows that the decline of the Oracle went on in the 2nd century B.C. The Delpians wished to be liberated from their Aetolian rulers. At last ‘freedom’ was brought by a Roman victor: Flaminius. The Romans reformed the Amphictiony and the Delphians fared well under that. The Roman conqueror guaranteed independence for Delphi and ‘freedom’ for Greece. Some Greek cities, like Corinth, turned against Rome and were punished with destruction. Delphi survived and became – ironically – the place where Roman victories over Greece were celebrated. In the first century B.C. Roman general Sulla plundered the Delphic Shrine, and barbarian tribes did the same afterwards.
Chapter 10 is about the remarkable ‘renaissance’ Delphi made through during the age of Augustus. Emperor Augustus reformed the Amphictiony, which he imagined to be ‘the great council of Greece’. In reality the organ never had been a representation of all Greek city states. By this reform – in fact based on a Roman misunderstanding – Delphi regained its high position. The Delphians honoured the Roman Emperors by means of statues in the shrine of Apollo. Claudius was the first Emperor who showed a permanent interest in Delphi. The Delphians made sure this high attention was never lost, by erecting momuments that showed their connection with the Emperor. Nero was the first Roman emperor to actually visit Delphi. He plundered the shrine and took around 500 statues to place them in his Golden House. The Flavian Emperors Titus and Domitian followed the example of Claudius. Domitian copied the Pythian games by introducing the so-called Capitoline Games in Rome.
A famous inhabitant of Delphi was the Greek-Roman writer Plutarch, who became a priest of Apollo in the sanctuary. In his treatises he discusses interesting issues like: why was the mysterious letter ‘E’ attached to the Appolo temple and from where does the Pythia get her inspiration? From Plutarchs writings it becomes clear, that Delphi had become a popular destination for tourists (like it still is today) and a place for religious pilgrimage (a great amount of festivals was held there), but also a place full of history and commemoration.
Chapter 11 starts with the happy relationship between Delphi and Emperor Hadrian. Hadrian soon visited the Oracle and introduced the cult of Antinoos, his deceased gay lover and declared god. Delphi honoured the Emperor for ‘bringing peace to the universe’. Hadrian dreamt of a united Greece and founded the so-called Panhellenion in the year 131. Delphi would – again – be the centre of the Greek world. Delphi also gained a reputation as a place for philosophical discussions, thanks to a unique combination of history, oracle, philosophical heritage and games in sports and music. The priesthood of Plutarch and the spreading of his writings helped this reputation a lot. In his Description of Greece another important writer, Pausanias, presents us what he wished to see in Delphi: the picture of a united Greece. He focusses largely on the stories, places and monuments that underlined the panhellenic thought, promoted by Hadrian. But Pausianias didn’t reach his literary goals. His book wasn’t read much in antiquity.
From 180 A.D. onwards the Pythian games were copied to different cities around the Roman Empire and served to honour the Emperor. Apollo – the god behind the Pythian Games – was suitable for this, as his Roman equivalent Sol Invictus (the Invincible Sun) was the guardian god of the emperors. When Emperor Constantine and his succcessors turned to christianity, their statues were still placed in the ‘pagan’ sanctuary of Delphi. In 365 A.D. Delphi (as the whole of Greece) was shaken by a heavy earthquake again. The christian Emperors Valens and Valentinus came to help, and were therefore venerated by a monument.
Chapter 12 makes clear, that the pagan days of Delphi were not that suddenly cut off, and that the transition to christianity in fact took place in a more subtle and gradual manner. In years to come three christian basilicas were built. The christian community that inhabited Delphi did not destroy the sanctuary of Apollo but they also made no efforts at all to conserve it. What fascinates me most about this period is the intermingeling of pagan and christian elements, as can be seen in the iconography. We have examples of Christ crushing a snake (just like Apollo). Also the battle of St. George with the dragon has a clear connection with the myth of Apollo, beating ‘Pytho’.
In the beginning of the 7th century Delphi finally was destroyed and abandoned. The story does not continue until 1436 A.D., when the Italian mercant Cyriacus of Ancona visited the spot. The village was then known as ‘Castri’ and the inhabitants seemed to know nothing of its glorious past. It’s a wonderous thing that such an important past can be ignored and forgotten for so long. After centuries in which the desire to discover the ancient Greek world in general and Delphi in particular grew, in 1892 finally the excavation began. It would become a turning point in the history of archeology.