Primum non nocere
The Hippocratic Oath dating from the fourth or fifth century BC serves as guidelines for physicians and medical employees. Although it isn’t legally binding, it is universally accepted that following them would eliminate most malpractice charges. The first rule of this oath is Do no harm, simply meaning, don’t expose the patient to any unnecessary risk.
Dr. Lars Herman and Dr. Charles English use their position at Plainview Community Hospital to perform unnecessary tests and surgeries indicated by spurious diagnoses. Because these surgeries were extremely lucrative financially, for both doctors and the hospital, all questions and complaints were promptly whitewashed or dropped by the hospital’s executive board.
Dr. Laura Patel, a doctor of Osteopathic Medicine, served on the Plainview Community Hospital staff and lodged a formal complaint against Dr. Herman for malpractice. The hospital administrators berated her for her formal complaint and put her on non-active status, without pay; consequently exonerating Dr. Herman of all charges.
This appears to be the makings of an extremely lucrative class action suit. Unfortunately, everything isn’t what it seems. The reader can witness, first hand and ringside, a feeding frenzy of lawyers and doctors, completely overshadowing the suffering clients and their families.
Like many of the stories written by the acclaimed author, John Grisham, are situated in the Deep South. This one too takes place in the Volunteer State, Tennessee, but any other similarities are hard to find. There is a common public mistrust of lawyers. This story adds to this suspicion. In addition, the trustworthiness of the medical community is also brought into doubt. A lawyer is required to navigate the quagmire of motions, affidavits, and depositions. Law isn’t a static, inert, motionless world. It continues to change each year as advancements in science, technology, and new litigations. I am an avid fan of the works of Erle Stanley Gardner and his legal maverick, Perry Mason. The legal novels of today are vastly different from the mid-twentieth century. Upon completion of this story, it will probably leave an unpleasant aftertaste in the reader’s mouth. For a first novel, I give Mr. Tuck high marks and look forward to reading more of his work.